Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 First things first, no domino remarks, you will be struck by lightning if so i recently added the powernatic 719t to my shop and i need bits. Im assuming 1/4 5/16 and 3/8 are more commonly used in furniture scaled work. I bought a cheap hf 1/2" bit last night so i could at least try out my new tool. The bit slighlty potruded the chisel so the walls werent 100% but still effective for blind mortises. The machine is awesome and i love it, i made two deep mortises rather quickly. So to the point of the thread; i was looking at what brand bits to purchase, i was looking at the fisch chisels and thought i would get those. Then i stumbled across clico today in my internet travels. There is a wide spread of price in bits for the hcm and i wondered what all of you are using and why. Thanks! Quote
Trip Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 Before I replaced my HCM with a ?omino, I used fisch chisels/bits -- expensive, but worked well... Never tried clico, so no point of comparison... Hay.. Is that thunder I hear? Quote
dwacker Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I would just buy middle of the road and learn to sharpen them. Quote
Boatworks Today Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I use the PM brand chisels and they are pretty good. I don't have anything to compare them to, but they've held their edge and cut clean. As far as the wobble of the bit outside the chisel area I've run into that as well. What I ended up doing was taking a metal file (while the machine was running) and gradually rested it flat along each outside face of the of the chisel. This nibbed off the part of the auger that wasn't cooperating and took care of the issue :-) Quote
dwacker Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I have a friend that works at stickily and after seeing some video I have a renewed new appreciation for the HCM and will be buying one myself. If you can find stubbies meaning short cutters instead of the long ones typically sold along the imported machines you will get better results. The center bits on the long ones flex so the shorter the better without going so short that they dont clear. Quote
Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Author Report Posted February 25, 2014 Thanks pb but im good, im a very efficient sharpener and fast learner Quote
dwacker Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 Thanks pb but im good, im a very efficient sharpener and fast learner I just meant your not going to see leaps and bounds improvement by spending money. I have a set of fisch for my jet bench top and really they are no real improvement over the Chinese bits that came with it after sharpening and grinding the sides. Quote
Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Author Report Posted February 25, 2014 Thats what my question is geared towards, the market for these bits and where they sit, and what are the comparisons. Are the more expensive ones using a better tool steel, the question of edge retention, and ease of sharpening and touch ups. We all know why grizzly is so inexpensive, its a big game of hit or miss when you get one of their tools. Is this the similar game for thw cheaper bits? Quote
dwacker Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 You can get good life out a morris bits and great life from forrest city tool works but your going to pay industrial cutter prices even much higher than fisch. Unless your cranking out doors or loads of mission furniture I doubt they will ever be worth it in a hobby shop. Quote
Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Author Report Posted February 25, 2014 I am a hobby shop with occasional commissions, but its nice to have nice things Quote
Trip Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 ==> I have a renewed new appreciation for the HCM and will be buying one myself What's captured your interest? Quote
Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Author Report Posted February 25, 2014 I built a cradle a few years ago and it had 28 mortise and tenon joints. I love the joint. My main reason was to be able to work with the traditional joint as opposed to the domino alternative. I love matt wolfes work and he builds using a hcm in his work. I also want to include pegged m&t joinery in future builds. Quote
Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Author Report Posted February 25, 2014 Sorry i answered that trip i just realized you were asking pb Quote
dwacker Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 ==> I have a renewed new appreciation for the HCM and will be buying one myself What's captured your interest? "Real" mortise and tenon joints I have avoided them for years since leaving the plant and owning a domino and slot mortiser but having the ability to cut tenons so quick and easy I think getting a mortiser would be nice. I probably would not even think about it without owning a shaper but since I have a beautiful FCT tenon head it just makes sense for furniture. Quote
Freddie Posted February 25, 2014 Author Report Posted February 25, 2014 Pb could you link the video here? Quote
Trip Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 ==>I built a cradle a few years ago and it had 28 mortise and tenon joints. ==>Sorry i answered that trip i just realized you were asking pb No problem... Years ago, I kind of went a bit wild for A&C design -- and got a HCM -- Yea, when your average build has twenty or thirty M&Ts and another 10 through tenons, it's time for a HCM/Slot Mortiser/etc... I build about twenty pieces to feed the A&C addiction, then lost interest --- HCM went on eBay... I get PB's comment on short-shaft chisel/bit sets -- that was always my big complaint with HCM. Anyway, good luck... Quote
dwacker Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 Pb could you link the video here? This is a very similar head, just a bit smaller. You can also just use two straight cutters the only difference is really with straight cutters you use a spacer of your desired tenon thickness. Straight cutters are inexpensive by comparison. If you want to go a slower route and have the right machine with a bolt instead of a nut you can go to w moore profiles and just call them up and tell them you want the cutter on their home page. They will custom make it for you for about $150. There are so many options, to many to list them all. Or you can go cheap and go this route http://www.toolstoday.com/p-6200-prestige-mighty-adjustable-super-fine-dado-groover-for-shaper-machines.aspx?&variantids=11485,0&keywords=61370 Quote
Tom King Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I too have never spent premium price for a chisel set. I don't buy the bottom end either. One thing that I do find helpful, is to have an X-fine flat diamond file kept next to the machine. I don't remember the brand, but it's the kind with the plastic handles in red, blue, and green for the different grits. After a while, the chisel will start to get burrs turning towards the outside. If you hone it every so often, on the outside flat sides, to avoid those burrs, and keep it sharp, it makes the operation go smoothly, and helps to cut clean. I've done some fine tuning on the bit diameter too, with just the bit in a drill press, and a diamond stone with good results, but do this at your own risk to the bit. I like the diamond hones for the chisels that LV sells. We had hundreds to cut on the window sash job, so these recommendations might not apply to a hobby shop that is going to cut just a few. Quote
Trip Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 ==>I don't remember the brand, but it's the kind with the plastic handles in red, blue, and green for the different grits. EZ-Lap http://eze-lap.com/woodworking_shop_machine_use/hone-stone/ I've got a set -- good kit. Quote
Dan S Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I am a hobby shop with occasional commissions, but its nice to have nice things Save the cash for nice things that will make a difference though, like quality measuring, layout, and sharpening tools. One step down from PB's shaper head would be what Garrett Hack uses, a table saw tenoning jig and dual box joint blades separated by spacers. Quote
Tom King Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 If I'm running just a few tenons, I won't even change the blade in the table saw. With a tenoning jig, I just mark and eyeball the mark on the edge of the saw cut in the zero clearance insert, and make two or three test cuts by just turning the piece and cutting both sides, snapping the corners of the offcuts off by hand until I get one to fit like I want it. I made one oak door last week like this, and it only took a few minutes to cut all four tenons like this-probably in less time than I could have changed the blade to some other setup. Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 Hi Freddie, Watching the kind of work you have been doing on FB the HCM will be golden and a real asset. We have two and for my work they are essential. I have not found Clico very good I find they just don't clear quickly enough. This side of the pond they are refferd to as "English Pattern". We use "Japanese Pattern" and they are markedly better. Quote
Tom King Posted February 25, 2014 Report Posted February 25, 2014 I looked up the ones we used last. They cost more than I remembered, but they are better than machine brand bits. I really like these. I don't remember one clogging once. http://woodworker.com/14-mortising-chisel-and-bit-set-mssu-123-881.asp?search=mortise chisel and bit&searchmode=2 I do a lot of business with Woodworkers Supply because stuff I order one day gets here the next day with regular shipping, since we are in the same state. Sign up as a "Pro", and you get a decent discount on almost anything they sell. Once you have your Pro ID, you go to a sister site to order. For instance, the 3/8 bit is $8.50 cheaper than on the page linked above. I don't really know what you have to do to sign up as a Pro. I walked in one day to buy a dust collector, and the salesman asked, "You're a pro aren't you?", and I answered something like for 35 years, and he said he was signing me up for the pro discount, and told me the price difference on the DC, and I've been a pro ever since. The reason I ordered these to start with, was because they had the bits available separately, and I knew I might screw one up tuning it, but fortunately I didn't mess one up. It turned out that I'm sticking with these because they work so well. Quote
Freddie Posted February 26, 2014 Author Report Posted February 26, 2014 Graham, i just recieved a message back from matt wolfe and he recommended the japan bits as well. He said from rockler and from lee valley. The lee valley premium bits are well priced. Quote
pghmyn Posted February 26, 2014 Report Posted February 26, 2014 Graham, i just recieved a message back from matt wolfe and he recommended the japan bits as well. He said from rockler and from lee valley. The lee valley premium bits are well priced. Did you see the video just put up regarding their 25" jointer with shelix? I'm speechless. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.