Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collection 101 – what do I need?

Featured Replies

hey all --

two months into my new hobby and I'm already tired of brooming up shaving and sawdust. I'm also uneasy about having my "shop" coated in fine wood dust. It looks like the place has survived a nuclear winter.

So I'm ready to buy a dust collection system, but what to buy is unclear to me. I'm interested in furniture, so I have a few of the "big four:" a grizzly jointer, a delta 10" table saw, and a dewalt portable 13" planer. These all have ports for dust collection.

What do I need, and can some quality be achieved on a budget? Apparently I need a vacuum and I also need a dust separate -- these are two separate things, right? What about moving the system around? A lot of pros seem to have a network of tubes around the shop so that their major power tools are stationary. But apart from my table saw, my other tools are mobile...

any advice for a noob would be great.

thanks.

This is essentially the same model I started off using. The pleated filter goes a long way toward removing the very fine dust. You can incorporate a cyclone separator, too. When I built my new shop, I moved to a 3HP Oneida Dust Gorilla and fully ducted system. While that is definitely superior, you can get by with the former unit, but yes, good DC is a must in a shop.

I have a Delta 50-760 it's portable easy to change bags 1200 CFM I bielieve I bought it on sale at the Rockler store in Seattle on sale for $300+/- about three yrs ago I love it, but I've never had anything to compare it too except a Rigid shopvac and bielieve it or not that kept up with my Delta 12" lunch box planner. It's seems to me pretty easy to move from machine to machine except when the shop mess gets to great, and thats usually my cue to stop and clean up. Wow just looked it up the price, dust collection has got alot more expensive http://www.cpodeltam...492&zmap=50-760 Good luck

If you go the shop vac plus separator route, definitely consider building a Thein separator if you want to save a few bucks.

-- Russ

How much can you spend on a DC system? Oneida has various levels/sizes of their cyclone (dust deputy) separators, and when combined with a single stage DC will give you a top notch system for a reasonable price. Here's what I have, which is more than what I need now but is something I can grow into.

Grizzly G0548Z 2HP Canister Dust Collector

Oneida Super Dust Deputy

And stay away from cheap hoses. I'd recommend Wynn Environmental

You can go a few ways with dust extraction. Like Vic and the others have said, a 2 horse unit will be fine at this stage. I bought a 2 horse and also fitted a pleated cartridge filter and found it to work very well. The cartridge filter filters out to 1 micron where the standard needlefelt filter is only good to 5 microns. Might sound like a lot of mumbo jumbo but the 1 micron solution works very well. It also allows me to keep the filter clean due to its built in rubber cleaning paddles. This unit can be wheeled around the shop to where ever you need it and save you a heap of money. If you want to spend more on a seperator you can, but the plastic collection bags that are standard to the 2 horse dusty are relatively cheap so hold off on a cyclone at this stage.

A shop vac works very well if you have a small cyclone such as the dust deputy fitted to it but it will not be great for the jointer or thicknesser if doing wide boards and lots of them. From the info you gave I don't see this as a problem so maybe a shop vac would suffice for the moment. It can also be used as a vacuum cleaner later on if you lose interest in carpentry.

I also have the delta 50-760, which is a 1.5 HP collector. It is a single stage unit (no cyclone), and comes standard with a 1 micron filter bag, and 6 mil plastic bags.

I did a lot of research before selecting a DC, and decided to go with the delta for a few reasons:

1. CFM is very high for this unit - best in it's class according to Fine Wood Working magazine

2. Cost - this unit is reasonably priced - I paid about 400 CDN 5 years ago

3 filtration - This unit comes standard with a 1 micron bag, which almost no other collector does (most come with a 5 micron bag)

I use the Delta to collect dust from one machine at a time, and wheel the unit around to my machines. I use a 5 foot length of flex hose. It works great.

If you cluster your machines, it takesd about 3 seconds to disconnect and reconnect to another machine.

Someday I will buy an oneida cyclone, but they are about 2000 dollars here in canada, before piping the shop.

If you get a roll around DC with a 1hp or less motor its best to use it on 1 machine at a time for maximum

performance. Invest in the dust right connection fittings at rockler(16.99) it makes moving and hooking up to all your equipment a breeze.

My advice for any DC newbie would be to read every word on the Bill Pentz website, then ignore it. Welcome to the wormhole. :blink:

  • Author

My advice for any DC newbie would be to read every word on the Bill Pentz website, then ignore it. Welcome to the wormhole. :blink:

Just ignore and get, Woodshop Dust Control...

So confused right now.

Just keep it simple. You know you need to collect dust to keep your shop clean and keep your lungs healthy. Get a decent collector, with a minimum of 1 micron filtration. If you are on a budget, get a single stage collector that can be wheeled around your shop to get to all your machines (the delta 50-760 is about 400 bucks). If you have the means, get a cylone collector (about 1500 bucks).

I am thinking about adding dust collection to my tiny shop especially because if I am going to add a table saw soon. This is what I am thinking about getting, its small portable and seems that it would do the job much better than a shop vac. I was think about putting it on a mobile base and just moving it from tool to tool. In the future when I get a bigger shop and want a "real" dust control system I can just dedicate the Rikon to one tool.

If its in your budget James the grizzly 2hp is only 75.00 more and it should serve all yours needs in the future.

post-5469-0-79312900-1345398245_thumb.jp

You can get the same info from Bill Pentz's website that you can get from that wood shop dust control book. I found a copy online to read for free. If your interested in your options just skip the parts on the hazards to your health.

I myself started out with a 1 hp delta 2 bagger and it was fine when I was working out of a 10' x 14' building with the double doors always open. Once my wife got my current 24' x 24' shop with climate control built it became a different story and I found out what I really had was a chip collector that pumped fine dust into the shop.

Thats when I got online and did some research and decided that this one time I was going to the extreme. I figured might as well cry once and be done with it. Cost me $1200 for the whole system but it was worth it and thankfully Bill Pentz was nice enough to post his design online for free.

post-202-0-86059400-1345402506_thumb.jpgpost-202-0-33058600-1345402559_thumb.jpg

If its in your budget James the grizzly 2hp is only 75.00 more and it should serve all yours needs in the future.

I like that one the only problem is its wired for 220v and I only have 110v available.

Etienne,

Let us know what you have to spend. This will give us a better sense of what is realistic given your budget. As you can see, opinions on what may or may not be the best dust collection system are almost endless without some sort of parameters to focus suggestions.

  • Author

Etienne,

Let us know what you have to spend. This will give us a better sense of what is realistic given your budget. As you can see, opinions on what may or may not be the best dust collection system are almost endless without some sort of parameters to focus suggestions.

I have about $500 to spend, give or take $50... it looks like there's a big jump from the Delta 50 -760 that a lot of people are recommending here and the cyclone systems....

etienne

Alan kind of touched on this...the system you need to buy depends on what you want it to do. If you are just looking for a DC to suck up all the chips and shavings, the bulk of the mess so to speak, then almost any model, any brand will do that job. But if you're wanting to collect the fine dust, the particulates that create the nuclear fallout look in your shop - AND particulates so small you can't even see but still get into your lungs - then you're gonna need to do a lot more research and buy a much bigger unit...which will cost far more than your $500 budget.

I work in the garage, usually with the doors and windows wide open, fans blowing and respirator on when I'm in the thick of it, so I opted to go cheap(ish) on my DC with a 2HP unit and an aftermarket cyclone, vented outside. It cleans up 99% of the chips and shavings but is basically ineffectual when it comes to the fine dust. If you have a basement shop, or a poorly ventilated garage shop, or you hate respirators, or you're (rightfully) uber-paranoid about breathing in the particulates, then you should look into a unit that has the ability to collect that fine dust. Any of those 1 1/2 to 2HP units simply won't cut the mustard if you're looking for true, comprehensive "dust" collection.

The reason I suggested the Bill Pentz site is because he goes into excruciating detail of the science and engineering behind a DC that gives you the most effective collection, but for most people, including myself, the task of creating that system becomes not only cost-prohibitive, but basically turns into a hobby unto itself...it seems there is no end to it and you can find yourself obsessed with efficiency and pulling your hair out over the details. So that's why I called it a wormhole and suggested that after you read the whole thing, ignore it. Ultimately I said screw it and just went with a basic model. And I'm completely satisfied until the doctor tells me I've developed polyps on my lungs. :D

But the Pentz site is a great *free* place to learn the intracacies of DC, even if you ultimately don't go to that extreme with your system. It also gives you lots of info that will be pertinant to ANY system you create, so it's worth a read either way. Just like everything else in woodworking, it boils down to personal preference, and only you can decide what's right for you and your shop.

If you can get a decent “Shop-Vac” you could add something like this. Or, if your into DIY, you could go with Russ’ suggestion. The separator catches the big stuff and the shop vac filter catches the fine stuff. Some of the higher end shop vacs like the Fein and Festool, are also quieter than lower end shop vacs. Usually the advertisement will say if it’s a quieter shop vac, and also list a decibal value. I have no experience with this type of set up, so maybe someone else can comment on how well this combination works.

Here's one of the advertisement pictures for the Dust Right Separator (click on).

post-302-0-59321700-1345476971_thumb.jpg

I have a very small shop, with no room (or power) for a DC. I have a 6.5HP Ridgid vac and a 5-gallon bucket with a Woodstock separator lid. Wood Magazine has a review on it in the October 2012 issue and it compares favorably to the more expensive Vortex and Dust Deputy. Works fairly well, and I have enough power that it can clear the planer unless I'm using the far left side.

Check out our website for our used equipment listings, or feel free to give me a call to discuss your dust collection options. www.paperanddustpros.com 816-966-1473

  • 8 months later...

Necroing a thread since I was going to ask the same question.

 

I'm about to add dust collection.. the Delta 50-760 seems well recommended.

 

I've got a garage shop 15x25-ish. I'm about to assemble a Sawstop PCS, I have a Dewalt 735, and I'll probably be adding a bandsaw and an 8" (hopefully) jointer in the coming months. 

 

I don't mind wheeling something from tool to tool right now but this Delta looks like it has enough pull to handle sitting in the corner of the shop if I decide to add ductwork. Is this a decent assumption?

 

Would it still be advisable to add an air cleaner to the shop as well?

 

 

I don't mind wheeling something from tool to tool right now but this Delta looks like it has enough pull to handle sitting in the corner of the shop if I decide to add ductwork. Is this a decent assumption?

 

 

No it does not have a large enough inlet. But on the other hand its better than nothing. I would just get one of those long stretchy 4" hoses from rockler and move it from machine to machine.. 

No it does not have a large enough inlet. But on the other hand its better than nothing. I would just get one of those long stretchy 4" hoses from rockler and move it from machine to machine.. 

 

In that case I may just suck it up and get a larger collection system.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.