Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Upgrade Dewalt 735 or go for PM 15HH Planer?

Featured Replies

I am debating on upgrading my dewalt 735x to a Byrd cutter head or investing in the PM 15HH.

I want to start using figured wood, so the Byrd head is what I'm after. My Dewalt 735x works great but I cannot get the snipe to completely disappear. The snipe is very minor and can usually be corrected with a very light sanding. I haven't had to waste any stock due to snipe.

My question to the current owners of the 15hh is; can snipe be completely eliminated using this machine? What can I expect from the 15HH?

I would rather spend the extra money to get a machine that can mill figured wood and eliminate snipe than sink more money into the 735x and deal with the minor snipe.

Also, how well does the 15hh perform when milling curly and quilted boards?

Thanks for your help.

Death, Taxes, Snipe...  :)

 

==>mill figured wood and eliminate snipe

Mill figured wood, yes.... Eliminate snipe, no.

If you do a lot of milling I'd go for the pm for the simple fact that's it's a 220v machine. Stepping up into that kind of power is a night and day difference from a 110v planer. Doesn't matter if it's pm or another good brand; money well spent. As far as dealing with the figure I think you'd be fine with new edges on the helix (but you'll still likely have snipe without a sled)

  • Popular Post

Are you looking at new Powermatic 15hh's or have you found a used one for a good price.  New I've seen them listed around ~$2600, probably doesn't include freight.

 

I'd consider this option personally:

Byrd Shelix Head for Dewalt 735:  ~$450  AND

Supermax 19-38 drum sander:  ~$1400

Total:  <$2000, saving you over $600

 

Or, this if you have the cash and really want a 15" planer:

Grizzly G0435PX (spiral head) with freight:  $1950

Supermax 19-38:  $1400

Total:  $3350

Sell Dewalt:  ~$350-400

Net:  ~$3000

 

For around $400 more, you can get the best hobbyist drum sander out there and a pretty darn good planer with a spiral cutterhead.

 

Just a couple of options to toss around.

FWIW, finewoodworking did a review of these planers and, from memory, both the Grizzly and Jet did better controlling snipe. They are all a similar design so I might chalk it up to luck of the draw. Tiny adjustments in rollers can make a big difference in snipe control. I recall Marc commenting that he spent a ton of time getting his PM 15" planer calibrated.

If you modify the bed on the 15" you can get snipe way down but it's going to take a carpet planer to eliminate it all together. The Byrd head on the pm is much better than the Grizzly knock off and is easier to get a good finish and control snipe. I have the 20" and at this level you get a pressure bar which makes even more difference when it comes to controlling snipe. It a pretty tough call if snipe is a big concern.

  • Author

Thanks for all the input. I appreciate all your opinions and you've given me a lot to consider.

The Grizzly is also a fine option and I am happy with the drill press I own. I recently purchased a couple PM pieces and I am very pleased with their products. 

 

A drum sander is on the purchase list in the near future. I have to evaluate my available space as I prioritize my other machine purchases. 

 

If snipe will exist in each planer option, then I don't think I will sink anymore money into the 735 since I won't see a decent return on it in the used market.

I was reading through the 15hh manual and noticed they recommend a dedicated 40A circuit. Is that correct? How do you guys power your 15hh? I have 2 other machines in my shop with 3hp motors and they are on 20A circuits.

  • Author

If you're going to get rid of the DeWalt let me know.  :)

 

I'm in western NY. Not sure what the shipping cost would be. I assume you wouldn't want to come pick it up.

Thanks for all the input. I appreciate all your opinions and you've given me a lot to consider.

The Grizzly is also a fine option and I am happy with the drill press I own. I recently purchased a couple PM pieces and I am very pleased with their products. 

 

A drum sander is on the purchase list in the near future. I have to evaluate my available space as I prioritize my other machine purchases. 

 

If snipe will exist in each planer option, then I don't think I will sink anymore money into the 735 since I won't see a decent return on it in the used market.

I was reading through the 15hh manual and noticed they recommend a dedicated 40A circuit. Is that correct? How do you guys power your 15hh? I have 2 other machines in my shop with 3hp motors and they are on 20A circuits.

 

You may need a 30 but not a 40. My 5hp 20" uses a 30. Planers and jointers use more amperage on start up than things like tablesaws. If you already have some 20's I would try it first loaded planning a wide board before running a new wire for the 30.

If you modify the bed on the 15" you can get snipe way down but it's going to take a carpet planer to eliminate it all together. The Byrd head on the pm is much better than the Grizzly knock off and is easier to get a good finish and control snipe. I have the 20" and at this level you get a pressure bar which makes even more difference when it comes to controlling snipe. It a pretty tough call if snipe is a big concern.

Fyi, you can get Byrd heads for the grizzly models.

OP,

If you plan on upgrading, Id recommend skipping the 15" and going for a 20".

Fyi, you can get Byrd heads for the grizzly models.

OP,

If you plan on upgrading, Id recommend skipping the 15" and going for a 20".

 

 

My understanding is Grizzly will even install for you before shipping, and the cost is close to or better than buying their knock-off.

 

In terms of size, I have debated 15" vs. 20" myself.    If he is going to get a wide drum sander, i think he will be fine with 15".   15"+ is nice for glued up panels, but a drum sander would do a fine job there as well.  At least that is my long term plan.   Very rarely would I need to plane a single board wider than 15".  

My understanding is Grizzly will even install for you before shipping, and the cost is close to or better than buying their knock-off.

 

In terms of size, I have debated 15" vs. 20" myself.    If he is going to get a wide drum sander, i think he will be fine with 15".   15"+ is nice for glued up panels, but a drum sander would do a fine job there as well.  At least that is my long term plan.   Very rarely would I need to plane a single board wider than 15".  

 

As soon as you think 15 is enough you will need a 20. :)  

==>As soon as you think 15 is enough you will need a 20. :)

As soon as you think 20 is enough you will need a 610mm... 3p, tersa, segmanted pressure bar, DRO, spindel keyway... :)

My understanding is Grizzly will even install for you before shipping, and the cost is close to or better than buying their knock-off.

 

 

 

No they are self install only, you pay full price and install yourself.

==>My understanding is Grizzly will even install for you before shipping

Maybe I'm not getting this?

 

There really isn't much to 'install' on the bearing-cutterhead side of things -- it's the bearing/block where you need a press -- or do they send you a cutterhead/bearing/block assembly, which would be pretty nice...

  • Author

I can't justify the cost of a 20". Not to mention it's about 800 lbs and my movers may not agree to put it in my basement. 

==>My understanding is Grizzly will even install for you before shipping

Maybe I'm not getting this?

 

There really isn't much to 'install' on the bearing-cutterhead side of things -- it's the bearing/block where you need a press -- or do they send you a cutterhead/bearing/block assembly, which would be pretty nice...

 

No just the head the bearings are separate. You also don't need a press just a block of wood and a hammer. You only need a puller if your reusing the old bearings. Some Byrd dealers like the one I use they come with the bearings pre installed but with these machines the bearing are so inexpensive it really doesn't matter all that much.

==>My understanding is Grizzly will even install for you before shipping

Maybe I'm not getting this?

 

There really isn't much to 'install' on the bearing-cutterhead side of things -- it's the bearing/block where you need a press -- or do they send you a cutterhead/bearing/block assembly, which would be pretty nice...

 

 

No they are self install only, you pay full price and install yourself.

 

I am probably wrong, I am just repeating what I heard elsewhere (bad habit, I know).  My understanding was you could buy the straight knife planer and they would swap the cutterhead to a byrd for you.  

 

in any case, buying their straight knife planer and a byrd head only costs a little more than buying their spiral head planer.  It is a $825 uprade from a straight knife cutterhead to their byrd knock off.  You can buy the Byrd cutterhead for $875.  So for $50 extra, you get a byrd head and can keep the factory head as a spare.   If I were buying a Grizzly that is what i would do.  

I am probably wrong, I am just repeating what I heard elsewhere (bad habit, I know).  My understanding was you could buy the straight knife planer and they would swap the cutterhead to a byrd for you.  

 

in any case, buying their straight knife planer and a byrd head only costs a little more than buying their spiral head planer.  It is a $825 uprade from a straight knife cutterhead to their byrd knock off.  You can buy the Byrd cutterhead for $875.  So for $50 extra, you get a byrd head and can keep the factory head as a spare.   If I were buying a Grizzly that is what i would do.  

 

I got to ask, why keep a spare cutter head? 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.