Recommended Posts

Posted

I always see these in the woodpecker email blast ... What is so special about these that they want $100 when not on sale?

Does it alleviate the need for brad nails or what? Or just another way to do things and spend lots of money on?

 

10-31-2016 9-17-03 AM.jpg

Posted

It looks like the angles are complimentary so they will always fit together,  eliminates the need for brads and won't let it slip when glue is applied.

The $66 price isn't too far from where 1/2" whiteside bits normally are. 

Posted

Increased glue area and preventing the edging from moving around while clamping.   Brads obviously aren't the best idea since they will be visable even after finishing.  In the end it is a time saver that prevents some of the issues with just butt jointing edging.  No different than miter lock bits and other similar treatments for glue joints.

Posted
1 minute ago, HuxleyWood said:

  In the end it is a time saver

I wouldn't call it a time saver. setting up the router with each bit takes a lot longer than spinning up my compressor and grabbing the micro pin nailer..

  • Like 2
Posted
Just now, Brendon_t said:

I wouldn't call it a time saver. setting up the router with each bit takes a lot longer than spinning up my compressor and grabbing the micro pin nailer..

Its a time saver in glue up and shooting 23g pins is still leaving a tell tale sign.  For shop shelves or that sort of this then pins or even brads isn't an issue but for something closer to furniture most like to avoid visible fasteners.  So the time savings only come into account if you want to avoid visible fasteners.  If set up properly using a joint like this will save time in sanding (or planing) to match the surfaces in prep.  But, no it won't save time compared to a nail gun.

Posted

I have had my eye on that set for a while now too but havent found enough out there from people actually using them to justify picking them up myself. That said, with Woodpeckers always over priced shipping, their price of $76.40 shipped is by no means a great deal. Thats about the normal price including shipping from several online resellers. So no need for urgency to buy there.

Posted

I don't have a LOT of experience with micro pins but the few times I have used them for banding in walnut, the pins were unnoticeable from 2 feet away. I think that a damp cloth and an iron for a few seconds would swell the fibers enough to close the hole completely. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Brendon_t said:

I don't have a LOT of experience with micro pins but the few times I have used them for banding in walnut, the pins were unnoticeable from 2 feet away. I think that a damp cloth and an iron for a few seconds would swell the fibers enough to close the hole completely. 

I actually build some pieces I call 3 foot pieces because they look great from 3 feet.  In general anything that is going in a house I avoid mechnical fasteners on any visible face, and entirely if it is feasible.  If someone wants to use them thats their choice but it isn't how I was taught.  That said in the shop I will use a framing nail if called for.  It is like pocket holes, some have no issues using them and some won't use them where they will be concealed even in a cabinet carcass on principle.  That said these are primarily used for sheet goods so more likely to be found on items people do not consider fine furniture when building them.

Posted

I use the T&G banding set from MLCS, personally. Tons of glue surfaces, plus the tongue gives some extra strength. Paid $50 for the set.

Something I've been meaning to do to reduce setup time is grab some HDPE and make a pair of setup blocks. This would virtually eliminate setup time for each instance. I actually want to grab a good bit of it and make setup blocks for a few items in 3/4" (or near enough) thickness.

It's a personal decision, but I'd rather take the time and set something like that up than just use the butt joint and pins.

Posted
34 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

How would a fixed setup work with the inherent variability in the actual thickness of different ply?

It's not really going to matter if you take that into consideration beforehand. The point or tongue being a mm off center isn't going to matter to the strength of the joint, just the appearance if the sides aren't covered. I prep my banding stock to a true 3/4" or a pinch over and just flush cut the offending side down - the other should already be flush.

If being precise in the center was an issue, if you had a dial on your lift or whatever, it wouldn't be too far outside the scope of the procedure to knock both bits down a 1/4 turn or so, as long as you were consistent doing it on both bits. I think either way you're following up with flushing the wood down to the ply in some manner. I see it as a cost of doing business with these bits, but YMMV.

Posted
4 hours ago, Cochese said:

I think either way you're following up with flushing the wood down to the ply in some manner. I see it as a cost of doing business with these bits, but YMMV.

In a case like this you obviously always want the banding to be proud since the opposite requires leveling the entire flat surface and probably burn through the veeneer in the process.  

 

There are a million ways to "skin a cat" but the more banding you have to do the more this approach makes sense.

Posted
11 minutes ago, HuxleyWood said:

In a case like this you obviously always want the banding to be proud since the opposite requires leveling the entire flat surface and probably burn through the veeneer in the process.  

 

There are a million ways to "skin a cat" but the more banding you have to do the more this approach makes sense.

You must do this for work. Are you a cabinet maker?

Posted
1 hour ago, mat60 said:

You must do this for work. Are you a cabinet maker?

Nope, just a hobbyist.  From my vantage point I tend to only use banding when I am building shelves and that usually means I am doing a pretty decent amount as a bookcase for example has a lot of banding.  I would rather spend time setting up the router table (or better yet shaper) than to spend more time in the glue up phase since I prefer not to use fasteners.  I see it like a lock miter bit, more time now for less time later and you get a stronger joint in the end.  

Posted

I used just butt joints on the solid banding I used on my vanity, I'll let you all know if it falls off.  I'm doing a lot of testing of things like that on this house, figure my own stuff is the best to test on. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 63 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined