Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been saving for a new table saw, and had settled on the Ridgid R4512 at Home Depot.

I've read reviews and comparisons, and feel confident in my choice.

But now that I've come up with the $500+ for the saw, it seems no Home Depot (at least none in the DFW area) carries them anymore.

Assuming this is true for the foreseeable future, which saws should I consider for the same price?

I know Craftsman carries pretty much the same saw, but there are subtleties about that saw I don't really care for (ie - the fence, the location of the power switch, etc).

Any suggestions?

Posted

I second the notion of checking craigs list. Your dollar will go farther when buying used and my experience has taught me that the type of people that have the decent equipment know how to treat it properly and if not you wont have to look hard to see it. I have weeded out so many meetings just by talking to the person before going! Shop it, it's worth your time and money.

Posted

A couple of questions about intended purpose. What's the primary task you'll be using this for? What capacity do you anticipate needing? Are the alternative ways to complete the same task? Can you wait to save up for a cabinet or higher end contractor saw or is there a specific need this purchase fills right now. This will help us offer some options.

I'd hesitate suggesting you buy an entry level contractor saw without more information.

Posted

I have been using the ridgid TS3650 for years now. It is a great saw, and you can get one used on Craigslist or kijiji every once and a while. Don't be confused with the newer models (TS3660) which are far lower quality. The 3650 went out of production a few years back. Check out www.ridgidforum.com for lots of unbiased opinions and such.

I have seen them for as little as 300 dollars used, which is a STEAL for this saw - they retailed for 1000 dollars for a long time.

Posted

I have been using the ridgid TS3650 for years now. It is a great saw, and you can get one used on Craigslist or kijiji every once and a while. Don't be confused with the newer models (TS3660) which are far lower quality. The 3650 went out of production a few years back. Check out www.ridgidforum.com for lots of unbiased opinions and such.

I have seen them for as little as 300 dollars used, which is a STEAL for this saw - they retailed for 1000 dollars for a long time.

The 3650 retailed for $549 USD. The TS3660 is the same as the TS3650, except that it has some extra leg support. You're correct that neither has been made for a couple of years. Both of these models were part of the evolution of several Emerson made Craftsman contractor saws, which went on to become the Emerson made Ridgid contractor saws (TS2412, TS2424, TS3612)....the next sequence were the TTI/Ryobi made Craftsman contractor saws, that went on to become the TTI/Ryobi made Ridgid contractor saws (TS3650, TS3660).

The successor to the 3650 and 3660 was the R4511, made by Steel City. It actually had several updates that were advantages, and a couple that were questionable.... the upgrades were the big cabinet mounted trunnion, which added a lot of mass and were easy to adjust. The motor was moved inside the enclosure, which helped DC quite a bit, and allowed for a shorter drive belt (more efficient power transfer and lower vibration). The upgrades also include a riving knife vs the standard splitter. At the same time, they changed from a cast iron top to granite....some loved it, some hated it, but the ill-advised double stacking of the saws in HD's warehouses caused a lot of damage. THe R4512 also sported a steel t-square fence design, that could have been similar to the Delta T2 (Beisemeyer "Lite"), but it was poorly executed and incorporated a split front rail, plus they opted not include faces, which made the fence appear unsubstantial....some liked the fence, and it appeared functional, but the overall perception seemed to be that it was a downgrade from the fence on the 3650/3660. I think with a cast iron table, and better execution of their fence, they would have clearly had a winner with this one, but they aborted the attempt as opposed to revising it.

A couple of years ago, Ridgid introduced the current R4512, made by Dayton. Gone was the granite top and steel fence, and back were cast iron and a dual locking fence that were similar to the TS3650's, but also gone were the cabinet mounted trunnions from the R4511, and cast iron wings from the 3650/3660, which were replaced with thin sheet metal wings. The motor remains inside the enclosure for improved DC. This saw is nearly identical to the current Craftsman 21833, and the Dayton 4KXD1, which all have similar guts to the new Grizzly G0715P. Unfortunately, many of these saws have had some alignment issues that appear to be from either poor machining at the factory, or poor design....could even be poor instructions or an adjustment that's not mentioned....the actual cause remains unclear, and doesn't effect all the saws, but reports aren't hard to find.

I disagree that the successors to the 3650 are "far lower quality". There are pros and cons with all of them either by design or execution of the design, but it does appear that Ridgid let the bean counters make some decisions that took a clear step backward with the steel wings of the R4512, no doubt to hit a price point....hopefully, the quality issues will be resolved soon, but it's already been too long.

Posted

The 3650 retailed for $549 USD. The TS3660 is the same as the TS3650, except that it has some extra leg support. You're correct that neither has been made for a couple of years. Both of these models were part of the evolution of several Emerson made Craftsman contractor saws, which went on to become the Emerson made Ridgid contractor saws (TS2412, TS2424, TS3612)....the next sequence were the TTI/Ryobi made Craftsman contractor saws, that went on to become the TTI/Ryobi made Ridgid contractor saws (TS3650, TS3660).

The successor to the 3650 and 3660 was the R4511, made by Steel City. It actually had several updates that were advantages, and a couple that were questionable.... the upgrades were the big cabinet mounted trunnion, which added a lot of mass and were easy to adjust. The motor was moved inside the enclosure, which helped DC quite a bit, and allowed for a shorter drive belt (more efficient power transfer and lower vibration). The upgrades also include a riving knife vs the standard splitter. At the same time, they changed from a cast iron top to granite....some loved it, some hated it, but the ill-advised double stacking of the saws in HD's warehouses caused a lot of damage. THe R4512 also sported a steel t-square fence design, that could have been similar to the Delta T2 (Beisemeyer "Lite"), but it was poorly executed and incorporated a split front rail, plus they opted not include faces, which made the fence appear unsubstantial....some liked the fence, and it appeared functional, but the overall perception seemed to be that it was a downgrade from the fence on the 3650/3660. I think with a cast iron table, and better execution of their fence, they would have clearly had a winner with this one, but they aborted the attempt as opposed to revising it.

A couple of years ago, Ridgid introduced the current R4512, made by Dayton. Gone was the granite top and steel fence, and back were cast iron and a dual locking fence that were similar to the TS3650's, but also gone were the cabinet mounted trunnions from the R4511, and cast iron wings from the 3650/3660, which were replaced with thin sheet metal wings. The motor remains inside the enclosure for improved DC. This saw is nearly identical to the current Craftsman 21833, and the Dayton 4KXD1, which all have similar guts to the new Grizzly G0715P. Unfortunately, many of these saws have had some alignment issues that appear to be from either poor machining at the factory, or poor design....could even be poor instructions or an adjustment that's not mentioned....the actual cause remains unclear, and doesn't effect all the saws, but reports aren't hard to find.

I disagree that the successors to the 3650 are "far lower quality". There are pros and cons with all of them either by design or execution of the design, but it does appear that Ridgid let the bean counters make some decisions that took a clear step backward with the steel wings of the R4512, no doubt to hit a price point....hopefully, the quality issues will be resolved soon, but it's already been too long.

I have owned the 3650 for quite a few years, and when I bought mine, it retailed for 999.99 CDN here in Ontario. I paid the full price, and kept my receipt. It went down (or was on sale - don't remember) to like 599.00 a few months later, and the good folks at HD gave me the difference back.

There are a lot of people on the ridgid forum who have discussed who made what model, and what changes have been made. I have used the 3650 and I can tell you first hand it is a very reliable and accurate saw.

I wasn't implying that all the successors to the 3650 are poor quality. I was thinking that if the orginal poster could get a good deal on a ridgid saw, he should keep his eye out for the superior 3650, which is easily confused with the 3660 (which I think I confused with the stamped wing 4512, after reading your reply).

I have many ridgid tools, and I agree with your assessment of the cheapening of their brand. They have started to elimate some of the things which many fans of the brand have noticed (like the elimination velcro cord wrap and lighted plug on their tools). I have started to skip over some of the ridgid tools, in favour of other brands.

Many of their older models are selling for cheap on places like craigslist and kijiji. If a person is looking for a good machine, the older ridgid models can be had for a great deal (like the TS 3650 and TP1300 for example).

Posted
The 3650 retailed for $549 USD. The TS3660 is the same as the TS3650, except that it has some extra leg support. You're correct that neither has been made for a couple of years. Both of these models were part of the evolution of several Emerson made Craftsman contractor saws, which went on to become the Emerson made Ridgid contractor saws (TS2412, TS2424, TS3612)....the next sequence were the TTI/Ryobi made Craftsman contractor saws, that went on to become the TTI/Ryobi made Ridgid contractor saws (TS3650, TS3660). The successor to the 3650 and 3660 was the R4511, made by Steel City. It actually had several updates that were advantages, and a couple that were questionable.... the upgrades were the big cabinet mounted trunnion, which added a lot of mass and were easy to adjust. The motor was moved inside the enclosure, which helped DC quite a bit, and allowed for a shorter drive belt (more efficient power transfer and lower vibration). The upgrades also include a riving knife vs the standard splitter. At the same time, they changed from a cast iron top to granite....some loved it, some hated it, but the ill-advised double stacking of the saws in HD's warehouses caused a lot of damage. THe R4512 also sported a steel t-square fence design, that could have been similar to the Delta T2 (Beisemeyer "Lite"), but it was poorly executed and incorporated a split front rail, plus they opted not include faces, which made the fence appear unsubstantial....some liked the fence, and it appeared functional, but the overall perception seemed to be that it was a downgrade from the fence on the 3650/3660. I think with a cast iron table, and better execution of their fence, they would have clearly had a winner with this one, but they aborted the attempt as opposed to revising it. A couple of years ago, Ridgid introduced the current R4512, made by Dayton. Gone was the granite top and steel fence, and back were cast iron and a dual locking fence that were similar to the TS3650's, but also gone were the cabinet mounted trunnions from the R4511, and cast iron wings from the 3650/3660, which were replaced with thin sheet metal wings. The motor remains inside the enclosure for improved DC. This saw is nearly identical to the current Craftsman 21833, and the Dayton 4KXD1, which all have similar guts to the new Grizzly G0715P. Unfortunately, many of these saws have had some alignment issues that appear to be from either poor machining at the factory, or poor design....could even be poor instructions or an adjustment that's not mentioned....the actual cause remains unclear, and doesn't effect all the saws, but reports aren't hard to find. I disagree that the successors to the 3650 are "far lower quality". There are pros and cons with all of them either by design or execution of the design, but it does appear that Ridgid let the bean counters make some decisions that took a clear step backward with the steel wings of the R4512, no doubt to hit a price point....hopefully, the quality issues will be resolved soon, but it's already been too long.

What is interesting is why some many Home Depot locations are not stocking the R4512 anymore. I was close to buying one recently but opted for a TS55 instead. I have looked at this saw very closely a few times but never pulled the trigger. I really liked the design of the R4511 but wanted cast wings. Like you said Knot, the bean counters are the ones that probably pushed for the steel wings vice the cast to hit their price point. Ridgid has a big following and some of the upgrades we were hoping for would have probably pushed the price of the saw closer to $700. It most likely was not worth the risk of trying target the more serious hobbyist at the risk of losing the weekend warrior.

As always excellent insight Scott!

Posted

Well, I went to my local HD today to get some garden items and wouldn't you know it they had an R4512 in stock after not having one for awhile now. I debated getting the saw right there but decided to sit on it for a few hours and at the very least run it by the wife. Let's just say she was not jumping for joy when I told her that HD had the saw in stock but she gave me the go ahead and I now have the saw sitting in the back of my SUV waiting for a buddy to help me unload it. I really would like a cabinet saw but space and power constraints limit my saw choices. It had to be mobile and tucked away when not in use. I looked at the Grizzly 0715P a few times and even went to show room to check it out in person. Its a nice saw but for the extra $400 (including a mobile base) it just did not seem worth it. I got the R4512 out the door for just over $500 after a 10% discount, so I was happy. Not sure if I am going to even put it together right away because I plan on getting the Delta T2 fence very soon. I also saw on one of the forums where someone added a cast iron benchdog router table to one of the wings, which I might also do in the future. Hopefully I didn't hijack the thread. Jchon, good luck with your table saw search!

James

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I have been using the ridgid TS3650 for years now. It is a great saw, and you can get one used on Craigslist or kijiji every once and a while. Don't be confused with the newer models (TS3660) which are far lower quality. The 3650 went out of production a few years back. Check out www.ridgidforum.com for lots of unbiased opinions and such.

Check out www.ridgidforum.com for lots of unbiased opinions and such.

I think forums such as that, abound with biased opinions.

Buy an old Unisaw and be done with it. See old ones that need cleaning up for $300 - $400, and mint ones for $800 - $1200.

A Powermatic 66 would also do the trick.

For those who are limited to 120V circuits, the older "bullett motor" Unisaws run on 15 amps, just fine.

Posted

I think forums such as that, abound with biased opinions.

I disagree. I have been a member of that forum for many years, and the members there will tell you stay away from products (ridgid or otherwise) which are of lower quality or that have issues. A couple of good example are the ridgid bandsaw, or the ridgid radio, and a particular ridgid chop saw. Very well documented on the forum. There was also an issue with the arbour on the TS, which was a hot topic for a long while.

Posted

Well, I went to my local HD today to get some garden items and wouldn't you know it they had an R4512 in stock after not having one for awhile now. I debated getting the saw right there but decided to sit on it for a few hours and at the very least run it by the wife. Let's just say she was not jumping for joy when I told her that HD had the saw in stock but she gave me the go ahead and I now have the saw sitting in the back of my SUV waiting for a buddy to help me unload it. I really would like a cabinet saw but space and power constraints limit my saw choices. It had to be mobile and tucked away when not in use. I looked at the Grizzly 0715P a few times and even went to show room to check it out in person. Its a nice saw but for the extra $400 (including a mobile base) it just did not seem worth it. I got the R4512 out the door for just over $500 after a 10% discount, so I was happy. Not sure if I am going to even put it together right away because I plan on getting the Delta T2 fence very soon. I also saw on one of the forums where someone added a cast iron benchdog router table to one of the wings, which I might also do in the future. Hopefully I didn't hijack the thread. Jchon, good luck with your table saw search!

James

James - It might be wise to get the saw put together within whatever HD's stated return policy and get it registered in their LSA program. If there's an issue, at least you'd be able to swap it for another of return it without any trouble. Good luck!

Posted

James - It might be wise to get the saw put together within whatever HD's stated return policy and get it registered in their LSA program. If there's an issue, at least you'd be able to swap it for another of return it without any trouble. Good luck!

Actually I never even took it out of the box and ended up returning it a few days later. It just did not feel right, not really the saw I wanted so I decided to take it back. Scott do you know anything about the new grizzly contractor saws?

James

Posted

Actually I never even took it out of the box and ended up returning it a few days later. It just did not feel right, not really the saw I wanted so I decided to take it back. Scott do you know anything about the new grizzly contractor saws?

James

Sorry, don't know too much about them. It looks to me like the G0661 and G0713 are the same except that the G0661 has a 2hp motor vs 1-3/4hp for the G0713. I've read a handful of positive reports, and no problems. The new G0732P looks pretty overpriced for what it is....small top, steel wings, lame fence....

Posted

Sorry, don't know too much about them. It looks to me like the G0661 and G0713 are the same except that the G0661 has a 2hp motor vs 1-3/4hp for the G0713. I've read a handful of positive reports, and no problems. The new G0732P looks pretty overpriced for what it is....small top, steel wings, lame fence....

I agree that the G0732P looks overpriced. I thought the same thing about the G0661 and G0713 but was not sure if I had missed something. Is there a big difference between the G0713 and G0715P besides the fact the G0715P has a fully enclosed cabinet? Maybe I should take a look at the GI saws. Thanks again Scott!

James

Posted

I agree that the G0732P looks overpriced. I thought the same thing about the G0661 and G0713 but was not sure if I had missed something. Is there a big difference between the G0713 and G0715P besides the fact the G0715P has a fully enclosed cabinet? Maybe I should take a look at the GI saws. Thanks again Scott!

James

The schematic drawings look similar, but not identical, so perhaps the G0713/G0661 are made in a different factory than the G0715P. Which could mean that it's less likely to have the same alignment issues that some of the G0715P's have had.

GI has some nice hybrid saws....look the fence over well on the models in this price range, as they offer a couple of different options.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have looked at the GI saws and like the 50-240 but not in love with the granite top and 50-200 but don't like the steel fence. The new jet pro shop saws with Irving knives also look good. The one I like the most is the PM 64b but at $1600 it' may be out of my range.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

When I read posts of $500+ saws, It's hard to believe that an old Craftsman 10" contractor saw, in real nice shape, will only sell for $125. I have one for sale now, and someone coming later to look.

I've had and used a few of these old saws.

If you put a Delta T-2 fence on it for about $150, you get a good saw for $275, or use orig fence, and have $125 invested.

Butt, if you can afford a cabinet saw, do it!

Then again, you can find used Unisaws, for decent prices, for a great saw.

Posted

== > Craftsman 10" contractor saw, in real nice shape, will only sell for $125.

​a big part of that write-down is the 'unknown' of how it was 'really' used. Similar to the proverbial used car driven only by grandma on Sunday to church.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 46 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined