Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Invest in land? Future life question.

Featured Replies

It's no secret to my fiance and my family that I like to be in the country. I like my neighbors to be distant from me, but not out of reach. I have lived in a relatively big city my entire life, about 600,000 people with houses on top of houses, and house lots about 1/4 - 1/2 acre. I take a few weeks out of the year to travel around the state to a town of less than 2,000 with untainted lakes, full forests, and genuinely nice people who rely on each other. Along with other towns that are just a little bigger. These are the times I look forward to the most.

 

I am in school for civil engineering, and have 58 credits remaining after this semester. Not too much longer, depending on how much I pack on the course load (shorter is the plan). I live at my fiance's parents house, with my fiance of course. I am extremely grateful for the free room and board, but I still thirst for independence and having something of my own to grow on. The thing is, I don't want to finish my degree, own a property here in Milwaukee, and then find a job in Madison (1.5 hour ride West).

 

So, my idea was that I could invest in a parcel of land somewhere in the country. Not as a permanent residence, but a current time vacation destination, and possible later retirement location. To gain perspective, I want something in the double digit acre range. More is better, in my opinion. I don't want to be cut off from civilization, so a convenience store (gas station, mom/pop shop, anything with general supplies) within a 15-25 minute drive is a must. Ability to have electricity, water, and other typical features run is essential as well - but not a deal breaker to me at time of purchase.

 

Budget, not sure where I stand on this. I guess it depends on how much I really want it.

 

In general, my question is whether it is something that even seems plausible, and above all - not crazy, to be my age and even consider in investing in a piece of land that I described.

 

I had a boss once who said "Always buy dirt, they don't make it any more". In other words buying ground/property is usually a good investment over the long haul.

I bought my house in 1970 for $13,500.00 and it was appraised about three years ago for 82,000.00. We have made improvements over the years so that helps but, most of the increase is due to time and the economy.

Needless to say, the house is paid for and we raised two kids in it over that time and are still living in it. I'm impressed that someone of your age is considering buying/investing in something of this magnitude and looking at the long haul. 

Now finding a property that suits your desires is a whole different matter but it doesn't cost that much to keep looking and hoping that it is there somewhere. 

 

Rog

Land has historically been a good investment. 

  • Author

I had a boss once who said "Always buy dirt, they don't make it any more". In other words buying ground/property is usually a good investment over the long haul.

I bought my house in 1970 for $13,500.00 and it was appraised about three years ago for 82,000.00. We have made improvements over the years so that helps but, most of the increase is due to time and the economy.

Needless to say, the house is paid for and we raised two kids in it over that time and are still living in it. I'm impressed that someone of your age is considering buying/investing in something of this magnitude and looking at the long haul. 

Now finding a property that suits your desires is a whole different matter but it doesn't cost that much to keep looking and hoping that it is there somewhere. 

 

Rog

Thank you. I guess I have two real desires in a property for myself. A lot of land, or waterfront - whether that be a river or lake. Can I get them both...probably not. Will I settle for one, absolutely. But, with the waterfront, I do not want to live in a house on top of house community. I would still like to have at least a minimum of 3-5 acres. I guess I should have mentioned the waterfront option in the initial post.

I grew up in the country and miss some things but don't romanticise it too much or you might be disappointed.

Sent from my T-Mobile G2 using Tapatalk 2

Lot prices are high now Sam. Not sure where you are looking, but the average "decent" lot I'd build on is around $125,000. That's just the dirt. With not much land. Enough, but not 5 acres, or water. There are a few lots that are priced lower, say around $80,000 that are ok, but for the acreage you want it'll be tough to find something that's worth the investment, or living there if the economy doesn't pick up.

Just my .02.

Ultimately, it depends on where you want to buy land. 

 

There are areas where land is very cheap.  Usually for a reason but, there are some diamonds in the rough if you do your homework.

  • Author

Lot prices are high now Sam. Not sure where you are looking, but the average "decent" lot I'd build on is around $125,000. That's just the dirt. With not much land. Enough, but not 5 acres, or water. There are a few lots that are priced lower, say around $80,000 that are ok, but for the acreage you want it'll be tough to find something that's worth the investment, or living there if the economy doesn't pick up.

Just my .02.

I don't intend for this to be my residence, just yet. I will still be buying a home wherever my workplace so happens to be. This land that I want to invest in is not something I am going to jump out and buy without really finding something I love. I'm making it seem like I have oodles of cash to throw around, but that is not the case. This isn't a next year purchase, but rather years down the road. I really just want to educate myself now and be ready when the time comes - and the market suits me. Could work, but it could also bite me in the rear.

I didn't intend on sounding negative if I did. Just that lots are very high now. As TIODS said, some lots are cheap and for a good reason. Land in Jackson, for instance, has gas in the water... they can't give that land away. In West Bend, the land is ok, but there isn't much of it anymore. Well, unless you want to live by the airport. Point is, TIODS hit it on the head. Land costs more based on demand. The lot in Jackson is $15,000 to a comparable size/feature lot in the better parts of Germantown or Waukesha and it's $95,000. 

With today's low interest rates investing in real assets makes total sense.

In real estate, there is an old saying ... location .... location ... location.

My wife and I invested in property in the mountains in Colorado and life gave us a few bonuses, so now we are in the finishing stages of building our log cabin on 10 acres.

FInd a location, don't over extend yourself. Great idea.

Today interest rates are basically negative, considering what is the real inflation rate. Great idea, pursue it and you will be happy.

Make sure your location passion and lifestyle is shared by your fiance.

  • Author

I didn't intend on sounding negative if I did. Just that lots are very high now. As TIODS said, some lots are cheap and for a good reason. Land in Jackson, for instance, has gas in the water... they can't give that land away. In West Bend, the land is ok, but there isn't much of it anymore. Well, unless you want to live by the airport. Point is, TIODS hit it on the head. Land costs more based on demand. The lot in Jackson is $15,000 to a comparable size/feature lot in the better parts of Germantown or Waukesha and it's $95,000. 

I didn't take it negative at all. Just thought I would more thoroughly explain myself.

 

To give you more of a range of area that I would drive for this location, think west of 43, east of 51, north of 94, and south of 10. I am not picky on the area, just as long as it meets my criteria. I'm sure I can find something in this square (I guess you can call it that) that I narrowed down to. But, it is just important to me not to be impulsive. I'm sure I wouldn't have known about that Jackson water if you didn't say something about it. Also, the day I live in that over-priced ritsy "lake country" area is the day hell has frozen over - just sayin' :) There was a lot on Rock Lake in Lake Mills that was going for I think $300k-$500k! For only 1.x acres of land!

If you're looking for an investment, rather than somewhere to live, I wouldn't suggest buying land. You will get a better compound annual rate of growth (CAGR) investing in stocks over the long term. I repeat, over the long term, say 20-40 years. If you want some guidance, check out the Motley Fool, I have been following their advice since 2007, wish I'd done it earlier. My portfoglio CAGR is currently 9.1%, but I did choose a rather unfortunate time to start!

 

Other advantages are that you don't have to pay annual taxes, or maintenance with stocks. Plus you can sell half, or a tenth of them if you need the money - difficult to do that with a house, or property. They move when you move too.

The major disadvantage is that no single stock mirrors the S&P 500, so you'll need to invest in at least 20 stocks, which the Fool does indeed do. (I'm just a happy customer btw, no vested interests).

 

As a simple example, because he supplied some figures, Rapid Roger's house had a CAGR of 4.61%, the S&P 500 over the same period had a CAGR of 9.89%. In other words $1 of house became $6.01, whereas $1 of S&P 500 became $43.48, over the same period (1970-2010).

 

However, the house that you live in is always a good investment, and has many other rewards, other than financial.

 

John

  • Author

If you're looking for an investment, rather than somewhere to live, I wouldn't suggest buying land. You will get a better compound annual rate of growth (CAGR) investing in stocks over the long term. I repeat, over the long term, say 20-40 years. If you want some guidance, check out the Motley Fool, I have been following their advice since 2007, wish I'd done it earlier. My portfoglio CAGR is currently 9.1%, but I did choose a rather unfortunate time to start!

 

Other advantages are that you don't have to pay annual taxes, or maintenance with stocks. Plus you can sell half, or a tenth of them if you need the money - difficult to do that with a house, or property. They move when you move too.

The major disadvantage is that no single stock mirrors the S&P 500, so you'll need to invest in at least 20 stocks, which the Fool does indeed do. (I'm just a happy customer btw, no vested interests).

 

As a simple example, because he supplied some figures, Rapid Roger's house had a CAGR of 4.61%, the S&P 500 over the same period had a CAGR of 9.89%. In other words $1 of house became $6.01, whereas $1 of S&P 500 became $43.48, over the same period (1970-2010).

 

However, the house that you live in is always a good investment, and has many other rewards, other than financial.

 

John

 

Mainly looking to inhabit, and not invest. Although, stocks are something I have been interested in for a little while now. Just too nervous to pull the trigger and start with them.

 

If you can afford to do it and will enjoy it, then go for it.  Just don't buy it expecting it to be a financially good investment.  It might turn out to be, but do not go in with that expecation. 

 

1) Yes location is everything.  There is a reason why you will see a lake front lot going for $300K but 22 acres in the middle of nowhere going for $100K or less.  More people want the lake front lot. 

2) Yes interest rates are low, making it easier to finance a purchase.  But they won't be low forever.  When they go up, it will be harder to finance a purchase.   Which is bad for you if you own a property  because fewer people can afford it.  I am only 36 but can remember when 6% was a good rate.  now 3% is a good rate.   A 100K loan will cost you $420 a month at 3% but $600 a month at 6%.  Guess what, more people can afford $420 than $600.  so when rates go up your property value might go down.

3) Vacation properties are a different animal than primary residences.  Everyone needs one place to live.  Very few people need 2.  So when the economy tanks or rates spike, there are fewer buyers for your property.

4) Very few people can afford a vacation property and a small subset of those are looking for acreage.   If you ever decide to sell, expect a very very very long market time.

 

I am not trying to disuade you at all.  My wife and I bought a vacation house 2 years ago.  We were "looking" for about 8 years before we pulled the trigger.  We started out, like you, wanting 20+ acres in central/northern wisconsin.  I told the realtor "I want to look 360 degrees and see nothing but trees, grass, hills, or water."  But the longer we looked the more we realized some of those properties were on the market for years, literally 5 years or more.  And this was in the middle of the biggest real estate boom in the last 100 years.   We also had kids in the process and realized that driving 5 hours to maintain a 20 acre parcel just wasn't in the cards.  So we decided on a smaller place closer to home that we could use every weekend in the summer. 

 

Real estate agents will all tell you that there are fewer and fewer properties, it is hard to find acreage, you need to pull the trigger when you see what you want.  It is all BS.   Due to job relocations, marraige, family changes, etc we have bought 7 properties in the past 12 years and rented one apartment.  I  can tell you this, every time I get into the market I find something I like.   There is plenty of housing stock out there and plenty of undeveloped acreage.  Don't fall in love with something without a very long courtship. 

 

Driving 5 hours would be a deal breaker for me. If I find a property that I have to drive more than 2 hours for, I will just keep on looking. Ideally, I would like to only have to travel about 1 hour, but property that close to my current driving range is just too expensive. Go a little further, and the properties drop quite a bit.

 

If I had to say my perfect scenario, I would have my primary residence near my job, and this plot of land. It would stay "natural" except for a storage shed of some sort for maintenance equipment, until I have enough money to build a small cabin. Then, this is the way it would remain until I decided to retire. If I wanted to live there for good, I'll build something bigger. If I didn't want to live there, it would stay as is.

 

Again, that is a perfect scenario. I like to think with optimism and try to work towards the goal, instead of telling myself it cannot be done. Anything can be done :)

I agree with TIODS...there are gems to be found but you won't find them easily.  My family purchased 100 acres about ten years ago...surrounded on three sides by National Forest and the other side bordered by a gin-clear, spring-fed Ozark stream.  Paradise.  No one around.  We paid $1,000 an acre.  That was a "fair" price at the time comparing it to other nearby acreage.  My dad had some health problems and had to move back to the city about five years after we bought it, and we sold it for $3,000 an acre.  Do the math...buying land can be a great investment.  It takes work to find the right deal, though.  I spent about 18 months driving around in the general area we wanted to buy.  I'd stop into businesses in the small towns and talk to the locals.  Check the racks by the door where you always find the Thrifty Nickel type papers and what not...often they have something with local real estate for sale.  That's where I found ours.

 

All that said, at your age and in your position...I'd personally be saving my extra money for a down payment on a house.  Your fiance is gonna want that when she becomes your wife.  And technically that's an investment, too.  Not like it was 10 years ago, but the housing market will rebound and people will start gaining equity again.  You gotta walk before you can run, young man. :)

  • Author

All that said, at your age and in your position...I'd personally be saving my extra money for a down payment on a house.  Your fiance is gonna want that when she becomes your wife.  And technically that's an investment, too.  Not like it was 10 years ago, but the housing market will rebound and people will start gaining equity again.  You gotta walk before you can run, young man. :)

 

Yeah, I should probably be looking at that perspective of house down payment. If I can get my career all settled away, and find somewhere to settle down, I would like to put forth the effort and build my home. I even have a minimum for this, and that would be around 2 acres. Might be a stupid reason, but if this is going to be my long term property I want to be able to expand my house if I choose to. I want to be able to tell myself, "I can expand my house, but I can't expand my land."

 

Again, that may seem like a frivolous reason to most, but that's just how I feel.

No, don't do it.  If you buy property anywhere you are really limiting your options when you look for employment.  Finish your education.  Get a job and get married first.  Put money towards a decent place to live, raising a family, puttiing kids through school.  Your first house does not have to be your last. 

a little morbid, but check the obituaries. 

 

I would find an area that you know you want to live in or some day live in, go by the county office and pull the records to see what land has historically sold for over the last 20 years, then watch the death papers. 

No, don't do it.  If you buy property anywhere you are really limiting your options when you look for employment.  Finish your education.  Get a job and get married first.  Put money towards a decent place to live, raising a family, puttiing kids through school.  Your first house does not have to be your last. 

 

This.  ^  

 

Consider the differences between zoned vs. unzoned land (costs and property restrictions) 

You have to pay taxes on land every year

It's hard to tell what you will want (or need!) later in life  

Might be difficult to dump land later if you have to sell it

The time share mentality sounds good but usually doesn't work out

  • Author

Looks as though it is a majority vote to keep myself contained for the time being.

 

I will just stay behind my keyboard searching countless properties :)

It's a real shame that land is so expensive there.

 

It's the same here in the UK, probably even more so because it's an even rarer commodity.

 

I've been looking at Sweden. Something like 80-90% of the country's population are south of a city called Uppsalå, which is not even closer to the middle of the country. So up north there are a few large cities and the surrounding areas you can buy land pretty darn cheap.

 

That's where I'll be looking in the future!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.