Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Band Saw and Table Saw recommendations – best bang for low-range bucks?

Featured Replies

Band saws and table saws are few and far between on CL where I live. I'm looking to buy both. Any recommendations for these items?

I prefer spending a little more to buy quality as opposed to buying cheap and getting a crappy product.

But budget is always an issue and I'd prefer to stay below $300 for each.

I thought I'd tap the experience on this board ....

etienne

I prefer spending a little more to buy quality as opposed to buying cheap and getting a crappy product.

But budget is always an issue and I'd prefer to stay below $300 for each.

Good luck solving that puzzle! :D

Band saws and table saws are few and far between on CL where I live. I'm looking to buy both. Any recommendations for these items? I prefer spending a little more to buy quality as opposed to buying cheap and getting a crappy product. But budget is always an issue and I'd prefer to stay below $300 for each.

With those constraints, I'd say your only option is to be patient and keep looking for a deal on used equipment.

-- Russ

Buy (new?) and not off CL? Though I don't know the price off the top of my head, I think one of the Rikon tabletop bandsaws sells for around $300 though that is the smallest size and may or may not meet your needs.

Otherwise, unless it's a generous CL buy, I can't see getting a decent saw for $300. I don't even see many decent portable jobsite table saws going for that.

  • Author

Good luck solving that puzzle! :D

With those constraints, I'd say your only option is to be patient and keep looking for a deal on used equipment.

Well, what reasonable figure should I be thinking about?

Look on the Evansville Indiana CL. Some good buys pop up every now and then. Be about 3 hour south drive for you, but might be worth it.

Well, what reasonable figure should I be thinking about?

Taking CL out of the equation, I would budget anywhere from $600-$1000 on an average table saw. Depends on what kind of saw, though. Contractor saws can be had for the lower end of the spectrum than cabinet saws. My cabinet saw was $800-900 IIRC, but WoodCraft was clearing their floor models and was selling it at a $300 discount.

Bandsaw, a floor standing model, I'd go $500-$1000. The most basic Grizzly one sells for $500-ish (but add freight charges). Rikon 10-325's are a very good bang for the buck, sells around $950-ish. But Rikon stuff goes on sale at WoodCraft all the time, got mine for $800.

Well, what reasonable figure should I be thinking about?

That depends on what you consider "quality." If you asked fifty people you'd get fifty different answers. I made the decision to invest more than a thousand dollars each on the big five...table saw, bandsaw, jointer, planer, router table. Some people will find that a ridiculous amount to spend, and some people will say I bought garbage...the sky's the limit when it comes to tool prices.

But for $300, your choices are very limited, and you'll be buying a contractor table saw and a "hobbyist" bandsaw. That certainly doesn't mean they can't work for you, but you won't find a lot of guys put those tools in the "quality" category...even though they can still be great tools for the right applications.

There aren't many new $300 saws that I'd consider. I'd split up the $600 budget differently.... spend $500 for a better TS, and get a Bosch jigsaw until you can save up for a decent BS. The Ridgid R4512 and nearly identical Craftsman 21833 get mainly good reviews at the $500 mark...the Ridgid has a better warranty, and they'll sometimes accept a 20% HF coupon.

Spend most/all the budget on the one you need the most (TS in my opinion if you have neither now) and save for the other.

If I were you, combine your budget to get a decent TS. New table saws in that price range will be frustratingly dissappointing. You can get a contractor saw (and by that I mean one with a cast iron top, belt driven motor) at the box stores. For a little bit more, I would consider this saw as well: http://www.grizzly.com/products/10-Hybrid-Table-Saw-with-Riving-Knife-Polar-Bear-Series-/G0715P

  • Author

If I were you, combine your budget to get a decent TS. New table saws in that price range will be frustratingly dissappointing. You can get a contractor saw (and by that I mean one with a cast iron top, belt driven motor) at the box stores. For a little bit more, I would consider this saw as well: http://www.grizzly.c...-Series-/G0715P

THanks. I think that's what I'll do.

etienne

There aren't many new $300 saws that I'd consider. I'd split up the $600 budget differently.... spend $500 for a better TS, and get a Bosch jigsaw until you can save up for a decent BS. The Ridgid R4512 and nearly identical Craftsman 21833 get mainly good reviews at the $500 mark...the Ridgid has a better warranty, and they'll sometimes accept a 20% HF coupon.

X2

I purchased my Ridgid contractor saw off CL for $400 and it hasn't disappointed me yet. I have probably already outgrown it but poor men have poor men ways. I also purchase a Ridgid 14002 bandsaw off CL for $190 and it'll get the job done as well with a few cheap mods (new belt, better blade, proper set up...). I worked with the same budget as you and accomplished my goals. I see no reason you can't as well.

Neither of these tools would be considered professional grade, but I think I did very well for the money I spent and they are a good fit for an intermediate wood worker such as myself.

==> If I were you, combine your budget to get a decent TS

+1 .. Seriously, if you get a cheep tool, you will just replace it anyway. You can also check eBay for 'local pickup' listings.. I sold a jointer, TS and some other stuff that way...

If it was me, I would buy a good bandsaw with your budget. Bear in mind, tho, I am using a lot of hand tools.

I have to agree with PaulC. There are $200-@300 in additional table saw costs that usually are not factored in right away. A good combo blade, dado blade, safety equipment, miter gague and a few other misc. accessories. I would go with a bandsaw, this saw is within your price range http://www.grizzly.com/products/14-Deluxe-Bandsaw/G0555LX. I have a very similar bandsaw, the G0555P but without the cast wheels. I think this is a very nice bandsaw for under $500.

Although I love bandsaws more than table saws (I have 6 of the former) most people will get more use from a table saw. One could certainly use just a bandsaw BUT planning this around a 14" cast clone is pretty ambitious. If we were talking 20+" saws than it is much more feasible.

It's worth noting that it's certainly possible to spend $200-$300 in TS accessories, but not mandatory ....many are optional. A decent combo blade can run as little as $30, and will leave a glue ready edge right off the saw. While nice to have, a dado blade and aftermarket miter gauge are optional, and push devices and crosscut sleds can be easily made in the shop. Also worth noting....the BS leaves a rougher cut with an unglueable edge that would need to be addressed....planer, jointer, hand plane, sander, etc,

I have to agree with PaulC. There are $200-@300 in additional table saw costs that usually are not factored in right away. A good combo blade, dado blade, safety equipment, miter gague and a few other misc. accessories. I would go with a bandsaw, this saw is within your price range http://www.grizzly.c...Bandsaw/G0555LX. I have a very similar bandsaw, the G0555P but without the cast wheels. I think this is a very nice bandsaw for under $500.

I just bought the Grizzly G0555LX bandsaw and I'm loving it!

Tough one here. I think i would agree with most others, that you should combine your budgets and purchase a good TS. In many shops, the TS is the workhorse, and can perform many operations. If you want the accessories (like a Tenoning jig, etc), sometimes they also pop up on sites like CL.

Another option is to buy neither, and join a woodworking club or guild. All the tools there will be of high quality, and will be well maintained. Then you can spend your 600 dollars on lumber to build some stuff (or keep saving up). When you budget allows, then purchase the tools for your own, home shop.

We might be able to offer better suggestions if we knew what kind of woodworking you do, and what tools you have already.

I'm not sure that a TS is an ideal purchase in your budget, but no way to know that without more info.

  • Author

We might be able to offer better suggestions if we knew what kind of woodworking you do, and what tools you have already.

I'm not sure that a TS is an ideal purchase in your budget, but no way to know that without more info.

I would like to start doing higher quality furniture than I have to this point (with hand tools). That means: dining tables, dressers, end tables, bed frames, etc.

I would like to start doing higher quality furniture than I have to this point (with hand tools). That means: dining tables, dressers, end tables, bed frames, etc.

I'd definitely go with a decent a TS then...

You might consider whether you need a tablesaw or not, if you want to do a lot of casework that will probably be the case. I'm not going to reinvent the wheel here, you can check this article for the pros and cons.

http://www.thewoodwhisperer.com/articles/life-without-a-tablesaw/?category_name=tools-articles

I do however think if you're looking to spend $1000 on both a tablesaw and bandsaw you're going to have to buy used to get quality.

I dearly love bandsaws, I think the minimum for a shop is 3 with a minimum wheel size of 16" BUT I still feel the tablesaw should be the center of the shop for most power tool oriented flatworkers. I see the argument made for no table saw all the time, but in almost every instance it is academic in that the perseon proffering the option owns and uses a table saw themselves. There are primary handtool workers and plenty of turners that only own a tablesaw, there are some that have switched to a track saw and possibly a miter saw and do without a tablesaw BUT that isn't the most economical choice compared to a solid low budget new or used tablesaw. In the end if you are going to do machine oriented flat work I think the table saw makes the most sense as the first stationary saw, on the flip side if you are going to do flat work with the bandsaw as main cutting machine a 14" cast saw seems like a pretty poor choice...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.