00101 Posted December 30, 2012 Report Posted December 30, 2012 Hi I received a four piece set of Stanley sweetheart chisels for christmas. These being my first bladed hand tools that don't cost $10 at a home improvement store. Because of that, I don't really have any sharpening equipment. I started the scary sharp method to lap the backs flat with the intention of after hitting 1000 grit sandpaper to get a 5000 grit shapton stone to finish it off. I've used the sharpie trick to see where I've taken material off and have hit the whole back at every grit. Currently I'm on 600 grit sandpaper, and I've run into a small problem. The very front and back of the chisel are much more polished than the middle. This only seemed to happen after about another minute of fast strokes past the point where all of the sharpie was gone. Is this because the front and back, probably due my lack of skill with sharpening, had more pressure and have worn the sandpaper finer there? Or is it something else? More importantly, should I stay at 600 and try to get it all to polish up evenly, go back and get it even for that grit and then work my way back up, or should I just move on to the higher grit? Quote
rodger. Posted December 30, 2012 Report Posted December 30, 2012 You will probably find that water stones are far less frustrating to use. The only problem is that they are a bit pricey to buy iniatially. You can get a jig to help, which can be expensive (mk2) or inexpensive (but still good). Quote
00101 Posted December 30, 2012 Author Report Posted December 30, 2012 Yeah that's my ultimate goal, but I unfortunately don't have the cash to plunk down on an entire set right now. I'm only going to get a 5000 stone right away because I can get away with the sandpaper for the coarser grits for now because it's cheaper and I usually have it on hand anyway. I did actually receive a mk2 as well, which was a very nice surprise. Quote
Dave H Posted December 30, 2012 Report Posted December 30, 2012 If you can hold a piece of paper in one hand, and slice through the paper with the chisel with the other hand without tearing the paper. Than your sharp enough to do anything wood related that needs to be done with a chisel. Take the chisel to a chunk of wood give it a go, you'll see. Quote
Len Posted December 30, 2012 Report Posted December 30, 2012 Not quite sure I understand what you are trying to accomplish. If you are still in the stage of flattening the back of the chisel, there is no reason to try to polish the entire back, just a inch or so from the tip should be plenty. Quote
00101 Posted December 30, 2012 Author Report Posted December 30, 2012 Not quite sure I understand what you are trying to accomplish. If you are still in the stage of flattening the back of the chisel, there is no reason to try to polish the entire back, just a inch or so from the tip should be plenty. Yeah I know, I just figured if I'm going to do it I might as well hit the entire backs. They really didn't take much to get the entire back flat either, the worst one only took about a minute. Plus I'll admit to wanting the back to be like a mirror. Quote
RJsumthn Posted December 31, 2012 Report Posted December 31, 2012 I tried the scary sharp method and I just could not get good results with it. I picked up a King combo 1000/6000 waterstone at woodcraft for $38 and you can flatten that with sandpaper. I think that if you really can't afford any stones right now then either put fresh 600 down or go back a grit and lap it again and then call it good until you can get some stones. Thats not saying that you can't get a mirror polish with scary sharp but it will be a long frustrating process. In the long run stones with save you money compared to scary sharp. Quote
Dan S Posted December 31, 2012 Report Posted December 31, 2012 Currently I'm on 600 grit sandpaper, and I've run into a small problem. The very front and back of the chisel are much more polished than the middle. This only seemed to happen after about another minute of fast strokes past the point where all of the sharpie was gone. Is this because the front and back, probably due my lack of skill with sharpening, had more pressure and have worn the sandpaper finer there? Or is it something else? What technique are you using to lap the back of the chisels? side to side, skewed side to side, front to back, other? Are you using any kind of lubricant while lapping? I'd recommend you go back to 200 grit, and make a few strokes (less than 10). If you get a uniform scratch pattern, then the back is flat. Quote
00101 Posted December 31, 2012 Author Report Posted December 31, 2012 I tried the scary sharp method and I just could not get good results with it. I picked up a King combo 1000/6000 waterstone at woodcraft for $38 and you can flatten that with sandpaper. I think that if you really can't afford any stones right now then either put fresh 600 down or go back a grit and lap it again and then call it good until you can get some stones. Thats not saying that you can't get a mirror polish with scary sharp but it will be a long frustrating process. In the long run stones with save you money compared to scary sharp. I'm getting a shapton 5000 right away and am just using scary sharp initially to get to a level where I can stick with the 5000 stone. What technique are you using to lap the back of the chisels? side to side, skewed side to side, front to back, other? Are you using any kind of lubricant while lapping? I'd recommend you go back to 200 grit, and make a few strokes (less than 10). If you get a uniform scratch pattern, then the back is flat. Side to side. 600 girt wet/dry paper with water lubricant. I planned to go to 1000 grit sandpaper and then jump to the 5000 stone. Quote
Dan S Posted December 31, 2012 Report Posted December 31, 2012 Side to side. 600 girt wet/dry paper with water lubricant. I planned to go to 1000 grit sandpaper and then jump to the 5000 stone. Ok, you need to start much lower when you are lapping the back of new chisels. Go to an auto supply store and pick up some 200 grit wet dry, that's as low as you can go without special ordering. Also if you have a machinist supply store, or a farming supply store, see if you can pick up some cutting or tapping fluid, it's cheap and designed specifically to emulsify fine swarf (what you produce when lapping). Then lap the back but hold the chisel at an angle, say 30-45 degrees, this will help prevent you from rocking side to side. this video shows the Technique I have the new Sweetheart chisels, and some of then required a lot of work at 200 grit. They are good chisels once prepared, but they require more work initially than higher end chisels. Quote
00101 Posted December 31, 2012 Author Report Posted December 31, 2012 Ok, you need to start much lower when you are lapping the back of new chisels. Go to an auto supply store and pick up some 200 grit wet dry, that's as low as you can go without special ordering. Also if you have a machinist supply store, or a farming supply store, see if you can pick up some cutting or tapping fluid, it's cheap and designed specifically to emulsify fine swarf (what you produce when lapping). Then lap the back but hold the chisel at an angle, say 30-45 degrees, this will help prevent you from rocking side to side. this video shows the Technique I have the new Sweetheart chisels, and some of then required a lot of work at 200 grit. They are good chisels once prepared, but they require more work initially than higher end chisels. I've already done the low grits 120 > 220 > 400 > 600. Quote
tombuhl Posted December 31, 2012 Report Posted December 31, 2012 re: flattening the back. I agree that the cutting capability only requires the a small portion near the end to get a good cutting edge. However, if you do paring and such you'd like the majority of the back surface to be flat. Mirror finish is not necessary, but you can benefit from flatness. I've never used the sandpaper method other than "repairing" some badly nicked edges so cannot speak to your specific problem at the 600 grit. Hope you've gotten enough feedback to more along. It is nice to do the major tune-up once at the beginning. But there is also some benefit to doing a good job (even if not as great as you'd like), put the chisel to work. Then narrow the gap each time you work on the sharpening. More work long term, but over time some issues tend to take care of themselves as you gain experience and sense of how things feel when done "right." Good luck with your new chisels. Quote
jHop Posted January 3, 2013 Report Posted January 3, 2013 I'd go back to the 200 and "start over," personally. NOT A COMPLETE DO-OVER. *ahem*. Sorry. This is not to say all your work has been wasted. This is merely to confirm you've done the right steps. I've discovered, every time I think I made some form of major mistake, going back and running through the whole process finds that one little mistake and gets rid of it. That one little mistake threw everything else off. I've got a set of plexiglass strips that I permanently labeled with the grits for the wet/dry sandpaper. I've done mostly dry sharpening, having only recently switched to wet, and there is enough difference that going back to 200 made worlds of improvement. These plexi strips get mounted into a holder made from MDF, so I can quickly and easily swap out the grits without having to respray and remount paper. If I had more granite or cast iron, I'd use them as a backer. Shop is too small for that, so I use what I have. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.