Jfitz Posted September 24, 2017 Report Posted September 24, 2017 Is anyone here an Apple enthusiast with a knowledge of networking? I'm trying to get a printer on my PC (Windows 7) usable from all our various iOS devices. I have the Bonjour and Airprint services installed on the PC, and using an app on my iPhone ("Discovery", used to scan for all available Bonjour services) I can see the _ipp service available and it lists my printer. Good to go, right? not so much. None of the devices can see it when it searches for Airprint printers. Pretty sure my phone is not the issue - if I get on my neighbor's wifi (yes, we use each others' when visiting), it quickly recognizes her printer. I've pored over all the documentation on the interweb I can find, and my last line of thought leads me to my wifi router. It's a Linksys E2500 - a little old, but still working reasonably well. I flashed it with the latest firmware, and tried enabling/disabling various features one at a time to see if one might be the issue (filter multicast, Wifi encryption, isolate AP, etc). It is not clear to me if it supports multicast DNS (mDNS) or IGMP which are both identified as 'needed' . I'm considering a router upgrade anyways to get better coverage throughout the house, so I might just do it and see what happens. But I wanted to see if anyone here has any experience getting Airprint to work with a shared PC printer. Quote
Tpt life Posted September 24, 2017 Report Posted September 24, 2017 Printers are not super expensive. I switched to a printer that did not require a desktop to be the go between. The printer connects to Mac and mobile devices all wirelessly without needing the Mac powered up. I hope you get this sorted, but next purchase look for cutting out the middle man. Quote
Jfitz Posted September 24, 2017 Author Report Posted September 24, 2017 Yeah, but I was hoping not to buy a new printer just for this....although at the current price points for new printers, it seems better to just buy a new one instead of buying replacement ink cartridges! Quote
TerryMcK Posted September 24, 2017 Report Posted September 24, 2017 This works and I have it installed on a Windows 2012 R2 server. It will work on Windows 7 upwards. http://jaxov.com/2010/11/install-airprint-for-windows-the-easy-way/ Quote
Jfitz Posted September 24, 2017 Author Report Posted September 24, 2017 Thanks Terry. I saw that and I (think I) basically followed the same steps. But one of the comments in that article got me thinking.....I have Bonjour installed, but the Bonjour Printer Wizard was installed in the Program Files/ directory (not Program files (x86) ...... So I'm wondering if I ran into some confusion with 32 bit /64 bit utilities/etc that I might have run. I'm in the middle of a new reinstall of Bonjour properly, and then I'll follow the steps in that article completely.....see if I made a misstep elsewhere. Quote
TerryMcK Posted September 24, 2017 Report Posted September 24, 2017 Yes you need Bonjour out of iTunes but that is about it. Installing airprint for windows installs a windows service of the same name. Then any printer on your PC that is shared can also be set up to be discovered by a Mac, iPhone or iPad. It says it tends to work with HP printers only but my Samsung colour laser works fine with it. It can be a bit of a fiddle getting it going but that article explains it well. There are 2 versions of iTunes and you may have selected the 64bit one by the desciption of where it is installed. I think you are good to go. Quote
Chet Posted September 24, 2017 Report Posted September 24, 2017 3 hours ago, Jfitz said: although at the current price points for new printers, it seems better to just buy a new one instead of buying replacement ink cartridges! I finally gave up this fight. We have a printer specific to printing color photos and then I recently purchased a a Brother laser jet B&W printer for everything else. The starter cartridge that came with it printed over 1000 sheets at medium quality and the high volume replacement cartridge only cost $69.00. Supposed to get 5000 - 7000 sheets out of it. 1 Quote
Marmotjr Posted September 25, 2017 Report Posted September 25, 2017 Using a networked printer, I have never had to install any software to find the printer. And yes, it is often cheaper to sell/trash the previous printer, and buy a new one than go buy new ink. 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted September 26, 2017 Report Posted September 26, 2017 4 hours ago, Marmotjr said: And yes, it is often cheaper to sell/trash the previous printer, and buy a new one than go buy new ink. Until you discover that printers, just like cars, are never sold with a full tank. Mfgs got wise, and started supplying 'demonstrator' cartridges with the printers, which are half (or less) full. On the other hand, the trade-in value of my truck doubles every time I fill the tank! 1 Quote
thatCharlieDude Posted September 26, 2017 Report Posted September 26, 2017 Is the printer Bonjour compatible? Bonjour is a peer to peer service and it won't work if the printer cant use the service. If it is then it should be pretty easy to connect to it, at least it is on OSX. I've never tried with a iOS. I think you can print with the Google cloud printing service from an iPad. Is it a networked printer or is the printer connected to the PC? If it's connected to the Windows box have you enabled printer sharing on it? Quote
Jfitz Posted September 26, 2017 Author Report Posted September 26, 2017 Charlie - the printer is a network printer, and is not Bonjour compatible (i.e. it is not an Airprint printer). You should be able to utilize a Windows shared printer, using Bonjour and Airprint Services, to enable the printer to be used from Apple devices that leverage Airprint. The printer **is** set up to be shared on the Windows system. Also, the Bonjour diagnostic app I loaded onto my iphone does 'see' the printer - at least, it recognizes the _ipp service and lists the printer underneath it. I haven't looked into Google could printing.....if my current plan is a fools errand then I'll probably just cave in and get an Airprint capable printer. I just think it's getting to me, and I want to either get it working or at least understand WHY it's not working. shrug. If the kids need to print something from an iPad, I'll send them to the neighbors house..... Quote
Marmotjr Posted September 27, 2017 Report Posted September 27, 2017 21 hours ago, wtnhighlander said: Until you discover that printers, just like cars, are never sold with a full tank. Mfgs got wise, and started supplying 'demonstrator' cartridges with the printers, which are half (or less) full. Even then, I've done this where the cost of a new printer was the same as the replacement ink. 1 Quote
thatCharlieDude Posted September 27, 2017 Report Posted September 27, 2017 8 hours ago, Jfitz said: Charlie - the printer is a network printer, and is not Bonjour compatible (i.e. it is not an Airprint printer). You should be able to utilize a Windows shared printer, using Bonjour and Airprint Services, to enable the printer to be used from Apple devices that leverage Airprint. The printer **is** set up to be shared on the Windows system. Also, the Bonjour diagnostic app I loaded onto my iphone does 'see' the printer - at least, it recognizes the _ipp service and lists the printer underneath it. I haven't looked into Google could printing.....if my current plan is a fools errand then I'll probably just cave in and get an Airprint capable printer. I just think it's getting to me, and I want to either get it working or at least understand WHY it's not working. shrug. If the kids need to print something from an iPad, I'll send them to the neighbors house..... I don't know enough about iOS and network printing to say it's not working. If the diagnostic app sees the printer then you should be able to connect to it. Connecting to a printer on OSX is super easy, easier than on Windows. Quote
thatCharlieDude Posted September 27, 2017 Report Posted September 27, 2017 On iOS can you add a printer by IP address? If you can that might be easier than using bonjour. Quote
thatCharlieDude Posted September 27, 2017 Report Posted September 27, 2017 Wife says she's had similar experiences, her iPad sees the printer but she can't connect to it. Quote
Jfitz Posted September 27, 2017 Author Report Posted September 27, 2017 10 hours ago, thatCharlieDude said: On iOS can you add a printer by IP address? If you can that might be easier than using bonjour. Nope. 10 hours ago, thatCharlieDude said: Wife says she's had similar experiences, her iPad sees the printer but she can't connect to it. Thanks Charlie. Seems like there are many posts online about similar issues with AirPrint, but no definitive guide about "use <xxx> settings on <yyy> network components with <zzz> software". Lots of people have it working though. So far the kids' homework hasn't made this a crisis but time will tell. Quote
thatCharlieDude Posted September 27, 2017 Report Posted September 27, 2017 1 hour ago, Jfitz said: Thanks Charlie. Seems like there are many posts online about similar issues with AirPrint, but no definitive guide about "use <xxx> settings on <yyy> network components with <zzz> software". Lots of people have it working though. So far the kids' homework hasn't made this a crisis but time will tell. Sorry I couldn't be more helpful. It seems strange that iOS is so flaky with printing when OSX is so easy. My daughter had the opposite problem in college; she could never get her Windows machine to network print while her roommate just pressed one button on her Mac and it was connected. Quote
Jfitz Posted September 27, 2017 Author Report Posted September 27, 2017 Funny, I've fond setting up the printers for our Windows machine to be a piece of cake. shrug. FWIW, I don't think this is an iOS issue, I'm leaning towards some sort of network/router issue. I might spend some time on it this weekend, so I'll post any updates. Quote
sjeff70 Posted September 28, 2017 Report Posted September 28, 2017 On 9/24/2017 at 11:23 AM, Chet said: I finally gave up this fight. We have a printer specific to printing color photos and then I recently purchased a a Brother laser jet B&W printer for everything else. The starter cartridge that came with it printed over 1000 sheets at medium quality and the high volume replacement cartridge only cost $69.00. Supposed to get 5000 - 7000 sheets out of it. Plus the cartridge in my Brother doesn't need any maintenance if it goes 6 months not printing anything. I love my Brother, brothers. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.