Tony Wilkins Posted June 7, 2014 Report Posted June 7, 2014 I mentioned a while back in a couple of different threads that I was using my LN LA jack more and more and how much I like my LN bronze #4. The backstory to both of those stories is that I was having trouble with my LV bench planes - that I had liked so much when I packed up my shop this winter to move. Now I just can't seem to get a decent shaving with either of them. For the record, the two planes are the LV 5 1/4 jack and LV 4 1/2 smoother - both with PM-V11 blades. It seems that I go from no shaving at all to catching the blade in the wood with sometimes dust in between. Sounds like the blades are sharp from what I've read. However, I've tried sharpening the blade each a couple of times. I raise a burr and smooth it off the back. I don't have any problems with my A2 chisels or plane blades or the few O1 tools I have. I use a Hida 1,000 grit and King 6,000 grit waterstone. TIA, Tony Quote
rodger. Posted June 7, 2014 Report Posted June 7, 2014 How deep a cut are you taking? are you using some parrafin wax on the sole of the plane? I used to only sharpen to 4000, and noticed a big difference when i went up to 8000. Are you doing final smoothing, or flattening a board? both? 1 Quote
jmaichel Posted June 7, 2014 Report Posted June 7, 2014 I am no expert when it comes to sharpening but I think that King 6000 is just not fine enough for that PM V-11 blade. Now I would think that the PM-V11 would work best if polished on 10K or higher stone. I think you could get away with an 8k Stone but if you are going to buy another stone you should just go with a 10K. I am also not to sure on the quality of the King waterstones. Again I could be off base with my reply, it's just more of an educated guess than anything else. 1 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 7, 2014 Author Report Posted June 7, 2014 How deep a cut are you taking? I've started on the board not taking a cut and slowly adjust it out until it starts to take a cut. are you using some parrafin wax on the sole of the plane? yes I used to only sharpen to 4000, and noticed a big difference when i went up to 8000. Are you doing final smoothing, or flattening a board? both? I started with it set up to try to flatten/take off material; after this last sharpening I set it up more as a Charlesworth type super smoother. James, I wondered if the stones were 'cutting it'. If I'm not quite getting them to sharp then that would explain why my results were slowly devolving and my comfort with the planes would decrease. Quote
rodger. Posted June 7, 2014 Report Posted June 7, 2014 well it sounds like you are taking the right approach. your cut is light, your have a waxed sole, and a sharp blade, When i have issues, i dissasemble the plane, clean it, resharpen the blade, and then reassmeble and test cut. this often solves any issues i have. how about the mouth of the plane? when i was having issues with my smoother, tightening the mouth solved the issue. What species of stock are you working on? 1 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 7, 2014 Author Report Posted June 7, 2014 I'll check the mouth - it's pretty open now. I'm still working with the walnut I've been puttering away with on the table I may someday finish Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 8, 2014 Author Report Posted June 8, 2014 Turns out I asked this question back when I got these planes and the answer was whatever you use for A2*. I think I'll try sharpening again but I'm still open to ideas of what I'm doing wrong. *TBI moment on forgetting I asked the question before. Quote
jhl.verona Posted June 8, 2014 Report Posted June 8, 2014 Perhaps you've over-tightened the lever cap? Should be that you screw down until the screw grabs the blade, then add a quarter turn. If you're using too much pressure you won't be able to regulate the depth adjustment screw very easily (it's a Norris type on both those planes I believe) HTH John 1 Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted June 8, 2014 Author Report Posted June 8, 2014 They are both Norris adjusters. So I'll go for another sharpen and then do the lever cap as you're suggesting John. Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 8, 2014 Report Posted June 8, 2014 Tony, to me at least they just sound blunt. I have a couple of A2 blades and it's blooming hard stuff. Make sure you get a good burr across the whole length of the balde. Once you've rubbed the back you might need to work the bevel again as the burr might not of broken away. Derek Cohen is your man on this, he is Mr BD > LV > A2 > PM-V11. Good luck! 2 Quote
jmaichel Posted June 9, 2014 Report Posted June 9, 2014 Nice to see you back on the Forum Graham! 2 Quote
PaulMarcel Posted June 9, 2014 Report Posted June 9, 2014 Silly as it seems, Lee Valley had a promo item at Christmas long ago that was a low-powered microscope. As the catalog said: "excellent, too, for examining tool edges". I got it for that and every time I have a problem where something doesn't seem right with a blade, I look at it under that toy and sure enough I'll find some flat spot that is somehow escaping the stone. Not suggesting you get it or a loupe, but it might help. Also what Graham said: when I got some PM-V11 chisels, I noticed the first sharpening took longer than my A2s. I have no O1s to compare. Now that they are sharp, though, they go a long time and the touch-up is about the same as the A2 touch-up. Hmm, looks like they now carry that microscope as a regular catalog item: http://www.leevalley.com/US/gifts/page.aspx?p=64257&cat=4,53201 Free shipping through end of today if you add enough to hit $40. That's too easy. Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 10, 2014 Report Posted June 10, 2014 Cheers James, it's been mucho busy. You don't escape me that easily! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.