Recommended Posts

Posted

I've got some thinner scrapers that I've had for a bunch of years that i used for scraping guitar bindings and rosettes. Thin scrapers are better for finer finishing. The hooks don't last too long.

 

I have 1 rather stiff .032" scraper that Is a pleasure to use. That came with my new burnisher. I wanna add a few more scrapers with different hook angles, and wanted some opinions on which scrapers. I know, I know... It's a piece of steel and there shouldn't be too big of a difference, however steel quality make a huge difference. The finer the grain structure the better the hook. 

 

Right now it's a toss up between 

 

Bahco

Two Cherries

Crown

 

I've read the Bahco steel is a finer grain structure and better overall steel. Any thoughts or comments on which you'd recommend?

Posted

I got the Bahco...now I just need to figure out how to use them... so far I've just gotten rid of glue squeeze out on a couple projects with them :)

 

Takes a bit to get used to, and they can get pretty hot. I just ordered 2 Bahcos to go with the 8 I already have. 

Posted

I buy mine from LN and Veritas.  I may be paying a little more for no reason, but they're so cheap to start with I really don't care and prefer to know I'm getting good stuff.  I try not to think too much.

  • Like 1
Posted

I buy mine from LN and Veritas.  I may be paying a little more for no reason, but they're so cheap to start with I really don't care and prefer to know I'm getting good stuff.  I try not to think too much.

 

The crappy thing is I just ordered something from Lee Valley Last week and something from LN the week before. I had 2 scrapers in my cart from LN and dropped em as I figured I already had scrapers.  For 2 scrapers I won't pay 8 bucks shipping when Amazon is free 2 day shipping.

Posted

Yeah I know I HATE paying for shipping and it's a turn-off.  Lucky for LN and LV, they have certain items that are difficult or impossible to buy elsewhere, so you're kind of stuck buying from them a lot of the time.  But they need to wake up to the 21st Century...people don't like seeing shipping charges...just inflate your prices a teeny bit and deceive us...please!

  • Like 1
Posted

Yeah I know I HATE paying for shipping and it's a turn-off.  Lucky for LN and LV, they have certain items that are difficult or impossible to buy elsewhere, so you're kind of stuck buying from them a lot of the time.  But they need to wake up to the 21st Century...people don't like seeing shipping charges...just inflate your prices a teeny bit and deceive us...please!

    It seems to me, that with your NSA and CIA contacts, you could put the squeeze on them, if for no other reason, than to help out your comrades in wood! Please!

Posted

Hey Eric, do you have the "Super Hard scrapers " from Lee valley? If so which thicknesses or do you have the set ?

Any advantage over the Bahco ones ?

 

Yes I have the set.  They're not quite as big as the LN scrapers but I still use them.  I use the two middle thicknesses the most...can't remember the numbers.  Never used Bahco scrapers so I can't offer a comparison.

Posted

Hey Eric, do you have the "Super Hard scrapers " from Lee valley? If so which thicknesses or do you have the set ?

Any advantage over the Bahco ones ?

 

The Variable Burnisher I just got came with a Super Hard Scraper. When the Bahco's get here on Thursday and I turn a hook on them I'll give you a comparison. 

Posted

Yea, I bet it would work well, not sure I want to find out bad enough to spend a couple hours making one to find out. That be a whole

Thicker then the Crown scrapers I have

Posted

Hey Eric, do you have the "Super Hard scrapers " from Lee valley? If so which thicknesses or do you have the set ?

Any advantage over the Bahco ones ?

 

I got my Bahco .8 and .6 6" scraper yesterday. Got them sharpened and tested them out versus the LV Super Hard Scraper. 

 

My thoughts:

 

LV Super Hard Scrapers:

Pros:

Clean and ready to burnish edges with no prep work needed

at a 5 or 10 degree hook they make nice consistent ribbons and the hook lasts a decent amount of time. 

 

Cons:

Very stiff, longer sessions are gonna hurt your fingers

a 0 degree hook for fine shavings isn't very effective on the thicker steel

 

Bahco .8 Scraper

Pros:

More forgiving on your fingers

Finer grain steel which gives a bit of a better and sharper hook

 

 

Cons:

Edges are rounded and need prep work upon arrival

 

 

Summary:

Both scrapers when properly burnished do a great job of smoothing a surface. The LV was more tiring to use than the Bahco. They both held a hook for about the same amount of time of work on hard maple. Neither did a great job of fine shavings at a 0 degree hook. I put a 0 degree hook on my .6 Bahco and got really nice results. I have no thinner LV scrapers.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 70 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined