Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Buying Lumber, Can the PRO's Marc, Matt, and Shannon tell us how they do it?

Featured Replies

Marc, Matt, and Shannon

I would be nice if you dedicated one of your shows to buying lumber. I consider myself a green newbie and think myself and others could benefit from your wisdom.

Do you need to know some covert language to get a good deal at a lumber yard?

How do you find lumber yards that sell #1 and #2 Common Hardwoods?

Do you need a business license to get a good deal?

Do you have to buy xxx hundred of board feet to get a good deal?

I live in North Tampa, and we have a pretty good dealer intercitylumber.com but they say they don't carry common hardwood lumber only FAS. Any ideas to find ones that do?

When buying plywood do you purchase prefinished or unfinished plywood? And do you purchase that from your standard lumber yard or order that somewhere else?

Your show is great, very informative and a great listen on my commute to work. Helps pass the time.

Thanks,

Devildawg91

Fat chance getting those guys to speak up here...they've abandoned us! :)   But the info is out there...see video below.

 

First of all, I don't know why you want commons...FAS is better lumber.  Commons are mostly going to be skinny and short boards.  You want FAS.  There's no magic word you can speak to get a "deal" at a lumberyard.  But generally, the larger your purchase, the better chance that your haggling will yield a discount.  Contractors who buy hundreds of board feet at a time will get better prices than the average Joe hobbyist who buys enough lumber to build a project or two every month.  That's just life.

 

That vid is a one of my favorites. Funny intro, and good explanation of "lumber lingo".

I've never gotten a "deal" because I don't buy a lot but they are still very helpful, and generally have discounts at over 50bf. Plus - it never hurts to ask about discounts or if there are any "specials".

Eric - sometimes common is a better choice if all you need are short and skinny pieces. Buying a nice 8" wide FAS board only to rip it into small pieces sometimes rubs me the wrong way.

Sometimes, yes, but usually, no.  I certainly wouldn't rule out a lumberyard because all they carry is FAS...that's the desirable material.  If grain and color matching in a project is important to you, FAS is the only way to go.  If all you build are little boxes, commons are great.  Trying to build a table out of commons is a recipe for an ugly table.  IMO

My grandfather taught me to look through a pile of lumber. Grab a piece and sight down the length of it looking for warp , twist and bowing. Measure the narrowest part to see if it will yield the clear cut parts you need. If it is not a board you want leave the pile neater than it was when you found it. As you pull boards note the total board feet.

Some yards will not let you select for an extended length of time but all the yards know I leave a pile neat so I get much more leeway. I overheard someone complaining and they said he doesn't leave a mess like the one you are making!

Ask to see the cull or downfall pile. Some beautiful boards get passed over that will make small projects. My supplier sells them for $1 bd ft .

I'm partially with ERIC on his choice of lumber. FAS are pretty much the best you can get, in terms of quality. You will pay more, but you get what you pay for at a reputable dealer.

 

My dealer has a whole section of 4ft or less boards sold at strictly #1 Common prices. Even if these boards are perfect grain and wide. I'm not sure if that just something they do, or if it is normal. Either way, it is nice.

 

When I am looking for stock in a project, I have a process. I first hit up the 4ft or less bins for any wood that doesn't need to particularly match in grain, or exacting color. Most of the time, I get lucky here. Then I move to the full size #1 Common boards. I just picked up two Cherry boards that had absolutely NO sap wood in them, 7" wide and 8" wide, and 96" long. However, there was one knot about the size of a quarter in one that went all the way through in one, and a little larger knot in the other. I'm not using those for a table top, but for pieces with grain matching like table aprons, I can cut that knot out. After I browse the #1 Common boards, I go over to the Select & Better. I will find the rest of what I need here.

 

That process has worked well for me, and I save money every time I do it.

 

Been there done that picking and choosing through stacks of lumber. Going through stacks of lumber not finding what I want.  Not for me anymore!!! I pick-up the phone and call Bob Kloes or send him an email. Show's up on my door step. Yep may spend just a tish more...but in my book, well worth it. Tell Bob what your building. He will be upfront with ya...and you may learn a thing or two about wood. Just saying!  :)

 

This is just an option....NOT an excuse to NOT learn how to buy wood.

 

-Ace-

 

http://www.bobkloes.com

 

 

Been there done that picking and choosing through stacks of lumber. Going through stacks of lumber not finding what I want.  Not for me anymore!!! I pick-up the phone and call Bob Kloes or send him an email. Show's up on my door step. Yep may spend just a tish more...but in my book, well worth it. Tell Bob what your building. He will be upfront with ya...and you may learn a thing or two about wood. Just saying!  :)

 

This is just an option....NOT an excuse to NOT learn how to buy wood.

 

-Ace-

 

http://www.bobkloes.com

 

 

Looking for the wood is one of my favorite processes, though. I will never spend less and sacrifice quality. For example, if I want a table top free of sap wood and knots, I will not settle for a piece that has just a little sap wood to save money. This is where I would go to the next grade up and finish looking for my stock. I like saving money, and if I can it's good, but if I have to go up a grade I have no problem.

 

I do like the method in which Bob sells his stock. Sounds like an amazing thing for him to get rid of unwanted stock, and for customers to get really nice stock. Win-win.

Trying to build a table out of commons is a recipe for an ugly table.  IMO

Come on now Eric, that's not exactly true, It depends on a lot more than just the grade. I could go buy all select boards, and still make something that looks like crap. for example some species are very sensitive to the environment they are growing in, Jatoba is this way. The grain and color can very greatly from one tree to the next.

Check out this pdf, it visually explains the real grading scale.

http://www.ahec.org/hardwoods/pdfs/IllustratedGradingGuide.pdf

my dad gets his domestics from a small local mill where he lives, and he almost always buys 1C because it's much cheaper.

My grandfather taught me to look through a pile of lumber. Grab a piece and sight down the length of it looking for warp , twist and bowing. Measure the narrowest part to see if it will yield the clear cut parts you need. If it is not a board you want leave the pile neater than it was when you found it. As you pull boards note the total board feet.

Some yards will not let you select for an extended length of time but all the yards know I leave a pile neat so I get much more leeway. I overheard someone complaining and they said he doesn't leave a mess like the one you are making!

Ask to see the cull or downfall pile. Some beautiful boards get passed over that will make small projects. My supplier sells them for $1 bd ft .

 

 

Yes, Yes and Yes! The place I go to doesn't have a "time limit", but I've been in there for hours looking through the stacks to get the piece I was looking for. I always leave the stack nicer than I found it. Heck, I even organize it by width because that is how I usually look for my boards, so when they go back in they are stacked accordingly.

 

They are also a great resource for information. Don't be afraid to let them know what you are working on. They may have a solution to a problem you are facing. 

Looking for the wood is one of my favorite processes, though. I will never spend less and sacrifice quality. For example, if I want a table top free of sap wood and knots, I will not settle for a piece that has just a little sap wood to save money. This is where I would go to the next grade up and finish looking for my stock. I like saving money, and if I can it's good, but if I have to go up a grade I have no problem.

 

I do like the method in which Bob sells his stock. Sounds like an amazing thing for him to get rid of unwanted stock, and for customers to get really nice stock. Win-win.

 

Building is one of my favorite processes. Wood isn't perfect. And you can drive yourself nuts looking for boards. Hey and I get that!!!

 

I let Bob go nuts looking for me.  B) But that is just me :rolleyes:

 

-Ace-

Yes, Yes and Yes! The place I go to doesn't have a "time limit", but I've been in there for hours looking through the stacks to get the piece I was looking for. I always leave the stack nicer than I found it. Heck, I even organize it by width because that is how I usually look for my boards, so when they go back in they are stacked accordingly.

 

They are also a great resource for information. Don't be afraid to let them know what you are working on. They may have a solution to a problem you are facing. 

Mel, I think that is why we might be spoiled. I read up on lumber yards before going to KM hardwoods, with the thought that I might not be able to select what I want, or feel rushed. Just the opposite. It is a take your time atmosphere, and friendly too.

 

I will always make sure those stacks look as good or better than they were when I leave. I don't think that can be said enough. It is people who genuinely do not care and make a mess that ruin it for everyone else.

Building is one of my favorite processes. Wood isn't perfect. And you can drive yourself nuts looking for boards. Hey and I get that!!!

 

I let Bob go nuts looking for me.  B) But that is just me :rolleyes:

 

-Ace-

You can't tell me that going into a store and seeing a 6ft wide, 12 ft long, and 3" thick slab of Bubinga wouldn't get you imagining you sitting around it for your Thanksgiving dinner, drinking from your goblets, and watching Game of Thrones (or your favorite show). That is what makes lumber yard runs great!

Also keep an eye on crags list. I sort of wheel and deal in a bunch of alder and maple. I'll buy a few thousand board ft pull out and color match the clearest then sell the rest to hobby folks for $2-4bf. There are quite a few people who do this.

You can't tell me that going into a store and seeing a 6ft wide, 12 ft long, and 3" thick slab of Bubinga wouldn't get you imagining you sitting around it for your Thanksgiving dinner, drinking from your goblets, and watching Game of Thrones (or your favorite show). That is what makes lumber yard runs great!

 

Well you do have a point...exception made on Bubinga. Stop/Drop/Roll for that! 

 

-Ace-

Come on now Eric, that's not exactly true, It depends on a lot more than just the grade. I could go buy all select boards, and still make something that looks like crap. for example some species are very sensitive to the environment they are growing in, Jatoba is this way. The grain and color can very greatly from one tree to the next.

Check out this pdf, it visually explains the real grading scale.

http://www.ahec.org/hardwoods/pdfs/IllustratedGradingGuide.pdf

my dad gets his domestics from a small local mill where he lives, and he almost always buys 1C because it's much cheaper.

 

+1.  Buying from a mill is a completely different experience than buying retail.  My local retailer only stocks FAS and while everything looks fine, it is expensive and often lacks character.  The mill I buy from grades some species and sells others ungraded.  I just bought a huge 8/4 cherry board that is 14" wide and 9 feet long.  It has some bark inclusions and pitch marks and other defects.  Maybe you could get one FAS board out of it, but I think it is great just the way it is.  So commercially maybe 50% or less of that board is viable.  But that is why I paid $3 bd/ft for it (edit: actually it was $2.25 bf, I just double-checked).  A FAS cherry board would be 2 or 3x times that at retail prices.  

I like clean, long, wide, straight boards.  That's why I happily pay extra for FAS.  There's nothing wrong with sub-FAS lumber...if "character" is your thing.  I'm not really into the rustic look so bark inclusions and other defects just get in my way and end up costing me more in the long run because I'll have more waste working around it.

 

One thing I don't really get though, is that domestic lumber isn't really that expensive...around here walnut and QSWO gets a little pricey, but cherry, maple, oak, ash, hickory, etc...all very cheap, even FAS.  FAS cherry at my dealer is 4something/bf...that's not really the kind of price tag that gets me worried...and I'm a fairly frugal guy.  Yeah, if we're talking about needing a big pile of wenge or zebrawood, let my inner cheap-ass out.  But cherry?  Just buck up for the glorious, straight-grained, wide boards, y'all. :)  Common cherry boards can be very frustrating to work with, in my experience...if color and grain matching is important to you.  I'm not saying it can't be done, Dan...I'm sayin' I don't wanna deal with it. ;) 

I like clean, long, wide, straight boards. That's why I happily pay extra for FAS. There's nothing wrong with sub-FAS lumber...if "character" is your thing. I'm not really into the rustic look so bark inclusions and other defects just get in my way and end up costing me more in the long run because I'll have more waste working around it.

One thing I don't really get though, is that domestic lumber isn't really that expensive...around here walnut and QSWO gets a little pricey, but cherry, maple, oak, ash, hickory, etc...all very cheap, even FAS. FAS cherry at my dealer is 4something/bf...that's not really the kind of price tag that gets me worried...and I'm a fairly frugal guy. Yeah, if we're talking about needing a big pile of wenge or zebrawood, let my inner cheap-ass out. But cherry? Just buck up for the glorious, straight-grained, wide boards, y'all. :) Common cherry boards can be very frustrating to work with, in my experience...if color and grain matching is important to you. I'm not saying it can't be done, Dan...I'm sayin' I don't wanna deal with it. ;)

for me it just depends on the project. some call for a clear more uniform appearance. my personal taste is a bit more rustic. That doesn't mean sloppy or lazy joinery, but i don't mind sapwood or some defects. And i like using wide boards so embracing those defects gives me more choices. the reason i like buying ungraded lumber is that i get to decide what looks good or doesn't. That works fine for my hobby, family and friends work. But if i were trying to make a living doing this I wouldn't have the time to deal with all that and would likely buy FAS and be done with it. Like you said if you shop around the prices are not that high on most domestics.

I am lucky in that there are a number of Great lumber yards and specialty wood stores here. I too have spent hours and hours searching for just the right piece of lumber. Last year I walked into one of our specialty stores that I have been going to for over 15 years. I was looking at some boards for a table and walked around to where they have the "large" specialty pieces and there it was a 6' long 26" wide beautiful piece of cocobolo with 3 large eyes and the sap wood on the outside! I couldn`t leave it there, so it followed me home. I am still debating on what style of table I will make with it. But I have a ton of other hand picked boards from lumber yards that are ahead of that one for now. I will try to post a picture of it later.

I have never had any issues with #1 common (actually prefer it).  You have to be selective, but you can get some really heavily figured wood for next to nothing.  You won't find the wonky figured grains in the FAS unless you are giving up your first born child.  It just takes some practice to know what is worth your time and when to move on.  A quality planer and 10 minutes of your time will turn a #1 common into a top notch FAS board.  

 

I have never had an issue getting full length, ~10'+ #1 commons.  Perhaps I am just spoiled though with my lumber yard.  Though I normally only deal in domestics, finding #1 common exotics is a little tricky.  It's not really worth the boat trip and trucking to the Midwest for #1 commons.  

 

Each to their own.  

I can see the FAS being worth the price for Pros.  Semi-Pro and hobbyist can save some money but add labor, so its probably a situation thing.  

Hey Devil, I don't live in tampa, but I have been to this location before http://craftsmensupply.com/ and have purchased some nice white oak, padauk, etc. from them. The stores selection was pretty good last time I went there. I don't think they have 100's of board feet of one species on hand, so if you need a lot you may be better off trying to broker a deal with intercity or check craigslist for this company http://www.lumberspecialtiesinc.com/ - they often have good deals on lumber when they close outs from larger jobs. Hope this helps.

  • Popular Post

"Good deal" is a relative term.  Today the retail lumber yard is much further removed from the sawmill than ever before.  This means that there are many many people in the supply chain taking their cut of the profit.  Regardless of what any of us may think, the lumber industry operates on a very very low profit margin so we are all getting a good deal in the mind of the dealer you are buying from.  To get a better price, find a dealer that is further up the supply chain.  The problem there is that lumber is is not bought by the stick from the mills and concession holders so the further up the chain you go the more you are dealing with a wholesaler who thinks in terms of MBF (thousand board feet).  These guys just don't work with the average woodworker because breaking a pack is more trouble than its worth when you consider the labor investment, inventory headache, and the degradation of the quality and cost of the pack when it is picked over.

 

The yards that will break packs and sell orders under 500-1000 bf have to add workers and forklifts and inventory systems, and storage sheds, and air drying yards, and kilns, and grading chains, and saws, and and and and.  Now overhead skyrockets and adds to the final price of the lumber.  

 

The converse of this is to carry a smaller inventory that can be more accurately managed with a small staff and low overhead.  So this dealer buys 200 bf packs of 10 different species and relies on his wholesaler to do all that buying, drying, and grading grunt work.  This dealer's cost is higher because the wholesaler has taken on more expensive and also must defray the cost of degraded packs that have been broken.  So now this smaller dealer is running on a product with a higher cost that he has to sell at a higher price.  Still he is marking up a pretty comparable amount to what the wholesaler/mill/importer is using.  

 

This just in time inventory model has dramatically changed the lumber industry and caused prices to climb dramatically in the last 50 years.  The thing is where JIT models have been refined in other industries by adding efficiency and decreasing cost while increasing supply and decreasing time to market this just isn't possible in the lumber industry.  It still takes time to grow a tree and maintain a healthy forest concession.  It takes time to fell and extract the trees.  It takes time to saw and dry the boards.  It takes time to transport and grade and redry the lumber.  If you speed this up and cut corners you get crappy lumber.  Now add to this regulations and certifications and legal considerations that can hold up the sale of a lumber species.  Imports take even longer with customs and sea travel time.  In other words there is little we can do to streamline the "manufacturing" process so costs stay the same or climb over time.  

 

This brings us back to the woodworker who is at the end of the line trying to buy small quantities or lumber with exaggerrated quality demands and highly specific dimension specs who expects to see and handle every board.  I don't say that to make anyone feel bad.  It is what it is.  Demand what it takes to make your masterpiece, just recognize that this method flies in the face of how the supply chain works and prices will reflect that.  

 

So this dissertation can answer some of the other questions.  Common is harder to find because no one can make any money on it.  Commercial demands also won't tolerate defects.  Flooring and millwork houses need straight and clear grain.  Clear logs are sold to veneer makers for plywood also.  These industries buy up the majority of the stock.  What is left will be of lower quality so the grading schemes continually adjust and lower the bar so that more stock can be labelled FAS.  This in turn makes the Commons almost worthless.

 

The only way I know of to truly get Common material is go straight to the sawmill.  Here you can get a great deal because this mill is gleaning the common from the good stuff to sell to the wholesalers and is essentially considering the common material as a loss and tax deduction.  

 

Imported material is an entirely different ball game where global concerns and regulations play more of a role in availability than anything else.  

 

So I'm not sure if I added anything to this convo that wasn't already said in regard to Devil's actual questions but I do think we as woodworkers need to understand the greater picture when it comes to lumber.  It is an antiquated industry that really can't change to meet modern expectations in our Amazon Prime world. 

The only way I know of to truly get Common material is go straight to the sawmill.  Here you can get a great deal because this mill is gleaning the common from the good stuff to sell to the wholesalers and is essentially considering the common material as a loss and tax deduction.

Beyond the cost saving I have found the stock to actually be thicker as well. For example 4/4 is almost always an inch or thicker, because it hasn't been skip planed.

Beyond the cost saving I have found the stock to actually be thicker as well. For example 4/4 is almost always an inch or thicker, because it hasn't been skip planed.

 

Your just not paying the labor cost involved in planing. A good supplier you should be getting 15/16+ 4/4 domestics planed. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.