Boatworks Today Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 http://www.powermatic.com/Products.aspx?Part=1791001K Quote
mikem Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I was just reading about this myself. Since I dont have access to 220 in the garage, this is definitely a consideration for me for when my current table saw decides to quit. Quote
bgreenb Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I've been slowly looking at cabinet saws for a purchase (hopefully) next year. One thing I'm not sure of is how much horsepower I need. What is the practical difference among 1.75HP, 3HP, and 5HP? I'd like whatever I buy to be my last table saw, so I'd hate for it to be underpowered, but 5HP sounds like it would be overkill. I use hard maple from time to time but mostly work in walnut and cherry. I feel like it's hard to make a decision like this without trying all the saws personally. Quote
Tpt life Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I do not have a complete understanding of all things surrounding motors but as I understand usage I have been led to believe one thing. If your task requires 1.5 HP, the 1.75 will run hotter than the 3 or 5. This may not affect your everyday function but could affect the life of the motor as heat is one of the most degrading forces at work on the motor. Quote
pghmyn Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 That's quite a bit of money to pay for a hobbyist table saw. $800 more, and you have the PM2000 with the 3HP motor. BUT... Then again, I look at it as, if you want the Powermatic name, and only have access to 120V power, this saw is for you. Quote
dwacker Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 That's quite a bit of money to pay for a hobbyist table saw. $800 more, and you have the PM2000 with the 3HP motor. BUT... Then again, I look at it as, if you want the Powermatic name, and only have access to 120V power, this saw is for you. It also has the more compact typical homeowner size table. Quote
pghmyn Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 It also has the more compact typical homeowner size table. How big of a difference can 2" x 3.5" really make if you are considering purchasing a cabinet saw in the first place? Quote
Freddie Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 It makes a big difference. The blade is further back and its much easier to load sheet goods and align with fence before contact with blade. Plus extra weight provides vibration dampening. And, if youre into this sort of thing, its a bigger table to accumulate crap on. Quote
pghmyn Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 It makes a big difference. The blade is further back and its much easier to load sheet goods and align with fence before contact with blade. Plus extra weight provides vibration dampening. And, if youre into this sort of thing, its a bigger table to accumulate crap on. I just don't see the 2" making that big of a difference. Is the full 2 inches in front of the blade? Quote
dwacker Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 How big of a difference can 2" x 3.5" really make if you are considering purchasing a cabinet saw in the first place? It makes a big difference. The blade is further back and its much easier to load sheet goods and align with fence before contact with blade. Plus extra weight provides vibration dampening. And, if youre into this sort of thing, its a bigger table to accumulate crap on. Then you have the inch pinchers that have small shops that try to save every square inch of space. All these smaller lower HP saws are just contractor saws with enclosed bases but there is a market, so why not. For most week-end warriors I think they are a good compromise. I don't know what the specs are but the extra inches in front of the blade do make a big difference when you rip and cross cut full sheets on the tablesaw. But really most folks have the misconception that its unsafe so really it wont matter to most. The extra bit of crosscut sled support may be more appealing. When you use a full sized saw on a regular basis going to a contractor size is pretty obvious, but if you don't have the time with a full sized saw most wont notice the smaller size. Quote
Freddie Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 Easy to umderstand once used. I forgot to mention that if you had a miter gauge or sled on the saw you will also gain room for larger crosscuts. Quote
pghmyn Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 Then you have the inch pinchers that have small shops that try to save every square inch of space. All these smaller lower HP saws are just contractor saws with enclosed bases but there is a market, so why not. For most week-end warriors I think they are a good compromise. I don't know what the specs are but the extra inches in front of the blade do make a big difference when you rip and cross cut full sheets on the tablesaw. But really most folks have the misconception that its unsafe so really it wont matter to most. The extra bit of crosscut sled support may be more appealing. When you use a full sized saw on a regular basis going to a contractor size is pretty obvious, but if you don't have the time with a full sized saw most wont notice the smaller size. If we are talking about the inch pinchers, I can't imagine they would have the room to maneuver large sheet goods in their shops anyway. I understand a larger top is better if you can get it. But is it something that will really end a deal for you? I guess I don't have a good enough background to comment on it fully. Just my initial conception of the subject. I went from a small contractor saw to the hybrid saw that I have now. The top wings are solid instead of ribbed. Which is fabulous since now my pencil or tape measure do not fall through. The table is also 3-4" deeper and about 7-8" wider. I had a track saw prior to purchasing this saw, so I haven't had to process full sheets on it ever. The motor is 2HP wired to 220V, which seems like should be a minimum for anyone who uses any hardwoods on a regular basis. Quote
dwacker Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 If we are talking about the inch pinchers, I can't imagine they would have the room to maneuver large sheet goods in their shops anyway. I understand a larger top is better if you can get it. But is it something that will really end a deal for you? I guess I don't have a good enough background to comment on it fully. Just my initial conception of the subject. I went from a small contractor saw to the hybrid saw that I have now. The top wings are solid instead of ribbed. Which is fabulous since now my pencil or tape measure do not fall through. The table is also 3-4" deeper and about 7-8" wider. I had a track saw prior to purchasing this saw, so I haven't had to process full sheets on it ever. The motor is 2HP wired to 220V, which seems like should be a minimum for anyone who uses any hardwoods on a regular basis. It definitely not a saw I would purchase but IMO there is a market. Quote
Tpt life Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 Tools and fixtures need to project above the table saw in order to hinder ripping sheet goods. Inch pinching is about ease of movement around nested tooling. Inch pinching and sheet goods are not antithetical. Quote
jimmykx250 Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 $2269 vs $2819 for the sawstop. Why isnt anybody bringing this up? I still havent made the leap but for me it's a no brainer. I will say it's about time someone else put out a cabinet version with a 1.75hp. It looks like a decent saw too. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 $2269 vs $2819 for the sawstop. Why isnt anybody bringing this up? It's apples and oranges... You either care about flesh sensing, or you don't... If you do, there are only three saws to choose from, and all three have the same name on the cabinet. Quote
dwacker Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I've been slowly looking at cabinet saws for a purchase (hopefully) next year. One thing I'm not sure of is how much horsepower I need. What is the practical difference among 1.75HP, 3HP, and 5HP? I'd like whatever I buy to be my last table saw, so I'd hate for it to be underpowered, but 5HP sounds like it would be overkill. I use hard maple from time to time but mostly work in walnut and cherry. I feel like it's hard to make a decision like this without trying all the saws personally. The 3 and 5 hp are generally the same saws. So if you buy a 3hp you can generally swap out the motor for a 5 hp if you decide you need more power down the road. Quote
Chris H Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I've been slowly looking at cabinet saws for a purchase (hopefully) next year. One thing I'm not sure of is how much horsepower I need. What is the practical difference among 1.75HP, 3HP, and 5HP? I'd like whatever I buy to be my last table saw, so I'd hate for it to be underpowered, but 5HP sounds like it would be overkill. I use hard maple from time to time but mostly work in walnut and cherry. I feel like it's hard to make a decision like this without trying all the saws personally. I didn't see a reply to this, but perhaps I overlooked it. First, this statement is based on a high quality blade (read: Forrest WWII). 1.75 HP will make easy work of any domestics less than or equal to 6/4 stock. It will make its way through 8/4, but may bog down a bit. If you are going to work in 10/4+ wood regularly, you will want a 3hp. Quite honestly, if you are asking, 5 hp is very likely too much saw. You need to be making a lot of saw dust, out of extremely dense, and thick cut lumber to ever stress a quality 3hp saw with a good sharp blade. Quote
Freddie Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I would imagine 5 hp would be more likely in a production shop where power feeders are being used. Faster feed rate can also bog down or stall an underpowered machine. Quote
bgreenb Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 Thanks guys - that's what I figured. I think a 3HP is almost certainly the way to go for me (and probably most hobbyists). Quote
knotscott Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I've been slowly looking at cabinet saws for a purchase (hopefully) next year. One thing I'm not sure of is how much horsepower I need. What is the practical difference among 1.75HP, 3HP, and 5HP? I'd like whatever I buy to be my last table saw, so I'd hate for it to be underpowered, but 5HP sounds like it would be overkill. I use hard maple from time to time but mostly work in walnut and cherry. I feel like it's hard to make a decision like this without trying all the saws personally. There's a big difference between 1.75hp and 3hp. I'm sure 5hp would be nice, but I can't imagine needing it in a hobby shop. With good alignment, and the right blade, a 1.75 hp motor can cut all that you need it to, but it's alot fussier about setup, blade choice, and feed rate, plus it'll labor a lot more, 3hp barely works up a sweat, and doesn't seem to care much if I change to the correct blade.. If you've got 220v, go with 3hp Quote
Scott M Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I was just reading about this myself. Since I dont have access to 220 in the garage, this is definitely a consideration for me for when my current table saw decides to quit. Looking at the specs they are recommending a 30 amp circuit. My guess would be that most people setting up shop in a garage/basement aren't going to have available 30 amp circuits either. Quote
mikem Posted July 26, 2013 Report Posted July 26, 2013 I saw that, but the amp draw of the motor is rated at 15amps. I have a feeling powermatic is being overly cautious for those who try to use it as a PM2000. Quote
Rick LoDico Posted July 27, 2013 Report Posted July 27, 2013 I have a US made PM66 and the saw really impresses me. But there's no way I'd spend over 2K for a hybrid saw even if it's a PM. Get the Grizzly for 1K less. Quote
wdwerker Posted July 27, 2013 Report Posted July 27, 2013 I have an old 1 1/2 hp UniSaw that runs on 120 v. It only rips 8/4 with a 30 amp circut and a thin kerf 3/32 blade. When I had it on a 20 amp circut using a 1/8 kerf blade it would bog down and trip the breaker. Pulled heavier wire, changed the breaker and it just bogged down sometimes. Switched to a 3/32 kerf thin rip blade and it rips 8/4 maple like a champ, as long as there is a splitter to keep the kerf open. My 5 hp 220 UniSaw never hesitates, I crosscut a large batch of 8/4 x 10" planks at 45* and was glad to have the power. 3 hp might have done it but who knows? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.