Grant Goodrich Posted June 11, 2017 Report Posted June 11, 2017 I have another choice to make. Thanks to all of you who helped me figure out that my choice between two jointer was actually a choice between a jointer and a routing table... I now have to decide which of these scroll saws to take (inheritance) without any understanding of what makes a good scroll saw (I'm very new to woodworking). Both are 16". One is a Delta and one a Craftsman. Both are in good working condition but old. Thanks! Grant Quote
wtnhighlander Posted June 11, 2017 Report Posted June 11, 2017 I would choose whichever has the larger table, and/ or is heaviest. Quote
Marmotjr Posted June 12, 2017 Report Posted June 12, 2017 5 hours ago, wtnhighlander said: I would choose whichever has the larger table, and/ or is heaviest. While that is a good recommendation, also look at the blade attachment type, and how easy it is to swap blades. 2 Quote
Gixxerjoe04 Posted June 12, 2017 Report Posted June 12, 2017 I'd probably go with the Delta if it were me. Quote
SawDustB Posted June 12, 2017 Report Posted June 12, 2017 I have that Craftsman scroll saw. It's OK, I guess, but not great. My main complaints are that the dust blower doesn't do anything (not sure mine even works) and the blade mechanism under the table is kind of fiddly. I tend to break a lot of blades with it, but to be fair I tend to give it a lot of jobs that really should belong to a bandsaw (if I had one). I'd be inclined to push you towards the Delta - I think they're a little better quality. Quote
CharleyL Posted June 18, 2017 Report Posted June 18, 2017 I teach and demonstrate scroll sawing at woodworking shows. and have been scroll sawing for over 40 years. If you are serious about scroll sawing you need to get a saw that mechanically pulls the blade up as well as down. The old scroll saws that used a spring to pull the blade up are total junk when compared to a modern saws. You also want a saw that uses "pin less" blades, because they can be fed through much smaller starter holes for doing inside cuts. The "pin less" blades are much more readily available to buy and come in much smaller sizes for doing more intricate work too. With a saw that mechanically pulls the blade up as well as down, you won't break blades very often, even the very small 3/0 sizes anywhere near as often as the spring return saws will break even the large pinned style blades. Unfortunately, one of these better saws will cost $450 and up new, however many people who buy scroll saws, even good scroll saws, don't stay with the hobby and eventually put their saws up for sale at half or less of the original price. A DeWalt 788 in nearly new mechanical condition can frequently be found on Craigslist for $2-350. If you buy one this way and decide that scroll sawing isn't for you, you can put the saw back on Craigslist and get all, or nearly all, of your money back. Cheap scroll saws like those in the photos posted in the early part of this thread are frustrating to use and don't work well. The owners quickly loose interest in scroll sawing because of this and they put the saws up for sale, and they are frequently unable to sell them at even 1/3 of what they paid for them. I have several scroll saws of different styles and sizes, to give my students a feel for the differences between them, but I mostly use the DeWalt 788. When they buy their own saw, none have purchased a cheaper saw than the DeWalt 788 or one of the similar designed saws that use the short moving arms to move the blade both up and down. I strongly recommend that you buy a clean used saw that uses the same blade arm style as the Dewalt. Saws like this are made by Delta, Excalibur, Jet, and Seyco, although the Jet and Seyco saws are new on the market in the past year, so you won't likely find a used one yet. I have a 20 year old Delta Q3 saw that uses a C frame design where the blade is attached between the ends of this C. It is also a good scroll saw that was being sold just prior to the DeWalt 788 introduction. The rocking action on the Q3 blade movement causes the blade angle to vary front to back as it operates, which gives it a great aggressive and fast cutting action, but this rocking action is not very suitable for very tiny work. Some of my own projects are less than 1" tall and I prefer using the DeWalt style saws for cutting these. The DeWalt 788 cuts a bit slower, but the blade moves straight up and down, so it's better for the smaller work that I do. Both do well when cutting larger work. Charley 2 Quote
Vyrolan Posted June 19, 2017 Report Posted June 19, 2017 On 6/18/2017 at 9:40 AM, CharleyL said: I teach and demonstrate scroll sawing at woodworking shows. and have been scroll sawing for over 40 years. Great response Charley! Thanks for sharing your experience/perspective with us. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.