Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Knock Down or No?

Featured Replies

As I approach the base portion of the workbench build, I find myself wondering if I should bother with the knock-down joinery. For me personally, being able to remove the top is mobility enough for if/when I move the bench to a different location. Flat-packing it just isn't necessary. So I'm thinking I will just use glue and drawbore the joints.

My question for those who are building this bench is, do you see a real need for the knock-down joinery? I might just cover the drilling technique using sample pieces so you can see how it is done. But I am trying to gauge just how many folks actually plan on using this method.

I'm doing knockdown. I'm living in a duplex house right now paying rent. We hope to move in a few years and hopefully have a lil bit more space. Thus, the knockdown just make sense because it will take up a WHOLE lot more room in the UHaul otherwise. I got the barrel nuts from benchrafted.. nice stuff.

I'm going knockdown as well. My shop is a small section of my basement and I'm shoehorning the bench in place as it is. We have plans to build a two-car garage which will be mine when it doesn't have cars parked in it. So I know I'll have to move that puppy at least once in my lifetime. While I don't need to flat pack it, the knockdown will allow me to minimize it to manageable pieces that are compatible with my basement stairs.

Not doing the build with the guild, as I built mine a couple years ago, but my two cents: If you can do it like marc (not full knockdown) do it - nothing to tighten over time. It won't take much more room in a uhaul (you can pile stuff all over the base and top in there, no worries.

If you can't move the base assembly without knockdown, then, well, you know what you've gotta do. I think a demo of the procedure on scrap would be sufficient for those needing the visual guidance. Marc: since you've got a substantial group building along, maybe there is a video capable member you can work with to get footage and voice over as needed. Just a thought. I would say try Vic, but I think you talked him out of knockdown!

Yes, you did! I'm also thinking of not actually dadoing the shelf boards into the base , but rather glue on ledger strips and let the boards float on top. The wood I'm using will never warp, so why go to the trouble of letting them in.

(null)

I am going with the knock down. In fact I may be racing the moving van trying to get this done. Just don't know what direction the van will be headed - my wife is in for jobs on the east coast and the west coast. In any case we tend to move often and it will make life easier. A demo video is probably fine.

I'm leaning towards the knockdown version, but from a perspective of not having much experience with M&T and no experience with drawboring. I'd kinda like to see the more complicated method, and a walk through of marking for the knockdown bolts, maybe a practice joint demonstrating it?

I would prefer non-knockdown. I plan to die in this house in 100 years or so, and I plan to never build another bench. So I'd like to see as much detail as possible, but I understand if you can't go into all of it.

  • Author

Keep in mind, that regardless of the knockdown concept, the bench still requires large drawbored m/t joints. If you were to make a "non-knockdown" version, you simply omit the step where the bolts are added to the 4 long stretcher joints and use glue instead (and drawbore if desired).

As I approach the base portion of the workbench build, I find myself wondering if I should bother with the knock-down joinery. For me personally, being able to remove the top is mobility enough for if/when I move the bench to a different location. Flat-packing it just isn't necessary. So I'm thinking I will just use glue and drawbore the joints.

My question for those who are building this bench is, do you see a real need for the knock-down joinery? I might just cover the drilling technique using sample pieces so you can see how it is done. But I am trying to gauge just how many folks actually plan on using this method.

I am up in the air...I am building this bench for my lifetime and hopefully my sons lifetime and for that matter his sons. I do not ever plan on being up and down stairs with this thing, but who knows if my son decides he wants to get a lof in downtown Manhatten in a 5 story walk up. Then knockdown would be nice for him, but being that it is my bench, for the interim, I am probably going to do a through tenon and rising dovetail on the legs if I am feeling up to the task. I do like the traditional and asthetic look to this system and it is also very solid with or without glue. Well I hope this post puts more people on the fence like myself so I don't have to be alone.

ciao,

THE KAISER

I am probably going to do a through tenon and rising dovetail on the legs if I am feeling up to the task. I do like the traditional and asthetic look to this system and it is also very solid with or without glue. Well I hope this post puts more people on the fence like myself so I don't have to be alone.

Are you talking about doing a rising dovetail for attaching the legs to the top? I've been considering that as well but it does present an assembly challenge since the rising dovetails slide in at an angle. Have you puzzled this one out? If so, do share.

Are you talking about doing a rising dovetail for attaching the legs to the top? I've been considering that as well but it does present an assembly challenge since the rising dovetails slide in at an angle. Have you puzzled this one out? If so, do share.

yes. This is not a sliding dovetail. the tenon on this inside of the leg is what makes it a challenge. So what I am planning on doing is make the legs in 2 sections and glue them up after they are in the top. In other words, I will put in the sliding rising dovetail section of the leg, then slide the monster tenon on the backside section of the leg into the top and glue them together in place. I will try to post pics. Another way you can do it is to not put on your outermost laminate on your top and cut it to the rising dovetail after the legs are in.
the tricky part is getting the stretchers together with this way of doing this. Once I work that out I will post it.

Are you talking about doing a rising dovetail for attaching the legs to the top? I've been considering that as well but it does present an assembly challenge since the rising dovetails slide in at an angle. Have you puzzled this one out? If so, do share.

the tricky part is getting the stretchers together with this way of doing this. Once I work that out I will post it.

Yeah.. that's where I'm hung up... I was thinking of maybe doing rising dovetails only on the front legs and angled tenons on the back legs. that way the whole top can go on at once at the same angle.

I'll try to remember to link to a friend's post on the rising DT later. Erik, do you remember meeting Ryan from WIA? He was from Salt Lake City. Great guy!

(null)

Marc,I'm sticking with the plan in the knockdowns what I understand now is that the drawbore

pins and joint do not necessarily need to be glued. So you could do a non-metal knockdown so to speak. Is that what you're thinking.

Yeah.. that's where I'm hung up... I was thinking of maybe doing rising dovetails only on the front legs and angled tenons on the back legs. that way the whole top can go on at once at the same angle.

Yes. Good idea. I still see a problem as far as gettiing the stretchers in after the legs are installed. I just might use a whale tail on the face of the stretchers into the face of the legs to remedy this issue.

Yes. Good idea. I still see a problem as far as gettiing the stretchers in after the legs are installed. I just might use a whale tail on the face of the stretchers into the face of the legs to remedy this issue.

If you do the rear legs like that, you can assemble the base completely then attach the top.

I am leaning towards a full glue-up as I do not anticipate moving again (I sure hope I am right on that one). The bench is going to be heavy but I should think that if a move is in order I could move it along with the rest of the equipment in my shop and use it to hold boxes of all my other tools etc.

I just don't want to have to go around and tighten up the joints as they work loose. This may be more of a concern in my situation as I intend to build with Douglas Fir which is softer than Maple or the SYP options.

I'm going the glued draw-bore route. Not planning on a move but if it happens the bench (hard maple) will still be significantly easier (lighter) to move than stationary power tools!

Marc, you could always build yourself a nice side table with 4 inch legs and stretchers to demo the use of the Benchcrafted knock down hardware.

Yeah.. that's where I'm hung up... I was thinking of maybe doing rising dovetails only on the front legs and angled tenons on the back legs. that way the whole top can go on at once at the same angle.

They would have to angle in the same direction.

If you do the rear legs like that, you can assemble the base completely then attach the top.

this would be really cool to see and I have decided to go the standard route with my legs. Maybe on my sons bench I will come up with a crazy detail.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.