rodger. Posted November 26, 2012 Report Posted November 26, 2012 After my stanley #5 took a dive off the workbench last week, I was very concerned with the sole (which received a small dent). I filed it out gently, and cleaned up the sole. I thought I was in the clear. Today I went to use it, and I noticed the tote was loose. I went to tighten a scew, and I noticed the tote had broken. Any ideas on how to repair it? Wood glue probably won't be any good, due to the nature of the break. Epoxy maybe? Make a new tote? Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted November 26, 2012 Report Posted November 26, 2012 maybe try looking on Ebay for a "parts plane" with a salvageable tote? Or, and this thought is completely un-researched so it may not be possible...drill both pieces to receive a dowel to beef up the joint then simply glue or epoxy it back together. Quote
duckkisser Posted November 26, 2012 Report Posted November 26, 2012 i would just make a new one its a simple shape and you can band saw it out and then file it down to create the curves you want. Quote
jhl.verona Posted November 26, 2012 Report Posted November 26, 2012 Did exactly the same thing on Friday, only a Record #5. Fortunately it rotated as it fell, and landed on the back of the blade. Dent in the heel of the blade, broken knob and tote. But no damage at all to the casting or frog, fortunately. Well, I needed the #5 back in action, so I just glued (PVA) the tote - the break was a the tip, not the heel - and knob back together and used some sticky tape. A couple of hours later and I was back in business. Knob and tote screwed down nice and tight, and still are. Not going to win any beauty prizes though... John Quote
KMoura Posted November 27, 2012 Report Posted November 27, 2012 You can glue your tote back together with CA glue and then use it as a template to make a new one, or if you do not want to do that there are a couple of guys on the internet who sells plane parts. The first guy is Bob Kaufman in Washington, and New Hampshire Plane Parts on Ebay. I have bought plane parts from both of them and the are pretty reasonable.I made a mistake, it is Bob Kaune in Washington, not Bob Kaufman. I was thinking of somebody else. 1 Quote
rodger. Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 Is the CA glue strong enough on its own? I am happy to glue it together and put it back into action if that's all it will take. Quote
Bob Rozaieski Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 Glue it back together with regular wood glue. If you really want to reinforce it, drill two holes up through the bottom and glue in some dowels. Quote
rodger. Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 Glue it back together with regular wood glue. If you really want to reinforce it, drill two holes up through the bottom and glue in some dowels. Even with the nature of the break? Wouldn't it be a weak joint? Quote
Craig Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 At one time Lee Valley had plans and instrucitons for making Totes on their website. Quote
Bob Rozaieski Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 Even with the nature of the break? Wouldn't it be a weak joint? Sorry, missed the picture as I was replying from my phone. I just assumed it was a typical break further up the handle, which is where the break happens 90% of the time. I'm actually surprised that yours broke where it did as that area should have long grain going right through it. So you're looking at an end grain to end grain repair. You can still do it though. Size the joint with thinned glue first. Regular wood glue will be fine. Just paint a thin coat on the end of each piece and let them sit for a few minutes to suck up the glue. It's dense rosewood so it probably won't suck up that much. After a few minutes, apply more glue and clamp the two pieces together. Let them dry and then reinforce with dowels. Make sure the glue dries before you drill the holes for the dowels so that the boring doesn't knock things out of alignment. Then, from the bottom, where things won't be seen, drill up at an angle from the small piece into the main part of the handle. Be careful not to drill the dowel holes where the threaded rod goes through the middle. You'll need one on either side of the hole. You probably won't be able to reinforce with anything more than 3/16" dowel. You might be able to sneak a 1/4" dowel in there, but 3/16" will probably be sufficient. Glue the dowels in, making sure they are a snug fit that has to be tapped home with a mallet...not driven, tapped . After the glue dries, saw the dowels off and flush them to the bottom of the tote with a paring chisel. 1 Quote
rodger. Posted December 2, 2012 Author Report Posted December 2, 2012 Well I tried TB3 (after sizing) and it didn't work very well. I expected this I suppose, as it's an end grain to end grain glue up. I tried epoxy (Gorilla) and it looked good. I wiggled the parts, and they held just fine. I cleaned up the plane and took it for a test drive with the repaired tote. The handle re-broke on the same spot after about a dozen passes. Looks like I have no other option but to build a new tote. I thought about reparing it via the above post, but it seems a difficult task. Quote
Brian Tracey Posted December 3, 2012 Report Posted December 3, 2012 Franklin Pug, An alternative ....if you don't have the time or inclination, is to check out Drozs Olde Tyme Stanley Totes and Knobs website. For around 25.00 he'll make you one out of Cocobolo. I've replaced a few on planes that I've rehabed. He does a great job at a great price. www.drozsoldetymestanleytotesandknobs.com/ Quote
rodger. Posted July 22, 2013 Author Report Posted July 22, 2013 I know this is an old thread, but I created a new handle for this plane a while ago. I installed it, and have been using it for a few months. It never fit quite right, having a bit of play. I decided to try a two part epoxy on the original handle, as I bought some for a repair/filler. It seemed to work really well. I'm gonna transfer the handle today and take it for a test drive. Here is the one I made, from maple. I didn't put any finish on it, and you can tell by the wear/dirt. Here is the repaired (hopefully) original. I cleaned up the extra epoxy a bit with a chisel, and I may sand it up and put some new finish on it later. Right now I just need my jack plane back! 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 "wear/dirt" = Patina. Sounds nicer 2 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted July 23, 2013 Report Posted July 23, 2013 I've got a good tote that was supposed to be a replacement for a Union #5 that I bought. However, the plane ended up not being worth the tote. It's yours if you want/need it. PM me. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.