Recommended Posts

Posted

For years now, I have owned a little DeWalt compressor. It has served my needs (blowing air up my shirt just for fun), but now i think it's time to upgrade. The DeWalt unit is going in the garage for various DIY stuff like pumping air into tires, and I'd like to step up my game in the shop. I will eventually run pipe through the shop so that I have compressed air at various locations. And although I don't currently use many pneumatic tools or even compressor-driven HVLP, I'd like to have that option in the future. I am thinking something in the 20-30 gallon range should be adequate and I don't necessarily think I need one of those giant floor-standing units.

As I try to educate myself on the world of compressors, I was hoping you guys might give me an idea of what you use, what you like, and what you would buy if you were in my shoes. I don't necessarily need specific model recommendations but those are certainly welcome.

I have heard Ingersoll-Rand makes some really nice stuff and I was considering this unit: http://www.amazon.com/Ingersoll-Rand-Garage-Mate-Model-P1-5IU-A9/dp/B001O3E9WC/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1355412137&sr=8-2&keywords=ingersoll+rand+compressor

41ReXT-Sw9L.jpg

Posted

I'm currently using a Porter Cable pancake compressor, probably PC's version of your DeWalt. I do use pneumatic nail guns ( pin nailer, brad gun & narrow crown stapler). I'm looking to add a spray finish kit to the shop in the coming years.

Like you I really don't need anything huge. I've been thinking that this one would do the trick for me, and the price is right...

http://www.homedepot...r&storeId=10051

Ingerson Rand does make excellent industrial compressors. I'm not too familiar with their consumer market stuff though.

Posted

I'll throw my 2 cents in. One thing I'd be concerned about is that if your compressor runs too often you get more water in your tank. I've been known to over-tax mine to the point where I was spraying almost as much water as I was paint. (Granted this was a rare high volume painting application which really isn't very common in what I do.)

I might try to up-size as much as possible just to avoid the rare but annoying case mentioned above. I don't know what its like where you are, but there are so many large compressors on Craigslist out here that I think I'd lean toward buying a much bigger used unit for the same price or probably less than the new unit you are considering.

Posted

I ran metal piping across my ceiling to my hose reel which is attached to the ceiling between my table saw and workbench. The hose reaches all four corners of my shop. I also installed at the compressor a regulator/filter to regulate air pressure and to catch moisture. Nail guns and water don't mix.

Posted

I just upgraded to an oil type and they are so quiet. I would never go back to oil less. I went with a 20 gallon from northern tool. It is actually the same as their store model but by the OEM. I ran the rapid air but am not real happy with it. I may upgrade to air jcertified plastic in the spring.

BRuce

Posted

What ever you decide to get try this. When you plumb it, come out of the compressor, run a pipe down, then put in a water separator, then run back up.

This will put the water separator at the lowest point in the line (where the water wants to collect anyway). If you use it for spraying finishes or paint, then make sure the water separator is at a height where a bucket sitting on the floor will enclose it. If you fill the bucket with ice then the moisture will condense in the separator and it will be more effective. May not be a big deal in Arizona, but the dryer your air the better it is for the tools and finishes. You can also look into auto tool oilers for each outlet (except the one you are plugging your paint gun into of course).

Posted

I just upgraded to an oil type and they are so quiet. I would never go back to oil less. I went with a 20 gallon from northern tool. It is actually the same as their store model but by the OEM. I ran the rapid air but am not real happy with it. I may upgrade to air jcertified plastic in the spring.

BRuce

I've been using the 5 gal (or so) portable compressor for years and will upgrade eventually. While we're on the subject, please explain the difference between "oil type and oil less" and why one is better.

Marc, my philosophy always is "buy/build something a little bigger than you need is usually better". For example, if you're building a shop, build it a little bigger than you need right now, if you're able. You never know where your interests will take you and if you buy something that's "borderline big enough" for now, you may 1) goof up and not buy it big enough for what you actually need at this time and the compressor constantly runs and 2) if your interests change, you may need a larger compressor. Duckkisser is going through a new phase now where he is carving more. If you began carving and decided to use pneumatic tools, it would be good to have bought a compressor that's large enough to handle it. It's kind of a "Tim the Tool Man" approach....if 1HP is good, 5 would be great! [Grunt Grunt Grunt]

Thanks

Tim

PS...Dad ran Parts Departments for dealerships all my life. He always told me anything made by IR was "the Cadillac" of the pneumatic world. I guess it still holds true?

Posted

I have had good service from an upright Campbell Hausfield compressor in my 2 man custom cabinet shop for more than 20 years. Get a cast iron pump, drain the tank regularly, and change the oil. Only modification I did was to add an oversized air filter housing to the intake.

Posted

==> oversized air filter housing to the intake

that's a good idea -- I should do that. The filter on my unit is factory stock and have always been a little suspicious... Thanks.

Posted

Marc,

That I-R looks decent, would probably work well for the shop as long as you don't need to run DA sanders or conventional spray guns. I-R doesn't give specs at 40 PSI but I'd assume it would run most HVLP conversion guns just fine since they're almost all around 5-7 cfm@ 40. Two cylinder pump, hefty weight for a 20-gallon vertical, you could do a lot worse. I used to have one of their small twin tank hand-carry units, it made a lot of noise for an oil-pump compressor and vibrated enough to chase you around the room if you didn't keep an eye on it. But that was a cheap big-box store tool, made to a price point.

Personally, I'm a big Rolair fan. Used to be an Emglo devotee until they sold out to the baby-crap-yellow tool conglomerate but the old Emglo people are now selling their made-in-USA stuff as Jenny and they're good. We switched over to Rolair when Emglo sold out and haven't had a reason to look back. My framing crews use the big twin-tanks, I recently bought one of their VT20's for shop use and couldn't be happier(after I replaced the filter/silencer with a larger Sjoberg). I've had a few contacts with their customer service people, the experience was excellent.

All in all, you could do a lot worse IMHO. Biggest thing is to decide what you might eventually want to use and buy accordingly. But if air sanders are in your future you might want to build an addition on that new shop... :wacko:

Have a blast!

Bill

Posted

I just picked up the Home Depot version of the one you posted. First and foremost, I can't believe the noise difference in an oiled vs a pancake compressor. I've plumbed it into my shop with schedule 40 PVC. I know a lot of people say you shouldn't use PVC but the bursting point for schedule 40 is higher than what most of these compressors put out. The secret for sealed joints is to twist the PVC into the coupling not just pushing them together (I found out the hard way). It's way easier to work with and a lot cheaper than copper or black pipe, When I lived in AZ I didn't have any water issues and I still don't up here in CO but I put a separator on anyway.

Posted

It is not the bursting strength of the PVC but over time the the compression/decompression fatigues the pipe. Also there is a minute amount of oil in the air and that degrades the pipe. You might not have an issue but 5 to 10 years from now you may bump it with a board or tool and it will explode. Lots of 1 - 3" x 1/8" or smaller fragments hurling through the air, like a PVC porcupine. It is not woodworkers making this up, OSHA prohibits it in all commercial applications. I have used the RapiAir and do not really like it. I may go to copper with compression fittings later this year.

BRuce

Posted

DANG Bruce....Exploding PVC shrapnel with Sunday morning coffee... :o You're probably right though...I have a friend who plumbed his mechanic's shop about 1991 with pvc for the air and hasn't had a problem....yet...I don't like that 'porcupine thing' possibility.... I had a few years metal working and we used all sorts of machines that you just stick the pipe into and it threads it....you don't have to be that fancy...I've borrowed a 3/4 pipe threader (handle and die) from a friend and when I get to it, I'm running some galvanized pipe for air. If you're reading this and say "I can't do that" you're wrong. You just need a vise, couple 18" pipe wrenches, and a 3oz bottle of thread cutting solution. I have a horizontal band saw that's the trick for cutting lengths; but if I didn't have it, I'd use a chop saw or sawzall. It's not as easy as pvc....few things are, but it's definitely doable.

Can someone please address the oiled compressor vs no oil?

Posted

I had an oil less and it lasted 5 years and was super loud. It died about a month ago and I replaced it with a oil type. HUGE difference in the noise level. You can actually talk while standing next to it and the noise is also not as harse, if that makes any sense. Unless I needed one for a job site I would never buy another oil less.

BRuce

Posted

Oil is the way to go, better durability than oil free...just keep up with minor maintenance.

Good price too. Sears wants $600.00 for this unit.

If I were in the market for one of these, this is the one I'd buy.

Warranty is 1 year which is standard for this market.

Posted

You know whats funny (or maybe a bit sad)... This thread made me realize that I haven't changed my compressor oil in 'a looooong time'. It's getting cold here, so time for the winter weight oil... Shop maintenance never seems to end...

Posted

One of the most important issues that needs to be considered along with CFM is Duty Cycle. If you are looking to run pneumatic sanders or conventional spray applications duty cycle is critical. Most oil compressors have longer duty cycles but not all.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Hi Marc, Hope you had a great Christmas and that all is well with you and the Family. Not sure where your at with your compressor decision but here's my 2 cents. I don't run too many tools off my air tank,except nail guns and an air nossle to blow dust off tools, filters, and furniture projects before I put on a finish. Although I do occasionally run a spray gun for painting. If you plan on running any tools that require a high volume of air then you can't get a compressor big enough. One task I've done a few times where I needed high air vloume was in sand blasting. This requries a pretty high air volume and I was glad I had a 5 hp 80 gallon tank unit. They do generate a little noise and I know you probably can't put one outside your shop, but you can put one of those uprights in a corner and if you do, I recommend you do what I did and run a drain line outside so you can occasionally drain out the moisture that accumlates on the bottom of the tank. I put a cock pit value at the bottom of my tank and ran a rubber line right through a small hole in the wall.

The current unit I have in my shop was made by Coleman. I actually picked it up at Costco. Ingersol Rand is obviously a quality brand and you probably couldn't go wrong there. What I would reccomend you do before purchase is find a local compressor shop and see what brands they carry ,service and recommend. This way if and when you have problems you will get quicker and better service. And if you've already done your home work then you know that copper lines are best and safest to run through out the shop. Personally I just ran one line from my compressor, up the wall , on the ceiling to a central location in my shop which is close to my work bench and this has worked well. Another thing you might consider is buying used. Find a local auction house in your area and you will probably find quite a few compressors up for auction. There are still a lot of businesses that are closing and auctioning off their stuff. If you do this then just be sure you find one that runs on single phase 220 power,which I know you have in your shop. Anyways have a happy new year and who knows you just might be able to make it over this way for Comic Con this year. Cheers, Danny

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined