Recommended Posts

Posted

I have an opportunity to buy a Grizzly G0609 jointer for $1,200 or a General 80-300M1 jointer for $2,500. From what I can tell, they have approx. the same specs. but significantly different prices. Does anyone have experience with either machine or the brands in general, and what do you think about them? Are there somethings that I should check out carefully, and which one whould you buy? Thanks for your help.

Posted

The General is a better machine, but is it twice as good?  I doubt it.  I'd personally go with the Grizzly unless you're doing production work and you'll be using it hard every day.

Posted

What does "new" price tell you?

 

There are lots of tools out there that are outrageously overpriced.  Price is just half the value equation, and doesn't mean much without the other piece.  I don't know anything about either tool, but base your decision on more than asking price please.  

 

There are very distinct marketing tactics, one is to sell many units at low margin, another is a few units at high margin.  Plenty of companies, in all industries, are happy at either end of the spectrum.  Again, neither is a reflection of quality or performance.  In some cases pricing is a reflection of distribution strength and strategies.  Grizzly is definitely a juggernaut in the USA for distribution strength.  They get to keep a healthy margins in their pocket while under cutting competitors because they don't pay a distributor or retailer.  I don't know anything about General, but if they sell to someone who sells to consumers, then a lot of that price has nothing to do with the product at all.  

  • Like 2
Posted

What does "new" price tell you?

 

 

 

It tells you that your comparing machines on different level. The general is more comparable to the Grizzly Ultimate series in fact it uses the same bed assembly and cost $1200 additional. The difference is the cutter head. The general uses a 3 knife vs a 4. The three knife head is better head than the 4 knife. The three knife head has a higher chip load capacity and deeper depth of cut. Add generals overall better quality standards and you have two different machines.

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think the price tells you that, but all of those things are excellent reasons why the General sounds like a better machine.  Magic question is whether or not it is twice the machine or not.  

Posted

I don't think the price tells you that, but all of those things are excellent reasons why the General sounds like a better machine.  Magic question is whether or not it is twice the machine or not.  

 

Sure it does. Original price is the first clue that your comparing machines that are at different levels.The clue that you need to look a little deeper. Is it twice the machine? Thats up to the guy buying the machine to decide. Is a $30K Martin 15 times the machine? Again up to the purchaser to decide. 

Posted

Are they not both Taiwanese machines? It's been my experience that paint color and switch mounts and maybe a few other upgrades are all that separate most new machines of similar looks. I have PM yellow parts on a North State blue machine.

It seems like general, delta and powermatic all are operating off of their reputations built over the decades of in house production.

Steve

Posted

==> There are lots of tools out there that are outrageously overpriced.  Price is just half the value equation

 

==> Original price is the first clue that your comparing machines that are at different levels.

 

There's a lot of truth in both statements...

 

Sure some brands are 'premium' -- is a FT sander really two-times 'better' then a PC-low profile sander, however one defines better?  Is a Mirka CEROS really three-times 'better'?  Same goes for Felder -vs- Powermatic -- is the Felder five-times 'better'?  Is a LN plane four-times as good as a Stanley record?  Is Snap-on really three-times better than Craftsman?  Are these brands 'outrageously' priced?  The market says not --- they are considered 'premium' brands and are priced at the top of what the market is willing to pay --- if the marketplace considered them outrageously-priced, they wouldn't remain in business...

 

Sure, there are some price-outliers.  But over the years, I've learned that, in general, with woodworking tools you basically get what you pay for.  As PB points-out, price is a starting point.  But as others point out, there are more factors than just price...

 

A metric that I use for quality/value/etc is how well tools/eqpt hold their value on the used market.  Some brands simply hold their values long-term.  I think I sold my 10-year-old PM66 for just about what I paid for it -- that's not going to happen with Grizzly.

 

@OP: both prices are very low for that kit -- the Grizzly is usually about $2K and the General is closer to $5K... So it looks like you are getting them at a 50% discount... That's a bit unusual.  Are you getting some special deal, is the eqpt used?  If you can, get a chance to look-over both pieces of kit in person -- it's the best way to select new gear... 

Posted

How do you determine what products do or don't hold their value?  (That isn't sarcastic, I am genuinely interested.  I haven't found a good source)

 

Internet auction sites are notoriously illogical at best when it comes to pricing.  They are what people are asking, not what they are getting.  Those that are getting what they ask quickly have the auction removed due to sale, and you are left with what we call "noise" in the data.  Also, I find that quality products just aren't available (maybe just in my market).  People buying non-HIC (home improvement center) brand tools, typically seem to be holding onto them for a long time (myself included).  So CL is flooded with Ryobi, and Craftsmen tools, not too many PM, or Grizzly's out there, and if they are they're 30+ years old.  

Posted

==> Internet auction sites are notoriously illogical at best when it comes to pricing.  They are what people are asking, not what they are getting.

Agreed, you can’t really rely on Craigslist, eBay, etc…  On eBay, you can filter for completed sales -- that helps with portable tools, but large kit is few/far between. 

 

 

==> How do you determine what products do or don't hold their value?

 

Over the past 15+ years, I've relocated for my ‘real job’ several times, so I've had to buy/sell stationary machines accordingly…  My best source was ForceMachine, but he went under last year.  I've also used WoodWerks -- they have a great sales staff and have been quite helpful when I had to buy/sell my last round of kit…  The sales staff know what holds value and what doesn't.  Since I have to periodically both buy and sell, I get help on both sides of the transaction. 

Posted

Market price is an interesting dynamic.  It can lie, but  also doesn't lie for very long.  It is possible to have a premium priced product, and have poor value, poor quality and no innovation. But that doesn't last for too long, the market will react.  Price will come down or sales will slow.

 

On the other hand, some companies have great value and good quality yet charge low prices, it is just their strategy.  Grizzly is a great example of this, not exactly an innovative company and they have inexpensive distribution.  Low price and high volume.

 

I would go with the tool you like best and can afford.  Based upon the new price, I think the General is a better value but I don't know much about them.  I know I am happy with my 6" Grizzly jointer.  

Posted

Wow Guys! Am I impressed. All these responses in less than 10 hours. This says something about WoodTalk and you guys on the forum. I appreciate all your comments and suggestions. I'm unsure what I'm going to do, but I'm leaning toward the Grizzly because I will not be using it in a production environment but for producing custom furniture. When I make a final decison, I'll let you know.

 

Thanks again for all your help and comments.

Posted

"Are FT twice better than PC?" No they are not. They are about 10 +times better. I was going through 2-3 porter cable top shelf 6" angle sanders a year. The festool ro150 is now 7 years old and has cost me about $ 100 in new brushes, cords ect. But a weekend warrior would be pleased with a pc sander and it might just last 10 years. So really there is a place for the two price points.

I have a generic North State 12" jointer that I'd expect is a litter mate to the grizzly (dovetail ways) and several others. I'm not specifically familiar with the general. But if its not a parallelogram style and its made in Asia, then it's about the same quality. I use it every day and sometimes all day everyday. New motor, belts, bearings, and a starter in 14 years ain't too bad. Don't get me wrong though. It works but I have to constantly check and adjust it to keep it going great. I will replace it with a 17-18" Martin or other European model one day.

So get the cheaper one I guess is my advice. Unless it is a Canadian mfg general jointer then it might really be worth it.

Steve

Posted

What makes folks think choices like this have anything to do with a production environment? Jointers are not a production machine they are a one man shop machine two man at very most. For the most part they are thought of as a hobby shop machine unnecessary in the production world. The same applies to most every machine you will find in our shops be it powermatic or grizzly. Wether you do this professionally or not none of the machines you find in our average shops are in any way production machines. None of these import companies make production class machinery. It's all just small custom shop and hobby shop equipment some is better than others. Some will hold up better to daily use than others but all of it is light duty moderate intermittent use machinery.

Go out and kick some tires and see what machine fits your idea of what your looking for. You may find the Griz meets your every expectation or you may take one look and run away.

Posted

==> "Are FT twice better than PC?" No they are not. They are about 10 +times better. 

 

==> I have a generic North State 12" jointer... I will replace it with a 17-18" Martin

 

Being that the Martin is about $20K, will it be 10x better than the North State?   :)

 

 

Comparing equipment can become an exercise in apples/oranges and boils down to the experience and expectation of the user... Both the Martin and North State surface stock, but they certainly play to different expectations... and for a $20K difference in price, they should...  

 

I've got a mix of Powermatic and Euro kit (Felder & Griggio) in my shop...  Is the Euro kit 'better' than the Powermatic -- sure...  But is it 4x better than the Powermatic? -- that's highly debatable...

 

@OP:  PB is right -- go kick some tires prior to spending hard-earned $$...  don't make decisions based on specs, sales/marketing literature, internet reviews, etc -- or the opinions on this forum...  We all approach 'value' from our own experience, expectations, workflow, and projects...

Posted

What makes folks think choices like this have anything to do with a production environment? Jointers are not a production machine they are a one man shop machine two man at very most. For the most part they are thought of as a hobby shop machine unnecessary in the production world. The same applies to most every machine you will find in our shops be it powermatic or grizzly. Wether you do this professionally or not none of the machines you find in our average shops are in any way production machines. None of these import companies make production class machinery. It's all just small custom shop and hobby shop equipment some is better than others. Some will hold up better to daily use than others but all of it is light duty moderate intermittent use machinery.

Go out and kick some tires and see what machine fits your idea of what your looking for. You may find the Griz meets your every expectation or you may take one look and run away.

Yeah what he said!

Posted

Every now and then Mercedes makes a lemon.  Some people loved their Yugo.  The likelihood of getting a lemon Mercedes in comparison to a champ Yugo is night and day but the analogy holds.  Comparing the dollar value has only a minimum of value.  Go out an look at the tool.  Look at the way it is assemble, how the parts are machined, if it has a good warranty and customer support.  Figure out the types of challenges you are going to present to the tool, the environment you are going to use it in and how it's going to effect your budget.

 

Personally, I think anyone who uses the color the machine is painted or the look of it's logo as the primary purchasing criteria out to be taken out behind their shop, painted with the same color and branded with the logo.

 

Yeah, sometimes I can be a little opinionated.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 56 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined