Popular Post Mark J Posted February 12, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted February 12, 2017 Well here's a crazy thing. My wife and I up and bought an electric car. It's actually working out, but there's a learning curve. We decided to pass my wife's 11 year old Scion on to one of our son while it still had life in it. With the transfer looming near I said "You know Honey you need to give me some ideas of what kind of car you'd like". Maybe a dangerous thing to ask, but after 30 years of marriage I think she's earned more than a little say so. Two days later she catches me and announces: "I want an electric car." Now I was real quiet for a real long time, and then, after a while, I heard myself say: "wwwwelllll ohhh kay" in a real slow kind of stupefied drawl. To which she says, "yeah I want the new technology" and walks away. Now ordinarily I would do a lot of research on just a regular car purchase. I am not saying I research a thing to death -- that wouldn't be a fair statement. But I do like to research a thing until it stops moving, and is very still, motionless, for a very long time, really not moving, and then sometimes I poke it with some more research just to make sure. But we were now under some time pressure. We started looking at what was available in the used market in Illinois which is pretty much dominated by the Nissan Leaf. In and among the used Leaf's we stumble upon this other electric, the BMW i3. We schedule a test drive. OK, the wife is liking the car and its kooky looks and quite frankly she's always wanted a "fancy" car (i.e BMW Mercedes). I believe that cars are appliances and would not generally be disposed to paying BMW like prices. But hey I can hit a triple here, new car, electric and she finally gets a BMW. And the car has this feature we both really like, too. It has a range extender which is basically an electric generator driven by a 600 cc gas engine. It kicks in when the battery is at 6% and makes enough juice to keep you going. According to the EPA it gets you another 60 miles, or so, and the EPA rates the battery for 80 miles and the EPA is reliable, never exaggerating, real world testing. So that's 140 miles, what can go wrong here! We check out another ride. A week goes by, but hey the first car is the one. I've been trying to do some research in my spare time about the car and electrics in general and recharging in particular. The car is supplied with a charging cord that plugs into 120V and the salesman has assured me that will charge the car overnight; and you can always take the dealer's claims to the bank, right. So what's to worry! Now it's mid December in Chicago, real cold snap, a toasty 5 degrees F at high noon. But we're out of time to buy the car. We show up back at the dealership, the car is still on the lot. Yadda yadda we do the deal and buy the car. But they apologize, the battery is flat. No problem we've got the range extender so we drive home a couple of happy campers. Get into the garage and plug it in to 120V. The car bleeps and chirps the dash display lights up and proudly announces that the car will be fully charged in 20 hours! My wife and I are looking at each other: Have we just bought an every other day car?! We come out to the car the next day and it is fully charged, but that 80 mile range is more like 59. By the end of the driveway it's 57 miles--and no we don't live in a "mansion" with "grounds". Even the range extender estimate shows 40 miles not 60. More shock. Now I kinda saw this coming. I mean I figured the EPA figures would be optimistic, and that cold weather would degrade performance, but I wasn't prepared for the magnitude of the effect. And I knew that charging times would be longer on 120V than 240V, but the "overnight" idea had sounded plausable. I knew I wanted 240V charging, but truth is I hadn't had the opportunity to investigate if it would be possible to do in our garage. Scrabbled around a bit for the first couple of weeks being careful not to take the car out for long trips or too far, allow plenty of time for charging, etc. Meanwhile found an electrician to look at the job, researched the charging appliances (called an EVSE) and bought one. Had the EVSE and 240V installed right after Christmas and now that 20 hours has become 4 or 5. Much better (sigh of relief, followed by second sigh of relief). Actually had a 60 degree day in January and, fully charged, the dash did give a battery range of 80 miles. The other thing we discovered we were doing wrong was taking the car out without pre-conditioning. The battery performs best when it is warm so there is actually a heater for the battery. Pre-conditioning takes about 15 minutes. You send a command from your cell phone to the car while plugged in and it warms the battery up to operating temperature. You can drive without pre-conditioning, but the car then has to warm the battery with current from the battery while you drive, which is why we were loosing range faster than we were covering distance. Electric car driving does need a different mind set. You are accustomed to having a 300 mile range with a full tank of gas, and at first we were like: Oh my God we only have 50 miles! It took a while to really come to understand that the grocery store is 3 miles away, and that 50 miles was way more than plenty, particular since you won't go out again for a couple of hours and the car will be recharged (with 240V) by then. Actually now that we've gotten past the initial "electric shock" and had a chance to figure the car out more we're are pretty happy with it. I don't think driving this car from Chicago to California would be wise, but for around town, even a big town like Chicago it is eminently practical. My wife enjoys driving the new technology and not going to the gas station. And of course she's grooving on the fact that she has a BMW. But of course now she tells me she wants this Mercedes :-) The New All Electric Mercedes AA Class Sedan – Your next car?http://sundown.me.uk/ technology/mercedes-aa-class. mp4 Sorry previous link was broken. Fixed. 3 Quote
Tpt life Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 Here is something I would appreciate, please check in after a year with the increase to your electric bill. Like you, I don't trust the estimates but am always looking for real world data. 2 Quote
gee-dub Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 Too late but, the worst time to buy a house or a car is when you "need to" or are in "a hurry". ;-) At least if the electric bill takes a jump, you can blame the car . . . but she gets to blame the shop 1 Quote
Mark J Posted February 12, 2017 Author Report Posted February 12, 2017 16 minutes ago, gee-dub said: Too late but, the worst time to buy a house or a car is when you "need to" or are in "a hurry". ;-) Yup. 20 minutes ago, C Shaffer said: Here is something I would appreciate, please check in after a year with the increase to your electric bill. Like you, I don't trust the estimates but am always looking for real world data. OK, but it will be hard to know what electricity goes to what as the garage is on the same meter as he house and I've added electric heat to the shop. When I put the electric heater in the shop I calculated the draw and looking at the electric rates I figured it was about a dollar an hour. I can tell you this electric car draws 26 amps at 240 volts when charging and that typically you are not charging the battery from a flat condition, but rather topping up. Also I can tell you that the last 10% of battery charge takes longer than the first 10%. I can't explain the physics/chemistry, but that's a consistent observation. So let's say you drive 10 or 20 miles on atypical day you probably charge 2 or 3 hours. So one can do the math and make some estimates. By the way we have not gone to any special electric rate arrangement with the power company at this point in time, just so much per KWH regardless of when. It is possible to program the charging to take place at off hours, but we just aren't ready to tackle any more of the learning curve right now. 1 Quote
mat60 Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 Are you ok with the car now and will you go electric again? Quote
Mark J Posted February 12, 2017 Author Report Posted February 12, 2017 20 minutes ago, mat60 said: Are you ok with the car now and will you go electric again? I would have no problem with an electric car as a second car for around town. You have to get your head into a different mind set. For example you have 300 miles of capacity with a full gas tank as opposed to say 65 with a full battery, but you don't top up your gas tank every time you drive the car. You do top up your battery when ever you park at home or find a charging station at your destination. Might as well. We've gone from panic struck about the range to being able to take it in stride the two times she forgot to recharge overnight. "Oh well, there's enough charge for where you are going and you have the range extender". By the way we've tapped the range extender twice in two months. Though not for the two above occasions. I really like the idea of the range extender. So different mind set, and you have to have 240 V (30 to 50 amp) charging capability. So it would be difficult to own a car like this while living in an apartment. Also I don't use this car for my long work commute. This is the errand machine, though we do tend to use it whenever we "go out" for the evening. By the way, I'm wondering if folks are missing the link at the end of the OP? I know it was a long post, sort of the nature of a saga, though. 1 Quote
Tpt life Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 1 hour ago, Mark J said: By the way, I'm wondering if folks are missing the link at the end of the OP? I know it was a long post, sort of the nature of a saga, though. It's broken. Did you click on it and see it got broken? How long for battery swap? Quote
Mark J Posted February 12, 2017 Author Report Posted February 12, 2017 3 minutes ago, C Shaffer said: It's broken. Did you click on it and see it got broken? OOPS! You can cut and paste the previous link into your web browser or the link below should work. The New All Electric Mercedes AA Class Sedan – Your next car?http://sundown.me.uk/ technology/mercedes-aa-class. mp4 1 Quote
NHSchreiner Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 According to the very truthful internet, the Netherlands will be gas, diesel and internal combustion engine free by 2020. All the major cities already have plug in stations at parking meters. I like that Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
wtnhighlander Posted February 12, 2017 Report Posted February 12, 2017 You said the Beemer was previously owned? Do you know how old the battery pack is? I like the idea of a near silent vehicle, with lots of low-end torque, but the limited range and cost of replacing batteries keeps pure electric out of consideration. Quote
Mark J Posted February 12, 2017 Author Report Posted February 12, 2017 It is a 2014 with about 19,000 miles at time of purchase. I don't expect to replace the battery, although the Fates may have a different plan. By the way my other car is a 2006 Highlander Hybrid. 10+ years old and 160,000 miles. So far no problem. Unless it suddenly craps out I have no plans to part with it for the time being. 1 Quote
BonPacific Posted February 13, 2017 Report Posted February 13, 2017 On 2/12/2017 at 8:20 AM, C Shaffer said: Here is something I would appreciate, please check in after a year with the increase to your electric bill. Like you, I don't trust the estimates but am always looking for real world data. Anecdotal, but I asked my father the same thing recently. He bought a used Leaf two years ago, and it's currently his only car (other vehicle is an F350 w/ dump bed that gets about 5mpg). He said he hadn't noticed a real change to his electric bill, if there was an increase, it was offset by the Mini-Split Heat Pump he switched to the same year. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.