Tony Wilkins Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 The question above (cambering of blades) for plane blades - especially bevel up blades? I thought I had read you shouldn't but came across this in answer to a question I asked elsewhere: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html Quote
rodger. Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 I camber my no 4, and leave all others square. My smoother is a bevel down, and my other planes are a combination of BU and BD. 1 Quote
Tom King Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 You have to. Different cambers for different plane blades. I have 2 no. 3's with different cambers, and 2 no. 6's with different cambers. I have one pair of block planes that are, and one pair that aren't. Also, one no.8 that isn't. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 I have a transition plane that is about the size of a #4 that I use as a scrub plane and I do a very heavy camber of about 8" radius on that, I read an article a long time back from Phil Lowe and thats what he uses, so its good enough for me. As for the rest of my planes, I just clip the corners a bit (about 8 seconds on each one, probably equivalent to 3 seconds on a h2o stone) but I camber my smoothers more, probable about 12 seconds, guessing somewhere around 1/64" higher in the middle than the edges. I have a #6 that is just for shooting and that is left perfectly straight. There is no right or wrong, I just played around till I got the results I was after. Hope this helps. Nate Quote
G S Haydon Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 All bevel down apart from the block plane Jack plane cambered aggressively Trying plane straight with edges eased Smoothing plane straight with edges eased Block Plane straight with edges eased Anything that rebates or grooves is square. Quote
TerryMcK Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 Only my jack plane is cambered using the Veritas MKII with the cambering attachment. It's so much easier than guessing. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted November 11, 2013 Author Report Posted November 11, 2013 TerryMcK, I have the cambering attachment but haven't used it. Glad to here it's easier than guessing Does it limit how much camber you can put on? Quote
TerryMcK Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 Hi Tony, No I don't think there is a limit. In practice what I do is sharpen as normal using the regular wheel honing to whatever high grit is on hand. Then just remove the wheel assembly and replace it with the cambered roller. Check that the blade is still in position with the gauge and then turn the microbevel adjuster up one notch.Then still using the high grit just press on one side of the tip of the blade and pull is back two or three times, then press down on the opposite side pulling back the same number of times. Then pull back by applying pressure to the middle of the blade and you're done. I suppose you could go the whole hog and use coarser grits and put a proper curve to the blade if you wanted. I've never needed to as I'm just after minimising tramlines. Just count the number of passes you do to keep it even all the way across. Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted November 11, 2013 Author Report Posted November 11, 2013 Thanks for the explanation Terry. It sounds like you can definitely use the Charlesworth/Schwarz/et al 5 station finger pressure camber sharpening method. Quote
Trip Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 ==> The question above (cambering of blades) for plane blades - especially bevel up blades? Chris Schwarz has a blog article outlining the radius for the 4, 5, 7. He leaves his shooting plane (#8) square. He breaks the edge on his bench planes. I could just post the numbers, but you'd get a lot from reading the article... The radius is identical for BU and BD bench planes... In addition, David Charlesworth has a blog article on back beveling his smoothing plane iron -- also worth a read... As a side note, Chris and David recommend exactly the same arcs... Quote
Tom King Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 I should have offered more of an explanation. Few, if any others do the kind of woodworking that I do. In working on old houses, we will grind an iron to match work that is nearby, or even on adjoining boards. Often a No. 3 will do. The second No.3 takes a deeper cut to specifically make a board that anyone can see is planed with a handplane-for instance entry steps making a statement. I took some pictures today, but forgot and left the camera at the jobsite-maybe tomorrow my memory will be better. The No. 4 takes a wider cut, as well as not as deep as even the shallow cutting No.3. The 4-1/2 takes the thinnest shaving at half a thousandth or less. No.5 removes wood fast, but not as fast as a scrub plane. I had one No.6 set to take a decent depth shaving, but then got another turn of last century 6 that was almost NOS for 35 bucks. I didn't really think I needed another 6, but I decided to tune it to take a bigger bite than the first one, and it's proved surprisingly useful. For different thickness shavings, the throat needs to be a different size, so it's really nice having both of them to do the primary flattening with. No. 7 is set to take a couple of thousandths with a wide cut for final flattening before smoothing. No. 8 is straight across, since I really only use it on edges anyway. I keep the camber roller on the MKII all the time. My fingers go down on the blade to make it do what I want it to on a stone. The only thing I used the clamp-on piece for was setting something to a specific bevel, and then using that iron/chisel to scribe a mark on the plywood base of a grinder. It makes it quick and easy to set up. I like the two step micro-bevels indents. I hone by hand if I'm in the middle of working on something, but use the jig if it's been on a grinder. I used the Eclipse (real Eclipse bought new) for decades before LV came out with the MkII, but now it only gets used for narrow chisels. I also have a Marples with a round ball for a roller that gets used for the scrub and 5 irons. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.