Tpt life Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 Anybody used it? Seems like just another cheap imitation at first glance. Quote
sgmdwk Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 It's $150. If you think that's cheap, I'm happy for you. Quote
Tpt life Posted May 15, 2013 Author Report Posted May 15, 2013 Rephrase, possibly poorly designed. Quote
krtwood Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 None of the track saws "need" clamps, there's a non slip surface on the underside. It's a track and a base to get attached to a circular saw. The pricing is in line with what a good track should cost. The only thing cheap about it is potentially going to be the cheap circular saw you stick on it. It's not going to magically turn a cheap saw into a good saw, but it should do better than a shop built guide. Much like Marc's review of the Grizzly track saw, okay it may not be as good as a Festool but it's not trying to be. 1 Quote
duckkisser Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 ya clamps are not necessary if you carful and aren't shoveling it around. that said I would prefer to put a clamp on my rail just so I know it wont move and I have to start over. a pair of spring clamps are usually enough 1 Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 Having used many brands of these things as well as my trusty shop made version from 20 years ago. I find the thing that really separates Festool from everyone else is the dust collection. I know I will have one of the green warriors jump in about the quality of the cut, but I haven't been able to notice any difference between the quality if the blade is properly sharp. But the dust collection on Festool is really impressive. Quote
Bobby Slack Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 I use the clamps every time I have an important cut. Some people can get away with it ... I don't. Ah ... I use the Festool system so there you have it. Quote
dwacker Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 Back when I was part of the cult and had my flaming exorcism I never used the clamps. It took a bit to learn to trust the rubber strips but they did work. I think the clamps are a good idea for routing but for straight saw cuts you really dont need them. Quote
Trip Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 ==> clamps are a good idea for routing but for straight saw cuts you really dont need them ==> I use the clamps every time I have an important cut. Some people can get away with it ... I don't. while these two statements are basically opposites, I agree with both. I think if you are careful, you don't 'need them' for sawing (but I agree w/ Don -- they are needed for routing). When I first got the TS55, I bought into the hype and never used clamps. However, I did screw-up an entire sheet of cherry ply when it bumped the track and did not notice -- clearly my fault. Now I use the clamps for cuts that need to be spot-on or when a mistake would waist a lot of material. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 Most of the time I can get away without the strips, espeically with plywood, but I ALWAYS use clamps if cutting MDF with the tracksaw. Have screwed up a piece or two because the surface was too slick for the grippy strip and the track shifted, and no dust was on the surface nor the strip. Quote
RJsumthn Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 I love the idea of being able to convert your circ saw into a track saw. I would be interested to see how well it works though. I'm not all that worried about the rubber stripping because if it doesn't work then you can use clamps and you problem is solved. I am more concerned with the tolerances between the track and the base. As Marc showed in his Grizzly Track Saw review he was not impressed with the amount of wiggle room on the tool and I have the same skepticisms with this device. I would love for this to be an accurate system and if someone can prove that then I will likely purchase one for myself. At the price point that it is at I would hope that the tolerances are high on this product. Quote
dwacker Posted May 15, 2013 Report Posted May 15, 2013 I love the idea of being able to convert your circ saw into a track saw. I would be interested to see how well it works though. I'm not all that worried about the rubber stripping because if it doesn't work then you can use clamps and you problem is solved. I am more concerned with the tolerances between the track and the base. As Marc showed in his Grizzly Track Saw review he was not impressed with the amount of wiggle room on the tool and I have the same skepticisms with this device. I would love for this to be an accurate system and if someone can prove that then I will likely purchase one for myself. At the price point that it is at I would hope that the tolerances are high on this product. My thing with all these track systems no matter how good the track is they leave off the zero clearance. The griz track wobble is easily fixed but I would have to look closer to see if there was an easy way to add the zero clearance. The one posted here seems pretty easy to add onto. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.