Recommended Posts

Posted

Here is my first attempt at 'fine' furniture. Needed a table with a drawer to stash tv remotes and such. I picked the Shaker style as something that looked doable for my (in)exeperince level. I chose walnut because I really like the color and richness. Maple drawer box for nice contrast. The legs are sized to fit next to the easy chairs in our living room. Sealed with shellac, topped with wipe-on poly, on the tabletop only.

post-14065-0-44791600-1380538079_thumb.j

post-14065-0-31291900-1380538133_thumb.j

Posted

Great job for a first go!  A couple easy tips to spruce things up on the next try:

 

Taper those legs! :)  It really makes a huge difference on a little table like that and turns a simple design into an elegant one.  A tapering jig is a breeze to make.

 

Rotate the table top 90* so the end grain isn't staring you in the face.  And be careful about cutting the checks out of the ends of your boards...those could cause some issues in the future.

 

Take a little bit more time to think about the grain on the drawer front...besides the top that's the first thing people see.

 

Your dovetails look great if they're your first try.  Love me some skinny pins!

  • Like 2
Posted

I agree with everything ~ERIC~ said.

 

Shaker stuff is certainly more approachable than some of the more ornate styles. However, the devil is in the details. :)

 

A very good habit to get into is, cut off the first inch of the board and check for checking... Keep doing it until they are gone. I take one more cut after the checks are gone just to be safe. I don't want a half-check in my pieces.

 

It also looks like you put a small chamfer on the top of the top. This takes away from the crisp features these tables are known for. Tapering the underside of the top makes a thick top look thinner, kind of the same idea as tapering the legs.

Posted

Just curious, what don't you like about the grain on the drawer front?  Do you think it is too strong for shaker? 

 

I'm anal and I like symmetry.  The grain on the drawer front slopes down to the right and gives me a feeling of imbalance.  Not only that, but it starts as flat grain at the top and ends up as rift-sawn, straight grain at the bottom.  If it were perfectly horizontal I don't think it would be so noticeable, but as it is it stands out to my eye.  Gives me the feeling of waves crashing into the beach instead of looking west upon that same beach and watching the sun settling beyond the horizon...which is the look I would be going for if it were my project.

 

A good technique (which was covered in the Guild's Shaker table build) is to make the drawer front and top and bottom aprons out of one piece of stock for continuity...and choosing that piece of stock very carefully since it is pretty much the focal point of the table.  It makes a big difference on a small piece like this one.

 

That said, I'm betting the Shakers building these tables 200 years ago didn't spend a whole lot of time worrying about grain since they were the practical utilitarian types.  Although they did take the time to add tapered legs and bevels to the bottom of the table (another detail I forgot to mention that really lightens the piece), so they were interested in aesthetics at least to some degree.

Posted

I like the grain on the drawer. Not an experienced woodworker, and also don't know a lot about shaker style, but I thought the grain was interesting (rather than staight and plain), and I probably would have picked it myself. But I guess if you're wanting to emphasize squareness and symetry, then not a good choice. Maybe a grain like that would be better for a piece with curves. But in my limited experience, I tend to think that a simple design can emphasize beautiful wood grain (let the wood speak for itself). But I could see how a more fully integrated design and grain layout can make a more powerful piece.

Posted

... I tend to think that a simple design can emphasize beautiful wood grain (let the wood speak for itself).

 

This was my thought process for making the maple table I recently finished. Simple is actually a hard thing to do, because everything matters that much more.

 

 Do you think it is too strong for shaker? 

 

I'd be in trouble if this were the case! :)

Posted

Nice piece for a first attempt.  The overall dimensions of the legs seem too 'heavy'...I would have made them slightly slimmer, though I'm not a big fan of tapered legs.  Very 'old school, very 50's' but that's just me.  The drawer front grain looks OK but as Eric has mentioned, choosing material and the way it 'flows' is crucial.  Good points raised about the top as well.  Always remove material from the end of a board until all the splits and defects have gone...it's then safe to use and as has been suggested, turn it through 90deg and make a chamfer on the underside.  This will help to relieve the 'heavy' look of a thickish top.  Drawer pulls are always difficult and are very personal.  They're the first thing that a user will touch or see and I've come to the conclusion that the smaller and daintier they can be, the better...just enough to open the drawer when the pull is gripped lightly between finger and thumb...very JK!  This one looks nicely made but appears a mite too large.

Overall, though an excellent first piece - Rob

Posted

I want to clarify something.

The piece you made is very nice. The suggestions we are making would make a nice piece great. Ya know, the thing that makes it look professional. :)

I am really looking forward to seeing your next piece. It's going to be great!

Posted

I want to clarify something.

The piece you made is very nice. The suggestions we are making would make a nice piece great. Ya know, the thing that makes it look professional. :)

I am really looking forward to seeing your next piece. It's going to be great!

 

 

+1 on that.  If this is your first piece of fine furniture, then you have every right to be running victory laps.  Everything suggested above are the refinements that us "wood geeks" look for and generally have more to do with design than craftsmanship.   And you can tell from the discussion that good design is subjective.  Some like tapers, some like straight.  some like wild grain, some like symmetry. 

Posted

+3

 

I think this is super and although I would heartily agree with all the constructive feedback so far regarding refinements I would like to add that the quality and fit of your joints is very good. If this is a "first" of a foray into fine furniture then your off to a good start. 

Posted

First of all, I have to say I would have no issues putting this piece in my home.  That said, I tend to agree with the comments about the grain direction on the top, chamfering the underside of the top and tapering the legs.  I kind of like the grain on the drawer front and the pull.  

 

Altogether a great "first" effort (not sure that's entirely true) and a piece to be proud of.

Posted

+4...Hope I didn't come off as critical...just trying to be helpful.  But when it comes to people's finished projects that they take so much pride in, there's definitely a fine line between helpfulness and hurtfulness.  Hope I didn't cross that line...certainly didn't mean to.

 

There used to be a subforum here called "The Critique Room."  I suppose since that forum no longer exists I should probably moderate my comments accordingly.  There needs to be a place where people can post their projects without the fear of public scrutiny, and I suppose this is that place.  Duly noted to myself.

  • Like 1
Posted

First of all, thanks to all for the helpful feedback. I'll be sure to take all these suggestions into consideration for my next project. Having said that, I would like to reply to certain comments...

 

Great job for a first go!  A couple easy tips to spruce things up on the next try:

 

Taper those legs! :)  It really makes a huge difference on a little table like that and turns a simple design into an elegant one.  A tapering jig is a breeze to make.

 

Rotate the table top 90* so the end grain isn't staring you in the face.  And be careful about cutting the checks out of the ends of your boards...those could cause some issues in the future.

 

Take a little bit more time to think about the grain on the drawer front...besides the top that's the first thing people see.

 

Your dovetails look great if they're your first try.  Love me some skinny pins!

 

 

Thanks Eric, helpful suggestions. Perhaps it isn't obvious in the photo, but the legs are actually tapered by 1/2" over 18" of length. The 'customer' a.k.a. my wife, didn't want the extreme taper usually found on shaker tables like this. Also, the drawer front and rails are indeed cut from the same board, and arranged in proper order. Again, maybe not obvious in the photo. I understand your point about grain flow, but this piece was chosen for its visual interest. The shaker style (especially my interpretation of it here) is somewhat plain, and we were hoping to use the grain and color variation as a decorative element.

Thanks again for the praise on the dovetails. Hand cutting them was definitely a learning experience.

 

 

I agree with everything ~ERIC~ said.

 

Shaker stuff is certainly more approachable than some of the more ornate styles. However, the devil is in the details. :)

 

A very good habit to get into is, cut off the first inch of the board and check for checking... Keep doing it until they are gone. I take one more cut after the checks are gone just to be safe. I don't want a half-check in my pieces.

 

It also looks like you put a small chamfer on the top of the top. This takes away from the crisp features these tables are known for. Tapering the underside of the top makes a thick top look thinner, kind of the same idea as tapering the legs.

 

Mel, if you mean the upper edge of the top, it was intentionally 'distressed' a bit to create a time-worn appearance. Maybe not ass effectively as hoped. The underside of the top actually does have a cove edge approximately half the thickness of the stock, and ending about 2" back from the edge. You just can't see it in the picture.  

 

Eric and Mel were all over this and stole any thunder I could add.

But I am curious did you had cut your dovetails or use a jig? ... some other method?

 

Chet, those are cut by hand (backsaw and chisel), and don't fit nearly as well as they appear!

 

 

Again, thanks for all the feedback. This forum has been an excellent source of information and advice. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 61 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined