Brian VanVreede Posted March 16, 2012 Report Posted March 16, 2012 So thanks to the help of the community I purchased the Veritas 12 tpi rip saw for cutting dovetails. This thing is great, especially after my instructor, at the Philadelphia Furniture Workshop, Mario Rodriguez, took 2 swipes with a set stone over each side of my saw to remove some of the set. Knowing it was a new saw, which he also thought was a smart investment for what I was looking to get out of it, he had me cut straight into a board and examine the cut line. It felt super smooth while I was cutting but after a closer inspection, it looked jagged. Almost like you could see where I started each stroke. After he layed the saw flat on its side and ran a set stone over each side twice, he had me try again. Like a hot knife through butter! The cut was also straight down, just one straight, clean cut. He also warned that if you do remove to much of the set that you must be very careful. If you remove too much, the cut created by the teeth will be thinner than the metal behind it, causing it to bind. I really would suggest removing some set if your cut looks ragged. For all you Japanese saw users out there...... He lined up about 10 different dovetail saws and made a cut with each to show the difference. The last cut he made was with a students Japanese hand saw. The kerf left by this saw was basically invisable! Everyone ooooo'ed and awwwww'ed. He was even pretty impressed. I may have to look into one of these in the future.... Quote
Fah-Fah-Fooey Posted March 16, 2012 Report Posted March 16, 2012 Thx for the tip : ) and I like your mallet on your blog 1 Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted March 16, 2012 Author Report Posted March 16, 2012 Thanks Foley. There was an episode of the woodwright's shop on last night featuring christopher schwartz. they discussed the different classes of cuts, different types of saws, and they also talk about set. Do not try and remove set from a cross cut saw! The set is what allows of the saw do all of the cutting. Quote
Bob Rozaieski Posted March 16, 2012 Report Posted March 16, 2012 The thickness, or thinness in this case, of the kerf isn't important. What is important is where you put that kerf. Set is also a function of the type of saw, the cut being made, the thickness of the wood etc. Saws with taper ground plates can handle less set. Some taper ground plates are designed to be used with no set. The best thing to do is to learn to sharpen and set your own saws so you can control it for the type of work you do and the type of woods you use. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted April 24, 2012 Report Posted April 24, 2012 I collected an old hand saw vise, a saw set and a few other saw sharpening do-dads a long time ago. It is a lot of work to properly sharpen a handsaw. but the results are worth it. Adding set to a rip saw can make it cut a lot faster, but the quality of the cut is a bit rough. I still use my grandfathers handsaw occasionally then it goes back in the rack. Must have spent a full day sharpening that saw. Grandad told me he built the front porch on the house my dad was born in with just that handsaw and a hammer. Quote
ChrisG Posted April 24, 2012 Report Posted April 24, 2012 Do not try and remove set from a cross cut saw! The set is what allows of the saw do all of the cutting. I believe you are confussing set with fleam. Set is the amount to which the teeth are bent out to either side. Fleam is the knife edge filed into the fronts and backs of xcut teeth. While you can xcut with a rip saw (a saw with no fleam), this knife edge is what allows the saw to sever the fibers cleanly when crosscutting which is why you generally would not want to remove it on an xcut saw. On either a xcut or rip you do not want to remove all of the set, but you do want enough set. Enough is generally the smallest amount that will still allow the saw to cut the type of wood you want it to w/o binding. When I file my saws I generally overset them very slightly (though not always intentionally) and then take a few passes with a stone, as you described to dial in the amount I want. Finally, stoning a saw as you described will not remove fleam. To remove fleam, you would need to refile the saw so that the fronts and backs of the teeth are straight across (no knife edge). Stoning an xcut saw is not a problem. Thanks for sharing BTW - sounds like you had a fun learning experience. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.