Darren W. Posted April 29 Report Posted April 29 Ok, complete novice here. (which will become obvious as you read!) Wooden doors on a rental property were damaged by a large dog with deep scratches. Instead of doing the necessary research, I followed my wife's AI instructions by filling the gashes with an epoxy filler. Might not have been that bad but I failed to take into account the color difference. AAAGGHH! I've sanded it down and as crazy as it looks visually the surface is actually smooth. What if anything can I do at this point to save the look of the doors? Is my only recourse to paint them at this point? I'd really rather not if at all possible but I've really screwed this one up royally! 2 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted April 29 Report Posted April 29 Hi @Darren W. And welcome aboard! A picture would sure help to understand the extent of what you're dealing with - but i think you have to have a few posts before you're able to post pictures. Can you estimate how deep the scratches are? The other guys will probably have additional thoughts, but the see it, you can either sand or plane past the depth of the scratches, which would require refinishing, or the path of least resistance would be painting. On the other hand, if you can get the filler you used out of the scratches, the other guys might have some advice to hire to try to get it to match your existing finish a little better. Best of luck to you on this and welcome to the forum 1 Quote
Darren W. Posted April 29 Author Report Posted April 29 The scratches are quite deep. Enough so that I would be hesitant to try to sand it down and I don't have access to a planer. I thought of trying to scrape out the epoxy but there is just too much of it to be realistic. Would a gel stain be a possible path here? 1 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted April 29 Report Posted April 29 Ooof. That's ruff. (Pun intended and apologized for.) The other guys in here are more knowledgeable than me on finishing, so a grain of salt here... Matching any stain with the existing finish is going to be difficult. I'd bring the door down to Hirschfields or similar and see if they can match it. But... Unfortunately no stain is going to go into the filler the same as it will the surrounding wood of the door. So you're probably still going to still see the scratches through the stain. Gel stains are good for species that don't take stain evenly, as well as use on vertical surfaces. A gel stain wouldn't hurt you here, but i don't think it will provide much benefit over what a regular stain would give you. 1 Quote
Darren W. Posted April 29 Author Report Posted April 29 What SHOULD I have done in this situation BEFORE I messed it up with the epoxy? Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted April 29 Report Posted April 29 I probably would've started by bringing it into a finishing/furniture repair shop to get their thoughts. Which still might be your best bet. Seamless repair of that magnitude is an art all unto itself. We'll see what the other guys have to say though. Quote
Darren W. Posted April 29 Author Report Posted April 29 I appreciate your input! If all else fails I could paint it I guess. Such pretty wood though 1 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted April 29 Report Posted April 29 On 4/29/2026 at 3:53 PM, Darren W. said: I appreciate your input! If all else fails I could paint it I guess. Such pretty wood though Yep, keep that in your back pocket for a nuclear option. There's some pretty smart fellers in here, they might have some better ideas. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted April 29 Report Posted April 29 Scratches that deep, even in solid wood, will never disappear under a translucent finish. I can't tell from the photo, but even 'solid' wood doors are often constructed with a laminated stave core, and covered with a veneer. Those scratches seem deep enough to penetrate the veneer, meaning you could not even plane them away without altering the surface if the door. In all honesty, I think paint is your best recourse for salvaging that door. Possibly you could replace the veneer, but it sounds like you aren't tooled up for that sort of task. 1 Quote
Popular Post fcschoenthal Posted April 29 Popular Post Report Posted April 29 On 4/29/2026 at 12:25 PM, Darren W. said: Wooden doors on a rental property were damaged by a large dog with deep scratches. One reason that I have a very large pet security deposit on my rent houses. I don't think that you're going to be able to salvage that door back to an original wood look, at least economicaly. Either painting or replacement is the only options that I can see. 3 Quote
Von Posted April 30 Report Posted April 30 Sorry to agree, the epoxy won't take strain once set, so paint would seem your best choice. I didn't know how you could have done better. 1 Quote
Mark J Posted April 30 Report Posted April 30 You might have used a dark tinted epoxy, but honestly even a perfect color match would not hide this level of damage. Color matching the stain & varnish to the original un-sanded part of the door will be a challenge, too. As suggested, maybe a furniture repair shop can offer some suggestion. 2 Quote
tperson Posted April 30 Report Posted April 30 the Great Google Machine says the denatured alcohol may soften cured epoxy but that methylene chloride solvents (like found in MEK) are more effective. It'd be potentially tedious, but thoughts on trying to soften the epoxy and then scraping it? Quote
Von Posted April 30 Report Posted April 30 On 4/30/2026 at 12:10 PM, tperson said: the Great Google Machine says the denatured alcohol may soften cured epoxy but that methylene chloride solvents (like found in MEK) are more effective. It'd be potentially tedious, but thoughts on trying to soften the epoxy and then scraping it? Before I did that, I'd figure out what I'm going to replace it with which would be a significant enough improvement to warrant the effort. 2 Quote
Darren W. Posted April 30 Author Report Posted April 30 Maybe painting it using that simulated wood effect?! Never done it but what the heck..... 1 Quote
drzaius Posted May 1 Report Posted May 1 18 hours ago, Darren W. said: Maybe painting it using that simulated wood effect?! Never done it but what the heck..... That's worth a try. I've seen it done professionally and the results were impressive. 2 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted May 1 Popular Post Report Posted May 1 Sometimes you have to know when to say "when". Before you go too far down the road I would get a quote from people who make doors for kitchen and bath. There are outfits that do this exclusively and reasonably due to their specialized focus. I know it sounds like something only the pros would do but, you may be surprised. 4 Quote
curlyoak Posted May 11 Report Posted May 11 Paint is the only logical choice for me. The underlying wood is Douglas Fir. I think. So it is not precious wood. Are you the landlord? Tenant or landlord, either one, I'd go with paint. 1 Quote
fcschoenthal Posted May 11 Report Posted May 11 I'd also clean them well, fill every other scratch or nick and use a good primer first. Otherwise, you're going to have an issue with the paint bonding to the epoxy. 2 Quote
dwilliam Posted July 14 Report Posted July 14 Don't give up yet. If the epoxy is smooth, you can carefully tint it with gel stain, graining markers, or touch-up pigments to better match the wood. If the repair is too noticeable, replacing the filler with a stainable wood filler may be worth it before resorting to paint. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.