Recommended Posts

Posted

After becoming very frustrated with the big-box store router bits I own I have decided it is time to upgrade.  While looking around I came across this set, which at less than $17/bit, seems like a pretty good deal:  

 

http://www.eagleamerica.com/product/v100-2422/ea_-_router_bit_sets

 

I know that I may not use all of those bits, but some of them are $30 sold individually.

 

Thoughts, other suggestions?  Thanks.

Posted

If it were me I would just buy the bits that I need. Eagle America are pretty good but nearly $400 is a lot in one go especially as you will probably use about 5 or 6 of them. The rest will stay in the box and therefore will be money wasted.

Posted

I don't know about Eagle America and I assume for those set prices those are solid bits. Usually when I hear router bit package, I think something budget like MLCS. For people starting out, they're a step up from the store ones, but still not long life bits. They have their merits though...they good for people starting out who have no idea what bits to buy. This way, they get to find out for minimal cost which bits they use the most, then they can upgrade those to something solid like Whiteside or whatnot. Any other bit they don't hardly use can stay in the collection and will probably last a long time as it don't see frequent use.

Regardless of someone starting out or who knows what they want, I would suggest just upgrading the ones you use the most individually. The old rule that 20 percent of something gets used 80 percent of the time, or however that goes.

  • Like 1
Posted

Eagle America is supposedly good quality (I can't vouch), but that's a lot of dosh for 24 bits.

 

I've been happy with Stone Mountain bits from Peachtree. They have a 24-bit set that includes most of those same profile bits for less than $100. I'm pretty sure this is the same bit set I have, although I can't quite remember. I know the set I have is 1/2" shank.

 

http://ptreeusa.com/stone_mountain_bit_sets_page_1.htm#3742

Posted

The eagle america bits are either MLCS or Whiteside the USA one are the whiteside that being said they are not the same higher quality whiteside bits you get with the whiteside label from woodcraft. They perform the same as the mlcs but last a little longer. The price difference is the country of origin but the quality is not really worth the price difference unless you step up to "real" whiteside bits.

Posted

Thanks for the responses, after some more thought I agree that $400 is a lot to spend on a router bit set.  I ended up ordering the Whiteside round-over set which is what I really need for my current project.  Thanks again.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'd just purchase the bits as you need them. You'll probably find that u use 6 bits most often.

 

This is why I like big router bit sets when you're starting out. You don't spend a fortune on them, and probably use half a dozen of them. You can tell which ones you're going to use most often because they wear out so quickly and you replace them! And yet on that rare occasion when you might need to use another random bit, you've got it to hand.

  • Like 1
Posted

Those are really nice bits, but that is a bunch of money for 24 bits.  As a "very good" alternative, the Price Cutter bits are surprisingly good....a misnomer for sure.  I put them on the level Katana, CMT, Bosch and other "step above" bits.  They've got a 70 piece set for $210.  

 

Whiteside has a 7 piece set of the basic profiles for ~ $100....top tier bits, then you can add other profiles as needed.  Infinity makes a really nice 6 pc set in the same price range.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.