mtbercrash40 Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Hi. I am soo tempted to buy an air compressor from them. First off,...I am just getting into wood working as a lifestyle and hobby. I love it! My wife has been impressed with what Ive made for her and the family so far. My upcoming wood projects that I would love to have an air compressor are: Making windows for my shed. Drawers for under my work bench. Shelves for our laundry room, my son's room and spare closet. A shoe shelf for the lady of the house. Night stands for the grand children. Stepping stool for the youngest grand daughter. Keep sake chests for wife and grand daughter. Head board and foot board for spare bedroom. Jigs. Theres more but I cant recall right now. But with these projects in mind,...what would yall (so kindly) recommend? Im slowly reading up on the difference in air compressors. But the HFT prices are so attractive. Thx for any feedback guys. Quote
Dave's Not Here Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 A little more information please. What is it that you expect to use the compressor for? If all you want to do is shoot a few brads then pretty much any compressor will do that. If on the other hand you want to spray finishes or use air sanders, drills, etc. then you'll need to compare the air consumption of those types of tools to the cfm air output of the compressors you're considering. Noise could be another concern here, the HF compressors, the oil less variety, are notoriously loud. Quote
missioninwood Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 HF is good for some things but I would not recommend a compressor. If you do buy from there, spring for the extended warranty (which I never get!) and plan to make repeated trips back to the store for replacements. Like all good tools, you get what you pay for--for the most part. When I buy something from HF I am happy if I get two to three uses out of it before disposal. If you want a quality tool, well, you get the idea.... I work in specialty retail for WW enthusiasts, I know it is hard to justify the cost of a Festool Kapex when you can get three DeWalt saws for the same price, but in most cases spending the money is worth it. FESTOOL, baby! And "Dave's Not Here" is dead on. miw Quote
chrisphr Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 From multiple and pretty credible sources I have heard never to buy anything with a motor in it from HF. Quote
chrisphr Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 Check out this hitachi compressor, 55 reviews with nearly 5 star rating. On sale with a couple brad nailers. http://www.lowes.com/pd_331410-67702-KNT65APR_4294795218__?productId=3260195&Ns=p_product_avg_rating|1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 Being on a tight budget, I have purchased a lot of tools from HF. Generally, you can tell when you check it out in the store if it is crap or not. My experience has been that the ratio of crappy vs. OK hand tools is just about the same as it is for power tools. That being said, a lot of their stuff is well worth the money. Since a wood worker never has enough clamps, watch for sales and load up on those F style bar clamps. The Windsor Design '#33' hand plane is a surprising find as well, for just $9! And even though the Drillmaster cordless drill they carry is obviously not top quality, it IS an 18 volt drill, and is great for driving screws. Mine has already outlived my previous Ryobi ($99 on sale), it only cost $15! I don't have a compressor from HF, but the units I have seen in the store appear to be t least s good as my little Porter Cable pancake unit. Just look closely at what you are buying, and remember to buy the extended warranty for anything you don't consider disposable. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 From multiple and pretty credible sources I have heard never to buy anything with a motor in it from HF. I've heard from multiple sources that the HF 2.0 HP dust collector with metal impeller is a good machine at a great price. 2 Quote
Dan S Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 I've heard from multiple sources that the HF 2.0 HP dust collector with metal impeller is a good machine at a great price.My 8x12/14 metal lathe is very good as well, it's more precise than some machines several times what it cost me. Quote
missioninwood Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 Copy that on the F-Style Clamps. But how about this for a reference? http://www.toolcrib.com/blog/2008/08/buyer-beware-a-harbor-freight-buying-guide-the-good-enough-the-bad-and-the-abysmal miw Quote
mtbercrash40 Posted August 16, 2013 Author Report Posted August 16, 2013 A little more information please. What is it that you expect to use the compressor for? If all you want to do is shoot a few brads then pretty much any compressor will do that. If on the other hand you want to spray finishes or use air sanders, drills, etc. then you'll need to compare the air consumption of those types of tools to the cfm air output of the compressors you're considering. Noise could be another concern here, the HF compressors, the oil less variety, are notoriously loud. Well, when I took a close look at the size of nails that are used in these guns,..i would say a finishing nail up to 2" would be a good start. I've never used or maybe even seen brads though. My list of projects is definitely going to be taken care of with or without a compressor. And just like some of you guys mentioned, Ive heard too. About anything with a motor form HF is a gamble. I suppose I just need to be a little more patient for a bit longer and I'll have the money for something good from the larger box stores. No painting or auto work. Just air up some bike and truck tires, and for wood working projects. So the oil-free ones are loud? Quote
Dan S Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 with regards to the compressors I just took a look at what hf is currently carrying, and i wasn't really impressed. all the cheap compressors are oilless. Unless you like really loud machines, and machines that don't last very long, don't get an oilless compressor. Several others had low(125 psi) max outputs, and while that sounds fine, its usually means the tank has less air in it than a small tank that stores at a higher pressure.With all that said, the cheapest compressor that I would consider looking at would be this one.http://www.harborfreight.com/air-tools/air-compressors/2-horsepower-150-cast-iron-vertical-air-compressor-68127.htmlit has good reviews on the website, and has some good reviews as well out on the web.for reference I have had one of these for going on 7 years now.http://www.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-5-Gal-Mini-Wheelbarrow-Air-Compressor-DISCONTINUED-OL50145MWD/100618265#.Ug2cEJK1HTo Quote
Dave's Not Here Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 Yes, the oil less compressors tend to be more noisy than the oil lubricated compressors are. That being said there are some oil less compressors that are less noisy than others. If you can get the retailer to fire one up for you so you can hear the noise level that would be the best way for you to judge different models. Also, don't be fooled into thinking that just because something is sold at a big box store that the quality is necessarily better then what you'll find at Harbor Freight. From your description of how you intend to use your new compressor, I think that one that has as output of at least 3cfm @ 90psi and at least a 3 gallon tank will serve you nicely. Quote
dwacker Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 Just watch the specs manufacturers tend to fudge. Your going to get 3 to 4 cfm per HP. Alot of compressors are rebranded like Dewalt which is Emglo. You can buy the Emglo for much less than the Dewalt and have the same quality compressor. I would not buy an oil less. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 16, 2013 Report Posted August 16, 2013 I buy EVERY tool one at a time, regardless of source. That goes for everyone, Harbor Freight to Powermatic, Footprint to Lie Nielsen... 2 Quote
mtbercrash40 Posted August 17, 2013 Author Report Posted August 17, 2013 From your description of how you intend to use your new compressor, I think that one that has as output of at least 3cfm @ 90psi and at least a 3 gallon tank will serve you nicely. Thank you,..this is the kind of info I really needed too! This is a perfect guide for me to go by. Quote
aerofly0610 Posted August 17, 2013 Report Posted August 17, 2013 Get what you pay for still applies to HF. HF is a dice roll. Sometimes you can get stuff that is decent, other times its complete junk and waste of money. As long as people are willing to gamble, they will keep selling cheap Chinese stuff. Quote
Popular Post knotscott Posted August 17, 2013 Popular Post Report Posted August 17, 2013 From multiple and pretty credible sources I have heard never to buy anything with a motor in it from HF. It's hard for me to imagine a "credible source" making a such a generalized statement. You just can't generalize about an entire line of tools with any accuracy. HF tools are a far cry from top shelf IMO, and I'd be uncomfortable getting a big ticket item at HF, but there are some viable tools for a weekend warrior if you're selective. Like with any tools, you need to evaluate the individual tool, and consider the intended usage. HF's return policy is pretty good, so buying from a store is fairly safe.....get a dud, take it back. My HF DP, mortiser, multi-tool, and compressor were all good buys and decent performers for a hobby shop, though I doubt they'd last long on a job site...they're not professional grade tools. The only plug in device from HF that I've been disappointed in were the $5 hair rippers, I mean clippers. Lots of people own the 2hp DC and love it, many have had acceptable results with the HF jointers, and the new $50 routers have a pretty strong following. Compare prices and features, play the coupon game to your advantage, and don't overpay. 3 Quote
Byrdie Posted August 17, 2013 Report Posted August 17, 2013 I needed a scroll saw for a small project I was working on but wasn't sure that I'd use it for much else. I didn't want to pay the full retail price I was seeing elsewhere or at the local big box so I went to Craig's List and found a new in the box saw for $20. The brand was one I'd never heard of, "Central Machine," but I figured I couldn't lose at the price for a possible one time use. I did a little research and found out Central Machine is one of HF's house brands. I'd heard the same rumors about HF and had never bought there. This saw has a nice cast metal base, is very sturdy and works quite well as a cutting tool. The dust collection leaves some to be desired but I've found many more uses for the saw since I got it and figure I can modify the dust collection if I really get annoyed by it. I'm planning to build a base for the saw to make it better fit my workshop and have no intention of replacing it. I'll admit, I got lucky. But I'll also not knock HF tools. All the advice to take a close look at the tool, in store if possible, and buy on a per item basis is sound advice. There are winners and losers in every category. Find the tool that best fits your intended use and your budget and make the two work together. Quote
bobcrosley Posted August 19, 2013 Report Posted August 19, 2013 I own the HF 2HP DC because it gets pretty good overall reviews from the huge number of people who own it, and I can say it does work well. I also own about a dozen of their F-style clamps, and have no problem with them. I don't own, but have heard pretty good things, too, about their cast-iron bed lathes. I don't have any hard and fast rules about what I'll buy there. Consumables, like glue brushes and gloves are no-brainers. Other items, I tend to evaluate based on what I'll use it for, the need for precision in that particular device and reviews from places like HFReviews.com. Generally speaking, I make some effort to try to find quality used tools before deciding on HF, but I'm also a hobbyist wood worker, with a limited hobby budget, so I don't turn my nose up on tools that might help me get the job done. Quote
missioninwood Posted August 19, 2013 Report Posted August 19, 2013 I own the HF 2HP DC because it gets pretty good overall reviews from the huge number of people who own it, and I can say it does work well. I also own about a dozen of their F-style clamps, and have no problem with them. I don't own, but have heard pretty good things, too, about their cast-iron bed lathes. I don't have any hard and fast rules about what I'll buy there. Consumables, like glue brushes and gloves are no-brainers. Other items, I tend to evaluate based on what I'll use it for, the need for precision in that particular device and reviews from places like HFReviews.com. Generally speaking, I make some effort to try to find quality used tools before deciding on HF, but I'm also a hobbyist wood worker, with a limited hobby budget, so I don't turn my nose up on tools that might help me get the job done. This "turning up your nose" business is a good, soild point. I have always said you need to base your tool purchase decisions on how frequently you will use the tool and the quality you expect from it. I bought one of the HF Multifunction tools for less than $40. I have used it about ten times. It has always done the trick. Paid for itself, one might say. Would be another story if I paid $400 for a Fein. I say there is no shame in buying HF if it gets the job done and you don't mind directly tossing it when it craps out. But it is a crap shoot. I had an HF Band Saw that never did work yet I have met guys who have run their entire business (for 25 years!) on an HF Angle Grinder, go figure. Having said that, "Roll the Bones." miw Quote
woodieboy Posted August 20, 2013 Report Posted August 20, 2013 I don't have HF tools but I think it is a good place to buy your stuff. Of course, we always want affordable but reliable tools. Quote
pawon Posted August 22, 2013 Report Posted August 22, 2013 Hi, Personally I would never buy a Harbor Freight compressor. Go for a decent brand with a good reputation, like Quincy, Ingersoll Rand (their older compressors, most new are crap), Campbell Hausfeld. When choosing a compressor, it is very important to keep the following in mind: * What pressure do I need? * What capacity do I need? Don't look at horsepower. Horsepower is only a result of the pressure and capacity. Plus, most brands will inflate the horspower rating (you will read things like 'peak horsepower'), which is total nonsense. Nailers and small tools don't use a lot of air. A single stage air compressor would do the trick. If you want to use air power machines like drills and grinders (or anything that rotates), you gonna need a bigger air compressor! Probably, you will need to get a two-stage reciprocating compressor in that case. Single-stage compressores go up to about 20 cfm. Two-stage compressors go up to about 50 cfm. Make an inventory of all the tools you will use and add up the air consumption. Now you know the capacity of the air compressor you need. A must-read is this site: http://www2.air-compressor-guide.com/air-compressor-buying-guide/ Pawon Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 22, 2013 Report Posted August 22, 2013 One thing I forgot to mention earlier... My personal opinion of Harbor Freight changed dramatically when a local store opened. In my experience, the difference between a lot of off-brand and branded imported items is often quality control. Once I could select items personally, or easily return packed items that could not be inspected before purchase, I started buying from HF more often. For example, casters... HF has several models of casters that are extremely cheap. Picking through the bin, I can find a quantity that work fine for the intended purpose, along with many examples that should have never been shipped across the Pacific. Before the store opened, I had more than one bad mail order experience with HF, as their order pickers didn't seem to care which items they tossed into the box. While they do guarantee satisfaction, returning mail ordered items is a pain, and can be expensive. The ability to buy locally takes a bunch of the risk away. Quote
mikem Posted August 22, 2013 Report Posted August 22, 2013 Agreed there, it is much more of gamble to buy online with HF, and don't know that I ever would. I have a local store as well, and so far everything thing I have bought there (including the "2" hp DC) has ended up working out well for me. Even their cheapo clamps helped me by until I was able to afford higher quality clamps. I have seen their castors, and wish i had found them much earlier, but the next time I need them, that is likely where I will get them. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.