Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust collection strategy - how do you tell if yours is working?

Featured Replies

I've been thinking a lot recently about dust collection strategies, and how best to protect myself. Currently I have a shop vac and a separator collecting dust at the source. This is reasonably effective as far as I know because the chips are being collected. I'm also a fair weather woodworker*, so I have a 20" box fan in an open window cycling air through the barn shop. I don't do as much woodworking as I'd like, and I have a very limited budget.

 

My question is - how can you (cheaply) tell that your dust strategy is working? I'm not too keen on using my lungs as a test!

 

Have you bought an air quality tester? Are there any pitfalls to doing so?

 

*Nova Scotia's too cold to be wood working in an unheated barn shop in winter.

If I didn't have respiratory problems, I would probably be looking at the dust that accumulates on top of places that don't get disturbed very often. Anything that is there, potentially could have been in your lungs. Chips are not the problem, you will know when you breathe those.

Although gross, your nose is a good filer also. After spending the day in the shop, blow your nose and see if it it he same color as the wood you were working with. Other option is to wear a disposable dust mask and check it at the end of the day or week.

I have a Clearvue cyclone, an overhead air cleaner and a prefilter on my AC unit. Even with all that I wear a dust mask when sanding or working with MDF. Next step for me is a central filtered air supply for my Triton powered air mask.

BRuce

Just look around. I can pretty much guarantee you don't have sufficient dust collection. It takes serious dust collection equipment to actually collect "properly". All you can do is the best you can and install what is within your means. My shop stays very clean until I add another guy. My cyclone can't keep up with two guys. I can do a single kitchen by myself and when I'm done its still clean. We just finished a 40 unit batch and my shop looks like a dust bomb exploded. Dont over think it and just use some common sense.

==> It takes serious dust collection equipment to actually collect "properly"...

 

+1

 

The small systems just collect the easy stuff...   For all the marketing claims out there, it takes quite a bit of power (and $$) to get the truly dangerous stuff (say 3 to 5 microns)...  way more then the sales literature would have you believe.  Folks with small collectors should still be using dust masks -- especially around things like drum sanders...

==> MDF

 

Shame it's so useful because it makes such an unholy mess when you hit it with a router...  I use MDF for veneer substrate and [sometimes] shop jigs, but I really do try to avoid it because of the dust/mess-factor.

  • Author

I've been using a respirator with a P100 filter, but it's not the most comfortable thing to wear. It's heavy and the water coming off my breath collects on the inside of the mask. When I take a break from playing working I go outside before taking it off. I might try and find some of the filters Marc talks about in one of his filters, which is designed to keep the dust out, but not the VOCs.

 

I also do all my sanding outside to keep the dust levels in the shop down so I have less to clean up. Still wear my respirator when sanding even though I'm outside.

 

My exhaust fan is currently just hanging in the window. There's a substantial gap around the outside of the fan. I think I'll add a plywood panel round it to make sure it's not circling back into the barn shop

I hate respirators. 

 

I made a low-tech supplied air system that works fantastically.  I bought some "disposable" Tyvek supplied air hoods (I bought thee, but I'm still using the first one for many hours), a mid-sized new Shop Vac that is never used for anything else-marked "Breathing Air Only", and some long hoses.  The hoses are hooked to the blow side of the ShopVac, and the machine sits outside in clean air on the windward side of the building I'm working in. I never get dust in my nose regardless of how dusty the atmosphere is that I'm working in.  The air blowing over your head keeps it dry regardless of how hot it is.  You have to tie it on, or it will blow off.

 

  A small vac would probably be enough, but I like this one just fine.  I wasn't sure how much loss of air flow a little one would have with a long hose, and the mid sized one didn't cost much more.

 

Here's a picture of me working on plaster with it on.   http://www.historic-house-restoration.com/images/april182013_012.JPG

 

Here's a hood:  http://www.envirosafetyproducts.com/air-supplied-hood-low-pressure-9910.html

 

replacement hoods:   http://www.envirosafetyproducts.com/air-supplied-hood-respirator-replacement-9910-10.html

 

I have several types of respirators that I used to use before I put this system together.  A respirator is no comparison.  Take the hood off in clean air after you're (notice that's you're and not your) finished working, and your head is completely clean and dry.

That's wild.....what are you doing, avoiding lead based paint dust?

I doubt that is what he is doing. My plan is for a spa blower sucking air through a HEPA filter and blowing through an overhead flexible hose to my Triton head piece. I have only one functional lung ( paralyzed diaphragm) and asthma. I can't risk more impediments to my breathing or I will have to give up woodworking.

We all do what we need to do to keep woodworking,

BRuce

  • Author

Those are awesome hoods, and I love the breathing-air only vac. Do you have a filter on the vac, or is it just there to blow fresh air into the hood?

The vac pulls air through a HEPA filter, but where I sit it, it would only pull fresh air in anyway.  It avoids any kind of dust.  The whole thing is easily portable, and a snap to pop on.  It comes with a belt that snaps around your waist to hold it on.  It doesn't take long getting used to looking through the plastic shield, and is many times more comfortable than a respirator.

 

In that picture I'm cutting the picture rail out of the plaster with a Dremel tool and another Shop Vac to catch as much of the plaster dust as it can.  I explain it on that page:   http://www.historic-house-restoration.com/Plaster.html

Great idea!  I've always had problems with respirators for two reasons.  First, my beard makes problems with the seal around my face.  Second, trying to fit my glasses, goggles, and respirator on my nose at the same time doesn't work well.

 

I'm going get one of these hoods.

 

Thanks!

I think this is the air pump I use. I've had it some years, and mine is a little different looking than ones available now.  I don't think you could ever clean up a used one enough for breathing air.  Keep the box and all the packing stuff, try it, and if you don't like the amount of air flow, exchange it at Lowes up or down.  They're good about taking something back, and it will still be clean.

 

http://www.lowes.com/ProductDisplay?partNumber=334639-20097-9330611&langId=-1&storeId=10151&productId=3326078&catalogId=10051&cmRelshp=req&rel=nofollow&cId=PDIO1

 

The hose was the most expensive part of the system.  I have four of these, and when not in use, ends get put together to avoid junk getting in them.   http://www.lowes.com/pd_17026-20097-9198111_0__?productId=1042233&CAWELAID=1040759360

 

I had to modify an adaptor to get the vac hose to mate to the hose on the hood.

 

It's probably healthier to wear this while sanding, than to breathe room air normally.

Tom, how much distortion does the hood have? One of the things I don't like about my Trition is the distortion. When I am turning at the lathe it is most noticeable.

Thanks for the links to product sites.

BRuce

I don't wear glasses but am very aware of sunglasses that bend light at all.  Distortion is not an issue.  Field of view, yes, but not bad.  I wouldn't wear it while operating a powered saw or jointer just because the hose kind of has a hold on you.  I think it would work fine at a lathe.  At first you probably won't like it, but now, it doesn't bother me at all.  It comes with a tear-away cover.  When that thing finally got scratched up enough to pull it off, things became much better.  I've been careful with it since, and have used it for many hours with the single layer clear.  When I do change out to another hood, I'll pull the tear-away off to start with.

 

Someone gave me three of those Triton battery powered hoods.  The only one I use is the welding one in very special situations.  No comparison between one of those and the supplied air hood.

When I sanded wood with the Triton, I could smell what kind of wood I was working on.  With the air pump sitting in clean air, you can't even smell what you're working on.

I would be the prankster introducing an open jar of pickles or such to your inlet port lol!

What kind of noise level with shop vac volume air flow through your hood Tom?

  • Author

My hearing seems to be pretty sensitive to machine noise. If I don't use hearing protection, I end up with tinnitus if I use my router, table saw or planer for any practical period of time. I end up wearing in the ear foam pads which seems to work quite well and would be fine under a hood like that

It's certainly nothing like the noise from a saw running.  I keep the little foam ear plugs in my pocket all the time.  I probably do stick them in when I'm wearing the hood, because I'm running something close to it if it's on.  I take the ear plugs in and out so much that I don't even think about them.  Ear plugs stay in the pocket when pants go through a wash, and them come out clean and still in the pocket most of the time.  I keep a box of 100 or 250 pairs (can't remember which) on the wall in the shop, and the box lasts for years.

  • 2 weeks later...

A good respirator mask is a cost-efficient first line of defense in a shop. I like the 3M 6391. It's lightweight and smaller profile and comes with P100 filters. http://www.amazon.com/3M-6391-P100-Reusable-Respirator/dp/B001NDN29O/ref=sr_1_39?ie=UTF8&qid=1377804151&sr=8-39&keywords=dust+masks.

I also use a box fan for sanding and paint fumes. I encased one with scrap wood that has slots to slide filters in and out easily. I use the cheap 20x20x1 for painting but get the better pleated filters for sanding dust. Here's my blog post on that fan setup:

http://woodworkguy.blogspot.com/2013/07/boxing-in-box-fan-for-better-filtration.html. I also have other posts for shop vac accessories and dust collection on my contractor saw. I plan to put in a dust collection system this fall.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.