Popular Post bleedinblue Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Is it dumb that every time I open one of these threads on the topic I hope to see a post from Shane? Even if I've only been away from the post for a few minutes? I kinda feel like a kid checking every thirty seconds to see if his lost puppy has come home, lol. 5
Popular Post Eric. Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Well I guess I'll add my thoughts on the matter so we can all make kisses and put this thing to rest. Marc and I have had friendly correspondence about this situation, and we've both agreed that I'm probably not best suited as a moderator...for the specific and obvious reason that a moderator's primary role is to be and to keep things moderate. I'm just not a moderate guy, plain and simple - basically in any aspect of my life - but especially when it concerns things I'm passionate about, and woodworking pretty much tops that list. My dad taught me - if you do something, you do it all the way. And living by that philosophy can tend to manifest itself as intemperance. Also it probably doesn't help that I keep A Cabinetmaker's Notebook on my nightstand as if it were a Gideon's Bible...Krenov has this way of convincing you that there's much more "right and wrong" in woodworking than most people believe. And whether or not it's true, I've swallowed that conviction hook, line and sinker. Consequently, I've developed a fairly rigid ideology about certain aspects of the craft. That's not necessarily a bad thing...but when it starts to conflict with certain responsibilities bestowed upon me - i.e. "being moderate" - it's only logical that a change be made. I'm only intense about this stuff because I love it, and I think the incidents that I've truly crossed the line have been few and far between, and it's a very small minority of people who found it so offensive it was worth "leaving" over - and I do echo Brian's sentiment that most issues can be resolved if it's dealt with in earnest, man-to-man, instead of taking the coward's way and whining about it behind someone's back...but regardless, I'm adult enough to take ownership of my actions, and I admittedly have not been an angel around here all the time. I will add one slight wrinkle with the hope that I don't seem defensive or as if I'm making excuses...but I do think when you have a position of any kind of authority (however insignificant it may be), people do have a tendency to set their sites on you and are more likely to take you on for no other reason than simply to challenge that authority, regardless of the validity of their position. When you add to that recipe a guy like me who isn't sheepish about speaking his mind...arguments can and will ensue...and escalate. As far as the move from moderator back to mentor, it honestly makes zero difference to me what badge is under my name or if there's a badge at all. Truly. If you ask any of the other moderators I'm sure they'll tell you that on an average week, there was approximately zero minutes of "work" to be done. The badge is there so people know there are police in the area and that's usually enough...for the most part the extent of your duties as a mod is to be a living organism who logs onto the forum on a regular basis. Anyway, I don't fault Marc one bit for making the change - he's been completely up front and fair with me on the matter, and he actually came to me and asked me how I felt about it before he did it...something he was totally not obligated to do. We're still woodworking homies and he has my full respect. Ultimately, he's running a business here, and he did what he felt was best for the forum as a whole...and if I were in his shoes, I would have done the same thing. In fact, I'm quite certain I would have been far less patient with ALL parties involved in this childish affair. While it has been an admittedly strange week for me emotionally - no one likes to be put on trial - I have to say that some good did come out of it. I want to thank all (most) of you for the pretty overwhelming show of support...I appreciate every one of you who came to my defense. It's situations like this one when you find out who your friends are. To fold a little woodworking analogy into this thing, I remember something Marc said a long time ago about designing your own pieces...that you're putting yourself out there for criticism, and that some people will love them and some people will hate them...but if you're not evoking some kind of response, you're probably just wasting your time. Or something like that. And I take some solace in applying that theory to my own life and personality. Like Matt Damon said in Good Will Hunting..."At least I won't be unoriginal." And...in the spirit of wrapping this up in true Eric fashion, I will leave you with this quote from Elaine Benes... "Here's to those who wish us well, and those who don't can go to hell." (That's a joke, for those of you who still don't get me.) Now let's party. Oh...and I'm out of "likes" for today, otherwise I'd be dishing out a whole lot more of them in this thread. Thanks again, guys. 16
Popular Post Chet Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 49 minutes ago, bgreenb said: Another thing I can't help but notice is the other mods' absence from this whole saga. I guess I am the Mod to blame. I am the newest Mod and at the time I saw a particular post in the Shaneymack thread I new Kev (Mod) was on the road with work, and the post involved Eric, the only other Mod I knew, so I contacted Marc. But I didn't contact him until the next morning after I thought long and hard about it. The email I sent to him was just trying to find out if there was any concern there or just wait to see how it played out. As it turns out letting it play out was the thing I wish I had done. Call it a Noob mistake. I, at the time, didn't feel that I was running to the principals office I was looking for advice. But my hope was to get Shane back on the forum not create what has taken place the last couple of days. I did PM Eric and let him know my thinking, and I have been in contact with Shane trying to poke him back in this direction. I was trying to do something in the back ground and unfortunately it didn't exactly work out the way I had hoped. I am the guy you should shoot, my apologies to all on the forum and I hope we can resume our more productive discussions. Edit: I have posted this in two places today. 4
bleedinblue Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 11 minutes ago, Eric. said: ...but I do think when you have a position of any kind of authority (however insignificant it may be), people do have a tendency to set their sites on you and are more likely to take you on for no other reason than simply to challenge that authority, regardless of the validity or of their position. No joke. 1
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 Chet, much respect and I can appreciate your point of view and actions even if I disagree. It's clear you did what you thought was best and not at all out of personal animus. I personally have said (more than) my piece here and will let it lie. @thewoodwhisperer thank you for being patient and letting us have this discussion without locking immediately, as would've been your prerogative and I would've been tempted in your shoes
Eric. Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 55 minutes ago, RichardA said: I f-ing hate the fact that my search to locate Shaney, was the straw that put Eric and Marc in this position and broke the camel's back. My apologies to you Eric I didn't know there were so many "snowflakes" looking for their teddy bears and pacifiers on this site. I appreciate your input and always have. Your expertise has helped me several times, thank you. 7 minutes ago, Chet K said: I guess I am the Mod to blame. I am the newest Mod and at the time I saw a particular post in the Shaneymack thread I new Kev (Mod) was on the road with work, and the post involved Eric, the only other Mod I knew, so I contacted Marc. But I didn't contact him until the next morning after I thought long and hard about it. The email I sent to him was just trying to find out if there was any concern there or just wait to see how it played out. As it turns out letting it play out was the thing I wish I had done. Call it a Noob mistake. I, at the time, didn't feel that I was running to the principals office I was looking for advice. But my hope was to get Shane back on the forum not create what has taken place the last couple of days. I did PM Eric and let him know my thinking, and I have been in contact with Shane trying to poke him back in this direction. I was trying to do something in the back ground and unfortunately it didn't exactly work out the way I had hoped. I am the guy you should shoot, my apologies to all on the forum and I hope we can resume our more productive discussions. Edit: I have posted this in two places today. No worries, either of you guys. Seriously. We're all good.
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 2 minutes ago, bleedinblue said: No joke. I really don't think he was referring to you...but maybe I'm wrong. For the record, no I wasn't Ok NOW I will let it lie
Popular Post Al Capwn Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Now that we have all hugged this out, can @Eric. go back to happily taking pictures for the project journal he most certainly promised us all of the bed he was working on this morning? Tick tock, Mr. Eric. Tick. Tock. 3
Popular Post woodwhisperer Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Locked, only because I don't think anything more needs to be said at this point. Let's get back to woodworking now that we've acted out the woodworker's live action version of Days of Our Lives. 10
Recommended Posts