G S Haydon Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 I have been reflecting on this for some time. French or English, my opinion would sway like a clock pendulum. Finally today that has changed. I had been working out on site for a few days erecting a hardwood conservatory and I found myself needing a small section of lead to make a soaker. The client was kind enough to find some in his store. This is when I found this beauty (albeit it's in the eye of the beholder and no I was not wearing beer goggles). Although Mr Schwarz had a wooden leg vice on his "English Workbench" I had never seen one fitted to a British Workbench in the flesh until now. It's even splayed across like his design (clearly he knows his onions) In addition the vice has a generous splay on the top edge, as Mr Schwarz points out this must be to allow an easy approach with the tools. The legs are set upright rather than being splayed and the parallel guide is set within a boxing The aprons are really deep on this example measuring a full 12 inches. They are attached to the legs with some heavy gauge screws, nothing fancy. They are also set flush with the legs taking full advantage of of the extra support this offers. Nearly all benches of this type I have reference too always have the apron and leg flush. The drawer slides really nicely even though it's full of heavy stuff and it's only runners are pine cleats. And yes the drawer has half lap dovetails. The drawer position is very similar to that which is shown in "George Ellis, Modern Practical Joinery" Everything apart from the wood screw is in pine, even the vice faces. The only thing I am trying to weigh up is should I make my build "accessible" using timber that can be purchased in set sizes so any one could make one or be a purist and take advantage of my well equipped workshop to mill timber to the sizes I want? I will I think and a quick release vice in the tail vice position (not the all metal version but the ones you add your own wooden faces to) and I will probably splay the legs (George Ellis/Chris Schwarz style). It's been good to find the direction and as soon as I tune up my bench planes I can make a start . If you want to see some larger images take a look at the blog (if it works that is)! 1 Quote
chicks82 Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 i don't see any of the attached images :'( Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 17, 2013 Author Report Posted May 17, 2013 Sorry CH, My initial images were taking up too much memory so I had to edit, should be all good now Quote
TerryMcK Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 Nice design Graham. Looking forward to seeing progress. Any idea about hardware yet? Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 17, 2013 Author Report Posted May 17, 2013 Hi Terry, I'm going to start basic. I allowed myself to make a purchase a little while ago of a simple vice screw for the leg vice and a quick release guide to make my own tail vice in an attempt to force a choice of design. I will probably also add a wooden planning stop (the one I saw today had one). I'm really enjoying a stripped back way of woodworking just now, just relying on machines for the heavy conversion and planning. All I need now is an epic Edwardian tache BTW how are the planters going? Quote
Eric. Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 That thing is a beast. Pretty cool. Wish your pics were bigger so I could see it. Can you explain why on earth 12 dog dang inch aprons would be beneficial? Or are you baffled by that as well? Quote
RJsumthn Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 The only reason I can think of to have long aprons like that is to have holes in it for holdfasts but I don't see any holes in the picture. Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 17, 2013 Author Report Posted May 17, 2013 Eric, I still struggle with the photos on the forum, I added some bigger ones but I could only add three? I will get better at that (I hope). I will be posting them on my blog too although it's hit and miss if people can view that . Talking of photos how's the tool belt shoot coming along? On the aprons I think its two fold. This would of been a "joiners" bench so the work would of been quite large and I would assume that the aprons would offer lots of support when working on the edges of large items such as doors. In addition the tops of these benches are often on the thin side (this one was 32mm with a 20mm tool tray in the middle) so the aprons act like floor joist making a very rigid frame. Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 17, 2013 Author Report Posted May 17, 2013 Hi RJ, Aprons are usually quite thin so a holdfast would not get enough purchase. What aprons sometimes have is a few or a lot of holes into which a peg is placed that supports long work which has one end in the vice. Quote
chicks82 Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 I can't wait to see what you come up with. That bench would be a joiners dream I could do so much stuff on that thing I need to get a shop that would warrant such a bench. Quote
TerryMcK Posted May 17, 2013 Report Posted May 17, 2013 Try adding the photos in several separate posts in the thread. My planters are nearly complete and the cedar cladding is on. Just a little more to do probably Saturday. I'll update my blog this week. I've been working on a theatre play this week doing the lighting so no woodworking If anybody is interested in the Sketchup drawings for the planters I'll put them in the library. Let me know. Quote
mkirby Posted May 18, 2013 Report Posted May 18, 2013 Graham you should try and get down to the european woodworking show in essex this year. The maguire bench guy and gal will be there and they have an interesting take with the benches they do. Also the Swartz will be there. I have started my prototype bench, i just went to MKM and got me a load of dressed 4x4 and have made a nice top out of it. Im going the french route but i do like the look of the english stye benches. I may do that when i make it out of proper wood but i will see how my prototype goes. Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 18, 2013 Author Report Posted May 18, 2013 Terry, Please do add the planter drawings, I need to make some for my place but never around to it............. mkirby That event sounds sweet, time is my enemy right now, a 3 month old daughter and a 3 year old toddler keep my weekends v busy . When is the event? 2 Quote
mkirby Posted May 18, 2013 Report Posted May 18, 2013 it is on at Cressing Temple Barns, Essex, Saturday 21st September 10am-5pm, Sunday 22nd September 10am-4pm http://www.europeanwoodworkingshow.eu I want to go but the travel cost from up north means its just too expensive for me to justify at the moment. I need to buy wood to get a move on with my hand tool school projects. Quote
Byrdie Posted May 19, 2013 Report Posted May 19, 2013 "The Schwarz" but only because it's a name near and dear to my heart. Quote
mkirby Posted May 19, 2013 Report Posted May 19, 2013 i will just refer to him as Mr Black from now on, easier to spell 1 Quote
TerryMcK Posted May 21, 2013 Report Posted May 21, 2013 I may go. My wife said she will go shopping while I go around the showground. I can't figure out why she is not interested in the great joy of woodwork! Quote
chicks82 Posted May 27, 2013 Report Posted May 27, 2013 Graham when you going to start this beast? Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 27, 2013 Author Report Posted May 27, 2013 Hi C, Soon. I'm playing with a few bits in sketchup right now to avoid making any school boy errors and I've got my bench plane revamp to finish (posting a new entry on the blog tonight "Block Plane") There are a few things I'm trying to weigh up right now. Tool Tray or not Tool Tray, that is the question (at least I think that's what they said in Hamlet). I'm thinking of not having a tool tray even though it's a hugely common feature on this type of bench. If I do prepare stock by hand it is likely to be wider material that won't fit through a machine. I think a tool tray would potentially reduce support when planing this wide stock. I know I could have a drop in section to fill the tray but I don't want bits of wood everywhere. Also I'm not used to a tool tray, my regular bench top is an 8 x 4 of OSB I'm still a bit unsure on material (not the type I know it's going to be pine) but rather the sizes used. I like the way P Sellers made his bench accessible by using 2 x 4 & 2 x 3 stock but on the flip side when people have access to this I'm not sure what advantage there is to all that gluing up (apart from a slightly thicker bench top). Perhaps you could enlighten me, is 2 x 10 SYP from lowes a pile of crap and does it have the rounded edges? BTW over here SYP is a relatively expensive clear softwood, so jealous you guys get to use it for joist. What would you rather do, glue laminate or 3 wide boards for the top? I know what I would rather do. Quote
chicks82 Posted May 27, 2013 Report Posted May 27, 2013 I am on the west coast so I frame with Douglas fir. Most anything that is 2x is going to have the eased edges. I personally don't buy wood from lowes or Home Depot. I say no tool tray given that gorgeous tool chest you have As for laminating or just going one peice that's really a matter of budget I would think. Given that it is an imported(?) wood that you are using the cost of a single peice might out way the time of laminating. Quote
G S Haydon Posted May 27, 2013 Author Report Posted May 27, 2013 Thanks Charles, Doug Fir would be a sweet timber to use but mine will indeed be imported and will be European Redwood. Thanks for the kind words on the tool chest and I think a nice flat surface with no tool tray sounds good to me too. Thanks for the info on the eased edges. I want to keep a traditional vibe so wide boards seem my best bet. Quote
chicks82 Posted May 27, 2013 Report Posted May 27, 2013 No problem! I would ship you some real redwood but i think the cost would be quite great haha. I look forward to the build 1 Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted May 28, 2013 Popular Post Report Posted May 28, 2013 When I inherited my great-grandfather's bench, it had a tool tray all along the back, maybe 6-8 inches wide, couple inches deep. Sure enough, it was a handy to place to put small tools so they didn't roll off the bench. It was also handy for accumulating scraps, trash, shavings, dust, debris, the kids' toys, bits of asteroids, hamburgers, mouse poop, shoelaces, tape balls, glue boogers, nails and screws...uh, yeah, you get it. I chopped it off and replaced it with more flat surface. Now the whole bench collects all that crap. 4 Quote
toolemera Posted June 2, 2013 Report Posted June 2, 2013 a bit belatedly, I've seen this style of bench vise, with or without the apron, in many 19th C books for all sorts of purposes. Joinery, boys carpentry, house carpenters, etc. The one unifying word seemed to be carpentry & joinery as opposed to furniture making but that could be just the chance of the author. These were described as a popular vise for use when working on long stock (as mentioned), on wide stock and for jointing/forming edges rather than for working on tenons and such. Nicholson and Moxon discuss this in terms of house capentry and joinery. Trade catalogs feature classic european style two vise benches as Cabinet Makers benches. Go figure. Thing is, in a large joiners shop or at a job site, there was often more than one bench: the joinery bench which might have been made on sight and the more familiar bench with two vises that was carted to the site. Just to wreck that theory, I have photos showing both ways if only I can find them in the current mess that is my work room. All of which is to say, do what you want cause I think that there was no hard and fast rules about much of anything. Then as today I believe that people continued to work with whatever they became accustomed to working with. Me, I prefer a wide flat surface sans tool tray. My last was 3 feet wide, an old door and it lasted for 3 decades of all sorts of stuff. Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 2, 2013 Author Report Posted June 2, 2013 Thanks T, I plan to try a wooden leg vice very similar to that shown, if it does not work out no problem, and I'll pop a quick release on there. I also agree you get used to whatever you have. An 8 x 4 sheet of OSB on a sturdy frame and 1 x quick release vice has been just fine for me in our joinery workshop. Not going to think too much more about it and just make the beast. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.