Recommended Posts

Posted

I was all set to buy a low angle block plane when Marc released his top four recommended planes for hybrid woodworker and it didn't make the list. Instead, it was the rabbiting block plane that made the cut for its ability to trim tennons. Only difference I can see that might be a negative of the rabbiting block vs the low angle block is that it doesn't have an adjustable mouth.

Only a few bucks difference in the price, which one is the better, more useful buy?

Posted

It depends on what you need it for...

I'd buy the low angle block plane first. Second, I'd buy a good shoulder plane, then perhaps the rabbet block if you need wide rabbets.

Posted

I use my rabbet block more than the regular block, but I use a low angle smoother and a #3 or #4 bench plane where lots of people use block planes.

 

For example, I just got finished flushing dovetails on a box I'm making today.  Lots of folks might use a block plane for this, but I find a low angle smooth plane to be faster, because it's wider, and easier to use, because it's got a lot more mass.

 

My favorite tool to trim tenons is a router plane, because it automatically leaves a tenon face that is still coplanar with the face of the board, and easily gets right up to the shoulder.  No tapered tenon faces...   On longer tenons, just add an offcut from the same stock as the part with the tenon, or a second copy of the same part, to keep the router from tipping.

 

Scroll down THIS PAGE to see how to do tenon faces this way...  Derek Cohen appears to be a hand tool only person, but  I usually do the initial cuts on the table saw.

Posted

==> but I do loose tenons not the traditional ones. 

 

That's probably the key consideration...  I've got every one of LN's block planes...  The rabbiting plane got the most use until I got a Domino...

 

Now the block plane that gets the most use is the one that I know is sharp.....

Posted

The really nice thing about the rabbet block plane is if you are just getting started with your hand tool collection, it serves the purpose of both a block plane and a shoulder plane very well.  in fact, I haven't bought a shoulder plane yet, which has allowed me to build up my hand tool collection in other areas.

Posted

Thanks for all the good suggestions and different perspectives! It sounds like both are great tools so I can't get it too wrong. I think I am now leaning towards the rabbiting block plane. As far as I know, LN is the only company that makes them, correct? I couldn't find a competing version on the LV website...

Posted

The skew block plane is hidden away in the Rabbeting Plane section:

 

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=65373&cat=1,41182,41192&ap=1

 

The blade itself being skewed means you'll likely have to hone it by hand unless you find some jig that holds it (dunno, maybe the MK-II does... probably, but would look funny). The skew is nice for rabbetting as well as normal block plane operations since you get whole sole on the stock with skew instead of having to skew it yourself.  Free shipping right now, too.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.