Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The best AC for your shop?

Featured Replies

I live in coastal South Carolina. We often go through the summers with temps from 92 to about 102 along with lots of humidity - often over 90% to go with the heat. I've had an older, large window AC unit sitting in the corner for years. A couple months ago, I installed it in my 450 sq ft shop. It works 'ok'...just ok...probably needs a little freon but I've just gotten my electric bill and it has increased an additional $200. That's too money for just "ok" but it is an older unit that is probably not very efficient.. I have some HVAC guys who are looking for a used package unit but nothing yet has turned up. The shop is brick over block on the walls with the roof/ceiling uninsulated and an asphalt shingle roof. While money is a consideration, I do want to be cooler. What do you have and what can you suggest?

Thanks

Tim

Tim,

I am in North Florida and I feel your pain... My evaluation of the problem was as folows:

1. No A/C

2. No insulation overhead

3. uninsuated metal garage door.

My Solution:

A. Insulate the south facing garge door.

B. Insulate overhead

C. Install a Split A/C system

Is there a way to connect it to your home central ac (assuming you have a forced air system)?

  • Author

My shop has an upstairs - there's a staircase and the upstairs is floored but whoever built it, didn't extend the plywood flooring all the way to the walls (where the rafters meet the walls). It's within 1 foot or so....it seems that what they were going for was just storage but never to heat and cool it. Since the upstairs is small, I could heat and cool it too and just roll insulation between the rafters. The front doors are two sliding doors about 10 ft wide each that roll on tracks. I'm planning to change that to something like this. So I am working toward sealing it and insulating it. Franklin, the home's AC unit is plenty large enough. Our home is 2100 Sq ft and when I replaced the HVAC unit 3 years ago, I had a choice of the 4 ton that is a little undersized or the 5 ton that is a little over sized. I chose the 5 ton and it comes with its own set of challenges BUT...having said all that, I could run a duct from the trunk line to the shop. My shop is a detached garage separated from the home by a cement walkway so it's not a long span. It could be good to transfer heat and cooling. Question...if I did that, how would I control when the air flowed into the shop? Are there butterfly valves that can be installed in the duct line that seal good enough to stop the air to the shop when I do not want it going there? Vic, if you're reading this, I know you are crawling out of your skin! "Redneck AC rigging...." :P It seems the most simple solution is for the shop to have its own dedicated AC unit. Croessler said "install a split AC unit"....since that's 2 grand there's a thread....thoughts???

Tim-

Hopefully Vic will pipe in here, but I can think of a lot of reasons why you do not want to consider using the house system in your shop.

Rather, you need to seal the space you want conditioned and then insulate. I would recommend that you consider using a spray foam (open or closed cell - they each have their strengths) and seal the entire structure from concrete pad up to rafters. I would keep the second floor open to the first so you can get some conditioned storage/workspace .

With the entire structure sealed as a large envelope, you can then compute volume and size a split-pack accordingly. Since you are primarily interested in cooling, you should consider having two supplies - one at each gable end on the second floor - to service your space and let thermodynamics handle the rest (ensuring you have sufficient openings in your floor around the perimeter).

Or you can seal the ceiling rafters of the shop (1st floor) with gyp, insulate to at least R-30, and address the walls with foam board or spray and use 1 split to service the first floor. You also need to address leakage thru any doors/windows.

If you really want to knock down the summer heat on your roof, there are some ol' boys in Alabama or Mississippi or such that manufacture a roof sprinkler system that shoots out a mist over your roof. It's temperature-actuated and pretty neat.

Or, if you don't care how your roof looks, you can get some liquid ceramic paint and paint over your roof. That stuff will reflect the sun's rays and not allow thermal flow-thru. And it supposedly lasts a long time. Folks are starting to use it on those fancy ISO container dwellings.

There's my two cents, and for a few bucks and some labor, you could be the coolest Redneck on the block.

My shop was a former photo studio. They painted the entire warehouse white and installed a 7 ton AC unit. The first summer we fired it up. It had to run all night to bring the temperature down to just below 80 . If you opened the garage door you could feel a flood of cold air pour off the loading dock and across the parking lot! It could not recover the rest of that day. It sure was nice to work in a cool shop untill the power bill showed up, an extra $400 for one month in 1989! We rarely used it after that and when the compressor blew a few years later it was easy to decide not to fix it.

Typical warehouse 24 ft wide by 65 ft long x 16 ft ceiling,concrete block walls , un- insulated flat asphalt roof and we are in the middle of the building with only the back wall exposed to the outside. Garage door is insulated

I recently got a Fujitsu 30CLX 2.5 tonne mini-split (30,000 btu). Works great in my 3-car garage shop. I'm in Arizona so we get the heat and for the past 3-4 weeks, it has been a full-on monsoon season with lots of humidity. It keeps up just fine even though my garage is marginally insulated. I plan on addressing that over the winter when I can open the doors and move things from one bay to the other bay to spray some foam insulation into the west-facing wall; that one is the heat culprit. Some foam systems are DIY only requiring two 3/4" holes drilled per bay; not difficult, just difficult to move stuff so winter it is.

I've run it all day on the weekends and for 3-4 hours at night during the week (likely 2 or 3 evenings) for the month of August; it was installed just before my August electric cycle. Got the bill early last week. If there was a difference, it was far less than $50 and the excess also includes some of my house A/C losing a blower motor slowly over a week so it cycled a lot before the repair.

I keep the shop at 78. With the air mixer on the unit, it feels good in here when dry-bulb is 85. If the shop starts at 95, it gets to 80 within 40 minutes (2-car bay; other lags due to poor circulation there). Tonight, I have it at 78. If tomorrow's high were 105, the shop would get to 85 by tomorrow night, 90 the next night, 95 the night after; it doesn't usually get hotter unless you open the door to hell.

But, the unit isn't cheap. It is apparently the favorite of the data center market where reliability is key. My installer installs a lot of units. His recommendation was "if you want the best, Fujitsu" for those reasons. Mitsubishi was second. LG he recommended against. I've known the guy for a decade and he's done a lot of work for us; he'd make more money if he wasn't so honest.

If you consider a Fujitsu, the 2 tonne unit is only $200 less than the 2.5 tonne. Considering the rest of the unit cost and installation cost, you'd be crazy not to pay the $200. Unlike home units, 'over-sizing' a mini-split doesn't carry a penalty, only a benefit (unless your home unit is all equally inverter driven like mine is).

A note on mini splits. You CAN oversize, but not more than about by half. If its oversized leass than that, the variable feed drive in the compressor will ramp down to what is needed. If you oversize too much, it can't ramp down far enough and you get heating or cooling you don't need or want. I would address you air infiltration and insulation the best you can first, then size a ductless heatpump. Mitsubishi, Fujitsu and Daikin are your best units.

Didn't know that about mini splits but makes sense. I'm going back and forth between a 1 ton(12000 btu) and 1.5 ton(18000 btu) unit for an insulated 20x20 garage. I think 1 ton would be enough but not totally sure, I've had both quoted to me by different AC guys.

Folks are beginning to look closer at mini splits, particularly in projects that have very tight, well-insulated envelopes. I have heard that their efficiency outstrips that of ground source heat pumps in certain applications.

Your best AC for your shop is a decent HVAC contractor... Seriously, they will come-in, design your system, etc probably for free if you give them a nod for the procurement. Designing someones mechanical systems from afar without drawings won't produce optimum results...

  • Author

Would this AC keep up? I ask because it's a cheaper way to go and I already have a window unit installed in the side of the building.

Tim, your biggest battle with any a/c that draws air from your shop will be keeping your filter clean. Rule of thumb that I was told was you need 1 ton for every 500 square feet, so that unit looks big enough. Just be advised that it will probably run constantly.

Your best AC for your shop is a decent HVAC contractor...

That's assuming they are familiar with and support ductless mini splits. If you throw too much of your trust into your average HVAC contractor, you probably won't end up with a ductless mini split, which in many situations is the best option. I encountered a significant amount of resistance from various HVAC contractors when having mini splits installed.

==> That's assuming they are familiar with and support ductless mini splits.

got to pick a good one...

But more importantly, different part of the countries have vastly diferent requirements for HVAC. Bet folks here in NJ care a lot more about the H in HVAC then you all in Arizona. That's the point of getting local support -- they know the environmental load and locally-supported equipment packages. You also need to get something supported locally -- at some point, the unit(s) will need repair and if you get something too out of the box, then you are screwed (been there, done that).

I think it would be fairer to say be an educated consumer and familiarize yourself with the options available but get a quote from a professional to see if you're totally off base.

Tim,

The sizing of your Mini split really depends on, not only the size (volume) of the space, but how tight (airsealed) it is and what the total U values are for the structure. Normally, a Manual J calc is performed to get the size. I have a very tight well insulated shop, which is 30x40. I could get away with a 1.5 ton easily, but am going up a size to 2 ton. There are things you have to take into consideration and hhh is correct that consulting a professional that can do the actual calculations is the way to go. If you have a department within your serving utility that will do this, even better, since they aren't trying to sell you anything.

While you can oversize a mini split system, you don't want to go too big. Mini splits have a variable feed drive on the condenser which allows for oversizing and even rewards it to some extent if not oversized too much. In a standard heat pump application, oversizing can cause big comfort problems and in a shop big rust problems, if you live in a humid area.

I would check out your local utility. Even if they won't do the calculations for sizing, they may be able to offer a blower door test to see how tight your envelope was created. AC Superstores has a sizing calculator, but it is grossly simplified and, in my opinion, grossly oversizes the recommended equipment.

I have heard that if you get a an AC unit that is too powerful, it can ice up. Also, it can short cycle, which increases wear and power consumption. I've heard that you want to size it so that it runs flat out without stopping on the hottest day of the year.

I'd be interested in what people think of this.

I have heard that if you get a an AC unit that is too powerful, it can ice up. Also, it can short cycle, which increases wear and power consumption. I've heard that you want to size it so that it runs flat out without stopping on the hottest day of the year.

I'd be interested in what people think of this.

Chip, my understanding is that an icing can be a number of things, of which sizing can play a role. All heat pumps go through a super heating cycle that is specifically to deal with the icing. So, the proper charge, deep vacuum, proper pairing with the interior unit, etc can be the cause of icing. Short cycling is not good for the compressor and in a humid environment will cause a cold and clammy room. Basically, the unit is too powerful and cools the room before it can be fully conditioned (dehumidified). Many of these sizing problems have a much broader range with the introduction of a variable speed compressor. Standard heatpumps should also have an exterior sensor to really work properly with an advance thermostat. Mind you, I am not an HVAC professional. I just around it quite a bit. By far my favorite system is the mini-split variable feed drive heat pumps. They can be ductless or ducted, although the ducted mini split systems REALLY need to be designed well for proper cfm.

==> I have heard that if you get a an AC unit that is too powerful, it can ice up.

more to do you humidity control. icing has more components. If you need 4 tonnes for your structure, there can be benefits to 4.5 tonnes, but the limit would be about 5 tonnes. Again, that's where a pro can come in handy.... figuring the amount of hvac you actually need for a given space is the one area where a pro can help. i missed this one myself and a pro corrected my estimates and got me what i needed -- i was off by over 3 tonnes based on 'web' learning...

  • 2 weeks later...

Similar issues with heat here in South Florida. I have an insulated garage door and a closed in, 2 car, 400 sq ft garage. I bought an inexpensive 25,000 BTU AC window unit and installed it in a door that swings into the existing door opening when I am using it, which is usually only on the weekends. I keep the temp around 72 when I'm working. I think insulation is the key, and I know that there are some areas where i can improve on that, like in the attic and around the door i built. Even with those issues, the a/c unit has no problem keeping up even in Aug and Sep.

post-2510-0-85870700-1348584207_thumb.jp

  • 4 months later...

I love mini-splits. We have here 3 Fujitsu heat pumps in the shop. Not only are they more reliable than central units, you only cool the rooms that need to be cooled! Our electricity bills are lower by installing them.I purchased the systems from an AC contractor friend, and with his help we did all the plant functional. Almost 500 to $ 600, did I spend on the overall system. Everything is easy to install.

 

AC and Refrigerator repair in Arlington VA

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.