ZombieMonkey Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 So I have been getting more into woodworking and would like to start taking on larger projects and to use rough lumber rather than dimensional lumber. Currently have a many of the basics from drills, Bosch plunge router, SawStop PCS, Jet cyclone DC, Bosch sander, and a Lie-Nielson block plane. I'm looking for some assistance of picking out a good planer and a jointer so that I can start taking advantage of rough lumber. I am trying to figure out where to spend the money on these two items as I've gone through numerous threads and the options and opinions seem to be everywhere. For Jointers I've been looking at the Powermatic 60HH and the JEJ-8HH as they seem to offer good value for the quality. For planers I've considered the DeWalt 735 with an upgrade to the Shelix or gone as high up in price for considering the Jet JWP-15HH or Powermatic 15HH. The planer seems to be the tougher area in regards to whether its worthwhile to put that much money into a planer. If I went the DeWalt route I could justify picking up a Jet drill press with the savings. There just seem to be so many options that it's difficult in determining where to put the money. I've been skimming this place for some time and the amount of info and knowledge on this site has definitely made my head spin a bit. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Quote
Coop Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 If you've lurked here for even a short while, you'll know the planer of choice is the DeWalt 735, hands down. And being able to afford the Jet drill press is just lagnaiappe! Quote
Woodenskye Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 Welcome. If I was in your position, I would probably look for a 15" planer with spiral head. Coop is right, the 735 is a great planer and fan favorite, but if you are going to be swapping the head on purchase, I just wouldn't want to do it. You would be around 1200-1400, I would think for you could get a bigger planer with the spiral for $600-800 more. It seems with what you listed as tools you already follow the "buy once, cry once" model. Quote
Chet Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 Just for fun, I will add a third line of thinking. I have the Dewalt 735 and it does a great job. I don't have the spiral head and probably never will. Buy the Dewalt, skip the drill press for now and get a good drum sander such as the SuperMax 19-38. I use my planer to just get me close to final dimension and then the drum sander to final thickness. I think this gives me a better final surface and gets rid of any snip or tearout that I may have incurred with the planer. The Drill press is a nice tool to have but by far the least used power tool in my shop. I think there has been 3 maybe 4 of my projects that have required a drill press but some of those I really could have found other ways. With the knowledge I have, if I had it to do over, I still may not have a drill press. 1 Quote
Coop Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 2 minutes ago, Chet said: Just for fun, I will add a third line of thinking. I have the Dewalt 735 and it does a great job. I don't have the spiral head and probably never will. Buy the Dewalt, skip the drill press for now and get a good drum sander such as the SuperMax 19-38. I use my planer to just get me close to final dimension and then the drum sander to final thickness. I think this gives me a better final surface and gets rid of any snip or tearout that I may have incurred with the planer. The Drill press is a nice tool to have but by far the least used power tool in my shop. I think there has been 3 maybe 4 of my projects that have required a drill press but some of those I really could have found other ways. With the knowledge I have, if I had it to do over, I still may not have a drill press. I think you nailed it! +1 Quote
minorhero Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 It doesn't make much sense to buy the 735 and replace with a spiral head right away. Most people that swap it out already own the 735 or picking it up used and then swapping it out. For not much more you can buy a brand new stationary planer with a spiral head already in it. For example the grizzly 15 inch spiral head starts at 1800. While the 735 is great for the money I don't think many people are going to argue that it's better than a stationary planer. Regarding the drill press, I use my drill press all the time however almost never for woodworking. I end up using the drill press for other projects instead. I think part of your problem is it doesn't appear as if you have a set budget or if you do you haven't posted it yet. What machines you get is probably going to be dictated by how much you want to spend because frankly there's always going to be a better machine. If you're willing to put in a little work to get a machine setup correctly as well as replace bearings then the used market is always going to provide you with the best bang for your buck. That said a lot of people are not willing to do those things which is fine but it means you will have to spend more. If I were buying new machines right now I can tell you that I would not buy anything that had straight knives in it. The spiral head in both jointer and planer is sufficiently better both in the quality of the cut as well as the ease of setup that I would frankly never want to go back. I've used both and I much prefer the spiral heads. And now for the inevitable caveat, if the difference between owning a jointer or planer was the difference between having a spiral head or not having a spiral head and then I would always choose to own the jointer or planer with straight knives because a straight knife planer or jointer is better than no planer or jointer. Hope that makes sense. Quote
Eric. Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 19 minutes ago, minorhero said: It doesn't make much sense to buy the 735 and replace with a spiral head right away. Most people that swap it out already own the 735 or picking it up used and then swapping it out. For not much more you can buy a brand new stationary planer with a spiral head already in it. For example the grizzly 15 inch spiral head starts at 1800. While the 735 is great for the money I don't think many people are going to argue that it's better than a stationary planer. Agreed. If you're planning to put a shelix in a 735, I'd just buy a 15" planer instead. The 735 is a great lunchbox by all accounts but it's still a lunchbox. I have a really hard time recommending Grizzly for anything anymore, but despite some annoying maintenance issues, my G0453 has remained serviceable - and fairly maintenance-free for the last couple years. I have a shelix in both my jointer and planer, and while I don't think cut quality is vastly better than sharp straight knives (I also think it doesn't matter since neither surface is finish-ready), it IS vastly easier when it comes to maintenance, since you rarely need to touch anything. But make sure you have realistic expectations...you're not gonna get glass smooth surfaces because you have a shelix, nor are you immune to tearout if you don't pay attention to the grain or have some especially gnarly boards. Shelix is great, but the main advantage is not having to swap out knives all the time. It's a big price tag for a fairly minor inconvenience (although I did hate swapping knives more than anything in the world). I'd spend as much money as you can stomach spending on a really good jointer, then save up and buy a floor-standing 15" planer. I think 15" planers are good machines to buy used, since they're fairly easy to work on and get calibrated properly...and once they're set, they tend to stay that way unless they're abused. If you buy two good, large, powerful machines...chances are you'll never have to make another jointer or planer purchase the rest of your life. If you half-ass either one, chances are you will. Quote
Jfitz Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 All good advice above, but also somewhat all over the place - only you can know where the money is best spent for your needs. I'm going to be a contrarian and say that putting a Shelix on a new 735 can make sense - if it makes sense for your budget and woodworking needs. A brand new DW735 is $600 and the Byrd head is $430 (both on Amazon Prime) - so for 1030 (call it 1050) you're into a very good (albeit "lunchbox") shelix head 13" planer. The 15" grizzly with a spiral head is 1895 (call it 1900). That's another $850 you could put to other tools - and I actually don't see the extra 2" capacity worth it. However, if budget is no option (or is at least flexible), and you're looking past a lunchbox to a more dedicated floor standing model, you should at least consider going to a larger unit - say 20". If you can score a used 15" model then of course all things change......just some food for thought. Quote
Eric. Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 26 minutes ago, Jfitz said: All good advice above, but also somewhat all over the place - only you can know where the money is best spent for your needs. I'm going to be a contrarian and say that putting a Shelix on a new 735 can make sense - if it makes sense for your budget and woodworking needs. A brand new DW735 is $600 and the Byrd head is $430 (both on Amazon Prime) - so for 1030 (call it 1050) you're into a very good (albeit "lunchbox") shelix head 13" planer. The 15" grizzly with a spiral head is 1895 (call it 1900). That's another $850 you could put to other tools - and I actually don't see the extra 2" capacity worth it. However, if budget is no option (or is at least flexible), and you're looking past a lunchbox to a more dedicated floor standing model, you should at least consider going to a larger unit - say 20". If you can score a used 15" model then of course all things change......just some food for thought. On the other hand, a 15" Grizzly straight knife is $1200...barely more than a 735 plus Byrd. And since a shelix head is a luxury and not a necessity, I would recommend buying the bigger planer and upgrading the head down the line when you have all other necessity tools purchased. That's what I did...it's an easy afternoon project to swap out the head. Spending money on a shelix before you have almost a complete shop is buying out-of-order. It's like buying a Domino before you know how to do a traditional M&T. You have to earn the right. 2 Quote
ZombieMonkey Posted July 20, 2017 Author Report Posted July 20, 2017 So realistically 5500 is about as much as I want to go at this time. I was really drawn to the helical heads due to the much longer life of the cutters vs the straight knives. I know some mentioned the grizzly equipment and while I know it works for many, I'd just rather avoid it as I've had friends with mixed experiences in some of their other equipment lines. I've learned through years of working on cars, bikes and homes that when it comes to tools you often get what you pay for. I'm soon to be 31 so this equipment will be around and in service for many years and I hate buying multiple times. The powermatic and jet machines seemed like the best value for quality and price, but I also know many of you have been through this before so I'm really having a hard time selecting machines. These items will be on moveable bases as I do work out of a garage which my truck gets parked in when not in use. So size on the bigger end can be a limiting factor. Quote
Eric. Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 If you have $5500 to spend on a jointer and planer, you're in business. Wait until black Friday and you can buy a PJ882HH and PM15HH on budget or under. That's a dream setup and you'll never ever have to upgrade. https://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-1610082-PJ-882HH-Parallelogram-Cutterhead/dp/B001GOALW6/ref=sr_1_4?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1500563100&sr=1-4&keywords=powermatic+jointer+8 https://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-1791213-15HH-230-Volt-Cutterhead/dp/B001GOEPF0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500562966&sr=8-1&keywords=powermatic+planer+15 1 Quote
ZombieMonkey Posted July 20, 2017 Author Report Posted July 20, 2017 3 minutes ago, Eric. said: If you have $5500 to spend on a jointer and planer, you're in business. Wait until black Friday and you can buy a PJ882HH and PM15HH on budget or under. That's a dream setup and you'll never ever have to upgrade. Having had a look at the PJ882HH in person I'm a little unnerved by the sheer size of that beast as really I am looking for a mobile base setup to make the best use of space. How much difference between it and the 60HH would I see in real world use? Am I correct in believing that once setup the 60HH doesn't give much up unless you're changing stuff around a bunch? How much of a sale often comes around black Friday? I was really hoping to have machines by September to start taking advantage of the cooler weather here in Arizona. Also, I've got to say I didn't realize the supermax was so we'll reviewed and not crazy expensive. Is there a catch that I'm missing here? I thought drum sanders were crazy expensive. Quote
Eric. Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 Supermax 19-38 is the best bang/buck drum sander on the market. No-brainer for hobbyist use. The jointers - no you won't be giving up that much in terms of capacity...like 7-8 inches if IIRC. The main difference is dovetail ways vs. parallelogram. The footprint is not that different despite the enormous base on the 882. You can buy a mobile base for either one. Usually PM offers 10-15% off during Black Friday. But they've been a little stingy with the sales recently so I would hope for 15% but expect 10%. Quote
Woodenskye Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 Why not look at the Hammer combo machines. They have mobility kit and you may be able to get the A3-41 which would give you 16" capacity on both machines. They also offer straight knife and hh versions. Quote
Jfitz Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 1 hour ago, Eric. said: On the other hand, a 15" Grizzly straight knife is $1200...barely more than a 735 plus Byrd. And since a shelix head is a luxury and not a necessity, I would recommend buying the bigger planer and upgrading the head down the line when you have all other necessity tools purchased. That's what I did...it's an easy afternoon project to swap out the head. Spending money on a shelix before you have almost a complete shop is buying out-of-order. It's like buying a Domino before you know how to do a traditional M&T. You have to earn the right. Following that rationale, he needs to get a good set of hand planes and learn to mill by hand. You need to earn the right to use an electric planer for the OP...is a helical head a must? I assumed it was from your post......but Eric's point is a good one...you could definitely get by with regular knives and leave the upgrade for later. I'll still say that if I had to pick between the dewalt 13" and the grizzly 15", I might go with the dewalt with shelix, or dewalt with straight knives and redirect the extra money elsewhere. Or upgrade to a 20". If the budget is 5500 for a jointer and planer though.....go big. go really big. and never revisit the decision ever again. 2 Quote
Cygnus A Posted July 20, 2017 Report Posted July 20, 2017 55 minutes ago, ZombieMonkey said: Having had a look at the PJ882HH in person I'm a little unnerved by the sheer size of that beast as really I am looking for a mobile base setup to make the best use of space. How much difference between it and the 60HH would I see in real world use? Am I correct in believing that once setup the 60HH doesn't give much up unless you're changing stuff around a bunch? How much of a sale often comes around black Friday? I was really hoping to have machines by September to start taking advantage of the cooler weather here in Arizona. Also, I've got to say I didn't realize the supermax was so we'll reviewed and not crazy expensive. Is there a catch that I'm missing here? I thought drum sanders were crazy expensive. I was in a similar position (space constrained) and I was pointed to the Euro-style combination Jointer/Planers. Check out the Hammer A3-31 or A3-41 (12" vs 16") or the Minimax FS30 or FS41 for a single unit to give you both functions. Quote
ZombieMonkey Posted July 21, 2017 Author Report Posted July 21, 2017 9 hours ago, Eric. said: The jointers - no you won't be giving up that much in terms of capacity...like 7-8 inches if IIRC. The main difference is dovetail ways vs. parallelogram. The footprint is not that different despite the enormous base on the 882. You can buy a mobile base for either one. Interesting, I guess that base was just really distracting when I saw it next to the 60HH, the PJ882HH looked like a boat! 8 hours ago, Cygnus A said: I was in a similar position (space constrained) and I was pointed to the Euro-style combination Jointer/Planers. Check out the Hammer A3-31 or A3-41 (12" vs 16") or the Minimax FS30 or FS41 for a single unit to give you both functions. I had actually never even considered the road of one of the euro jointer/planers mainly out of lack of ever having seen or used one in person. They do sound appealing, but I am also curious about repair costs down the line vs something I pick up from Jet or Powermatic. How is it dealing with minimax or hammer for repairs? This would definitely be a possible avenue as well, but it would seem that this would be a bit more of a leap of faith as I don't believe there are any of these machines on display in Arizona. Quote
Art Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 Another vote here for the Hammer. I have the A3-31 and love it. I have about 2/3 of a 2 car garage, so space and mobility are an issue. It is very easy to use and move when needed. It is the first planer or jointer I have ever owned, so I have no point of reference, but I find the results to be what I expect - straight and parallel which is really all we're looking for. I have a great dealer here in town, so that made me feel better about it. With your budget, you should be able to pick one up and have plenty left over for other things. Quote
Cygnus A Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 4 hours ago, ZombieMonkey said: Interesting, I guess that base was just really distracting when I saw it next to the 60HH, the PJ882HH looked like a boat! I had actually never even considered the road of one of the euro jointer/planers mainly out of lack of ever having seen or used one in person. They do sound appealing, but I am also curious about repair costs down the line vs something I pick up from Jet or Powermatic. How is it dealing with minimax or hammer for repairs? This would definitely be a possible avenue as well, but it would seem that this would be a bit more of a leap of faith as I don't believe there are any of these machines on display in Arizona. Felder (who owns the Hammer line) and Minimax both have a strong presence in the US. Repairs should never be an issue, but there is really not much that can go wrong with these machines. What part of Arizona are you in? I am in Sahuarita (South of Tucson). I just moved into a new house so my garage/shop is a wreck, but you can come check out the machine if you are near me. Quote
ZombieMonkey Posted July 21, 2017 Author Report Posted July 21, 2017 I am in the east valley out in Phoenix. I'd just be curious what the downsides to combo machines would be vs dedicated machines. I plan on having everything on mobile bases so I will be playing musical machines when I want to reload ammo or park my vehicle inside the garage. Though I'm quite anxious to get a jointer and planer as my first project is making a really nice reloading bench for the gun room so that can vacate more space for woodworking toys. Obviously I would be gaining some space back and a A3-31 would definitely allow for the supermax as suggested earlier to be budgeted for. So many options and I really do appreciate all of the opinions as I find them quite helpful in comparing options available to me. If say I went the Minimax or Hammer route where tends to be the sweet spot and do either company do any sales or discounts throughout the year? I definitely want to get the best bang for the buck as it frees up money for a bandsaw maybe around tax refund season, which I could see being quite useful. Quote
Eric. Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 The downside to the combo machines is you have to switch them back and forth between jointer and planer. Depending on your workflow that might not be a big deal. It would drive me absolutely nuts. Quote
Chet Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 36 minutes ago, Eric. said: The downside to the combo machines is you have to switch them back and forth between jointer and planer And from the little I have seen, it doesn't seem like the switching process is a quick as you would hope. Quote
Eric. Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 13 minutes ago, Chet said: And from the little I have seen, it doesn't seem like the switching process is a quick as you would hope. If it took longer than zero seconds it would bother me immensely. It's just my workflow. I'm constantly going to one machine or the other and I would blow my brains out if I had to do more than push a button to get some action. Quote
Art Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 9 minutes ago, Eric. said: If it took longer than zero seconds it would bother me immensely. It's just my workflow. I'm constantly going to one machine or the other and I would blow my brains out if I had to do more than push a button to get some action. It takes less than one minute (and most of that is raising the planer bed), but if that interferes with your workflow, then it is what it is. For me the savings in space of one compact machine vs 2 full size ones, the cost savings, the jointer capacity and knowing I was getting quality machines made it a no brainer. Quote
Art Posted July 21, 2017 Report Posted July 21, 2017 Also, don't get me wrong. If I had lots of space, and didn't mind the extra cost, I would get dedicated machines and obviously the PM ones are great. Compromises are a fact of life... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.