Popular Post bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 I noticed (in this thread: ) that E's tag had been changed from "moderator" to "mentor" and jokingly asked if he got a demotion. Apparently it wasn't a joke, and indeed E has been "demoted" to mentor. @thewoodwhisperer would you mind commenting on this? As stated plenty of times, it's your forum and you have to do what you feel is best for it. Feel free to tell me it's none of my business, but I feel a change like this deserves explanation. I'm not dense, and I'm assuming it's due to the recent "troubles" - but I'm having trouble wrapping my head around why Eric would lose the moderator badge after he apologized to Shane, took (more than one) mea culpa's in that thread, and promised to soften his edges going forward. Again, feel free to tell me to buzz off, but I think it deserves explanation. 7
Popular Post woodwhisperer Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Well first off, being a Mentor is not a demotion. It simply means that I feel Eric's contributions to the forum are better suited as a Mentor, and not a moderator. I have received many emails and messages about this issue in the last 24 hrs and felt I had to make a change. Eric is well-liked and many enjoy his abrasive approach. I do not feel inclined to force Eric to change his ways, but the job of a moderator in this forum is to be a peace-keeper and a "door greeter" of sorts. And that especially applies when someone comes into the forum asking "dumb noob" questions. It takes a certain amount of patience and tact and not all personalities are right for the job. Eric even asked me when I made him a mod if I was sure, based on his somewhat abrasive nature. As a Mentor, Eric is still able to contribute to the forum as he always has and his advice is still valued. But now he's free to be a little gruff with his straight shooter approach and it doesn't have to conflict with his role as a moderator. And I'm pretty sure Eric agrees with the change and will hopefully feel a little less pressure as a result. 8
Popular Post bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Marc - I appreciate your candor, truly. You certainly don't *owe* anybody an explanation, but you are a straight shooter and I appreciate that. I just feel I can't let this die without speaking to this: 14 minutes ago, thewoodwhisperer said: . I have received many emails and messages about this issue in the last 24 hrs Given that your initial comments over on the facebook thread (sorry to cross reference) said (paraphrase) that you were reluctant to go against a moderator unless it was absolutely clear a change had to be made (again paraphrase), I have to assume the brunt of those emails and messages were negative. Again, I feel I cannot let this die without indicating how much this rubs me the wrong way. Nobody likes a guy on a soapbox, but I just can't stand how so many people's instinct when they have a personal issue with someone is to immediately "tell the teacher" and demand their pound of flesh. An apology and mea culpa isn't enough. To me, it speaks volumes about the type of person you are. A friend of mine recently had some trouble where he planted some trees on his property, and his neighbor filed a lawsuit claiming they blocked his view. My friend's lawyer said the suit was frivolous but that it would probably cost him more to litigate it than to just cut the trees down. My friend said to me "the thing that really galls me about the whole situation is that if he had just come to me we could've worked something out. The trees were sitting out front for days before I planted them. But instead he goes straight to his lawyer instead of coming to me man to man." Can't help but think of that story today. In the grand scheme, changing a guy's label on a woodworking forum is the Platonic ideal of "first world problems" that really have no substantive bearing on anyone anywhere. But I don't like the signal it sends and feel I had to say so. And Marc, of course as always I say this with all due respect, and I feel bad for any part I've played in this ongoing kindergarten drama that's no doubt caused you heartburn. IMPORTANT EDIT: 2nd paragraph - when I say "type of person *you* are" - I mean the abstract "you" - not addressing @thewoodwhisperer there! The sentence should really say "the type of person one is". 3
Popular Post prov163 Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 While I appreciate Marc's response and I understand his approach, it would be wonderful if we'd all just be less easily offended It's one of the problems in America today - not a political statement, just a fact. I have learned to ignore Eric's occasional abrasiveness and find the great advice and wisdom lurking underneath. I agree with Marc that we should let Eric be Eric. I've gotten my hackles up a few times on the forum; so have others. It happens. A free exchange of ideas will always come with varying personalities. 4
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, prov163 said: While I appreciate Marc's response and I understand his approach, it would be wonderful if we'd all just be less easily offended It's one of the problems in America today - not a political statement, just a fact. I have learned to ignore Eric's occasional abrasiveness and find the great advice and wisdom lurking underneath. I agree with Marc that we should let Eric be Eric. I've gotten my hackles up a few times on the forum; so have others. It happens. A free exchange of ideas will always come with varying personalities. Exactly my point, said more succinctly. I just can't stand the "run to the principal's office" approach to problem solving. 1
Popular Post woodwhisperer Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 The comments that came in recently were not from people "running to the principal." They were from people on both sides of the issue and all of them were the result of my own post asking for opinions on Facebook. Most expressed hesitation about getting involved at all but felt they should offer their opinion and feedback, since I asked. I used this feedback, comments on the Shaneymack thread, and my discussion with Eric to arrive at this decision. Now I'm no fan of an overly sensitive PC world either. But As someone who is responsible for several online communities, I can tell you from experience that things always trend downward. So if you start with a "hey suck it up buttercup" tone, it's a short trip to an angry unfriendly environment. The reason this forum exists in its current form is because the mods are here to help me continually course adjust. So there's room for the occasional curmudgeon or grump. And straight shooters are always welcome. But if you aren't the type of person to approach things with a more PC mindset, you're not a good candidate for the moderator job. It's unfortunate if this is bothersome to some folks, but my desire for a more friendly environment and the tactics I use to maintain it are probably a large part of the reason you like this place, whether you realize it or not. 5
Popular Post Immortan D Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 AFAIK Eric never abused his position as mod or used it for personal benefit. That is what I call integrity. The problem is that new members usually make the wrong assumption that, if they argue with a mod, they will get banned or deleted (because so many bad mods do things like that in other public forums). That makes people angry and not willing to participate. So I guess that Marc's decision is good for the forum and for Eric too, like Marc said. My two cents. 4
Popular Post Vyrolan Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Let's not forget Eric has been a moderator for a while... As many who have done it here and elsewhere know, it can be a burden. While I've never personally noticed Eric seemingly stressed by that burden, it's still probably a bit of a relief not to have to deal with that aspect any longer. Like Marc I remember Eric's reluctance in the beginning. I'd rather have a less-stressed Mentor Eric than a burnt out leaving-the-forum Moderator Eric. 40 minutes ago, bgreenb said: A friend of mine recently had some trouble where he planted some trees on his property, and his neighbor filed a lawsuit claiming they blocked his view. My friend's lawyer said the suit was frivolous but that it would probably cost him more to litigate it than to just cut the trees down. My friend said to me "the thing that really galls me about the whole situation is that if he had just come to me we could've worked something out. The trees were sitting out front for days before I planted them. But instead he goes straight to his lawyer instead of coming to me man to man." In that situation, I would have spent ungodly sums fighting it and then countered back at him for all the costs...that's scum of the Earth material right there man...absolute scum. 4
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, Vyrolan said: In that situation, I would have spent ungodly sums fighting it and then countered back at him for all the costs...that's scum of the Earth material right there man...absolute scum. Couldn't agree more. My buddy has a different disposition than you or I, probably to his benefit cardiac health wise 1
Popular Post Al Capwn Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 For what it is worth, I have never viewed the Mentor tag as a demotion from Moderator. hhh was a Mentor, and his posts were awesome. To me they are two different functions: A moderator is an organizer and administrator of content. A mentor is an individual you look up to because of their experience. Just because you are a moderator, doesn't mean I admire your work. Just because you are a mentor, doesn't mean I expect you to be a fair and impartial arbiter of content. I've always respected (and viewed) Eric more as a "mentor" more than a "moderator" and aspire to be able to produce works like he does. I still admire the tool cabinet journal to this day. 8
BonPacific Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 5 minutes ago, bgreenb said: Couldn't agree more. My buddy has a different disposition than you or I, probably to his benefit cardiac health wise I've personally experienced neighbor disputes like this. They just get worse and worse, spiraling downward. Enforcing a restraining order is one of the better outcomes.
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, BonPacific said: I've personally experienced neighbor disputes like this. They just get worse and worse, spiraling downward. Enforcing a restraining order is one of the better outcomes. Totally. And to be clear, I get along with my neighbors - we've had some very minor disagreements and always solved it over a beer or two. I think anyone would find that if you come to me with an issue about something I've done, I'm pretty reasonable in trying to work out a solution (and vice versa, if I have a problem with you, I'll come to you directly to try to address it). But if I get a letter from a lawyer before you've tried to come to me man to man...the earth will be scorched, the ground salted, and nothing shall grow there from now til eternity!
Tom Cancelleri Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, bgreenb said: But if I get a letter from a lawyer before you've tried to come to me man to man...the earth will be scorched, the ground salted, and nothing shall grow there from now til eternity! BY FIRE BE PURGED!
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, Tom Cancelleri said: BY FIRE BE PURGED! I recall an instant classic from a forum member who shall remain nameless but whose name rhymes with bomb dancer mary when a certain neighborhood association complained about rust on a copper chimney cap...apparently this neighborhood exists in a universe where rust can form on non ferrous metals. 1
Tom Cancelleri Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 Just now, bgreenb said: I recall an instant classic from a forum member who shall remain nameless but whose name rhymes with bomb dancer mary when a certain neighborhood association complained about rust on a copper chimney cap...apparently this neighborhood exists in a universe where rust can form on non ferrous metals. Bomb Dancer Mary is a total smartass. I hear he was out of town last week and it's been nothing but raining where he lives in Rusty Copper Virginia. He better mow that lawn soon before they come by with the broken ruler to measure his grass. 1
Popular Post bleedinblue Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Bottom line, if Eric has no protest, neither should we. I think our opinions on his presence, contribution and gruff have been thoroughly expressed. 4
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, bleedinblue said: Bottom line, if Eric has no protest, neither should we. I think our opinions on his presence, contribution and gruff have been thoroughly expressed. Ehhhhhhh. What's he gonna say? I don't care how self aware someone is about their personality or how much you split hairs about the definition of "demotion" - it sucks to be aired out like he has this week and know that people have been complaining about you behind your back instead of out in the open. I won't put words in E's mouth. He's a big boy. Bet my PM1500 against his grizzly that he's not psyched even if he's too classy to comment here I cannot help thinking that this was a situation where a few people with personal issues against Eric smelled blood in the water (so to speak) with the arrival of the shaneymack thread, so they piled on. No way for me to know what's in anyone's heart or mind, but that's how it looks from my end. 2
Popular Post RichardA Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 I f-ing hate the fact that my search to locate Shaney, was the straw that put Eric and Marc in this position and broke the camel's back. My apologies to you Eric I didn't know there were so many "snowflakes" looking for their teddy bears and pacifiers on this site. I appreciate your input and always have. Your expertise has helped me several times, thank you. 7
bgreenb Posted April 28, 2017 Author Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 minute ago, RichardA said: I f-ing hate the fact that my search to locate Shaney, was the straw that put Eric and Marc in this position Disagree. You're not the one who aired him out on that thread. Another thing I can't help but notice is the other mods' absence from this whole saga.
Popular Post Tom Cancelleri Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 I know I don't like being called out in a public forum, and want to publicly thank Eric for his contributions on the forums. He's helped me out in a number of projects and with some things I've worked through. I've run and managed forums that averaged 6,000 posts per day. Moderating can be a boring and tedious job best suited for people who have nothing better to do with their time. I'm sure Eric would just as easily enjoy his time building in his shop instead of baby sitting threads with playground like shenanigans. 3
Popular Post prov163 Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Eric is a big boy and Marc is a professional. I'm sure they worked this out in a way that was satisfactory for everyone. Marc, I honestly wasn't suggesting a "suck it up buttercup" approach. Just that some of the things I've seen people get their underwear in a twist over was so minor that it wasn't a moderator that was needed - it was a Xanax prescription. The forums must be, and to the largest extent are, friendly and fun. I started out making pallet wood projects and if I had let the comments about "real woodworkers don't use pallet wood" comments get to me I would have left. Instead, I used pallet wood to get me to a place where I felt comfortable using "real wood." I've still got a long way to go, but I credit my improvement, in part, to the encouragement I received here. So, sometimes it's how a comment is made, but much of the time it's how it's received. Thanks for keeping this a place that allows people to grow in the craft! 3
prov163 Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 Eric, I know you are reading this thread though you haven't commented. I wholeheartedly appreciate your help and respect your talents - and even enjoy the good-natured ribbing we all pass on to one another. I hope you won't let this incident quench your spirit or keep you away. It would be even worse to lose another great poster. 1
Minnesota Steve Posted April 28, 2017 Report Posted April 28, 2017 1 hour ago, prov163 said: While I appreciate Marc's response and I understand his approach, it would be wonderful if we'd all just be less easily offended It's one of the problems in America today - not a political statement, just a fact. My grandmother said "If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all"... Perhaps the biggest problem in America today is not being easily offended, but rather people feeling the need to be easily offensive? Not a political statement, just an observation. I don't know what any of you are talking about here as I just casually read the forum. :-) 1
Popular Post Tpt life Posted April 28, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 28, 2017 Mike nailed it. This forum seemed to swap moderator with mentor. I said as much to Llama earlier. Eric and Beech were the only two to use PM when deleting content. I miss Shane but also don't believe this is the place to be bragadocious with no call out. This was the forum I cut my teeth on and have made many mistakes that I needed to learn from. Stick and disagree. We all benefit from the friction polish. 3
Recommended Posts