prov163 Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 Just spent parts of two days making sure my tables are coplaner. Thanks Marc for the great video. Now I need some recommendations and sourcing from you guys. I have a Delta DJ-20 jointer and need new knives. Unfortunately the Byrd head isn't in the budget right now. Are the carbide knives worth the price - about double? Who's the best supplier? Also, what about a knife setting jig? In Marc's jointer tune-up video he shows three and gives his preference. I'd like to hear from you guys about what works best for you. Delta says the knives should protrude .015 above the cutter head. If the outfeed table is set level with the knives, would that really matter? As always, I appreciate all the advice you guys offer! Thanks. Quote
TerryMcK Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 I recently bought this knife setting jig for my jointer. It is an incredibly simple design coming as two jigs with 3 rare earth magnets in each. There is an electrical circuit between the magnet that goes over the top of the blade the other end of the electrical circuit being wired to one of the other magnets. There is an LED, switch and battery in the circuit. All three magnets in the jig are set flush to the jig. So you see the LED light when the blade is magnetically pulled up to the same height as the outfeed table. No more guess work when tightening the blade securing bolts. In practice I found I needed to put some more CA glue to secure the magnets into the jig as one of them pulled out when I tried to remove it from the jointer. Once reglued it worked perfectly. It takes about a minute or so to do each blade. I have set the blades at the same height as the outfeed table rather than 15 thou above. It planes very well. The jig works with carbide and HSS blades. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 I imagine the 15 thou above the cutterhead provides good chip breaking, just as setting the chipbreaker of you hand plane very close to the cutting edge does. Quote
Rick LoDico Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 I have a DJ30 and use a home made jig for setting the knives. I removed the springs from under the blades and epoxied some magnets under the tongues of a piece of melamine. The magnets lift the blades to the height of the out feed table and the screws are then tightened from the middle outward. Quote
Trip Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 ==>Are the carbide knives worth the price - about double? Who's the best supplier? Summary: HHS: sharper than carbide, leave a cleaner cut and [in most cases] available with a back-bevel to reduce tear-out. Carbide: stays sharp longer, but more brittle and subject to compete failure (rare). Sometimes available with a back bevel. Expensive Install: All Carbide: great until (not if) you hit something hard (like a pin not), and damage expensive knifes -- and you can only slide them around a few times to fix. Also, carbide knives can go completely if you hit something hard and you can't shift at all (rare, but does happen). All HHS: can leave a much cleaner cut, smoother surface, less tear-out --- until they dull... Mix: Interleave HHS and Carbide knives... Works well on 4-knife setups and highly recommended, maybe not as well on 3-knife setups (DJ-20). For a 3-knife setup, you should research mixing carbide and HHS knives. It works very well for my 4-knife Tersa/monoblock setups, but that's a different animal. I use American National Knife: http://www.americannationalknife.com/ and found them knowledgeable and helpful. They're geared more for commercial kit, but they can probably sell you what you need or send you to the right place. ==>Delta says the knives should protrude .015 above the cutter head. Chip clearing. You may also experiment with out-feed table height -v- apex of knife arc. Some jointer/species combinations benefit with the arc about 1.5 thou above the output table height. It's works best for my setup.... YMMV Quote
Tom King Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 I have all sorts of dial indicators and magnet this or that's for setting knives. The one I have used for the longest time, and the fastest, is a straight strip of Boxwood about 1/4" x 1/2" by about eight inches long. Any hard wood will work, but the harder the better so the knives can be pushed on the sharp edge. It's on the list of videos I need to make, but it a very simple process, and might take 20 seconds per blade. Put the blade in just tight enough to be able to slide it up and down by fingers. Feel for top dead center and push the blade down with the strip of wood on both ends until it just brushes the wood. Tighten the end bolts when it's right. Swing the head back and forth to make sure it's perfect. Tighten the middle bolts when it's right. It's faster to do it than to type it out. I've had people want to bet money that they can do it faster with some magnetic jig, but they always back out when I show them installing one blade. Once you learn to do it quickly, without even getting in a hurry, you are much more willing to sharpen the blades more often. I use the Veritas jig with sandpaper on a surface plate, and you would probably be surprised how fast it goes, and how good of a job it does. I hand finish them on an 8,000 water stone. I was timed taking the knives out of a 6" jointer, sharpening them, and reinstalling, and it was right at 15 minutes, but I had to dig out the sharpening stuff and get it set up. That was without really getting in a hurry. Quote
rodger. Posted March 25, 2014 Report Posted March 25, 2014 Here is a great jig that i use, after watching a FWW video on it. Dirt simple, and works perfectly. http://www.finewoodworking.com/workshop/video/jointer-knife-setting-jig.aspx Quote
prov163 Posted March 26, 2014 Author Report Posted March 26, 2014 Franklin, I saw video but wasn't sure if the jig would really work as well as it did on the video. Is it really that simple and accurate. Also, Delta suggests the knives be .015 above the outfeed table. How would you accomplish that using this jig? I like the idea, just wonder how it will work. Quote
rodger. Posted March 30, 2014 Report Posted March 30, 2014 Franklin, I saw video but wasn't sure if the jig would really work as well as it did on the video. Is it really that simple and accurate. Also, Delta suggests the knives be .015 above the outfeed table. How would you accomplish that using this jig? I like the idea, just wonder how it will work. I followed the steps just like in the video, and had perfect success. If you like, I can joint a length of stock and post a pic. Quote
Tom King Posted March 30, 2014 Report Posted March 30, 2014 The only reason to set knives proud of the outfeed height is because the sharper a knife is, the quicker it will dull the overall cutterhead diameter down to a smaller diameter. A jointer is usable with proud knives, but not with knife edges below the outfeed table. With that said, I've never seen anyone use fifteen thousandths to start with. That's the thickness of a folding matchbook cover-the tool we used to use for setting car points when there was such a thing, and you didn't have a set of feeler gauges. Sometimes I want to take less than that off with the jointer. The outfeed table is adjustable mainly for this reason. There is kind of a vicious circle here. The higher you set the knives to start with, above level, the longer they will do the job before you HAVE to sharpen them. If changing knives is a dreaded task, it tends to get put off longer. If you have it down to a quick job, and especially if you can sharpen them yourself easily, you do it a lot more often. I like sharp. I like close to level. When I dreaded changing them, I'd let it get really loud, and would have dropped the table a couple of times before I got around to changing them. I even bought the dial indicator, and later magnetic jig for changing them, but that was before I had to change some on a distant jobsite out of desperation once, without all the crutches, and never went back. A sharp knife gives a better finish. They don't stay sharp. I haven't moved the outfeed table on a jointer in years. For edge jointing, I start with fresh knives with the fence all the way on the other side, and move it as the knives get dull. If we do a lot of face jointing, I don't worry about it, and use the sharpest section left when we switch back to edge jointing. When the full width of the knives are dull to the point of needing to lower the outfeed table, I'll sharpen the knives. I would lower the outfeed if it was in a place in a job where it would hold things up too much, but I keep a fresh set handy, and can change them quickly and easily. If I couldn't change them quickly and easily, then it would be a dreaded job, like it used to be, and it would get put off. I checked the way I do it with a strip of wood with the micrometer, and they end up one or two thou proud just by finishing tightening the screws. It works well for me. I do the same thing with the various hand held power planers we use. It's one of those things that you probably can't do really fast the first few times, but once you get the feel, it's no hassle at all, and turns changing jointer knives (or power planer knives) into a non-dreaded and quick routine job. I've seen the "measure how much you drag the strip of wood forward method", but that's just extra time for a few thou more. I don't want to put off changing them if they get dull. I know this probably sounds a lot like the sharpening irons and chisels argument of someone who does it only by hand saying it's as good and faster than using a jig and nobody should bother to use a jig, but this makes even more of a difference in time spent. I like sharp everything for cutting wood, so changing jointer knives is not something I plan to put off, which is what you are doing by setting them so proud. Ask someone like Graham, who uses a Tersa head (they change almost instantly with no tools), how long they put off changing jointer knives as they dull, and if they EVER let them get dull enough to amount to the outfeed table being lowered .015inch. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.