Recommended Posts

Posted

I decided to make some upgrades to my house.  Re-paint, new trim on the windows, doors, baseboards, etc..  Was playing around with a design to carry through the main floor of the house and I'm not quite sure what I think about it.  The windows and trim would be painted white. 

 

Any folks here that do a lot of interior finishing care to offer an opinion :rolleyes: ?  The outside edges still need to be eased, but I think these pics give an idea of what I think I'm going for..  I think it's kinda / sorta what I would like to have but it's not 100%. 

 

Looking for some brutal honesty; I promise no feelings will be hurt!  Overall I'm looking for some suggestions to fine tune it..

 

Thank you!

 

post-6031-0-69416600-1374376756_thumb.jp

 

post-6031-0-40810700-1374376767_thumb.jp

 

post-6031-0-57162400-1374376775_thumb.jp

 

 

 

Posted

Just some considerations as I think it looks pretty good!

 

1.  Top plate - (Top window casing) Trim it back to the same size as the rest of the casing.

2.  Window Sill - Round the corners and (maybe?) add a small profile to the front.  Not too much, just a tiny detail.

3.  Sill support - A little narrower.  Possibly mitered bottom corners.

4.  Don't paint!  Plug the holes and clear them.  The natural wood is too beautiful to paint IMO

 

This is a tough one as everyone's taste is different.  In the end, I'd just make sure the boss is happy and walk away :P

Posted

Thanks Tiods :). 

 

Trimming things down is no problem; it's just a prototype..  The only reason I am looking to paint is because the windows are pine which has yellowed (not a fan of that) and the new trimwork will be all oak which I milled up last Fall from a tree on my Dad's property (cheap wood and I happen to have quite a bit of it)...  It's really the only way I can come up with to give a uniform appearance... 

 

Agreed on the easing / rounding of the outside edges, just didn't get that far yet :P ...  My 3 yr old Daughter was being "very helpful" which was cool, but didn't get as far as I had hoped....

Posted

It looks top heavy. I think the apron length needs to match the outside limits of your side casings. This would square the bottom off more and balance the top heavy design. I might try thicker projection with the top casing since it looks more like a capital with its side projection and sill cap.

Posted

don't realy like how top is bigger the bottom

 

The top and bottom are a little different appearance, but the overall height of each is the same,  4 3/4"..  The bottom is a 4" flat piece with a 3/4" shelf (sorry, I don't know the terms for the different pieces :unsure: ).  The top is a 3" flat piece (same as the sides) with (2) 3/4"roundover bumps which protrude 1" above and below the 3" piece...

Posted

I think the apron length needs to match the outside limits of your side casings. This would square the bottom off more and balance the top heavy design.

 

That was a thought I had once it was in place..  Like I mentioned, there are a few things that just don't seem right and I think that may be one of them :huh: ..

Posted

Just one more thought..

 

You could completely simplify the top, add a valance across the front of the cupboards and shelf the top to carry all the decorative stuff?

 

I know, probably a silly idea but, thought I'd toss it out there.

Posted

boat here is how i would do it

 

 

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/11239557/Interior%20Trim%20Detail.pdf

 

EDIT: This is drawn on a 2-0x 2-8window opening

 

Thats great Charles!  Thank you :) !

 

There's one thing on the diagram that I'm having a tough time understanding.   The middle annotation that reads, "1x4 or 1x6 ripped to width"  is this presuming that the window casing is recessed into the wall a bit?  On my windows the frame / jambs of the window sit flush with the drywall..  Would the new trim simply butt up flush with the jambs? 

 

Sorry for the noob Q's..  Houses and boats are apples and oranges when talking about finishing :unsure:..  I think I need to scour youtube to get a better understanding of how this is done..

 

EDIT: Taking a closer look at the jams (or whatever they're called) and it looks like they would be fairly simple to remove.  Would they typically be pulled out and replaced with the same appearance as the face-frames? Thinking this is what you're referring to with the 1x4 or 1x6 cut to width?

 

Yes, I know...  I'm a Noob with this stuff :P

Posted

Yes the 1x4 1x6 is referring to the jamb I would install the sill and top first then te sides. After that install your casing. Casing typically has a 5/16" reveal.

I like to back bevel the part of the jamb and sill that goes against the window to allow for simple adjustment of gaps with a little sand paper.

Posted

Aaahhh..  That makes sense!  I never really finished the house when we built it, just cobbled this kind of stuff together and focused on other areas of the house.   So the existing jambs that are on the window are there more or less for protection while shipping? 

 

Thanks for your help!

Posted

Easier top send you some pictures.

 

First off, please don't listen to my two cents, I'm going to say to you what I would say to a client if they sketched what you have. One caveat to add US design may vary a bit from ours.

 

Your sliding sash window is small and simple. It feels like your trying to add Georgian proportioned architraves (image one) to a small modern window. I would loose the chunk of timber under the cill board and add a large scotia or similar. Because your window finishes flush with the drywall I woud miter around a 4" x 1/2" with a corner bead and then miter around a 21/2" or 3" Ogee, Taurus or Ovolo profile level with the outside of the 4" x 1/2". If it were mine (it's not) I would want something like the second and the last image.

 

volume6-2.jpg

 

pvcsash4.jpg

 

Architectural-Stone-Window-Door-Surround

 

newsletter_201005_2.jpg

Posted

I stopped reading and dropped out to do a real quick SketchUp with my suggestions.  Not too different from what you have.  Basically I dinked with the top a little bit by make the corners of the top detail mitered and narrower at the bottom but wider at the top.  I also set in a bead parallel to the edge of the side trim just to add some detail.  Didn't take time to make the rounded edges and etc.

 

post-8974-0-56700500-1374451347_thumb.jp

 

post-8974-0-40302600-1374451351_thumb.jp

 

post-8974-0-52938300-1374451349_thumb.jp

 

Or you could just move out, sell the house and let the next owners worry about it.

Posted

That looks great TR!  Really blends well in the room!

 

Of course I like the safe room!  Looks like someone's got some serious stuff there!

Posted

First off, thanks everyone for the replies!  I really appreciate all the suggestions  :) ..  I made a few changes to the original; nothing major but I think it took care of some of my initial issues.  After realizing that the factory installed jambs were removable on my windows (thank you C. Hicks!) I pulled them out and built an actual frame / jamb out of the same material as the face trim.  I lengthened the bottom board (sorry, don't know the terms) to match the overall width of the side pieces and made the bottom sill ledge a bit larger as well.   Still not 100%, but it's closer (a work in progress)..

 

I guess what I'm trying to figure out is how to trim the doors and windows in a way that initially looks kinda / sorta detailed, but not really detailed (if that makes any sense).  I like the basic straight lined Stickley type appearance of things; don't really care for the very ornate, very busy router detail like in an old victorian home.  We live in the middle of 20 acres of woods and am surrounded by  hundreds more.  So a cabin type feel is definitely what we're all about; just a small step up from rustic..  Not sure if this makes any sense... 

 

I looked around online and the closest thing that I could find a describe my style is a 'Craftsman' type appearance.  Looks nice, but not over complicated; mostly a bunch of simple cuts situated in a way that makes it look a little more upscale than what it really is :rolleyes: .  Also, I was trying to make an attempt at having a tiny bit of asian flair which is why I have the top assembled the way that I do. 

 

I still don't know if it works; I think I'm going to leave this on the wall for a couple of weeks to see how it grows on me.  Guessing there will be a few more tweeks before I batch them out for the other windows in the house..

 

Still would like to hear suggestions!  Everything so far has been a huge help in figuring out the areas that looked out of place :P ...

 

Please keep in mind, everything still needs to be primed and painted (most likely white)..

 

Thanks!

 

post-6031-0-18633000-1374463919_thumb.jp

 

 

post-6031-0-08972700-1374463935_thumb.jp

Posted

There is an article in finehomebuilding's pay site called "craftsman-style casing"   It shows complete dimensions and drawings for a very simple craftsman design (all straight cuts and butt joints :)).

 

It sounds like their design is similar to the one C Hicks provided which I really like :).  I agree that what I put together still looks a little off; I may shorten the top pieces on mine to make it a bit more symmetrical on the widths or even have the top slightly narrower than the bottom so the bottom ledge acts more like an anchor?  Going to let the wife make that call  :rolleyes:.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 57 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined