lclocke Posted September 3, 2012 Report Posted September 3, 2012 I'm in the market for a new planer. As I'm doing all the research I thought I'd ask everyone on here what their thoughts were on certain planers. Which would you choose and why? Share a bad experience with a certain model if you have one. I am leaning towards the grizzly and budget isn't really the reason. I do mostly work for family and co-workers and have just recently got a request from a hospital for children's tables and chairs but other then that the extra money from the difference of a jet to a grizzly can get me some much needed hand tools and signed up to the hand tool school. So just to shoot the breeze which do you pick? Quote
STL Woodguy Posted September 3, 2012 Report Posted September 3, 2012 Are you considering the smaller lunchbox planers or the big stationary ones? (I assume you are looking at stationary units as you mention JET and I can't think of ever seeing a JET lunchbox.) There are pros and cons to both. I've only had experience with the lunchbox DeWalt's and my Jet 13" planer, so can't offer much as far as opinions on a wide variety of planers. FWIW, in the brief time I've had it I'm perfectly happy with my 13" Jet JPM-13CS, no-frills but the price is right, it's easy to move, takes up little space and gets the job done. While it's marketed as a planer/moulder, honestly the moulder feels tacked on and more trouble than it's worth, so I ignore that and think of this as a 13" stationary planer, somewhere between the lunchbox planers and the big 15" ones. No matter which one you go with, it's important to adjust the infeed and outfeed tables properly. I've seen some people give bad reviews to certain models due to snipe, and adjusting the tables correctly would have probably solved their problem. Quote
rodger. Posted September 3, 2012 Report Posted September 3, 2012 I have the ridgid TP 1300 (2 blade model) and I am really happy with it. It does, however, only cut 13" at a time. If I had a larger budget, I would go with a new spiral head cutter model. These planers are supposed to be "the cat's meow", and all the literature I read on them is positive. Quote
lclocke Posted September 3, 2012 Author Report Posted September 3, 2012 Franklin ive been seeing alot of ridgid equipment in shops lately. I always wondered about them. I do have there sliding compound mitre saw i got from craigslist and i wouldnt give it up for anything. Home depot had a sale a few months out on the ridgid planers for $200 but i was leary of it. Glad to hear good things about it. Thanks for sharing guys. Quote
Craig Posted September 3, 2012 Report Posted September 3, 2012 You could go with a lunchbox 13" planer and use the extra money for a 16/32" drum sander like the Performax. Quote
Bombarde16 Posted September 3, 2012 Report Posted September 3, 2012 So just to shoot the breeze which do you pick? Honestly, you can get great results from a cheap Ryobi lunchbox...just as you can get poor results from a bank busting Powermatic. It all comes down to how you use the machine and how you care for it. Look for a planer that won't break the bank when time comes to buy a set of blades. Pick a planer whose blades are easy to change and potentially to sharpen. Quote
lclocke Posted September 3, 2012 Author Report Posted September 3, 2012 Craig and rob those are good points. I use a delta 12" lunchbox planer now and it does an amazing job but I spend one a day month dedicated to cleaning and check tune of all my tools. Im going to 15" mainly because most panels I glue up are 30" or bigger and the 15 will save some time and free up bench space. I just rebuilt my shop (tornado) and put up a 1200 sq ft building so I have more then enough room. Speaking of drum sanders. Ive looked at a few and really like the 10" open end grizzly has. Quote
TRBaker Posted September 3, 2012 Report Posted September 3, 2012 I have a Dewalt 13" and love the results and the ease of blade change. The blades are reversable throw-aways and cost about $55.00 to replace. The only reason I have this planer and not a Powermatic is because I can't afford a Powermatic. I've used a lot of Grizzly planers and they are really fine machines. We put them to the test on the job sites where we set up a millwork shop. The Rigids we tried performed well but wore out too fast. Keep in mind that we were running thousands of board feet through the planers. Quote
knotscott Posted September 4, 2012 Report Posted September 4, 2012 Grizzly and Jet are often very similar, and in many cases are forged in the same plants. Jet gets a premium largely because they have a solid dealer network that deserves a cut, and they have a longer warranty. Grizzly is a direct importer....if you're willing to be the middle man in the event of a problem, there are legitimate savings to be had. Whether or not to get a stationary or portable planer is a decision you'll have to make. Few can argue, the power, longevity, and mass of a cast iron stationary planer over a 90# portable, but the portables can be very capable. In a portable I'd look to DW, Delta, Ridgid, Steel City, or Makita, but would skip the portable Grizzly G0505, simply because after shipping costs, it offers few advantages over the others, doesn't have a cutter head lock (more snipe), and the DC chute is extra. Quote
robjeffking Posted September 5, 2012 Report Posted September 5, 2012 You can try to use the harbor freight coupon at HD and get the rigid for 320.00 with the Lifetime Service Agreement. The steel city comes with the improved cutting head for 600.00. I think the dewalt 735 would be your best choice you can always upgrade to the spiral cutting head in the future. Quote
TimInGrained Posted September 8, 2012 Report Posted September 8, 2012 I use a Delta 22-580 I got off CL for rock bottom price of $250!! I mill large lots (150 bd ft +/-) of reclaimed/repurposed wood. It does not complain whine or cry I will note the dust port is very oddly placed almost a 1/2'' above the outfeed. On large 8/4 boards it does make the rollers slip. Everything I have seen or researched of the DW735 is very impressive It has 2 cutters, and a well placed dust exhaust. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted September 8, 2012 Report Posted September 8, 2012 I've been using my portable DeWalt 733 for ~ 13 years, and have used large stationary machines in other shops. If the 733 were to die today, I'd probably buy another lunchbox. Here's why, in my personal situation, I prefer to leave the big planers to mills and commercial shops: - I've never purchased wood that wouldn't fit through the lunchbox. Even if I did, I still couldn't joint the first face. - Glue-ups can be hard to plane, as there are often grain reversals. I like to plan my panels based on appearance, not how well a machine will work on it. - The lunchbox takes up far less space. - If I buy large amounts of stock, say... for trim, my dealer will surface it with his van-sized helical head machine, in about 15 seconds, for no extra charge. Running laps around my planer for hours, planing large amounts of stock, is not enjoyable at all... About 8 years ago, I was thinking of upgrading the planer to a 20", but spent the money on a Performax 22/44 instead. Fitted with 24 grit paper when necessary, the thing can remove wood faster than you'd think. I normally leave it set up with 120. Most of my stock goes from rough to the lunchbox to the 120 grit drum. Depending on use and finish plans, it then is ready for a ROS or hand planes and scrapers. I can take kitchen or built-in parts right to 220, keeping them identically sized all the way. To me, to match the lunchbox / sander combo, you'd need at least a 20" stationary machine with a good segmented cutterhead. After spending the necessary large dollars, you'd still lack the ability to finish sand stacks of stiles and rails, assemblies, ganged stock on end, and end grain. Quote
Sac Posted September 8, 2012 Report Posted September 8, 2012 Everything I have seen or researched of the DW735 is very impressive It has 2 cutters, and a well placed dust exhaust. It is actually a three knives. Quote
tim0625 Posted September 11, 2012 Report Posted September 11, 2012 It is actually a three knives. Three is kurect and me really likes mine.... Quote
TRBaker Posted September 11, 2012 Report Posted September 11, 2012 three knives, two speeds....I like the two speed option. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.