Recommended Posts

Posted

Was watching: 

 

I noticed a couple of things:

1. He was out of breath - even commented as much.

2. He wasn't using the 'stance' described in Wearing, Schwarz, Charlesworth.  It seemed like he was using his arms quite a bit as opposed to his lower body.  Part of this was because of the orientation of the board I'm sure.

 

So my question is - how much are these two things related?

Posted

You have to remember his age. My dad is 65 and gets tired so much faster and winded so much faster than a decade ago. There may be more to it but I do not think he is as fit as he may have once been. No offense intended.

Posted

Leg muscles are way stronger than arm muscles. That’s why a lower bench height is better if using hand planes. It allows you to put your legs and body into the planing stroke.

 

A higher bench height is better if you are just using your arms. But that’s still not an efficient way to use a plane.

Posted

I do realize his age C and I thought about that.  However, I still think that the other might be an influence as well.

 

Wilbur, it is interesting you bring up bench height as Mr. Sellers is such an advocate of higher as opposed to Schwarz, Tolpin, and others.

Posted

Also keep in mind he is speaking quite a bit while planing.  Next time you are doing anything physical, trying talking non stop while doing it.  You will become winded too.  Its hard to catch your breath when you are talking.   And even though he makes a lot of videos put a camera in front of anyone and their heart beat rises a little bit.   

Posted

Interesting points Woodsap.  If I ever do anything physical again I'll be sure to check ;)

 

Just want to point out that I'm not attacking or attempting to discredit Paul Sellers; it was just something I noticed and wondered about.

 

Also, when he moves on to the edge later in the video, his stance becomes much more in common with Wearing's stance.

Posted

Another variation on the same theme

 

http://youtu.be/0b8BchfQSAw

 

There are few things at play here. Number one is that Paul likes to highlight how versatile a tool is, namely his #4. As Paul shows you can indeed flatten and plane a board with a smoothing plane, but really it's not suited to that task. Take a look at nearly any book on joinery and you will see Jack Plane, Trying Plane, Smoothing Plane used after one another to do this task. There is nothing wrong with using a #4 at all and it is clearly something he likes to do. Although my video is poor in terms of production and my Trying plane is choking and Paul explains more than I do it demonstrates that the right tools in sequence IMO work better. This need not be expensive, my Jack plane cost £1.00. What I was really lacking was a vice as my bench was not finished, this made swapping the holdfasts around a bit more time consuming.

 

I find having the timber along the edge of the bench easier than trying to reach across to the end of it. He has to lean over what is already a high bench (but it's good for him and it could work well for others too, he even says that early on). The board it also to tightly clamped, watch it spring as tension is released undoing all his hard work go to 22m30s . I think Ricard Maguires Holdfast and batten method is superb for stock prep as it does not apply any distorting pressure to the wood.

 

Bench height could be an issue although as a rule of thumb I think Brits, wrightly or wrongly, have slightly higher benches. I did some very basic research on height before building mine and initially agreed with Paul's findings of 38". As soon as I stood it up I found it to be way too high (I'm a shade under 6') and cut 1 1/2" off and found a happy medium.

 

On age, who knows, he seems a fit guy but perhaps there is an issue we don't know about. I worked with a guy who was on the tools until he was 65 and he shamed many younger workers. He was not muscle bound, just looked after himself.

 

+1 on a raised heartbeat! I feel really self aware when messing about in front of a camera.

 

If you want to look at my take on this process I did a short article here http://gshaydon.co.uk/blog/preparing-wood-with-hand-planes/ . Also "The Schwarz" has Coarse Medium & Fine to purchase which goes over this process too. 

Posted

Interesting Graham.  What struck out at me was the tightly clamped board bit; I missed that.  What I've noticed in watching David Charlesworth's Handplaning DVD is he doesn't like to use an end vise for just about that reason.  I've almost decided to forgo one on my bench.

 

BTW, I'm more inclined to the Alan Peters #7 single plane solution than the #4 single plane solution.

Posted

You guys are way over my head.  I don't know any of these peoples' names you're talking about, or their version of how to do something.  I've never thought about what stance to use while hand planning.  It's a good day when we have a bench to use at a jobsite.  The last hand planning we did of any good size was a set of entry steps for an 1828 house.  8 steps 8' wide-16 boards 5-1/4" x 8', and 8 pieces 7-1/4" x 8' for the risers.  We didn't have a bench at the job, but did have a long rail tablesaw.  The boards got laid on the saw right above the Biesemeyer rail, C-clamped at the back end, and a board clamped to the top coming across from the other side. The guys held the board while I hit the spot where the C-clamp was.  The boards had already been flattened, so we were just laying an obvious hand planed pattern on them with a deep cutting No.3.

 

It took us 20 minutes. My two powerlifter helpers and I switched off.  The plane was super sharp to start and we didn't have to stop to whet.  It did need it at the end.  Wood was dry treated pine.  I ended up doing about half of it.  I'm 63 and do a good days work most days.

Posted

Tony,

 

I think and end vice could be quite useful Tony and I think some of David's benches do have them http://home.comcast.net/~rexmill/projects/bench/bench.htm

 

model_bench.jpg

As I think you alluded to the key is not bending the wood when you cramp it. Using a #7 is as equally valid as a #4 for everything, whatever works! I don't think I could cope smoothing a job with a #7 :). Alan Peters was one of the most gifted furniture makers of recent times, someone who I would like to learn more about.

 

Tom, I would agree, whatever you have at hand to do the job is fine. No holdfast or end vice here, just little plastic blocks screwed around the edges to support it. Worked fine

afc5404f681bfb87ea4e526622ef4d89.jpg

 

Although I do enjoy this process I would see it more as a useful skill to have rather than "I must do this or I'm not a hand tool guy". Machines are so good at this :)  

Posted

Im pretty sure I remember shwarz working up a sweat when he was on the woodwright shop using a no 5 as a fore plane.

I also bet that part whats going on is that sellers is trying to get a good camera angle on the hand motions (he seems to hold stuff funny so that its easier to see)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined