Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Which HVLP upgrade?

Featured Replies

I've been struggling with spraying GF Satin High Performance Top Coat on a mixed barn wood table. 

Table.png.630397fb8b943fded16f5e551e40d6

I'm currently using a cheap Harbor Freight Turbine (Rockler clone) HVLP. 

http://www.harborfreight.com/high-volume-low-pressure-spray-gun-kit-44677.html

The gun seemed fine for spraying oil based stain and poly however that tends to be extremely messy and very slow to dry. I'll be sticking with waterborne products from now on.

Applying a uniform wet coat leads to ripples / orange peel.

The only way I can get the finish to lay on is extremely thin coats after thinning the material with 20% extender and 5% water. This is so thin that it's basically dry after 20 seconds. Areas that are still wet after I'm done I have to immediately dry with the air from the turbine otherwise I get splotches with less satin. The end result is moderately rough. 

The harbor Freight page doesn't list turbine pressure however Rockler's page says 4 PSI. You would think that would be enough to get a somewhat decent finish so I measured myself and ended up with just under 2.5 PSI.... that explains a lot. Not to mention that it received poor ratings from Fine Woodworking.

56db23be03541_HFHVLPPressure.png.fb34194

Alright so I made a bad purchase, I want to learn from that mistake. Which system should I go with?

Requirements

  • Expected Usage: 4 - 5 times per year
  • Material: Mostly WB finishes (poly, lacquer, stain) Some WB paint (milk, alkyd enamel)  and NEVER Latex (that is what my airless is for).
  • Thinning: Some thinning is OK as long as I can get consistent results. I won't loose any sleep over having to apply another coat or 2. The system should be able to handle any RTS material with little or no thinning.
  • Noise: With as little as I'll use this I don't think it will be worth it to spend a ton extra on a quiet system
  • Budget: Willing to spend enough for a decent system to serve me for many many years without going overboard.
  • Other: Non-bleeder if possible. Bottom feed gun.

Considerations

  1. Earlex 5500 - I think this would get me passed this project but would leave me wanting to upgrade in the future. I'd prefer non-bleeder if possible. At 2.2 PSI it is really no upgrade from my current turbine - in fact I could just purchase an Earlex gun to use with the HF turbine.
     
  2. Fuji Semi Pro 2 - This unit looks very attractive. It is the right price and offers more control than both my current gun and the Earlex. I am slightly concerned that the 2-stage unit (5 PSI) might not have enough power to properly atomize WB finishes.
     
  3. Fuji Mini-Mite 3 - This unit is highly rated and should be more than powerful enough. My concern is that it might not be worth the extra $$ based on my needs.
     
  4. HVLP Conversion - I don't know which since I haven't really looked at these yet. I do have a compressor rated at 7.7 CFM @ 40 PSI. It is extremely loud and has been on my list to downsize to something smaller and more quiet. I've kept it around because of the odd time I need to break a bolt loose or spray sand texture on drywall. This would probably be my cheapest option if my compressor could keep up.

Thanks!

I have been happy with my American Turbine HVLP for years. Both gun and turbine have held up in my small custom shop for well over 10 years. Take a look at their smaller setup.

I would get a mini mite 3 or 4. Since you said you'll do paint occasionally the 4 will be better. I can spray GF milk paint full strength with a 1.8 tip with my 4 and you might have to thin using the 3. The turbine will probably last a lifetime for hobby use so that $100 is nothing over the long run. 

  • Author

Thanks for the replies.

I haven't heard of American Turbine before but will take a look.

It is starting to get a bit pricey! When I started looking for a replacement I thought the Earlex would do the trick. But for $100 more the Semi-Pro 2 is non-bleeder, more powerful, and has more control. But then that is a good chunk of $ if I'm going to want to eventually replace that with a 3 stage MM3. 

So now I'm at a minimum $620... Well that's a bit more than I planned on.

My only hesitation is that I don't understand why I should go with a turbine instead of a conversion gun. $200 for a gun & cup plus a line filter, regulator, and some extra hose to reach the basement. Maybe $300 total? 7.7 CFM on a 20 gal should be enough to drive a gun for small projects. 

Still go with a turbine?

Turbine provides a continuous stream of warm air that never runs out. I tried a conversion gun on my 60 gallon 5 hp compressor and was not impressed. You will also need to add extra oil/ moisture traps to your compressor.

Maybe the cost and small project size will make it work for you. But I would make sure what the return policies are in advance. Take pictures as you unpack and save all the wrappings just in case.

Conversion guns work fine if you have dry air, but you need something like a refrigerated dryer for that.  Filters just won't do it for the amount of air needed.  That puts you back up in the money again.  I just don't know any way to do really top quality spraying without spending a good amount of cash.

+1 for the Minimite. I've got the MM4 and I sprayed latex paint through it after a little bit of thinning (wouldn't have needed to if I had the bigger needle/nozzle set) I've sprayed WB poly through it with no problem. I bought it through Paintsprayersplus, and it came with some "bonus" stuff for the same price as everywhere else. Some strainers, and a cleaning kit with all the little brushes you could ever imagine. You also get the privilege of calling them when you have any problems or questions about spraying and the owner of the company will walk you through what to do, or make recommendations. 

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author

Alright so I have an update. After much deliberation I decided to go with a conversion gun.

I just couldn't justify the $620 for the MM3 based on how little use it would receive. Before doing anything I measured my 21 gal compressor and came up with about 8 CFM. Now I wouldn't paint a car with that size of compressor but it is plenty for a woodworking hobbyist. I removed the stock regulator and replaced it with a new regulator + oil/water separator filter. Being that I am spraying waterborne finishes I don't mind if there is a bit of water vapor still in the line. At least I am catching most of it. 

I ordered the TCP Global G6600 for $40 out of curiosity. This thing would definitely spray better than my HF turbine unit but the quality is still suspect - and it is quite heavy.

I ended up settling on the Astro EuroPro 1.3. This was a massive step up in quality from the G6600. Everything fits together perfectly, the unit is very lightweight, all of the adjustment knobs turn easily, and it has a nice plastic cup (so you can see your material). Astro recommends running at 29 PSI however I found that to be too strong and causes the material to bounce back. As of right now I am running about 22 PSI. My compressor just barely keeps up.

I just sprayed GF High Performance on the back of the table and the results were fantastic. The compressor kicks in at 125 PSI about halfway through (7 or 8 passes) - again I don't see air supply being an issue for any wood project I'll ever do. 

My 2 cents ...

I've had Lex-Air, Lemmer, Titan/Capspray and Turbinaire HVLP turbine/gun systems.

All worked good enough for the clear and pigmented water based finishes I use.

The $50 garage-sale Titan/CapSpray was the quietest of them all and the gun was pretty nice.

I'm currently using a (discontinued) Turbinaire system. It's noisier than the CapSpray but I really like the gun and the variable speed turbine.

I now generally use SDA/Craft finishes: http://sdacraft.com/

They seem as good or better than the other finishes I've tried and the price is lower than most if you buy in quantity.

 

 

I have been happy with my "American Turbine " 

Started this reply then realized it was an older thread I had already replied to.

12 hours ago, Tom K said:

 I removed the stock regulator and replaced it with a new regulator + oil/water separator filter. Being that I am spraying waterborne finishes I don't mind if there is a bit of water vapor still in the line. At least I am catching most of it.

Tom-

What did you purchase for the reg / filter / separator? I have been planning to get an HVLP gun to run off my compressor. Just havent taken the time to do the research for guns and reg ect.

  • Author

I just went with a masterforce combo unit from Menards. I think it was $23. They have a standalone filter / separator for less if you are happy with your regulator. I was not. 

The filter is only 40 micron so it is not going to get everything. It also isn't going to cause as big a pressure drop as the 5 and 0.5 micron filters. I'm guessing I can change the element with something smaller down the road if I want.

 

I I purchased a 3m regulator for the gun and am quite happy with it. 

M60 Filter Image

 

Go buy the M60 filter. Its uses single ply toilet paper to filter water and oil vapor from your compressor. REMEMBER YOUR NOT ONLY FILTERING FOR WATER VAPOR BUT OIL VAPOR, AS WELL.

 

I have this connected about 25 feet away from the gun.

 

-Ace-

10 hours ago, Alan G said:

Do people really use toilet paper in the M60?

Yes they do and I do. The manufacture sells a filter made of filter paper. The issue for guys using toilet paper. You must be diligent in replacing the roll or soggy wet pieces of toilet paper could break loose and enter the air line. By diligent, I mean use common sense and check your filter from time to time. If the bottom of the filter starts to become soggy. Get rid of it and chuck in a fresh roll.

Never leave a damp TP roll or the manufactures filter in the housing for extended periods of time. Before storing or lack of use, always take it apart dry the inside and store. 

 

-Ace-

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.