Recommended Posts

Posted

I am interested in purchasing a table saw I found on CL. I am a little iffy on it because the guy says it has been converted to run on single phase power. He sent me a description of of the conversion was done using capacitors and a contractor etc...

 

I don't know enough about 3 phase power and motors to know if this is safe for the motor or not. He says the saw runs great and the a hobbyist would never have an issue running this saw on single phase.  

 

Has anyone see or done a conversion like that? Can anyone confirm that what he is saying is true?

 

Here is the text from his most recent email:

 

"BLUF (Bottom Line up Front), as a hobbyist you will not break this saw. 

3 phase motors can run on two of the 3 power legs just fine, however they need the 3rd power leg to start. The phase inverter provides the 3rd power leg until the motor gets up to speed. The phase inverter then drops out the 3rd leg by disconnecting via a built in contactor. The phase inverter will not damage the motor. 2 of the 3 power phase legs are supplied from standard double pole 220-240 volt power like your electric clothes dryer or electric oven. The phase inverter draws from the same power source, but stores the power in capacitors, then releases the power at startup. This is actually similar to the way single phase motors work. On a single phase motor The capacitors are connected to the motor housing. With the inverter, the capacitors and other components are housed in a separate electrical housing and are replaceable as an entire unit, one for one swap if there is a problem with the inverter. "

 

Final question, what do you guys think a 3 phase 3 HP saw converted to single phase (220v), with 52" Biesemeyer style fence with over 52" rip capacity, new outfeed table and miter guage worth? the pictures of the saw show a very clean machine.

 

I have a few larger projects coming up that I would love to have a new(to me) cabinet saw for.

 

Thanks

 

Brian

Posted

Before we explore the mysteries of DIY phase conversion, couple of questions:

 

How much is the saw? How has the saw being used -- hobby only, cabinet shop?

 

Is he the original owner -- which begs the question, why a 3p, 3HP saw? I'm not sure there are many of those floating around... And considering the required change in controls, I suspect it's not all OEM -- so is it a rebuilt saw?

 

Can he send you a photo of his electrical engineering masterpiece?

 

What do you intend to use the saw for (hobby work, advanced hobby, small cabinet shop, etc)? Can you get by with 2HP saw?

 

When.... Oppps, I mean if.... Yea, Yea, definetly... if... OK, if the saw catches fire, will it burn-down your house?

Posted

I do woodworking as a hobby. I build 1 or 2 big projects a year (my most recent project was a king size captains bed). He is asking $1299 for the saw. I have only ever had a small contractor saw and a circular saw and figured out a way to get whatever i was working on done so I think a 2HP saw is probably enough for my needs unless someone were to tell /convince meotherwise.  here are a couple pictures I grabbed from the CL Listing:

 

00U0U_gsi4mR5Zp4L_600x450.jpg

 

00I0I_3YZVYclS5Vh_600x450.jpg

 

00M0M_8LQUKX3zEwq_600x450.jpg

 

00f0f_8ZKnJNW5dbT_600x450.jpg

Posted

I don’t know that much about GI – my father-in-law’s in Alberta and he’s got some General gear and loves it... So someone else will have to comment on the resale value on a GI 3HP saw...

 

The setup seems a bit hokey – again, I don’t know much about GI saws, but I’m trying to get my arms around the 3phase – was this a 1p saw with 1p controls (or 3p controls wired as 1p) and the motor died, so he replaced it with a 3p motor? Or was this a 3p saw in a shop with 1p so he hot-rodded the motor and rewired the controls? I suppose it does not really matter, the saw is what it is – 3p motor hot-rodded for 1p...

 

I’m going to assume its wye wound with caps bootstrapping the 3rd leg – very old school... Lots of guys do this...  While I’ve never looked myself, I bet there are dozens of plans available on the internet... Assuming there’s some knowledge, decent quality caps and some basic wiring skills behind it, there’s nothing really wrong with the approach (assuming he addressed the inherent phase imbalance) – there are drawbacks (beyond the scope of an internet post), but there is nothing fundamentally wrong...

 

However, it’s one thing to have a commercial purpose-made phase converter and another to go DIY – if there is ever a fire, then god forbid it’s traced to a DIY phase converter...

Posted

What would you say a good price would be?

To be quite honest,it wouldn't be worth anything to me until I knew more about the saw. from what you said, it seems a bit thrown together.

A big fence is nice to have if you actually use the capacity. A big motor is nice if you actually need it.

for $1300, I'd be looking at something new be it a grizzly or add a few bucks for the sawstop contractor saw. Call me a pessimist but I think a warranty is a valuable asset when buying a tool.

Posted

For $1300, I would pass and just get a Grizzly 1-phase saw. If this was $1300 for a North American or European 3-phase saw, I would then get an inverter-VFD to drive the motor, for under $200 (search for "inverter VFD 220 3HP" on ebay). The VFD's are IMO better way to drive 3-phase.

Personally, I am waiting for the right time financially to take the plunge and buy a 3-HP sawstop.

Posted

For $1300, I would pass and just get a Grizzly 1-phase saw. If this was $1300 for a North American or European 3-phase saw, I would then get an inverter-VFD to drive the motor, for under $200 (search for "inverter VFD 220 3HP" on ebay). The VFD's are IMO better way to drive 3-phase.

Personally, I am waiting for the right time financially to take the plunge and buy a 3-HP sawstop.

How does the power loss compare running on a VFD to running on this kind of set up?

Posted

FWIW, and this is just based on reading multiple posts on this subject, it is probably best/easiest just to replace the 3 phase motor with a new or refurbished single phase motor and not mess around with all the conversions.   As your search continues, keep that it mind.  If the used saw + new/refurb motor is a good price, then you have a good deal (the old three phase motor might have some trade in value).  Otherwise keep looking.     Conversion kits take up space, result in loss of power, and, as Trip points out, could be dangerous if they were MacGyver'd together the wrong way.   I guess I would put them in the category of "expert use", if you don't consider yourself in expert in power conversion, it is best to go with a motor designed to work on single phase.  

Posted

I would expect that a motor driven by a static converter, such as mentioned in the original post, would produce around 70% of its reted horsepower, as the third phase is only present during start up, as I understand the description. The VFD actually converts single or three phase AC input to DC, then back to three phase AC output, so the motor can operate at rated power, although more power will be required at the line input to account for small losses in conversion. There are also rotary phase converters that employ a second motor and some mechanism for spinning it up to produce the third phase. I understand they are relatively efficient compared to static converters, and allow the driving motor to operate at near rated horsepower.

I am not a phase conversion expert - this opinion is based solely on my knowledge of and experience with industrial electricity/ drive systems, and things I have read on the internet.

Posted

I don't expect any loss of power with a properly sized VFD. Not sure about the static conversions.

There is some from my understanding, because a VFD mimics AC voltages but not exactly.  It uses pulse width modulation to pulse the full voltage instead of having a sign wave voltage.  So from what I have read it costs some power output for it.

Posted

The best way to simulate a third phase depends on the application, power required (HP), quality of the power required, stability required, tolerable phase imbalance, number of machines, etc, etc – the list is long... We could get into the weeds, but it's not worth it...

 

 

<edit>

But for the next guy coming along, there is no such thing as 100% efficient 'magic' phase conversion -- there is always some 'loss' somewhere in the pipe and some level of compromise on power quality/fidelity (stability, frequency, waveform, balance, etc)... If you want high-fidelity 3p, then get the utility to run it for you... And yes, in most cases, they'll do it -- just depends on how much you want to spend – it’s usually cost-prohibitive for residential hobby-shops.

 

To clarify VFD efficiency: if you get a 7.5HP VFD that takes 1p input, then the saw can deliver almost 100% 3HP at full RPM... Now -- notice the imbedded caveats in that...

 

As a general rule, over-provisioning is the time-honored method to improve power-fidelity... If your biggest machine is 3HP/3p, then get a 5HP rotary phase converter, 7.5HP VFD, etc...

 

One method I’ll specifically call-out – back-feeding... There are internet forums recommending phase conversion for machine ‘A’, then using it as the basis of 3p distribution for the rest of the shop (sort of ad hoc shop RPC)... While popular for the truly thrifty minded, I’m not sure exactly what the insurance guy will say when you burn down your house, but it won’t be good...

 

Also, be careful when reading internet DIY forums... A lot of guys doing this stuff are machinists powering things like vintage mills who want RPM control and tend to spend as little as possible to get it – this mindset does not map to modern machines that may incorporate motor braking, computer controls, digital sensors, etc...

 

While 3p conversion is safe and done all over the place, you are much better off contacting an electrician to install a purpose-made solution... Care should be taken when digesting internet posts on method-A –vs- method-B phase conversion... Many [most?] of these comparisons are based on home-brew setups --- commercial purpose-made gear can be quite expensive and out-of-reach for hobbyists, so many of the comparisons are apples-to-oranges...

Posted

The best way to simulate a third phase depends on the application, power required (HP), quality of the power required, stability required, tolerable phase imbalance, number of machines, etc, etc – the list is long... We could get into the weeds, but it's not worth it...

 

Static phase converters, hot-rodding, rotary phase converters and VFDs all work --- but there is not one perfect solution for all cases... If there was, everyone would be using it... Each has their pros/cons and need to be considered on a case by case basis...

 

But to answer the question -- there is no 100% 'magic' phase conversion -- there is always some loss somewhere in the pipe and some level of compromise on power quality/fidelity... If you want real 3p, then get the utility to run it for you... And yes, in most cases, they'll do it -- just depends on how much you want to spend.... Since we're talking VFDs --- if you get a 7.5HP VFD that takes a 1p input, then the saw can deliver almost 3HP at full RPM (we'll ignore the small loss)... Now -- notice the imbedded caveats in that... If we want to get into the weeds of power conversion, then I'd suggest a separate thread...

I was happily ignoring increased power consumption, I was just speaking to output power.  But this really isn't important here.

Posted

==>I was happily ignoring increased power consumption, I was just speaking to output power.  But this really isn't important here.

Yea, I got that... But want to keep things clear for the next guy comming along... I'll add some clarifications...

Posted

One more clarification is that commerciall-built rorary converters will cost as much, or even more, than replacing the motor. That's one reason the DIY route is so popular. The other is that a lot of vintage machines can not be retrofitted (easily) with modern motor frames.

Posted

A 7.5 HP VFD only delivering 3HP? That sounds completely exaggerated. There's no reason a decent quality VFD can't deliver its advertised output, as long as they didn't lie about its true abilities (at worst you may have to up-size a little bit, not double). Modern electronics make generating 3 phase quite simple. PWM controlled power supplies should have no problem generating a dead simple 60Hz smooth sine wave at rated power. These days, we even have PWM power supplies amplifying digital audio at up to 96kHZ at thousands of watts.

Posted

I recall reading about the old single phase driver using a starter cap for the third winding (presumably you will be running the motor in delta) a looong time ago but have never done it myself. In theory in run mode the single phase (in reality it is actually operating in pseudo 2 phase mode since your active and neutral really operate as 2 phases but they are not separate phases since they are actually in phase) will really only generate a maximum of 2/3 of the total motor's power since one set of windings will be open circuit. So without taking into consideration the real phase of your active neutral you are already loosing 1 HP.

 

Now comes the tricky part. Each of the three windings of your motor are physically 120 deg apart and are driven by 3 phases that are 120 deg apart thus 3 phase power. You have lost one phase and the other two are actual effectively 180 deg apart thus reducing the efficiency of the remaining two windings. As a rough estimate (without doing the actual maths) I would expect to loose another 1/3 of the remaining power leaving you with roughly 1 1/2 HP. If you are happy with that then fine, it is still not a bad power for your table saw.

 

However if you want the 3 HP you can buy another 3 HP motor from ebay (if you are good at engineering that is since it will need some mounting) or buy the VFD.

Posted

A 7.5 HP VFD only delivering 3HP? That sounds completely exaggerated. There's no reason a decent quality VFD can't deliver its advertised output, as long as they didn't lie about its true abilities (at worst you may have to up-size a little bit, not double). Modern electronics make generating 3 phase quite simple. PWM controlled power supplies should have no problem generating a dead simple 60Hz smooth sine wave at rated power. These days, we even have PWM power supplies amplifying digital audio at up to 96kHZ at thousands of watts.

I thought the issue was how smooth the PWM was.  Because it is fundamentally not a smoothly varying voltage but a pulsed max voltage being pulsed to simulate the varying voltage.  With some capacitors it would help smooth out the pulses but it seems unlikely to perfectly vary it.

 

This sounds like a job to break out the oscilloscope.

Posted

Apples and oranges...

 

VFDs are a species, while this thread is parsing characteristics of individual members... The same way that Rigid and Altendorf both make something called a table saw and members of the table saw species --- the individuals are not the same... 

 

 

The $200 eBay special VFD so popular with the value-minded (ever notice how the $200 eBay unit doesn't specify the actual brand and/or model number) are not the same as those costing 10x as much (think Cutler-Hammer) being used to control high-end gear... Both are VFDs -- but they are not the same...

 

Bottom line – the best 3p conversion is to purchase a 1p motor and sell the 3p to recoup the investment... The differential spend will be a couple hundred bucks... Unless we are talking an unusual motor mount, the swap is straight forward... Many [most] 3p control sets in small stationary kit can be wired 1p and owner’s manuals typically show both wiring configurations.

 

As for the OP – at $1300, I’d take a pass...

Posted

Just an update, I called the local General tool dealer here in town and they quoted me $1200-$1500 for a 2hp single phase saw, new with warranty. They seller on CL was rather annoyed when I told him I was passing on the saw saying "you never had any intention on buying this saw or you are an idiot" 

 

I politely informed him what i had found out from the dealer and he apologized for insulting me

 

wish i would have called the store before sending the seller an email...oh well.

 

Thanks again for everyone's input.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 41 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined