notquitea90 Posted July 30, 2012 Report Posted July 30, 2012 *(I’ll apologize ahead of time for this being such a long post) Hey guys, I haven’t done a formal intro/how do you do yet so I’ll maybe do that quickly here before I get to my question. I’m a newbie to woodworking from Calgary, AB. I’m just getting my shop set up finally after a couple years of trying to do so. I was all hyped up to get set up a few years back but life has a funny way of getting in the way some times. Any who, one of the first items on my to do list is to construct an assembly table since I don’t really have one single flat surface in my entire garage. I’ll be following Marc’s video’s on how to do so but one problem I’ve come across all ready is that I really don’t have the greatest jointer for laying down the level base. I bought a Delta bench top a few years back for 80 bucks and to date it’s done the trick for the odd and end things I’ve done but to say the least it leaves a lot to be desired. For the time being I think I’ll just modify a straight edge that I was using as a guide for my circular saw into a edging sled and edge the boards on table saw to get by for now but I can all ready see how important a decent jointer will be going forward. So as I see it I have a few options going forward:Build a in feed/out feed table that I can bolt my little bench top onto to help extend the bed. Even with this though my little bench top will have some serious limitations.Buy a used jointer off of Kijiji. I’ve seen some old base model 6” Delta’s and Generals any where from $200 to $500.Buy new. I can afford to buy a new planer but since I’m just starting to set up my shop there are still a lot of other things I could put the money towards that might be of better use. I’ll get into some of my choices below.Buy a good old No. 7 hand plane which will still cost nearly as much as a used jointer and will be a bit more time consuming. I was hoping some of you could chime in on what you think I should do. I’m kind of leaning towards buying new but I’m not sure if I’m just spending on something I don’t need to be right now. Also, I watched Marc’s video on setting up a jointer and making it coplanar. What I’ve noticed however is to date every is that none of the “wedge” style jointers I’ve looked at have those handy little table adjustment bolts for making the bed coplanar, in fact all the ones I’ve looked at require you to shim them. So I’d really like to know, do all the wedge style planers require shimming or are there some with fine adjustment mechanisms for this purpose? I know the parallelogram jointers have these settings but those are a whole different ball game price wise other than the Grizzly G0604X. Choices for new planers right now are: General 6” Jointer - 80-100L General 6” Helical Jointer - 80-100LHC Laguna 6” SHEARTECH Grizzly G0604X I’m leaning towards the Laguna if I go new and the Delta 6" (older style) if I buy used. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted July 30, 2012 Report Posted July 30, 2012 As far as the base on that outfeed table goes, I guess it all depends on how the base is going to be built and how thick the legs are. I built my outfeed table with glueups of clear pine into 3x3ish legs. If I recall, I used the table saw (and some use of a hand plane) to cut two sides of the leg at 90 degrees from one another, then just took both opposite sites through the planer as it had enough surface to ride on both ways. Can't speak for all jointers, just got mine a short time ago. Used can be cheaper, but take note of the condition and that it could cost money (and time) to restore it. Learned a lesson on that after some disaster with my used jointer. Ended up spending the same amount of money restoring it that I could have spent on a comparable Grizzly, but on the other hand, the pros did outweigh the cons for my situation and learned a ton about jointers in the process. Quote
mikem Posted July 30, 2012 Report Posted July 30, 2012 If it were me, I would go with option 3 & 4. I am currently a step a head of you in this same situation, as I have the Delta benchtop jointer, and just ordered a new jointer from grizzly. If you have the ability to run 220V to your shop area, seriously consider an 8" jointer. For me, this was unrealistic, so I too went with a new 6" jointer. There are some techniques you can use to flatten a board that is wider then 6" on the jointer. However, if they are much bigger, and you don't want to rip the board down, nothing beats a good #7. Quote
notquitea90 Posted July 30, 2012 Author Report Posted July 30, 2012 Ya, I’m kind of leaning towards options 3 & 4 too. At the moment there isn’t much selection locally for used and as End of the World mentioned you have to be careful with the price of replacement parts if you can even get them. I bought my current planer used and learned that lesson the hard way. I bought it for $150 which wasn’t bad but it needed new blades and a few other parts. I think by the time I was done the total bill including the purchase price was around $350 which wasn’t much less than what a new planer with some warranty behind it would have cost. Being from Canada makes it a bit worse too, I just bought a part for my dust collector which was $4. The shipping was $14 and then I got hit with duty and taxes at the boarder which were $12. So $30 total for a $4 part, sigh. On 220 power, ya installing a new panel in my garage so I can run 220 is on my “todo” list but because of the way my house is laid out it would require me to rip apart that brand new ceiling in my basement I just installed about a year and a half go so I’m kind of putting it off. I know it will have to happen sooner or later but “ugh”, it’s gonna take a bit of work. I think for the time being I’ll stick with a 6”. Which Grizzly did you go with? I wasn’t 100% sure if they shipped to Canada but apparently they do so that might be an option. I don’t know much about Grizzly though, is it a decent brand? I also just found out that I can get Powermatic shipped here as well but I haven’t checked the pricing yet so that may also be an option. I was at Canadian Woodworker earlier seeing what they had. I mentioned the 220 power issue and he showed me a Casadei 12" combo PLANER/JOINTER. Imagine my surprise when I found out it runs on 110 (convertible up to 220)! You heard right, a 12” jointer on 110. How I don’t know but I guess it does and a it’s very nice machine to boot. Extremely expensive though (at least for me) so that won’t be happening. EofW, I'll post a pic of the extension I was thinking about when I get home. Quote
rodger. Posted July 31, 2012 Report Posted July 31, 2012 I have a delta 6" jointer, which I purchased from a wood workers machine shop. In the box, I could fit it in my car easily. I really like my jointer (X5 model), but I really wish I would have bought the 8" model. I will eventually upgrade to an 8" machine, and could have saved myself some time and effort by buying it first. Quote
Don Z. Posted July 31, 2012 Report Posted July 31, 2012 Since you're in Canada, have you considered General? 6in jointers there start for less than $800, and parts in Canada will never be a problem. Certainly, you won't be stuck with a duty! http://general.ca/pg_index/Promotions/Promo2012(rev2)_ENG_1-16.pdf Quote
notquitea90 Posted July 31, 2012 Author Report Posted July 31, 2012 Yup, I'm looking at 3 different General models right now. Every where I go though everyone keeps warning me that General isn't what it use to be since they off shored the manufacturing (there's only two models of table saws left with the maple leaf on them ) but I have an el'cheapo General drill press and I love the thing. I don't know, personally I still think they're pretty good bang for the buck. However I demo'ed the General General 6" Helical Jointer which is the same price as the Laguna 6" X 56" Jointer W/"SHEARTECH" Carbide Cutterhead) and I thought the Laguna was a way better machine but I don't have a heck of a lot of experience with jointers so I might not know the difference to be honest. There seems to be a bit of a consensus growing on the 8" jointer thing though. I might have to rethink this all together Quote
walnut_weasel Posted July 31, 2012 Report Posted July 31, 2012 There may be another option to consider. By assembly table are you considering the torsion box assembly table? If so, you may want to consider skipping that build for now. Although a torsion table is nice, it is far from necessary for someone just getting started (in my opinion.) Maybe consider checking out Marc's outfeed table video. That table would be flat enough for a new shop and it is much easier to build and will likely be less expensive. Quote
notquitea90 Posted July 31, 2012 Author Report Posted July 31, 2012 Well I guess I've got a bit of contemplating to do on this whole jointer thing but as I mentioned I'm planning on using my table saw to get me by for the time being. Originally I planned on doing a sacrafical fence type of thing like this: but I've since noticed a few other methods such as sleds such as these: This one rides dirrectly against the fence but there is also one such as the following which utilizes the miter slot : Any feed back on which is better? The sled would be a snap, I've already got an old straight edge I use to use for my circular saw that I can modify but the fence thing just seems so much simpler and less cumbersome. Quote
notquitea90 Posted July 31, 2012 Author Report Posted July 31, 2012 There may be another option to consider. By assembly table are you considering the torsion box assembly table? If so, you may want to consider skipping that build for now. Although a torsion table is nice, it is far from necessary for someone just getting started (in my opinion.) Maybe consider checking out Marc's outfeed table video. That table would be flat enough for a new shop and it is much easier to build and will likely be less expensive. You know, that's actually a damn good idea . I still wouldn't getting some feed back on the jointer issue though. Quote
rmac Posted July 31, 2012 Report Posted July 31, 2012 Those table saw jigs ought to work fine for putting a straight edge on an already-flat board. But they won't help you get the face of the board flat to start with. Dunno if you've considered that or not. As far as which jig is best, I'm a "simpler is better" kind of guy, so I like the one that rides against the fence better than the one that rides in the miter slot. The one with the sacrificial fence looks fussy to me, and it would also be a pain to set up every time you wanted to use it. -- Russ Quote
notquitea90 Posted July 31, 2012 Author Report Posted July 31, 2012 Ya I was thinking about that and board twist. If I clamp the board down to a sled it might flatten it out only to spring back once I unclamp it so I'm probably going to have to build a planer sled of some sort. Man I'm going to be building jigs until blue in the face at this rate . I guess the thing is though I'd rather do that then make a hasty decision and buy something I'll regret down the road. I'd rather take the time and do some research and make sure that the jointer I do end up getting is a good fit for me. Problem with that is that I'm going to have to figure out a way to get by with what I have for the time being. Quote
IronWood Posted August 1, 2012 Report Posted August 1, 2012 Earlier in the post you mentioned that the jointer doesn't seem esential to you and that there may be some other things that could use more since you're just starting out; in opinion, the joint is vital for just starting out and for every other stage of woodworking. I rebuilt an old, solid cast iron Rockwell that I don't think I could live without and can only remember about 2 projects in the last 2 years that I didn't use it. You'll be surprised how often you turn to a good machine when you know it's set up square and true. When I first started, I got the advice to buy the most expensive hand tools that you can afford and true-up the power tools you can find - great advice for starting out but I now lean toward simply buying the best if you're going to buy. I know money is a big deal for all of us but I have yet to regret buying the higher end tools after I use them a few times... And that Laguna is a great machine... Quote
Eric. Posted August 2, 2012 Report Posted August 2, 2012 If they both run well after cleaning and tuning them up and replacing that switch, I'd say you got a fine deal. Those are good machines...they just need some TLC. Quote
rodger. Posted August 2, 2012 Report Posted August 2, 2012 You can never have a planer that is too big! I would love to have a planer that size. I would say you got a great deal. Put your enerry into cleaning and setting them up - forget about buyer's remorse! The only think that makes me nevous is the missing blade guard on the jointer. Either get one from general parts, or whip one up yourself in the shop. Did the seller give you the jointer's push pads? ps - how did you get the jointer so clean! Nice work! Quote
STL Woodguy Posted August 2, 2012 Report Posted August 2, 2012 Phenomenal deal, providing everything is in working order. I may have paid $600 for the planer alone if I could fit something of that size. As mentioned, definitely secure a guard for the jointer before doing anything with it. And check the bolts and make sure everything is tight. On my jointer, a stripped bolt that I didn't know about (and likely the original owner wasn't aware of either) caused the cutterhead to rock up and toss a gib/knife - although I was standing off to the side the guard saved my butt and the pair shot out the flange instead. Quote
Sac Posted August 2, 2012 Report Posted August 2, 2012 Sounds like you have it all figured out. Make sure that you post pics to follow up. I love watching dirty tools come to life again. And if they work out good, you got a HECK of a deal!!!! $600 for a 6" jointer and a 15" stationary planer!! That is great!! That planer brand new is like $2000.. and I am guessing that the jointer new is about $1000. IF you really want, once you get all these tools cleaned up you could probably sell that jointer for about 500, and the planer for about $1200, and then buy what you want with a nice chunk down. But you are going to love that planer. Its only overkill if you don't have the space for it. I am upgrading to a larger floor model later this fall. Cant wait. Congrats again. Quote
knotscott Posted August 5, 2012 Report Posted August 5, 2012 You ended up with a couple of really nice tools. I don't know what I'd do without my jointer and planer, and yours are a definite step up from what I'm using. Good luck! Quote
jmaichel Posted August 5, 2012 Report Posted August 5, 2012 You ended up with a couple of really nice tools. I don't know what I'd do without my jointer and planer, and yours are a definite step up from what I'm using. Good luck! Just out of curiosity what kind of jointer do you use? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.