Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm trying to finalize (term used loosely) my shop layout, before closing the walls in. The shop will be 24' x 24' with a 12' x 24' finishing/storage room attached.

 

After getting the table saw, jointer and planer in the shop, I quickly realized they will not group nicely in the middle of the shop.  One tool (jointer) will occupy the long wall I had planned for a miter station. Now I have this dilemma on my hands that I could use some feedback on. although I only use a miter saw for rough cutting lumber, the ultimate miter station in my estimation would have at least 8' left of the blade and a minimum of 4 foot to the right. That is a huge space killer, and one I am struggling with. It kills so much wall space! So the crux of the question is, since I only rough cut lumber with it, would you find a home for it in the finishing room, or would you change the dimensions of the bench and squeeze it in the main shop. Another alternative it the dewalt stand with wheels, and extendable support arms. I could put that to the left of the jointer and pull it away from the wall if chopping or jointing a long board. Even that idea seems to take up precious wall space for what it actually does for me.

 

How do you folks deal with the ungodly real estate of a chop saw that doesn't do much, besides hack a long stick? I am almost inclined to say the hell with it all together and break down lumber with a circular saw on my foot!

Posted

I cut rough lumber on a sawyers bench with a handsaw (well 2 handsaws - one crosscut and one rip). I currently have no miter saw in th shop, but my kapex is on the way. I will continue to rough cut in the sawyers bench however - I've had a mitre saw jump back at me one too many times on rough cuts.

My kapex will have a dedicated space, but I too am still deciding where to place it. The kapex does, however, require far less space than the average chopsaw.

Posted

I cut rough lumber on a sawyers bench with a handsaw (well 2 handsaws - one crosscut and one rip). I currently have no miter saw in th shop, but my kapex is on the way. I will continue to rough cut in the sawyers bench however - I've had a mitre saw jump back at me one too many times on rough cuts.

My kapex will have a dedicated space, but I too am still deciding where to place it. The kapex does, however, require far less space than the average chopsaw.

 

Did your ship? I'm still on infinite backorder. I'm willing to bet I have children first =)

Posted

Why not put the miter saw under your lumber storage, so, when you pull a piece down, you have a place to examine it, as well as break it down to whatever size you require?

Posted

Did your ship? I'm still on infinite backorder. I'm willing to bet I have children first =)

Yes, should be available April 8 for pickup! Woot!

I took my other miter saw out of the shop. I will use it for diy and carpentry tasks now (it needs a little work first). I have crosscut at least 25 workpieces (rough) on the sawyers bench now - really liking it.

I did, however, get a good workout when I was ripping roigh ash and cherry the other day.

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think you'd like it in the finishing room. I use my miter saw for all sorts of smaller cuts too so I'd like it closer than the next room. Maybe consider having 4 feet on each side with a 4 foot part that can be removed or folded.

Posted

I wouldn't put in the finishing room. It would probably help to see a sketch of how you plan on laying out the machinery and the overall shop. It would probably help others give you suggestions.

Posted

How come I think PB is serious. Please tell me how you break down your stock without one PB. If you say your shaper has a severing blade I'm buying one tomorrow!

 

So far I am leaning toward following Tim's suggestion, building something new on a mobile cart, instead of hauling my long bench out to the new barn.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm clearly in the minority, but I love my SCMS and wouldn't want to be without it.  They're relatively small tools and it shouldn't be that hard to find a place for it.  Get all your bigger machines situated, then think about where to put the SCMS.  Incorporate it into an already existing bank of cabinets or other work surface...like this...

 

 

DSC_00112.jpg

Posted

How come I think PB is serious. Please tell me how you break down your stock without one PB.

Tablesaw and bandsaw is plenty for most anything. If it happens to be huge I might break out a worm drive circular saw but only if a piece is really large. I don't see a lot of sense in filling a shop with cabinets and unnecessary space hogging tools when the basics will perform most any task just fine.

Posted

I used a miter saw for 2x4's when I finished my shop and it will now collect dust the next 2x4 project. I use a circular saw to break down rough material to length and crosscut sled on table saw to get to final length. 

 

Like others said a sketch of your shop layout would be helpful. I ganged my tools in pairs which worked well and I fit all of them in one half of my shop, a 20x30 area. All machines will handle 9-10' long boards. Here is my layout. 

 

 

post-8178-0-40815500-1428239974_thumb.pn

 

Posted

Tablesaw and bandsaw is plenty for most anything. If it happens to be huge I might break out a worm drive circular saw but only if a piece is really large. I don't see a lot of sense in filling a shop with cabinets and unnecessary space hogging tools when the basics will perform most any task just fine.

 

The one thing I hate about my shop now is the real estate the miter station takes up. I'm also guilty of putting things in the clear space that will inevitably need to be moved when I do throw a long board on the miter saw. It's really convenient sometimes, but as you suggest, It steals valuable space that a machine can occupy. Thinking long term, I'd love to get a lathe, and I know I will want to stick it where that damn miter saw sits.

Posted

I used a miter saw for 2x4's when I finished my shop and it will now collect dust the next 2x4 project. I use a circular saw to break down rough material to length and crosscut sled on table saw to get to final length. 

 

Like others said a sketch of your shop layout would be helpful. I ganged my tools in pairs which worked well and I fit all of them in one half of my shop, a 20x30 area. All machines will handle 9-10' long boards. Here is my layout. 

 

 

attachicon.gifShopLayout.png

 

Mike, what utility did you use to create that layout?

Posted

Tablesaw and bandsaw is plenty for most anything. If it happens to be huge I might break out a worm drive circular saw but only if a piece is really large. I don't see a lot of sense in filling a shop with cabinets and unnecessary space hogging tools when the basics will perform most any task just fine.

It depends on the things you most often build.  Entertainment centers? No...you'll probably not need a chop saw much. Smaller projects? You'll use it a lot. Case in point, I want to make some sort of box around 7" x 11".  I take a piece of 8 foot maple and need 38-40" off of it.  I have an Incra system on my TS you can loosen a couple of knobs and take the fence off and use the table saw.  I have a sled that's about 36 inches....would work great....but it's so much easier to have a dedicated chop saw to do things like this.  Most of us need a little more horizontal surfaces anyway and the chop saw takes about 18" out of the table top.

Posted

My question is with a dedicated shop not housing household junk why do folks need so much storage space.

Sharpening stones, jigs, squares, pencils, blades, rulers, accessories for certain tools, hand tools, etc.

Where do you store all of your shaper cutters? Bits? Sandpaper?

Posted

My question is with a dedicated shop not housing household junk why do folks need so much storage space.

 

In my case, it's because I don't like things out collecting dust.  Yes, there's a lot of storage at my miter station but, nearly none in the rest of the shop.  So, I use that space to store everything I need in my dedicated shop.  I store everything from routers/bits to nail/pin guns to bags for my CT units in that space.  It's all stuff that I need and use in my shop. Those that have seen pics of my shop organization know that I'm pretty OCD about everything having a home.

Posted

It has been mentioned a few times in this thread that a miter saw is a small tool. I just can't agree with that. The needed space around it to make it useful lends it to be the largest tool in a shop. For a tool that I would personally use as a hack saw with a motor, I struggle with this. I can see Eric's point as he has a precision SCMS and has incorporated it well into his shop and work-flow. For me, I just don't see it the same glamorous way, It's more of a hindrance.

 

As far as space to put things, I will have a dedicated assembly table with drawers, outfeed table with drawers, eventially a roubo bench and plenty of wall space for cabinets and shelves. I tend to agree with PB that the cabinet space gained by the miter station is over-kill.

  • Like 1
Posted

I tend to agree with PB that the cabinet space gained by the miter station is over-kill.

 

Depends on what kind of stuff you build. Having built a guitar and going to be starting another one in the next 3-6 months, there's an ungodly amount of jigs and special tools needed for the task. Can't just leave everything out and about. Right now most of them are in a rubbermaid tub in my basement because there are no cabinets in the shop to hold them. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined