Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

How do I create an air tight barrier between my basement workshop and furnace?

Featured Replies

We recently purchased a house with an unfinished basement. I've been planning to use half of the space as a workshop. I'm trying to bolster my knowledge on enclosed space dust collection, but I think it's pretty clear I don't want a scenario where fine dust can make its way into the furnace intake and into the house.

I prefer not to put up anything semi-permanent like frames and dry wall around the furnace because I'd like to keep the use of the space flexible for now. Any other ideas on how to create an air tight barrier around the furnace area? I was considering plastic sheeting and duct tape, but weaving that in between each of the floor joists seems like a pain.

This may be less of a problem than you think. Unless you have a register/intake in your basement (which is unlikely), most air that would enter your HVAC system would be from 2 places: Gaps around joints in the ducting itself (which you can seal off with HVAC tape - which you should do anyway since it will dramatically improve your efficiency) and around your HVAC filter, which you should be able to solve fairly simply. The tape is super cheap, and easy to apply, though wear gloves since it will give you nasty cuts.

 

Keep in mind that you don't really want your furnace to be in a 100% airtight area since (assuming it's oil/gas based) you have to get the oxygen for combustion from somewhere (which, due to the exhaust/byproducts of combustion is, I think, separate from your houses actual airflow).

 

If you've got some sort of dust control solution for both the coarse and the fine dust particles, I wouldn't worry beyond that.

First, I'd recommend a dust collection unit of some kind, but I definatley understand budget restraints, especially with a new home!  (congrats btw).

 

If you want a temporary "Shield" to block workshop from the utility area, you can use the tried and true method of hanging a tarp from your ceiling joists.

 

Just buy a tarp that is big enough to give you some slack on all sides.  Also pickup some 2x4s.  Take the 2x4s and wrap the tarp on top and bottom a few times and fire something through to hold it (screws, nails, staples...whatever).  Then use the top 2x4 to mount to the ceiling joists, and let the bottom hang down with just a bit more slack than needed so the bottom 2x4/tarp combo is sitting on the floor.  This is very temporary, but helps keep junk away from the furnace.  It is not the best option, but probably one of the cheapest depending on the layout of your shop/utilities.

 

This won't stop ALL the super fines, but you will never notice them, and your HEPA filter in the furnace should catch these anyway.  (Keep a close eye on it for a while until you are used to its replacement schedule).

I have no answer to your original question, but I do run a woodshop in the same enclosed room as a heater and my washer/dryer for that matter (I have no other space I can realistically operate out of, and I cannot enclose the heater). For what it's worth, I've never had any issue with dust being kicked out all over the place, so as Fat Baron said, the issue may not be as big as you think.

 

I turn off the heater when I'm working in the shop (the basement always manages to remain a comfortable temperature), plus I have very top notch dust collection from collection at the tools themselves to a secondary air filtration unit that catches what they can't.

It depends a lot on exactly what kind of furnace (and probably water heater) you have.  It is very dangerous to seal off a gas or oil burning appliance if it does not have access to a fresh air supply that has been sized to match the BTU of the burner.  The burner must take in enough air to completely burn the fuel and to create enough draft for the exhaust to make it out the flue.  If this doesn't happen, carbon monoxide can build up in the house which is extremely dangerous.  I would strongly recommend you consult with an HVAC installer in your area to perform a "make-up air" calculation for the BTU of your furnance and water heater before sealing off a room which contains the furnace or WH.  The various permutations of burner type, efficiency, size, building construction, etc are really too complicated to get into on a forum.  Some furnaces (like a 96% AFUE) can be completely enclosed whereas others like an 80+ need a pretty signifcant amount of square footage to draw air from.  Very few gas water heaters would be okay in an enclosed space.

I have a workshop next to my HVAC. The way my layout is, I walked up my furnace into a seperate little room about 12x12'. There's a door put up directly in front of it so I can open and access the filters etc. the back of the furnace is in that little room where my workbench is, I do t do cutting here, just hand tools. It's also separated by a door.

In my other area 2 feet from my walled up furnace is a 12x12' or so with all of my machines. The ducts are taped and covered with bulkheads and drywall. I have a 2hp dust collector and an air cleaner, also a Dylos monitor. I have a draft strip under the door that opens to the furnace and have a flap (tape) that covers the filter slot. The air suction here pulls the flap tight. No intake vents here, all shut. I also had a combustion PVC tube from my furnace sticking out. My manual said to leave it or pipe it outside so I extended it outside.

A very big +1 on knowing exactly what you are dealing with before you try to enclose, or wall off your furnace.  Contact an HVAC contractor or you utility.  You still haven't said what type of furnace. Electric, passive vented gas, direct vent gas?  The concern is regarding passive vented gas furnaces, which I do not like, because I don't feel there is an "acceptable" level of carbon monoxide.

 

All that said, and DO heed the warnings, the easiest way to do a long term, but temporary sealed wall is rigid foam board put into place with spray foam.  I have advised this as a lowcost method of sealing off a fireplace to low income people who can't afford the heat loss going out their chimney flues.  

 

Again, GET PROFESSIONAL ADVICE for this, lest you kill yourself and your family.

 

Good luck!

  • Author

Thanks everyone for your input. So is the furnace intake (where you put the filter) just for the aspirating the furnace engine? or does air coming into the furnace intake also make it into the house? If it doesn't make it into the house, "Ends of the World's" suggestion of just not running the furnace while fine dust is in the air should suffice. I'm guessing fine dust is going to do a lot less damage to the furnance than to my lungs.

In terms of a comprehensive dust collector strategy, I'm thinking:

Active:
>5 microns = Harbor Freight 2HP DC (only $199 this month) This is essentially a chip collector, so I'm not planning to use a separator. I'll just empty the chips more often.
<5 microns = respirator

Passive:
>0.3 microns = ShopFox W1746 Fine Air Filter (http://tinyurl.com/ct3yg73). I'm not sure what size space this is rated for, but the larger cleaners don't seem to get dust <1 micron.

If I'm reading Bill Pentz correctly, if you hope to cut without a respirator, you're looking at a 5HP motor and a 6" hose, which is probably overkill for my size shop and budget. So I'm thinking about putting on the respirator when I begin to cut, then leaving it on until I'm done with my session, then turn on the ShopFox to filter the air after my session, so it's clean at the start of my next session.

Any holes here?

  • Author

The furnace is a Rheem Classic 90 gas furnace. It was installed when the house was built about 7 years ago.

Certain dusts have explosive ignition properties. This makes the questions you ask more important than simple comfort.

Air flowing over the furnace filter does not mix with ignition air. Ignition supply is kept separate since the exhaust from combustion contains carbon monoxide.

Properly sealing the furnace will depend on whether or not it is a direct vent system. In these systems combustion air is piped in and out of the building via PVC pipe. In this setting, provided you use tape or mastic to seal your ducts,turning the furnace off would provide some peace of mind but should not be necessary. (It may also keep your ducting cleaner. Ducting can get staticky and collect dust.

The furnace is a Rheem Classic 90 gas furnace. It was installed when the house was built about 7 years ago.
is it set up for direct or passive combustion air? If the combustion air is piped in from the outside, it is a much safer configuration. The PDF I found online for what you've identified says it can be set up either way. Seriously, get it services and ask the HVAC guy the same question you've posed here.

If you wall off your furnace and there is a filter being enclosed you make a negative pressure room. Every small leak in the walls will cause dust to be pulled into the make shift room at an even higher flow rate. You want to treat it like a spray booth with an AMU and filter the air being made up by either adding a filter to the wall of the makeshift room or taking air from some other part of the house.

A very big +1 on knowing exactly what you are dealing with before you try to enclose, or wall off your furnace.  Contact an HVAC contractor or you utility.  You still haven't said what type of furnace. Electric, passive vented gas, direct vent gas?  The concern is regarding passive vented gas furnaces, which I do not like, because I don't feel there is an "acceptable" level of carbon monoxide.

 

All that said, and DO heed the warnings, the easiest way to do a long term, but temporary sealed wall is rigid foam board put into place with spray foam.  I have advised this as a lowcost method of sealing off a fireplace to low income people who can't afford the heat loss going out their chimney flues.  

 

Again, GET PROFESSIONAL ADVICE for this, lest you kill yourself and your family.

 

Good luck!

+1

  • Author

is it set up for direct or passive combustion air? If the combustion air is piped in from the outside, it is a much safer configuration. The PDF I found online for what you've identified says it can be set up either way. Seriously, get it services and ask the HVAC guy the same question you've posed here.

Vic, I'll definitely bring in a pro before I do anything. I'd like to determine if I actually need to seal it up.

 

There are PVC pipes running from both the furnace and the hot water heater toward the side of the house.

Vic, I'll definitely bring in a pro before I do anything. I'd like to determine if I actually need to seal it up. There are PVC pipes running from both the furnace and the hot water heater toward the side of the house.
Then you would be direct vented and all combustion air is from outside and you have high efficiency gas units. I'd still get advise and have your units checked out while you're at it. Being directly vented would mean you shouldn't need to seal the unit from your dust. The firebox should be sealed. The only thing would be how well sealed is the cabinet, where the return air grate is located, etc. you want to make sure you don't create pressure imbalances. A good HVAC person will be able to determine your options.
  • 1 month later...

I currently have my shop set up in an unfinished basement, and I also had these same concerns. My first thoughts were towards dust, and how it would affect the furnace. All the intakes were upstairs, and we have a pretty darn good filter system. My only dust control is a shop vac that I connect to the sander and router tables. We haven't had any problems with the furnace or the filter, and the dust is NOT making it's way upstairs through the furnace system.

 

My main concern with having a basement shop is FUMES. This will limit what choices you can make regarding methods and products you can use for finishing.  My nightmare is possibly passing out while i'm in the middle of finishing! I would advise the use of any aerosols, paint thinners or any other oil based finishes in a well ventilated area...not in a hole in the ground.

  • 2 weeks later...

I have my shop in the basement of my house and i have 1 bench next to my water heater/ gas boiler systems and i just took a tarp and staples it to the ceiling joist and let it hang.

 

I haven't had any issues yet but most of the work i do is with hand tools, very rarely do i even turn my table saw on and when i do use it, its not for a long period of time..(usually 1 or 2 cuts) and i just clean up with my shop vac

  • 2 weeks later...

I used to work in a garage that also housed our furnace. There were no issues when we first moved in (summer time, working with an open garage door). But the first winter, with the garage door closed, my wife began complaining that she couldn't figure out why the house was getting so dusty. Yikes! That was a source of friction for two more years. Our solution was to build a new house, with a dedicated, walled off, shop bay. Works great (but not very cost effective).

Sorry i cant help much, just reminded me of a set of walls i made for more or less the same purpose, framed 5' sections with 7/16 osb instead of dry wall. They can be moved around easily and just butted together and pinned against the joists (i used shims but if this is goin to be used more often it wouldnt be hard to make a better system.

(I had to separate myself and dust from one side of a server room and because of air movement i had to have something more robust set up than plastic)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.