Nick2cd Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 I'm thinking I want to learn hand cut dovetails. I need a decent dovetail saw but don't know anything about them. Please make some recommendations. Quote
James Finley Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 Well, a few questions: 1. Western saws or Japanese saws? If Japanese I would recommend any saw from Hida tool of Japan Woodworker that is labeled dovetail or Rip. You'll want to make sure it has a back as well. 2. If you prefer Western saws, what is your budget? A good value for money saw is the Veritas molded spine model (I haven't used their DT saw, but I own the two similar carcass saws and they are very nice). If you want to spend a little more money (and time) my recommendation is a Bad Axe Tool Works dovetail saw. I absolutely love mine, and Mark Harrel (owner of Bad Axe) will work with you to figure out exactly how the saw should be filed for the work you want to do. People also really like the Lie-nielsen saw (I've wanted to try their progressive pitch model) and the Gramercy Tool Dovetail saw. Hope that helps! Quote
rodger. Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 I have taken two sessions on hand cut dovetails, and have tried both the Japanese and western style saws. I really like the Japanese saw, but it's kerf is too small for a coping saw to get in there and clear out the waste. I really like the veritas dovetail saw, though it is a bit expensive. It will be my next saw purchase, along with a nice crosscut hand saw. http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=64007&cat=1,42884,64007 Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 Hi Nick, I recently purchased a new dovetail saw for similar reasons to you and I have been really pleased with it. Not sure if you can them in the US but I obtained mine from http://www.flinn-garlick-saws.co.uk/acatalog/Pax_Range.html . It was ready to go straight from the box and cut really nice and true. The balance is good and I think it looks really nice too. I posted a review of it on my blog http://gshaydon.co.uk/blog/dovetail-saw-review/ . Its not a great article but at least you get to see a few photos of the saw. Never used any of the Japanese saws. As I have always used Western style saws I think it might be tricky for me to learn to cut on the pull stroke. Let me know what saw you do go for and how you get on with it. Quote
mkirby Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 How do you find the handle on the PAX saw? I have the Dorchester rip also made by flynn and the handle is enormous, the guy who makes them must have huge hands as i can get 2 hands in the handle nearly. Makes it very uncomfortable to use, though the saw cuts fine and i have heard the same complaint about the rest of there range. I would be interested in hearing your thoughts as i was thinking of getting the Dorchester tennon and Dovetail so i had a matching set. Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 Hi mkirby I must confess you are right, the handle does feel a little large for my medium sized hands although on the dovetail saw you definitely can't get anywhere near two hands on it. I guess I found myself holding it like a pistol grip type with my hand quite high therefore ignoring the lower section. It did not seem to cause a problem and I did not have any discomfort or inaccurate cuts. I must stress that I am really happy with it and when the time comes I will most likely buy more from the range. It also felt good to have a quality UK made product. If you do decide to go for one let me know how you get on. How do you get on with the hand rip saw?. When I have ripped the odd bits on sites I have used a standard hardpoint saw and found it quite a tiresome job. Quote
Nick2cd Posted February 2, 2013 Author Report Posted February 2, 2013 Well, a few questions: 1. Western saws or Japanese saws? If Japanese I would recommend any saw from Hida tool of Japan Woodworker that is labeled dovetail or Rip. You'll want to make sure it has a back as well. 2. If you prefer Western saws, what is your budget? A good value for money saw is the Veritas molded spine model (I haven't used their DT saw, but I own the two similar carcass saws and they are very nice). If you want to spend a little more money (and time) my recommendation is a Bad Axe Tool Works dovetail saw. I absolutely love mine, and Mark Harrel (owner of Bad Axe) will work with you to figure out exactly how the saw should be filed for the work you want to do. People also really like the Lie-nielsen saw (I've wanted to try their progressive pitch model) and the Gramercy Tool Dovetail saw. Hope that helps! i really don't know if i want to go western or japanese. as i've never cut with either of them, im not sure which i would like better. i think my best bet is to just get one and learn to love it. as far as budget goes, i'd like the top end to be $100. i still have to purchase a fret saw to the tune of $75-100 as well. then, chances are, i'll probably decide i need to upgrade my chisels. this is gonna be a slippery slope. maybe i should just get a leigh d4r and call it a day (joke....kinda). Quote
rodger. Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 FWW did a good article recently on hand saws. You should check it out. It's in the feb issue for this year. It's prob still available on the rack. You don't need an expensive fret saw for dovetails. A middle of the road coping saw will do a great job. Quote
JerrySats Posted February 3, 2013 Report Posted February 3, 2013 Nick I don't know where you located but perhaps you have a WoodCraft store near by , they usually have a nice selection you can try out . The Lee Valley line up of saws are very nice for the money , they would be worth test driving if you can . Maybe there's some fellow woodworkers in your area , he have quite a few around here and get together from time to time , that's a nice way to try out tools too . Regards Jerry Quote
Nick2cd Posted February 3, 2013 Author Report Posted February 3, 2013 Nick I don't know where you located but perhaps you have a WoodCraft store near by , they usually have a nice selection you can try out . The Lee Valley line up of saws are very nice for the money , they would be worth test driving if you can . Maybe there's some fellow woodworkers in your area , he have quite a few around here and get together from time to time , that's a nice way to try out tools too . Regards Jerry my nearest woodcraft is a little over an hour away. i will be making a trip there in the near future to get some festool stuff, so i'll be sure to take a good look at their saws while there. thanks Quote
tirebob Posted February 4, 2013 Report Posted February 4, 2013 I have used the Veritas, LN, Pax, and Bad Axe saws, as well as some well shapened vintage ones. Disregarding money, the Bad Axe saws are by far the very best I have ever used and I now own four of them. Bang for your buck though, you will be hard pressed to beat the quality for dollar value of the Veritas saws... They cut extremely well and are very well priced compared to anything else at that level. It is what I learned to cut DT's with. I would still be using them today if I hadn't gotten a bit of extra money and popped on the Bad Axe ones. http://www.leevalley.com/en/Wood/page.aspx?p=64007&cat=1,42884,68511&ap=1 You have to really pony up a fair bit more money to get only a bit better in something like the LN saws. I personally don't like the progressive pitch and find that you end up sawing with only 2/3's of the saw because the teeth towards the back are extremely course. That said, it is a nice, well built saw. I just find the Veritas to be much better value for virtually the same level of performance. As for the Pax saws, I really dislike the feel in hand and I I was less than impressed. I would buy the Veritas long before a Pax. Lastly, a well sharpened vintage saw will work as well as anything, but you would be better off buying one already tuned up by a reputable saw restorer if you don't want to take on a project and risk spending money on a saw that has issues you were not aware of... Quote
JMort847 Posted February 4, 2013 Report Posted February 4, 2013 I have a Veritas 14 tpi dovetail saw and a vintage Disston 15tpi dovetail saw I use. The Veritas saws are great value for the price and work really well. I plan to get one of their 20 tpi dovetail saws this year. Quote
Jfitz Posted February 4, 2013 Report Posted February 4, 2013 I have the 20tpi Vertias saw and like it a lot, but the fine tooth is meant for thinner boards. I plan to add the 14tpi saw soon. 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 4, 2013 Report Posted February 4, 2013 tirebob Really interested to hear you were not impressed with the PAX brand. I will soon be thinking about a new panel saw and tenon rip saw. I think I might jump in the car and go get a feel for a few of the other brands you mentioned before I invest in more PAX. Was it just the feel in the hand and balance you didn't like or were you not happy with other features too as well? Quote
nateswoodworks Posted February 5, 2013 Report Posted February 5, 2013 I went the ppath of a kit saw, you build it yourself. I bought mine through http://www.wenzloffandsons.com/ and have been very happy. Chris Schwarz has given them some great reviews and Bob over at http://logancabinetshoppe.com/ had told me about his experiences with them, that was enough writing on the wall for me! I like my tools to fit my hands perfectly so not only does this route save money (I paid about half of the cost of one of their saws) but I got the results I was after. Mike Wenzloff has has some major health problems in the past couple years but I see that he is back at it now so if this interests you at all you can call and talk to him, very nice guy, or ask here. In the next couple months I am going to buy parts to make another saw, this time a tenon saw and I know where I am going to get it! Quote
tirebob Posted February 5, 2013 Report Posted February 5, 2013 G S - I have to admit that the very first thing that put me off was the feel of the handle and from there on I was probably looking for things to dislike, but there were other things too. I didn't like the hang of the saw at all. It felt really out of balance. The cut was alright I guess but it was a bit ragged compared to every other saw. Now I am only comparing the dovetail saws and can't say anything about the other styles, but overall they are not near as good as the competition... Quote
mkirby Posted February 9, 2013 Report Posted February 9, 2013 G S, I like dimensioning by hand. Its the only bit about woodworking I'm any good at The Dorchester is a nice saw with the exception of the handle. It does the job fine but for a little extra i can get a saw made from Lui Rocca here in the UK. He only makes hand saws but they are very very nice. He wasnt impressed with the PAX saws he felt they had far too much set on them. At the end of the day it comes down to budget. 1 Quote
mkirby Posted February 9, 2013 Report Posted February 9, 2013 And to answer the original question this is where i will be getting my back saws from http://two-lawyers-toolworks.blogspot.co.uk Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 9, 2013 Report Posted February 9, 2013 Thanks mkirby I really like Lui Rocca . Will need to investigate them further although on the face of it they seem incredible. A real craftsman's tool produced by a craftsman, you can't do better than that. Quote
NorthSummmit Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 I can only speak for the one dovetail saw I've used which is the 14 tpi Veritas dovetail saw. I have no complaints thus far, the handle could be a bit larger but then again I think I have kind of long fingers. For the money get a good quality saw and I think it was a good starting point without a large investment in something I wasn't completely sure about. Not as pretty as the other saws out there but I don't see myself going to a different saw anytime soon. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.