Doomwolf Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 I just for a 1/8" parring chisel in the mail. It's lovely and sharp, but the handle is (very) lose in the socket. Is there a recommended way of fixing this? (pics attached) Quote
Trip Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 Socket chisel = expected condition in winter… Handles loosen with drop in %RH during winter months… Several ways to fix: Permanent = Epoxy - works very well, but not recommended... The idea of socket chisels is that the handle can be replaced without much effort... Recommended: wrap thin plane shaving around tenon to increase diameter slightly. Use hairspray as a releasable adhesive. Tap handle sharply against tablesaw top to drive socket down onto the tenon. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 My first thought was epoxy but, first I've seen the plane shaving option and hair spray.. I like it! Quote
Trip Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 It works... The nice thing --- if you want to swap for a paring handle, it's a 10 second operation... In the summer, usually don't need the shaving... I rarely change handles, so I just leave the shaving in-place until it's time to replace a cracked handle... Which is much easier without epoxy... Quote
..Kev Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 It works... The nice thing --- if you want to swap for a paring handle, it's a 10 second operation... In the summer, usually don't need the shaving... I rarely change handles, so I just leave the shaving in-place until it's time to replace a cracked handle... Which is much easier without epoxy... Well, that's why your a mentor and I'm just staff Quote
Trip Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 Father-in-Law trained as a pattern maker, then spent 30years running a huge pattern shop... Every time he's in the shop, I learn stuff by osmosis... 2 Quote
RichardA Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 Father-in-Law trained as a pattern maker, then spent 30years running a huge pattern shop... Every time he's in the shop, I learn stuff by osmosis... Osmosis........ Can I lean against you or your Dad in law? Quote
Arminius Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 Socket chisel = expected condition in winter… Handles loosen with drop in %RH during winter months… Several ways to fix: Permanent = Epoxy - works very well, but not recommended... The idea of socket chisels is that the handle can be replaced without much effort... Recommended: wrap thin plane shaving around tenon to increase diameter slightly. Use hairspray as a releasable adhesive. Tap handle sharply against tablesaw top to drive socket down onto the tenon. This is one of those brilliant tips that in hindsight is blindingly obvious, yet never occurred to me. The hairspray is a temporary fix, but with the shaving I would expect it to last much longer. Quote
Argus Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 ……Getting back to the question in point – it depends mainly on the type of chisel socket. Socket chisels were originally intended to receive heavy blows from a mallet as in framing work. The modern ones – older Stanleys, Lie-Nielsen et al, have the sockets milled to shape. This means that they are smooth-sided, round in shape and don’t tolerate being twisted due to the lack of internal resistance in the socket; eventually the handle will twist. Socket on older chisels were formed using a swage during the forging process. This resulted in an irregularly shaped socket; even so it was prone to coming loose with changes in temperature. The older users had neither epoxy resin nor did they use hair spray. Gluing the handles in is OK if you never intend to change them, but originally these tools were used in heavy duty work and the handles were flogged to pieces – literally, then replaced in a few minutes with a bit of whillting. So, the question remains on getting a good fit whilst still being able to get a broken stub out without major surgery. Here’s how it was done in the old days: The socket section of the chisel was stood on top of the stove or a hot brick so that it expanded slightly. Meanwhile the handle end of the new handle was smeared with linseed oil and dipped in builder’s sharp sand. The two were then united and the handle driven home hard with a mallet. The sand ensures that it won't come out in normal use unless it is heated slightly and dug out. Hope that this helps Quote
Trip Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 ==>The hairspray is a temporary fix Yes and no... As mentioned, there were various methods to add some bite... The goal of the 'adhesive' is not to be an adhesive -- it's there to lend support to the mechanical fit... i.e., the 'adhesive' just adds a bit of bite, but can be reversed when you want to swap handles... To that end, hairspray has favoriable properties: readily available (just raid wife’s vanity), no purchase necessary (just raid wife’s vanity), easily reversible, can be removed without residue, tacks immediately, etc. Prior to hairspray, lacquer was the adhesive of choice, prior to that it was resin, and so on… BTW: a lot of guys do use epoxy -- especially those with concrete floors in their shop... You can reverse epoxy with a heat gun to change handles... The only real downside is the ability to quickly change handles... So if you want to epoxy it, no problems... Quote
Doomwolf Posted December 31, 2014 Author Report Posted December 31, 2014 Are we talking epoxy putty (which I have) or liquid epoxy (which I don't)? I`m a hobbyist who plans on using said chisel for fiddly parring tasks, so I don`t forsee having to rehandle too much. Argus - what is `builders sharp sand`? And do you mean that I could literally prep the handle, put the socket on a red-hot stove element for 30 seconds and then whack them together with a mallet? All - thank you very much for the advice given in this post (and others). Happy New Year! Quote
Argus Posted December 31, 2014 Report Posted December 31, 2014 Perhaps I didn't explain it too well..........Carpenters using socketed framing chisels often shared work sites with builders so they had all the sand that they needed. 'Builder's sharp sand' is what builders commonly mix with cement. Examined under magnification, it has a sharp, fractured grain that aids the lime-cement bond, as opposed to river or 'washed' sand that has a rounded grain and is useless in building. The 'sharp' sand adheres to the oiled part of the handle and the jagged sand digs into the junction of the wood and the relatively soft iron of the socket. Repeated hammer or mallet blows increases the grip. A slight amount of heat on the socket end expands it very slightly and it grips tighter when cooled - you could used boiling water - the temeperature is sufficient. It should never get anywhere near red hot. I don't know about Canada, but it's a very old trick on this side of the pond................... pre-dates hair-spray and epoxy by a couple of centuries at least and is fully reversible with a few hammer-whacks to the side of the socket......... or a little gentle heat. Of course, all this presumes that the female bit of the socket and the male part of the handle are a well-mated fit for the full length of the junction in the first place. A badly shaped handle that only grips the inside of the socket in a couple of spots will always fall out. The simplest way to check the fit is to use the smoke test. Again, another time-tested old method. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 1, 2015 Report Posted January 1, 2015 Ok, I'll ask the question, since the only 'Smoke Test' I've every done is related to electical equipment. What smoke test? Quote
Argus Posted January 1, 2015 Report Posted January 1, 2015 Well, as a start to 2015, I’ll wish everyone a happy and peaceful New Year. To answer Wtnhighlander’s question, we may be becoming hostages to terminology. You may know it by another term, but in this instance a ‘smoke test’ involves checking the fit of the handle in the socket for high spots using the carbon smuts produced by candle flame. Again, this is an ancient technique, probably as old as the use of candles. You’ll need a cheap candle and a piece of thin wire gauze - a flattened tea-strainer is ideal for this. Light the candle in a candle stick and hold the gauze in the flame in a position where it interferes with the oxygen to the flame without extinguishing it. The result is a smoke laden with hot carbon that will condense on any cool surface. Introduce the tapered end of the handle into the smoke so that it gets covered with an even layer of carbon. It takes just a few seconds. Next, insert the handle into the socket and twist it half a turn and then pull it out. Any high spots will be visible on the carbon. Pare these down and repeat if necessary until you have a good interruption fit all the way down. The same technique is used to transfer embossed makers’ marks from the heels of wooden planes. These things are notoriously difficult to photograph ad the carbon deposits provides a reversed imprint. You may also use this method to check the fit of a tenon where an exact fit is essential. Substituting the pulverised graphite from a pencil also works, but a disadvantage in this instance is that it can also act as a lubricator and can discourage a good bond with the socket and the handle. I find that common problems with hand-tools were most likely to have had simple solutions a long time ago, so I hope that this helps and hasn't complicated the issue too much. Quote
Trip Posted January 1, 2015 Report Posted January 1, 2015 To highlight high-spots, I use sidewalk chalk: http://www.amazon.com/ToySmith-Jumbo-Sidewalk-Chalk-chalks/dp/B001A5SNXA/ref=sr_1_3?s=toys-and-games&ie=UTF8&qid=1420119785&sr=1-3&keywords=sidewalk+chalk... My dad uses powdered graphite: http://www.amazon.com/Generals-Powdered-Graphite-6-Oz/dp/B000A3W4HE/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1420120016&sr=8-2&keywords=powdered+graphite. His method works better; mine has less 'mess-potential'*... A friend of mine uses an interim product: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0000ANEPM/ref=pd_luc_rh_bxgy_01_03_t_lh?ie=UTF8&psc=1 If you use non-mechanical pencils, just rub the side of the pencil onto the tenon… All these work well… Take your pick… I did a write-up on this at some point, but it must have been in 2013, because I can’t find the thread… It’s great for any joint that doesn’t quite go together… In my case, it’s particularly useful with hand-cut dovetails -- my sawing isn't where it should be... *A long time ago I was helping my dad in the shop when I dropped the jar of powdered graphite -- a bigger mess would be hard to imagine... Quote
Tom King Posted January 1, 2015 Report Posted January 1, 2015 I appreciate all the posts about different ways to do it. I'll throw out another, completely modern way, even though probably no one will do it. For trying out new golf club heads on different shafts, nothing beats 3M DP810. It wasn't even an intended use of it, but Tour Vans on the pro tours, that provide work on players clubs, and new things for them to try all the time use it a lot. The golf clubs with big heads are mostly used with graphite shafts. Graphite shafts are made using epoxy to saturate the different types of "fiberglass" cloth. Adhesive that holds the head to the shaft has to be something that will melt at a much lower temperature than the epoxy the shaft is made from, but still has to be strong enough to hit a golf ball at sometimes over 120 mph. 3M DP810 breaks down at about the boiling point of water. Not only does it melt, but it bubbles and boils up, the residue is crispy once it dries, and very easy to clean off of anything. It's about the thickness of regular epoxy. 3M makes all sorts of interesting adhesives similar to this, for various purposes. Long story shortened some, this is what I use if it's a chisel that is going to be honed way beyond razor sharp, and I don't want to worry about the blade falling off into someones leg. For chisels I gave as Christmas gifts this year, this is how I fastened the handles into the sockets. One downside is that it comes in 50ml DuoTubes, and you need a gun that handles that kind of tubes. The gun costs about $35, and the little container of adhesive is around 20 bucks. You can also use disposable mixing tubes, that allow you to run a tiny bead somewhere if you need it, with great control. I used it for this chisel purpose because I already had it for working on golf clubs. Quote
Trip Posted January 1, 2015 Report Posted January 1, 2015 ==>For chisels I gave as Christmas gifts this year How do I get on your xMas list? PS. That 3M product look pretty cool... Thanks... Quote
Tom King Posted January 1, 2015 Report Posted January 1, 2015 Here's a link to the cheapest place I've seen to buy one of the guns. I have this one, and it works fine. I think the 3M gun is about 75 bucks. Golfworks has all sorts of epoxies for good prices too, as well as all sorts of accessories like the mixing nozzles. Most of the golf epoxy is black. I have no idea what's in the epoxy wipes they sell, but they work as good or better than acetone, and have virtually no smell. http://www.golfworks.com/product.asp_Q_pn_E_ESG2 wipes: http://www.golfworks.com/product.asp?pn=VB1015 mixing nozzles: http://www.golfworks.com/product.asp_Q_pn_E_VB1021_A_cn_E_33 3M info on DP810: http://www.3m.com/intl/kr/img/adh/adhesives/dpseries/DP810.pdf They have a bunch of different ones. I keep DP810 and DP100 on hand. Shelf life is very good, but I don't really know what the limit is. http://www.newark.com/3m/dp-810-black-1-7-fl-oz/adhesive-acrylic-cartridge-1-7fl/dp/95C2301?mckv=sBV6Ma088|pcrid|57087225141|plid|&CMP=KNC-GPLA Quote
Doomwolf Posted January 1, 2015 Author Report Posted January 1, 2015 If you check the first picture I showed you can see that the handle doesn't fit the tang well. I'll have to use the graphite method to figure out what works needs to be done and go from there. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.