Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Australian eucalyptus for fascia? HELP!

Featured Replies

I've got a contractor doing repairs / renovations on the mansard roof and gable on my 140 year old home.  He just texted me

Quote

Your fascia boards up top need to be replaced.  The issue with it is is there also Structural. Their a little more than an inch and a half thick. I went to my buddy who has a woodworking shop and because he’s the only one that I know that would have the kind of wood as quickly as I need it. He has red grandes, otherwise known as Australian eucalyptus, which is what you would want to use in this circumstance. There’s also detail in the facia that I have to mimic so there’s a good bit of labor involved with that, but besides even that the boards that I need are 8/4 which is a little less than 2 inches thick and they’re about 200 each for a 14 footer and both you need (2)14 footers. So just for the lumber it would be 400 bucks and then there’s going to be labor and installation but I just wanted to get your guys go ahead on getting a lumber before I get it. If you wanted to go another route, I could go to Home Depot and get pressure-treated, which would probably be like $25 but but it’s definitely going to crack and split within a year or two and it really don’t accept paint well because of the chemicals it’s soaked in to withstand the elements. I don’t even know why they tell you you can paint it because the paint never holds up. The labor and installation would be the same, whether it was pressure-treated or the red grandes so that’s why I just wanted to get your guys decision before I get the wood. And he’s given it to me for what he purchases it for he gets it in bulk from a wood supplier.

I figure people built houses in this area for a long time without importing wood from Australia, so it sounds fishy.  But maybe with cheap container shipping this is actually the best solution.  He says it's $8 / BF.

I'd like to get back to this guy quickly, but I'd really appreciate advice from you guys with more experience.

[update] Some of the price comes from needing it right away.  I checked prices of other rot resistant woods available locally, and $8 / BF is not crazy, so I told him to go ahead.

 

It is hard to believe that an Australian wood would be used when building. Regular pine, if sealed and painted properly, should hold up as well as anything. Unless there's something else going on to make it rot.

That's interesting here in California in the late 1800's there were some individuals that started growing stands of Eucalyptus because they found out it grew fairly fast compared to redwood and they thought it would be a good replacement for redwood.  Trouble was that when the started harvesting the trees, when the felled them they were all splitting lengthwise when the hit the ground.  They ended up abandoning the idea and just harvest the trees they had and sold the wood for firewood.

" Their a little more.."     He lost me there.   140 years old in Pa., I'm thinking not some wood from across an ocean, especially that ocean.

Whatever you end up doing about wood, if it's going to be painted, use Sherwin-Williams Rain Refresh.  Nothing better for fascia's.

I saw a joke recently, but it really wasn't that funny:  "If you don't know the difference between They're, There, and Their, your an idiot".

  • Author

The only way to access this fascia is to build a scaffold on top of my front porch roof, so maintenance is a bear.  Not just this guy - everyone I've talked to is unwilling to put a ladder on the porch roof to reach the mansard and gable.

IMG_1338.jpg

  • Popular Post

I would rent a lift.  Cost about the same as the time setting up scaffolding.  I quit working off ladders decades ago.  Tow behind lifts aren't that expensive to rent.

This was nothing like that high, but it's the only picture I could find of me using one.  The tow behinds are battery powered, so you don't hear a motor running all the time like the others.

This was a 45 foot reach one.  This brand also makes 55 and 65 footers.  The bigger they are the more they rent for.  They're easy to operate and very stable.  Even pretty quick to go up and down with once you get used to operating one.  

image.jpeg

  • Author
  • Popular Post
On 3/17/2026 at 6:21 PM, Tom King said:

I would rent a lift.

This is on a busy city street.  Might not be room/permission to use a lift.  I have used a crane to put an HVAC unit on the flat roof behind the mansard, but that was only for an hour or so.

Is there a sidewalk and small yard, and maybe parking spaces?  Those stabilizer legs self adjust to level but can each be quite a bit different in height of each foot and it makes no noise.  There are rules for directing pedestrians that you can even rent the required stuff to do that with.

  • Author
On 3/17/2026 at 7:31 PM, Tom King said:

Is there a sidewalk and small yard, and maybe parking spaces?  Those stabilizer legs self adjust to level but can each be quite a bit different in height of each foot and it makes no noise.  There are rules for directing pedestrians that you can even rent the required stuff to do that with.

Well, we've already got the scaffold, but I'll bring that up next time.  Thanks!

  • Popular Post
On 3/17/2026 at 5:02 PM, Beechwood Chip said:

Not just this guy - everyone I've talked to is unwilling to put a ladder on the porch roof to reach the mansard and gable.

Don't blame them. I don't know if I would want to work on scaffolding.

  • Popular Post

Having done the high work for about 10 years, there is likely a local liability and OSHA concern if you are on a busy street. 

  • Popular Post

I have been known to work from scaffolding, but I'm not climbing a tall ladder to get on it.

In North Carolina to have the highest level Contractor's License you have to have $150,000 dollars in the bank.  In Virginia, you have to have a $45,000 net worth. (Not sure how well that works out for them.) When I was working on old houses, one was in Virginia before they had a reciprocal agreement with NC licenses, so I had to get the Va. Class A license.  In filling out the form with an expert, I had 45k worth of scaffolding, so I qualified in the net worth department.

IMG_4459.thumb.jpg.6e19ae3160febf9f8fa1e0ab90288a6b.jpgIMG_4489.thumb.jpg.fd2c75f9e1996b77eb988e8929a8a8b4.jpgsinceslicedbread.thumb.jpg.07dffc519c2ed66330387c7bef04b7ba.jpg

DSCN8602.JPG

DSCN8756-250x187.jpg

  • Popular Post

I feel uncomfortable on the fourth rung of a six foot ladder! ;)

  • Author
  • Popular Post

When I bought my house, I needed some work done on my chimneys.  The guy I hired encouraged me to climb up so he could show me what he had done.  I'm glad he did.  Got me over my initial fear and after that I could climb all over my flat roofs to check out damage, make small repairs, and understand what was going on.

But that was over 20 years ago.  Now I hire people to do that.  It's not that I'm afraid, but I'm a lot heavier, a lot weaker, and a lot less bendy.

11 hours ago, Coop said:

I feel uncomfortable on the fourth rung of a six foot ladder! ;)

+1

On 3/18/2026 at 5:43 PM, Coop said:

I feel uncomfortable on the fourth rung of a six foot ladder! ;)

Me too and I used to rock climb as a form of outdoor relaxation.

  • Popular Post

If I have no choice but ladders, I'm not going up higher than I can jump without a safety line and climbing harness on.  In this setup the fascia is 27 feet off the ground.  On the roof there is a rope that goes over the ridge and is tied to a tractor on the other side.  That strong rope has a pulley on the end.  My safety line goes through that pulley and has a special thing tied to the trailer in the picture so someone belaying me can stop the rope if needed.  The other end that goes through that pulley is tied to my climbing harness.

The lower ladder was used to put a large stainless steel screw eye into one of the 4x8 ceiling joists.  While I redid these old museum houses to be as close to original as possible, every one has a number of these eye screws in a safe place.  This eye screw was used to pull up the 40' ladder and tie it securely to the house.  I would need to push on it with my feet once on the roof to get the specially made roof ladder in place.

I keep one Radial Arm Saw set up with a dado blade and no fence especially for making these lightweight roof ladders.  The top hooks are designed to jump over the ridge, then be turned over and are very secure in place.  The steps are horizontal for whatever the roof slope is and 3' apart.

Even going up that lower ladder to set the eye screw, I was saftied in harness.

I get double my normal rate with a four hour minimum for such jobs, which includes time for loading, setup, and takedown.  I have now quit doing this, but still get calls with people begging.

 

valleysetup_012.jpg

The most dangerous part of that job was the possibility of getting a rope burn from the throw line used to get the first belay pulley rope over the house.   It's a small slick line and you'd better be out of the way of it when let loose.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.