Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

One Nail Gun to Rule them All

Featured Replies

I'm in the market for a nail gun but I can't go out and buy 20 of them. If you were just going to have one, what would it be? I'm happy to hear brand/model recommendations, but what I really need answered is Brad? Pin? Finish? 18 gauge? 16 gauge? Staples? Magic?

 

I build furniture for my house, toys for my kids and I know my wife is going to remember any minute now that she asked me to put up crown in the kitchen.

 

Any advice on what I should be looking for when I go to buy a gun and compressor is also very welcome.

 

Thanks.

  • I have one of each, and multiples of some.  I don't see how one gun will do everything.  Sometimes there are package deals with 2 or 3 guns and a compressor-check with the big box stores, and amazon.  My first guns were Senco's, and I'm still using the same ones I bought in 1973, as well as newer ones.  For finish work, one gun that shoots up to 2-1/2 inch finish nails, and a 23 ga. pinner would be minimum for me.  I have heavier gauge pinners too, but since they came out with the 23 ga. guns, I can't remember ever using the other pinners again.

 

  • I have one of each, and multiples of some.  I don't see how one gun will do everything.  Sometimes there are package deals with 2 or 3 guns and a compressor-check with the big box stores, and amazon.  My first guns were Senco's, and I'm still using the same ones I bought in 1973, as well as newer ones.  For finish work, one gun that shoots up to 2-1/2 inch finish nails, and a 23 ga. pinner would be minimum for me.  I have heavier gauge pinners too, but since they came out with the 23 ga. guns, I can't remember ever using the other pinners again.

 

 

 

+1

 

Its been a couple years since I bought mine so I don't remember the exact price, but for about $200 I got a pancake style compressor, a brad nailer and and a 16 gauge finish nailer at Home Depot.   It might have even come with a 3rd gun but I can't for the life of me find it.    For hobbyist woodworking and DIY finish carpentry, this plus a pin nailer is all I need.   So you can't get by with one gun, but you don't need 20 either.

 

Or you can just go old school and go buy a hammer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VaWl2lA7968

I agree about the Grex and Emglo if they are going to be used for many hours on a professional jobsite or someone wants to only own top line stuff (not counting the low end Grex with green paint), but for the cost of a Grex pinner, a kit like this will serve a hobbyist for many years.   http://www.grizzly.com/products/BTFP12237-3-Tool-Compressor-Combo-Kit/T22978

I have the ridgid line of nail guns, and run a dewalt trim compressor. The only gun I use for furniture is the pin nailer. I often use the 18 gauge for jig construction, and for home renovation trim. I rarely use the 16 guage.

Porter Cable Kit from Home Depot. For less than $200 you get a pancake compressor, 16 gauge Finish Nailer, 18 gauge Brad Nailer, and a Crown Stapler. I use 16 gauge Finish Nails for trim (i.e. Chair rail, baseboard, crown, etc.) I use 18 gauge brads for just about everything else. The crown stapler I use for upholstery. I don't have a 20 gauge Pin Nail, but it is good for small things like picture frames, etc.

==>^^^

 

I had a flock of six PC brad, nail and staple guns in various gauges (and it's my post, so groups of nailers are indeed flocks)... :)

 

All fell apart after five years of DIY use -- they probably wouldn't last a month on a job site...  I replaced them with a mix of Grex and Cadex units. The build quality is night-and-day above PC...

Grex has the 23 gauge market nailed. There are 18 gauge combo guns all over the place that shoot staples and brad nails in the same gun. The problem with those is that the striking head of the gun makes a staple shaped gouge which makes a larger hole to fill.

I would recommend the package deal option. Get a trim nailer package that comes with several guns and the compressor ( and a hose, fittings, and carrying case if you can).

I have a senco 18 g nailer that can shoot 2 1/8" brads. I chose that to allow for the most options. That cost me about $225 8 years ago

I also have a husky combo 18 g stapler and brad nailer that shoots up to 1 1/4" which i use as a dedicated stapler for my picture frame backers and bookcase backers etc. its smaller and allows me to get into tighter areas. I found this one in my neighbors "free" pile at their garage sale.

If you were using your nail guns in a pro setting i would say invest in good guns. But for what you do, any gun will work great with certain exceptions.

Happy trimming!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

"One nail gun to rule them all" - Don't think no one got the reference.

Glad to see there is at least one other nerd in these forums. I suspect there are more...

Favorite novels I just do not have anything to add to the nailer debate. I have no brand loyalty. I have shot tens of thousands of nails through all manner of guns. I have rebuilt all manner of guns. Match the fastener angle with the gun angle for maximum plunger life. Oil if it says oil. Don't oil a finish gun. I never had a gun fall apart but have features that are a must. Directional or baffled exhaust is a must. Depth adjustment is a must. They are not that expensive and eBay easily. Buy one and find out what it can and cannot do and that will inform your next purchase.

I was building my second house in 1974.  I had built the first one with a hammer.  A guy pulled up on a boat right as I was just starting framing on the house.  It was a Senco nailgun salesman, and there weren't even that many houses on the lake at that time, much less many under construction.  I ended up buying an SNIV framer, an 1-1/4 crown shingle stapler, a 9/16 crown 2" stapler to put on Cedar Shakes, a 2-1/2" framing nailer, and a used SN1 finish nailer. 

 

The used SN1 finish nailer shoots a max length 1-1/2" finish nail.  It was old enough that a safety foot was not required when they built it, so it never had one.  I still use these guns once in a while, including the SN1 for special occasions.  The heavy SNIV will still shoot a 3-1/2" framing nail in 2x dry Oak if I need to do a repair a dumptruck or something similar.  I never used the 1-1/4 crown stapler for more than a couple of roofs, but it still comes in handy for some odd jobs.  That was way before they made a roofing tack nailer.

 

I've only had to put new guts in the SNIV once.  I don't think I've ever been in the other guns.  The large finisher doesn't have a depth adjustment, so I don't think that gun has been shot in a couple of decades.  The 9/16" crown stapler has put on many Cedar Shakes, and hand made reproduction shingles, including the roof we live under.

Jimbobpants,

You may only want to buy one for a lifetime since you're not using the gun on a job site. That may be a Grex but it's expensive. For the hobbyist/"round the house person" (like me!),  porter cable, dewalt, or ridgid are guns good enough.  You usually can buy a 16 gauge and an 18 gauge gun in a kit about as cheap as you can get one. Christmas time especially...look for combo packs at Home Depot, Lowes, and on line.  Personally, I have the Dewalts - 16 and 18 gauge and they do fine. Some mentioned the pancake compressor.  If you can find a kit with a compressor, that's best because it's portable for using in the house...if it were a compressor and gun kit and it only had one gun, go with the 16 gauge. You can get nails long enough to do the crown that you mentioned but it will also shoot small enough nails to do toys as well.

I would not buy a oilless compressor they are to loud and short lived. Home center nail guns are so inexpensive that you have a 50/50 chance that they will work. You get what you pay for. Buy what you can afford when it craps out buy another one. Nail guns are disposable now days. 

 

I have a mixed bag of brands and can say the only brand Id call complete garbage is Dewalt. Bostich and Grex pinners are both great pinners. I buy PC staplers because they are cheap and last about a year and I can keep a new spare ready for little out of pocket. I shoot many thousands of staples and would highly recomend the PC.  For the most part all the cheap brands are going to perform equally and be short lived.

If I read you right, you do small things. I would recommend an 18 gauge brad nailer that can shoot the largest brad you might be using. In your situation, possibly the second would be a 23 gauge pin nailer. Best if you could find a brad/pin nailer/compressor if you don't have a compressor.

I have a 8 gallon hot dog compressor and a three-gun kit from Harbor Freight I've been using for a couple of years. Since I don't use it that often and I was just starting out, I went cheap. Even if these only last you a couple of years while you evaluate what you need, the investment is minimal.

 

I second the recommendation for buying an oiled compressor. They're loud enough.

Its a bit pricey, but you don't need the compressor.  You don't realize how much you hate your compressor until you have tools that don't need it.  This is hands down one of my favorite tools, especially for quick fixes around the house, or for pinning things as the glue drives.  Super easy, without needing to dig out the compressor for it.  Also, no expensive CO2 cartridges.

 

http://www.amazon.com/DEWALT-DC608K-18-Volt-18-Gauge-2-Inch/dp/B0011Z5ZNU/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1386186838&sr=1-1&keywords=dewalt+nailer

 I shoot many thousands of staples and would highly recomend the PC.  For the most part all the cheap brands are going to perform equally and be short lived.

 

Since I don't use it that often and I was just starting out, I went cheap.

 

I second the recommendation for buying an oiled compressor. They're loud enough.

Jimbo, they make my point....it sounds like you won't even be shooting "thousands of nails" and you're "just starting out" buying a tool like this.....the Porter Cable kits or the Dewalt kits would be a safe way to go.  Now if you're going on a job site, that's a different story.

Jimbo,

I get to work and the regular email I get from Woodcraft was there.  Open this link as there is a PC nailer and a pancake compressor on sale as a kit.

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author

Sorry I haven't gotten back in here to post an update. I want to thank everyone for the advice and tips. I ended up going with this http://www.homedepot.com/p/Porter-Cable-Compressor-and-3-Tool-Combo-Kit-PCFP12234/203471431# based on recommendation, reviews, the ability to just go get it and price. It was on sale for under 200 when I picked it up.

I'm very happy with it so far. Yes, it's kinda loud, but I dont think it's any louder than anything else in my shop. I tend to use it's recharge as an alarm to let me know it's time to take a break and go get something to drink anyway. :)

 

Thanks again, you guys were very helpful and not one person called me a noob, a homosexual slur (you know which one) or to go die in a fire, which right there puts this forum 1000 miles above every other internet forum.

Whether you're green as a gourd or seasoned like a old piece of live oak.....it's all good.  The neat thing about the site is there are some people here who really know this stuff. (can't say "guys" cause there are some gals who have some mad skills too!). Sometimes, they lay back too much when they should jump into the discussion.  You know if I'm talking about you. <_< but generally, there is a lot of experience present in a discussion.  I'm an insurance agent so working with wood is a hobby.  I've been woodworking for three decades but only the last 10 years have I began to do it more seriously so I still have a lot of questions but have always been treated great by the forum.  We're all at different levels and that's cool here. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.