Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Why are there no 8 in jointers that run on 110

Featured Replies

I can get a 12in planer that runs on 110 and was wondering why I can't get over a 6in jointer that runs on 110 as well. I figured I would ask as I'm sure I'm missing something, but to me they seem to be pretty similar just set up differently for a specific task. I also am puzzled by why jointers pretty much start at 6 inch and get bigger while planers start at 12 inch, is there any reason why they don't make them the same size or is this just like a ten pack of hotdogs and a dozen buns kind of thing?. Any insight would be greatly appreciated as this has bugged me for awhile.

Thx

Jointers make things straight, so they need long beds to make long pieces straight along their entire length. Those beds need to be straight, so they need to be made of something like cast iron that is very stable, and pretty expensive. A 12" jointer is very heavy and expensive.

Thickness planers trim the top to be a set distance from the bottom, so they only need a short section a set distance from the cutters Only the cutters need to be absolutely straight, so they can use stamped steel, aluminum, or plastic for the infeed / outfeed guides. So, a 12" benchtop planer can be relatively inexpensive.

As for the 220 vs 110, I have no idea. Good question!

My Delta 8" joiner can run on either 110 or 220. Right now mine is wired for 110 since that's all I have in the garage. Eventually I will add some 220 outlets in the garage and may re-wire the joiner for 220 at that point.

A little 12" planer is turning at very high rpm just like a router. They rely on speed to get their terribly overstated horse power. Cutter heads for jointers can't spin at such high rpms. Induction motors spin slow by comparison but rely on torque to cut the wood. Think of your 12" planer like a router spinning that tiny 1/4 bit, compared to a shaper slinging a good sized cutter 16 times it's size. The shaper spins much slower but has much more power. For example a 3 1/4 hp router doesn't have anywhere close to the power of a 3hp shaper. The size of the cutters are the reason for the mass of the machine. Imagine putting a 5" diameter x 3" tall solid steel router bit on your little 3 1/4 hp router table. All hell would break loose, but it's no issue for a shaper.

Don

There are some like the Jet combo 10" jointer/planer that run on 110v but generally anything over 6 or 8" is used in a production environment not a home shop since they have large cast iron beds and weigh a lot more then the average 6" or 8" jointer. A jointer bigger then 8" will pretty much dominate a one car garage and I don't even want to think about what would be required to get one into my basement. :)

For a production environment you have to make the tool to handle high usage which means low amps high volts for longevity. 220V motors are just longer life and higher torque motors in most instances. Necessary for an industrial purchase and able to handle lots of hardwood jointing. It's just a matter of selling for the market from what I can see.

Just not all that many home owners have room for a 12" jointer so for the few most makers would sell, I don't think it's worth it for most to spin up a production line.They just wouldn't sell all that many at a price point they could make a decent profit.

Just a few guesses why you don't see many models with even an option for 110V above 8".

-Jim

My Delta 8" joiner can run on either 110 or 220. Right now mine is wired for 110 since that's all I have in the garage. Eventually I will add some 220 outlets in the garage and may re-wire the joiner for 220 at that point.

I have the same jointer and just re wired it to 220volts. Worked fine at 110. However the motor runs a lot better at 220...a lot better

The answers are all dodging around the central issue.

A 120V, 15A typical household circuit has a theoretical maximum for continuous HP of 2.4HP.

A 120V, 20A "beefy" household circuit has a theoretical maximum for continuous HP of 3.2HP

A 240V, 20A typical garage circuit has a theoretical maximum continuous HP of 6.4HP.

A 240V, 50A circuit typically run for ranges and welders has a theoretical max of 16.1HP.

Now, those are theoretical values. In reality, the breakers won't let you pull 100% of the rated load for a long period of time. Real world is no more than 80% and about 50% is the most you can really expect to get away with long-term. Now, keep in mind that the inrush current to start the motor will be even larger than that. It's not uncommon to see inrush currents that are 5-8 times the steady-state current. This is the reason that a lot of tools suggest a "slow blow" breaker. So, the reason that you don't see bigger 120V jointers is that it takes too much power to keep the wider blades spinning if they're biting into hardwood across their entire width. In order to pull off jointing 8" of cocobolo, you need a higher horsepower motor. This forces the motor to be run off of 240V since 120V can't deliver enough power.

  • Author

My Delta 8" joiner can run on either 110 or 220. Right now mine is wired for 110 since that's all I have in the garage. Eventually I will add some 220 outlets in the garage and may re-wire the joiner for 220 at that point.

I have the same jointer and just re wired it to 220volts. Worked fine at 110. However the motor runs a lot better at 220...a lot better

Thx for letting me know about the 8in Delta, I was unaware that you could get an 8inch that runs on 110, I currently rent and only have 110, so being able to get an 8in jointer that can be rewired is a very attractive option and one i will definitely look into. I have been putting off buying a jointer as everyone says that they find themselves upgrading from a 6 inch to an 8 inch, so spending the money to get a good 6 inch seems like a waste and getting a cheaper benchtop seems like it would just turn into something i would regret buying.

  • Author
A little 12" planer is turning at very high rpm just like a router. They rely on speed to get their terribly overstated horse power. Cutter heads for jointers can't spin at such high rpms. Induction motors spin slow by comparison but rely on torque to cut the wood. Think of your 12" planer like a router spinning that tiny 1/4 bit, compared to a shaper slinging a good sized cutter 16 times it's size. The shaper spins much slower but has much more power. For example a 3 1/4 hp router doesn't have anywhere close to the power of a 3hp shaper. The size of the cutters are the reason for the mass of the machine. Imagine putting a 5" diameter x 3" tall solid steel router bit on your little 3 1/4 hp router table. All hell would break loose, but it's no issue for a shaper. Don

Thank you Don, That explains it, I figured it had to be something due to power restraints, but i didn't realize that there was that big of difference between the size of cutter heads between the jointer and the planer, I just assumed there were about the same size and the reason for being smaller was to reduce the cast iron needed for the top, making them cheaper to produce. That the consumer would end up having to upgrade so they would be able to sell them a second jointer and that anyone who needs a larger jointer would be using it for production purposes and would have the 220 needed for a larger motor.

  • Author
Now, keep in mind that the inrush current to start the motor will be even larger than that. It's not uncommon to see inrush currents that are 5-8 times the steady-state current. This is the reason that a lot of tools suggest a "slow blow" breaker. So, the reason that you don't see bigger 120V jointers is that it takes too much power to keep the wider blades spinning if they're biting into hardwood across their entire width. In order to pull off jointing 8" of cocobolo, you need a higher horsepower motor. This forces the motor to be run off of 240V since 120V can't deliver enough power.

I never thought about the initial power draw needed to start the motor, I just assumed that i would have to take lighter passes to compensate for the lack of power if i wanted to use 110.

  • Author

I just wanted to say thank you to everyone who posted each post was helpful and informative, I am truly impressed, you all managed to explain the difference in power requirements between a jointer and a planer and even inform me that their are 8 and 10 inch jointers that run on 110. I am really glad that i was able to join the guild and support Marc when he needed it and can honestly say your answered easily saved me the cost of a years membership, So to everyone that posted I say thank you once again :)

  • Author
==> but i didn't realize that there was that big of difference between the size of cutter heads between the jointer and the planers The idea is spot on, but it also depends on the head technology employed. That is why some 15 inch planers are 1.5HP and some are 4HP... Some head technologies require much thicker/heaver heads than others and require more HP to move, but in general jointers heads are thicker than planers -- keeping the technology the same (knife, helix, tersa, etc) ... In general, helix requires less HP than knife while Tersa requires more (much bigger/heaver monoblock head).

Wow another helpful post, I know that helical cut cleaner then straight knifes as well as being cheaper to replace individual damaged cutting blades, but thx for pointing out that they need less HP, I will defiantly look into getting an upgraded cutting head when i get a jointer as the helical head would help compensate for my lack of power, just as a thin kerf blade does with my saw.

The weight of the cutter head has nearly nothing to do with keeping it spinning at a constant velocity. There's probably less than half-hp difference in terms of free drag between the biggest and smallest non-industrial jointers. Power does affect how long it takes to initially spin up the head. Most importantly, different head cutting styles will have DRAMATICALLY different power requirements once they touch wood. So it's not so much about the weight of the cutterhead as it is about the way it cuts.

I would suspect that you're right about cutterhead diameter being a strong influence on torque requirements. A smaller head is going to rotate the blade through a wider angle while it's in contact with the wood while a larger diameter is going to leave the cutter in the wood for a greater distance. One of those or both definitely will affect drag.

We’ve gone a bit off topic, but to continue the thought… May have something to do with mass/momentum as well as geometry. A large diameter/massive head will rotate through a variable hardness surface more smoothly than a head with less mass/diameter – flywheel affect. I notice that (in the machines that I have used) the ‘higher quality’ machines have a larger diameter head than the ‘lower quality’ machines (forget helix for the moment). The HP requirement may be driven by head diameter/mass itself (flywheel) or may be the ability to drive a given head more smoothly across uneven density surfaces -- motor torque headroom. Is the HP requirement the result of the inherent cutting geometry difference or the ability to provide more consistent torque throughout a cut using a more massive flywheel? Don't know, but will e-mail my local tool guy for some answers …

I have noticed that the head diameter/mass requirement changes when you switch to helical heads. The two helical machines that I own have much smaller diameter heads than my tersa units (3 inch .v. 6 inch), a fraction of the mass and lower HP requirements. I suppose that the segmented head requires a much smaller ‘flywheel’ because only a few cm of the surface is being contacted at any given time. The geometry of the cutter is also quite different – again, I’ll send an e-mail for some info.

Think jointer head sizes are generally larger than planer due to the operational max depth of cut and related geometry. The mass of the head -- flywheel -- may also come into effect at the larger depth of cut. On my 460mm tersa, I can take over 30mm depth of cut -- that would be a scary operation (and have never done it), but you can... The thing is 7.5HP 3 phase.

At some point it’s just a black box and really don’t care how it works as long as it does, but now I’ve gotten a bit curious.

As for the OP, many smaller shop tools below 3HP can be wired as 110 or 220 – depends on the motor technology. In some cases, the owner’s manual will give you the info – sometimes not. Look at the motor plate for alternate wiring. If the unit has a magnetic switch, it would need to be rewired, so it may not be as simple as switching the leads on the motor (which is why the manual may not give you the info)... Also, you need to take the marketing HP specs with a bit of salt – look at the plate on the motor for the actual power requirements.

If you look back at woodworking machines made in the 1950's or so, you'll see that the motors consistently have less HP than their modern day counterparts. Back then Delta and Powermatic 8" jointers typically came with 3/4HP to 1.5 HP motors, and yes, they ran on 110V.

What strikes me is that woodworkers back then still had to joint an 8" wide piece of wood, and that those machines, if anything, were beefier than 8" jointers today. So why was a 1 HP motor enough back then for an 8" jointer, and today we need twice that?

I know that people talk about differences between old motors and new ones, but those differences are really between A.C. motors found in machinery and universal motors that are in your router or shop vac, where peak HP is an allowable measure. The difference between Powermatic's 1 HP motor that went into an 8" jointer in the 1960's and the 2 HP motor that goes into Powermatic's current 8" jointer is much smaller in terms of how HP is measured and what that means for the motor.

Theroretical HP rating on a power line are just that and are meaningless, its only a small part of the math. HP rating come from alot more rpm, torque shaft diameter and Im sure there are more and those number come from many other numbers the simple watts to hp conversion really has no use. Max bearing speed and life play a critical roll to machine design. Cutter head weight and design play a critical roll in bearing life, an it can go on and on as to the factors that go into machine design. Cutter heads are designed for feed rates, cutter depth and chip load. There are just way to many factors to these machines besides hp and line voltage, to many for my tiny brain.

"I can get a 12in planer that runs on 110 and was wondering why I can't get over a 6in jointer that runs on 110 as well."

It boils down to rpm and mass. Simply put you cant run a big jointer at high rpm and get the cut quality and machine life expected from a larger machine. You cant replace torque with speed like you can with a router. We all have routers that well exceed the max theoretical HP rating of a 15a 110v line. This is done with pure speed and low mass. If you used a panel raiser in your router for very long the mass is going to destroy the bearings with the excess heat produced by the speed. If you reduce your speed to make up for the mass you reduced the HP, max cut depth, and cut quality. Then again there are just to many factors that go into machine design.

Yes you can get an 8" jointer like the delta that will run on 110v. Delta did the work and the design and HP is only a small factor in designing the machine. Head rpm, cutter angles, max depth chipload, and even pulley sizes can make it possible to have a machine with less HP. But this is also a homeowner class machine and probably part of the reason they designed it to run off 110v. You surely wouldnt joint boards all day with a powerfeed on this machine.

"For a production environment you have to make the tool to handle high usage which means low amps high volts for longevity. 220V motors are just longer life and higher torque motors in most instances. Necessary for an industrial purchase and able to handle lots of hardwood jointing. It's just a matter of selling for the market from what I can see.

Just not all that many home owners have room for a 12" jointer so for the few most makers would sell, I don't think it's worth it for most to spin up a production line.They just wouldn't sell all that many at a price point they could make a decent profit. "

Truely all jointers are homeowner and very small shop machines, real production shops dont use jointers.

Don

I still don't understand why a 13" lunchbox planer requires less power than a 8" jointer. Assuming straight blades on each, they are both making 1/64" to 1/8" cuts in wood, the are both cutting with the grain, and both want to leave a good, smooth, surface. So why does the 8" cut require more power than the 13" cut?

Is it that 13" lunchbox planers are considered "hobbyist" while 8" cast iron jointer are considered "production"? In that case, the "hobbyist" tool could strain the motor and still last through the warranty period, while the "production" tool would need a beefier motor that would run cooler and last longer with the same load.

I still don't understand why a 13" lunchbox planer requires less power than a 8" jointer. Assuming straight blades on each, they are both making 1/64" to 1/8" cuts in wood, the are both cutting with the grain, and both want to leave a good, smooth, surface. So why does the 8" cut require more power than the 13" cut?

Is it that 13" lunchbox planers are considered "hobbyist" while 8" cast iron jointer are considered "production"? In that case, the "hobbyist" tool could strain the motor and still last through the warranty period, while the "production" tool would need a beefier motor that would run cooler and last longer with the same load.

The bigger machines rely on torque not speed. Speed causes heat, heat kill machines and cutters. The cutter makes a much longer cut. The lunch box makes dust compared to what comes out of a bigger machine. In order to have this kind of chip load you need power. Big machines are capable of even much bigger cuts for all different purposes. A jointer is used for tapering, mine for example has a 3/4" single pass capacity thats a 1.5" taper. Not going to do that with a little motor. Its not really all about width, you have to look at depth. Solid wood door frames are another great example. Door frames are made on a jointer, your not going to cut the stop rabbets on a low powered jointer even in multipal passes because they dont have the capacity. Every time the blade enters the wood you have chatter wether you can see it or not its there. Even if you took a universal motor and stuck it on a long bed jointer with some sort of ultra light small diameter high speed cutter you would have loads of chatter. Its just like comparing the cut on a router to a shaper. I guess you really have to experience the real difference.

Don

If you look back at woodworking machines made in the 1950's or so, you'll see that the motors consistently have less HP than their modern day counterparts. Back then Delta and Powermatic 8" jointers typically came with 3/4HP to 1.5 HP motors, and yes, they ran on 110V.

This is because the way motors are rated has changed over the years. In the far distant past, electric motors tended to be rated pretty "honestly". That is, they were rated for the maximum continuous power output under real-world conditions. At some point, the advertising department was placed in charge of motor specs. Suddenly, they started being rated by stall torque and max RPM (do some math and you arrive at HP from those) even though you can't simultaneously have the motor stalled (which produces max torque) and running at max RPM. Then they started being rated under "lab" conditions where they were chilled, blueprinted, etc, etc and would only perform at that level for a few seconds before they let the magic smoke out.

Theroretical HP rating on a power line are just that and are meaningless, its only a small part of the math. HP rating come from alot more rpm, torque shaft diameter and Im sure there are more and those number come from many other numbers the simple watts to hp conversion really has no use.

Sorry, but you're wrong. The nice thing about a power measurement is that it doesn't care about HP or RPM. It doesn't care if you produce the spec'd power at high torque and low RPM or high RPM and low torque. It's the same amount of power. Now, since thermodynamics is a real mother, all of the power that exits that motor via mechanical motion, heat, and sound has to arrive into that motor via the electric line. So the limits of the electric supply set a cap on the power output of the motor. That's a cap, not an attainable figure though. Because motors aren't perfectly efficient, the amount of mechanical power the motor delivers always will be less than the amount of electrical power going in. Depending on the motor design, possibly much less.

We all have routers that well exceed the max theoretical HP rating of a 15a 110v line.

No, we don't. We have routers who's electric motors are rated dishonestly to win the advertising pissing match over which one is the most powerful. Routers obey the First and Second Laws of thermodynamics. If you were to measure the mechanical power output of the router in your shop, you'd find it was much lower than what the manufacturer claimed and you'd find that it's safely within what can be supplied by the electric circuit into which it's plugged.

If you used a panel raiser in your router for very long the mass is going to destroy the bearings with the excess heat produced by the speed.

No, no it wouldn't. First of all, if you just turned the router on and let it spin in free space, this would be the only condition under which only the mass of the bit would matter. Under those conditions, there would not be additional heating of anything due to the mass alone. However, upon introducing the bit to the work, you'd find that larger radius is introducing different side loads onto the bearings and this may have an impact of bearing heating. However, the change in operating conditions is determined by the *shape* of the cutter, not the *mass*.

If you reduce your speed to make up for the mass you reduced the HP, max cut depth, and cut quality.

With regards to the issue of power and torque output, that actually entirely depends on the desing of the motor and speed controler. Cheap motors and speed controlers do tend to be designed in such a way as that the torque reduces as the RPM drops off. This is what leads to motors "getting weaker" as you turn down their speed. Obviously, their power output drops directly in proportion to the settign on the dial. Better designed motors and speed controlers will actually fight this. As you turn down the speed setting, the motor controller can force the unit to maintain a specific RPM. As the load on the cutterhead drops, the speed controler will reduce the toruqe output of the motor in order to maintain desired RPM. This obviously affects power so when you're holding the router in mid-air thinking about the work, it's consuming very minimal power. As the load on the cutterhead increases, the speed controler will increase the torque output of the motor in order to maintain the desired RPM, up until the point where the maximum power output of the motor is reached.

Second, regarding cut quality and other factors, you're missing a critical issue. Cutting edges have a particular speed through the work at which they perform best. In machining, you can find nice charts of "Speeds and Feeds" that will list optimal cutting speeds for you. When changing cutters, it's important to realize that different cutterhead diameters require different RPM to reach the same optimal speed. So when you rout with a 1/4" up spiral, you need to turn the bit 4 times as fast as a 1" up spiral to achieve the same cutting edge speed. So, with a panel-raising bit, which has a very wide radius, you turn down the RPM not because of the increased mass of the bit but because it's required to slow the cutting edge back down to the ideal speed for the wood.

As far as Beech's question about the planer vs the jointer, that's actually a good observation. It would be interesting to see how different the interaction of the cutting edges are with the wood between the two tools. Possibly there's a geometry difference that accounts for the differing requirements. The other thing that may be an issue is that most people expect a jointer to take somewhere between a 0.5mm and 1mm cut in hardwoods while people seem to accept that you might get no more than 0.25mm cut in a lunchbox planer without bogging it down.

This is because the way motors are rated has changed over the years. In the far distant past, electric motors tended to be rated pretty "honestly". That is, they were rated for the maximum continuous power output under real-world conditions. At some point, the advertising department was placed in charge of motor specs. Suddenly, they started being rated by stall torque and max RPM (do some math and you arrive at HP from those) even though you can't simultaneously have the motor stalled (which produces max torque) and running at max RPM. Then they started being rated under "lab" conditions where they were chilled, blueprinted, etc, etc and would only perform at that level for a few seconds before they let the magic smoke out.

I thought that standard motors were rated at continuous duty, at maximum load, and at the top end of their temperature range. That's a NEC/NEMA thing, isn't it? If the motor is rated for short duty, which is allowable, it has to say so on the motor plate.

But even accounting for ratings shenanigans, that's not going to make up the difference between a 1 HP motor on a 1950's 8" jointer and a 2 HP motor on one that you buy today.

I thought that standard motors were rated at continuous duty, at maximum load, and at the top end of their temperature range. That's a NEC/NEMA thing, isn't it? If the motor is rated for short duty, which is allowable, it has to say so on the motor plate.

While there may be a standard for measuring motors (I honestly don't know) there's definitely *NOT* a standard for advertising them. It wouldn't surprise me at all to find that if you're buying motors on an industrial scale there's a real way motors are scored. However, in power tools, the sky's the limit when it comes to lying. How else do you get an alleged 6.5HP shop vac that doesn't blow a 15A breaker?

But even accounting for ratings shenanigans, that's not going to make up the difference between a 1 HP motor on a 1950's 8" jointer and a 2 HP motor on one that you buy today.

Honestly wouldn't surprise me if it did. A 1/4hp Dayton motor from the 70s is stronger than a 1/2hp from Harbor Freight today. That one I know from personal experience.

While there may be a standard for measuring motors (I honestly don't know) there's definitely *NOT* a standard for advertising them. It wouldn't surprise me at all to find that if you're buying motors on an industrial scale there's a real way motors are scored. However, in power tools, the sky's the limit when it comes to lying. How else do you get an alleged 6.5HP shop vac that doesn't blow a 15A breaker?

Again, here we're talking about two different types of motors. The 6.5 HP shop vac has a universal motor that is allowed to be spec'ed in terms of "peak developed horsepower" and other crap.

But that's not what I'm talking about in my example. A.C. induction electric motors, such as you find on jointers, have pretty tightly regulated specs, all identified on the motor plate, and they have been defined for decades. And that's a thing that has to meet real standards, set by NEC or NEMA. There's a good explanation of the specs on a motor plate and what they mean here. (You may have to click past an ad to get to the page.)

As far as your 70's 1/4 HP Dayton being stronger than a 1/2 HP motor from Harbor Freight, it could be that back then there was a lot more headroom in a motor's capabilities compared to its rating on the plate. But if that 1/2 HP Harbor Freight motor, if it is an A.C. induction motor and if it says 1/2 HP on the plate, needs to be able to put out a real 1/2 HP, even if it is otherwise a piece of crap. Given your description, maybe the HF motor you're talking about might not be an induction motor. I wouldn't be surprised if that is the case. Harbor Freight currently lists a 7" jointer with a 1 HP motor that supposedly draws 5.9 amps at 110V. If you work through the math, the only way that could happen is if the motor was 115% efficient, which violates the laws of physics. My conclusion is that that jointer actually has a universal motor, which allows a different rating standard that allows it to be called a "1 HP" motor.

It's a glass half full sort of thing. As long as the machine does what I expect I could care less what the sticker says. The theoretical hp physics stuff mearly means I can put a world of hurt on my pc 3 1/4 hp router before it dies. The breaker is going to protect it long before I hit that 3 1/4 hp breaking point.

Induction motors are not governed unless they are used for blowers or pumps. Department of energy enforces blowers and pumps, they could care less about jointer and saws. In fact there was just a big change in the efficiency standards that hit the dust collector market hard.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.