ChetlovesMer Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 I’m on vacation from the real world this week. So, I'm finishing up my miter saw stand and working on some Christmas presents in the shop this morning. I was ripping some purple-heart for a pen-box I'm making my mother. I should have been using either a sled or a zero clearance insert for the size piece I was ripping. (So, Yes. It was my mistake. Nobody to blame but my haste.) Honestly, I should have switched blades as well. I was using my general cutting blade as I was also building a miter saw stand at the same time as working on this project. If I had been making more than this one cut, I'd of switched to a thin-kerf for what I was doing. Same old story. "Oh, I'll just make this one cut". The piece I was cutting was fairly small. Maybe twice the size of a pen blank, or a bit smaller. I was feeding it with a trianglar plastic push stick. The front of the piece dipped and got caught up a bit (I know I should have been using a zero insert or a sled.) I got some kickback. The index finger of my left hand which was guiding the piece went into the blade. Then all of a sudden there was tons of clearance, because my blade had disappeared. I came away with a scratch. Amazingly, the blade didn't even have time to break the skin enough to draw blood. I was really impressed. What impressed me most was that I heard the blade disappear before I even felt it hit my finger. It reacted quicker than I could have. In truth the injury was not likely to be catastrophic, but who knows? Anyway, after 4-1/2 years its nice to know it works on something other than the bratwurst I tested it on a few years back. 2 Quote
rmac Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 Kinda brings new meaning to the words "attached thumbnails," doesn't it? Glad yours still are. Just out of curiosity, how close were your fingers to the blade before the kickback? -- Russ 1 Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 20, 2011 Author Report Posted December 20, 2011 Well, Russ, they were too close. I was sort of using my left hand as a feather board. My index finger was on top of the board, my middle finger providing just a bit of pressure holding the piece against the fence. The piece was maybe 1-1/4" wide and I was basically ripping it in half. My left hand was not even with the blade but more toward the front of the saw, the kickback kind of jerked my hand toward the blade. I really don't think the kickback would have happened at all if I had put the zero clearance insert in. Does that make sense? I mean, not why I didn't use a sled, which was only a few feet away, or the zero clearance insert which was actually hanging on the side of the saw. But how it happened? I consider myself a very safety conscious person, but this is the second time in my 20+ years of woodworking I've been bitten by a power tool. I've been lucky both times. Quote
Nick2cd Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 what a great story with a happy ending. i am in love with my sawstop. it's the best thing my wife ever bought for me. fortunately, i've never had to type out my "save" story and i hope i never have to do so. however, i feel confident that if i ever do have a "save" i WILL be able to TYPE about it with all ten fingers. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 20, 2011 Author Report Posted December 20, 2011 That's funny, Nick. My wife's the one who originally convinced me I should get the SawStop as well. Quote
rmac Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 Does that make sense? I mean, not why I didn't use a sled, which was only a few feet away, or the zero clearance insert which was actually hanging on the side of the saw. But how it happened? Yes, your description makes sense. I have heard stories like this one before, and the thing I could never figure out is how a kickback can move your hand in the opposite direction. I imagine that it happened so fast that you don't know for sure either. -- Russ Quote
jhl.verona Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 ... snip ... I came away with a scratch. Amazingly, the blade didn't even have time to break the skin enough to draw blood. I was really impressed. What impressed me most was that I heard the blade disappear before I even felt it hit my finger. It reacted quicker than I could have. In truth the injury was not likely to be catastrophic, but who knows? Anyway, after 4-1/2 years its nice to know it works on something other than the bratwurst I tested it on a few years back. Your reactions can be measured in tenths of a second, an electronic device in microseconds, and a mechanical device in milliseconds. Fortunately, with a safety device like that you'll never know if it might have been catastrophic or not. I'm also impressed that it works so effectively even after almost 5 years. Or possibly you have a better maintenance schedule than most people. In any case, humans err, get bored, loose concentration and so on, whereas machines don't. It's being intelligent about it that counts - or marrying someone intelligent . Glad that your finger didn't loose this fight. Kinda brings new meaning to the words "attached thumbnails," doesn't it? Glad yours still are. -- Russ Yes, indeed! Yes, your description makes sense. I have heard stories like this one before, and the thing I could never figure out is how a kickback can move your hand in the opposite direction. I imagine that it happened so fast that you don't know for sure either. -- Russ If he was using this left hand as a featherboard, and the wood kicked back enough, he'd be pushing his hand against very little or nothing - towards the blade. Just a hypothesis mind you. John Quote
Jfitz Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 Hey Chet, glad the SS saved you some serious damage! I think you are minimizing the potential.....if your hand contacted the spinning blade, it could have been (and probably would have been) bad. I hope that blade and brake get mounted in a conspicuous place, as a constant reminder. Unless you send the brake back to SS? I know for a while they gave a new brake in return so they could collect more data on what real hits looked like, so the could make improvements. "Attached thumbnails" - nice!! Quote
Indy Cindy Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 We have an old contracting saw that has been sitting unused in the garage for 15 years until I took up woodworking about 6 months ago. After learning how to correctly and safely use a table saw in the classes I am taking and getting over my fear of the things I decided to resurrect the old saw. My instructor said NO, don't use it. Get a SawStop. The safety equipment on my old saw isn't even up to the standards of modern table saws. So I will be using the SawStop that we have at class for big projects and a Bladerunner that my husband is getting me for Christmas for little projects at home until I can save up enough money for the SawStop. Hopefully the under $1K rumors I have heard on SawStop contracting saws by summer will be true. Chet - I'm really glad that your Christmas will be a merry one and not one spent in the hospital! Thanks for your story. -Cindy Quote
Eric. Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 Thanks for the reminder, Chet. Glad you're still intact. We're all guilty of saying, "ah, screw it," from time to time and taking minor but stupid risks, but most of us really can't afford that gamble since our saws don't know the difference between lumber and hot dogs. Those little pieces...yikes. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 20, 2011 Author Report Posted December 20, 2011 Hey Chet, glad the SS saved you some serious damage! I think you are minimizing the potential.....if your hand contacted the spinning blade, it could have been (and probably would have been) bad. I hope that blade and brake get mounted in a conspicuous place, as a constant reminder. Unless you send the brake back to SS? I know for a while they gave a new brake in return so they could collect more data on what real hits looked like, so the could make improvements. "Attached thumbnails" - nice!! I'm going to hang up the blade, and a photo of the blade and the brake. SawStop still sends you a free brake replacement if you mail them your brake and fill out a "save report". So, I'm doing that this morning. 1 Quote
Jfitz Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 I'm going to hang up the blade, and a photo of the blade and the brake. SawStop still sends you a free brake replacement if you mail them your brake and fill out a "save report". So, I'm doing that this morning. Nice! Maybe we'll see your testimonial on their website at some point! I also love me SS. I'm still on the original brake on mine (+3 years later) which is just fine with me. Quote
PeteJr Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 If you have to work with you fingers within 6" of the blade you need to take the time to make a jig. Table saw safety is all about working smart! 1 Quote
lighthearted Posted December 20, 2011 Report Posted December 20, 2011 Glad you got a sawstop! Saving for mine! 1 Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 20, 2011 Author Report Posted December 20, 2011 If you have to work with you fingers within 6" of the blade you need to take the time to make a jig. Table saw safety is all about working smart! You are 100% right. Quote
wilburpan Posted December 21, 2011 Report Posted December 21, 2011 Woodworking safety in general is all about working smart. I'd add that buying a SawStop was a smart move. 2 Quote
Boatworks Today Posted December 21, 2011 Report Posted December 21, 2011 Phew!! Merry Christmas to you ! All is well that ends well! Glad to hear that you weren't hurt and the saw lived up to it's claim ! Quote
Texfire Posted December 21, 2011 Report Posted December 21, 2011 Sorry to hear that you needed to use the safety feature of your SS, but glad it did so successfully. And thanks for posting publicly so we get the reminder to listen to that little voice that says, "how bad could it turn out if it goes wrong" instead of the one that says, "It's just one cut..." 1 Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 22, 2011 Author Report Posted December 22, 2011 Thank you to everyone in the forum for such kind words and well wishes. No matter what tool you are using we need to remember that safety is the most important part of any project and it should never be left out or hurried. With the holiday season and everyone in a rush to complete projects for loved ones, don't forget those same loved ones would feel horrible if you injure yourself while racing to complete their project. I don't have anyone on my Christmas list who wouldn't rather get their gift a day or two late, then have me give up a finger or worse just to get it done on time. This forum is filled with great people pursuing a great hobby. I'd like to see us all make a New Years resolution to be even safer in our pursuit of woodworking success. Thanks again to everyone and especially Marc for giving us this place to pal around. Merry Christmas Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted December 23, 2011 Report Posted December 23, 2011 Outstanding! Glad to hear everything worked out OK! After recently getting some serious hands-on time with three examples of SawStop Industrial saws, I'm planning to replace my General 650 cabinet saw. I'm convinced there is no worthwhile downside to having a SawStop, and am not surprised they are landing in more and more pro shops. I've put many, many, accident-free hours on table saws, have weeks of hands-on training, and am convinced I work safely. If I never "use" it, great! But if I do... Quote
JimB1 Posted December 28, 2011 Report Posted December 28, 2011 Not to belabor the point but just remember the best way to avoid the accident is to not put yourself in the position. Even the Sawstop folks will tell you that the blade break is the last line of defense if all the other safety options and proceedures fail. It's good that you had it and it worked as advertised. I'm glad you are OK. Hopefully you never need it to fire off again Have a happy and safe New Year. -Jim Quote
Dynablue Posted December 28, 2011 Report Posted December 28, 2011 I've owned a 52" Sawstop ICS for over four years (replacing a Ryobi BTS-20) and in my current job I sell various tablesaws which includes the SS. What I've noticed is that the majority of saws (well over 5:1) we sell are now SS. Retirement community woodshops, professional cabinetry courses at the local college, highschools..they're replacing their older equipment with SS. We have some folks who refuse to consider the SS because they've always used a Delta or a Powermatic or <Fill in the blank> but I refer to that as a 'Ford vs Chevy' attitude..brand loyalty over all. That isn't to say that SS is the 'best' saw on the market; Unisaw has some features that make it a competitive but different saw, ie, 31" deep table vs 30" for the SS ICS and 27" for the SS PCS, front-of-table to blade distance is greater on the Unisaw allowing more mitre engagement prior to encountering the first tooth, front mounted tilt/elevation controls, etc. Since we're not commission sales I don't make any more money selling a SS to a customer than I do a Unisaw and I let the customer guide my recommendations but many folks come in and they want that 'saw that won't cut off your finger' which narrows my options down to one of four SS models. SS is a great saw without the safety feature, comparable to any other high end saw in a comparable category (contractor, hybrid, cabinet) and when you consider that feature it's icing on the cake but I always caution people even the SS manual says (in many places) you MUST sustain some contact and injury for the mechanism to work. It isn't ESP or magic..it's conductivity and that requires touching the blade. Regardless of what you think of Steve Gass and his justifiable lock down on the SS patent he did what he was forced to do: Make a great saw with great features available to woodworkers. BTW- Any SS owners ever compare the instruction manual and assembly packaging against most other manufacturers? Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted December 29, 2011 Author Report Posted December 29, 2011 I have gone off on many a SawStop rant over the 4-1/2 years I've owned mine. I have even been accused of working for SawStop, which is not true. But even before I had ever had the saw brake mechanism fire, I was a huge fan of this saw. One of the things I love (I often list off about a dozen, which doesn't even include the brake mechanism) is the instruction manual. It is the best manual I have ever seen for any tool... not just for any table saw... It is the best manual for ANY TOOL! Quote
bladerunner Posted December 29, 2011 Report Posted December 29, 2011 My Sawstop ate up a couple years of my woodworking budget. But I wouldn't go without it. While I think I am safe, there's always that chance something will happen. This thread proves it. The Sawstop is the last line of defense behind other safety processes. I reload ammo and use a special tool inserted in my press that indicates if a round is double charged (twice as much powder would blow up the gun and my hand). There's just as much argument for reloaders that you don't need that device when using proper techniques. I wouldn't reload without it just like I wouldn't saw without a Sawstop. I still can't believe the other table saw providers have held up against the Sawstop. Just the liabilty alone....... And my son has worked with me a bit on things. I could never live with knowing I could have had a Sawstop and saved my son's fingers. I had never let my son use my Dewalt for just that reason. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.