jmaichel Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 I know this does not make a lot of sense but for those who may have seen my post under the general woodworking section it make more sense. Basically I have allotted myself between 4 and 5k to buy tools and setup a shop, this is what i started with. Bandsaw, Planer, Hand tools (saws, jack plane, chisels, layout tools) bunch of parallel clamps shop vac Rockler Vortex Kreg Jig This is what I added: CT26 OF1400 TS75 Domino Domino cutter and tenon assortment CXS ETS 150 I have spent most of my budget and half just enough left for either an MFT 3 or a ridgid 4512 or cheaper grizzly model table saw. Any suggestions from people who have festools and an MFT 3 and table saw or just an MFT would be great. Thanks, James Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 I'm only vaguely familiar with the MFT3 but consider this, every woodworking project you are likely to ever make will need to be sawn. Quote
stahlee Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 James, you could use the MFT instead of the table saw. I personally use my MFT more than my Unisaw and it's inherently safer. There are very few cuts that you couldn't just as easily make on the MFT over a table saw and for the other cuts you have a bandsaw. There are many people that use a bandsaw instead of a table saw. The MFT is accurate and repeatable. On top of that, you will be able to use the MFT for a lot more operations than the table saw will provide. My MFT is the center of my workspace. If there were anything that is not on your list that would make life easier, it would be a jointer. You can survive with the planer with a nice sled for jointing. chris Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 should have every possible opinion on the subject. If it were me, I'd start with the MFT3 and track saw, since it is a convenient way to get started. If you later decide that you want a table saw you will still want the MFT and track saw for breaking down plywood. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 IMO less is more. I would have just bought a Griz cabinet saw and 6" para jointer for $2200. Dominos are cool but honesly the jessem dowel jig is as good as it gets and beat the domino for alot less money. Maybe even try a griz track saw for sheet goods. A router in the saw extension wing is plenty. You can do most of everything with those alone. Don 1 Quote
jmaichel Posted February 13, 2013 Author Report Posted February 13, 2013 IMO less is more. I would have just bought a Griz cabinet saw and 6" para jointer for $2200. Dominos are cool but honesly the jessem dowel jig is as good as it gets and beat the domino for alot less money. Maybe even try a griz track saw for sheet goods. A router in the saw extension wing is plenty. You can do most of everything with those alone. Don Hi Don, I do not have 220v so a cabinet saw is out of the question. I almost bought a SawStop CNS but decided to go with the Domino instead which took a big chunk of my table saw budget. James Quote
Eric. Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 If it were me, and I had no plans to move anytime soon, I'd take the remaining money and get wired up with 220. Then save up for a cabinet saw and a jointer. I like thinking long-term. Quote
dwacker Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 Hi Don, I do not have 220v so a cabinet saw is out of the question. I almost bought a SawStop CNS but decided to go with the Domino instead which took a big chunk of my table saw budget. James Griz makes a 10" 2hp hybrid for about $900 that runs fine on 110v. Don 1 Quote
jmaichel Posted February 13, 2013 Author Report Posted February 13, 2013 If it were me, and I had no plans to move anytime soon, I'd take the remaining money and get wired up with 220. Then save up for a cabinet saw and a jointer. I like thinking long-term. I will be moving in the next 3 years. I am in the military so weight restrictions are a factor. When I move and a couple of big machines eat into that limit quickly. I will say that I was agonizing over my decision yesterday and after seeing the CNS for 2k and 3hp PCS for 3k and for the extra 1k I got a 3 hp cabinet saw it made my choice a little easier. i knew that if I bought the CNS that I would want to replace it with bigger saw within the next 5 years so I decided that spending the 2k on CNS would not benefit me and that I could get the domino, accessories and an MFT 3 or Ridgid R412 instead. James Quote
stahlee Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 I'm still in the opposite boat. Get an MFT and you'll do just fine. You have all the tools to do nearly any operation that a table saw will provide. Quote
jmaichel Posted February 13, 2013 Author Report Posted February 13, 2013 I'm still in the opposite boat. Get an MFT and you'll do just fine. You have all the tools to do nearly any operation that a table saw will provide. I am leaning toward an MFT. I am 85% there is this last 15% that I need to figure out. When I decided to add a significant amount of tools I knew that I needed to go all the way or at least all the way to my budget Quote
dwacker Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 Ill throw out another option. The $900 panel pro is a sweet option I'd get one over the MFT any day. For the money you get more tool. Don Quote
jmaichel Posted February 13, 2013 Author Report Posted February 13, 2013 Ill throw out another option. The $900 panel pro is a sweet option I'd get one over the MFT any day. For the money you get more tool. Don Not sure I would have room for that but I think you may by trying to make a point. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 I'd buy a couple of sweet Veritas hand saws, a pair of decent chisels, a #4 and a Block plane. Then I'd invest the rest of the money in a wealth management fund. In 3 years when you move, look for a place that has enough space for a shop. After you get settled, you'll have more money and some solid hand tool experience on which to build. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted February 13, 2013 Report Posted February 13, 2013 Not sure I would have room for that but I think you may by trying to make a point. No point just and opinion. The mft is just a little table with a guide and a bunch of holes. For a contractor to throw in the back of a van thats great. You have the ts75 on your list so you already have a guide. There is just no bang for the buck. I think the first time you want to rip a 6" wide board down to 3" you will regret not getting a table saw. For the money even the cheap panel saw will out perform the ts75 and actually use less space when wacking up sheet goods. I have a $5000 dollar band saw and even at that its not going to cut a line like a tablesaw. It seems to me like you want to make a full shop on your budget. Honestly I really just dont want to see anyone spend 5K and still have to completely improvise that just doesnt make sense. 5K is a good budget to get you a great little shop. Don Quote
jmaichel Posted February 13, 2013 Author Report Posted February 13, 2013 No point just and opinion. The mft is just a little table with a guide and a bunch of holes. For a contractor to throw in the back of a van thats great. You have the ts75 on your list so you already have a guide. There is just no bang for the buck. I think the first time you want to rip a 6" wide board down to 3" you will regret not getting a table saw. For the money even the cheap panel saw will out perform the ts75 and actually use less space when wacking up sheet goods. I have a $5000 dollar band saw and even at that its not going to cut a line like a tablesaw. It seems to me like you want to make a full shop on your budget. Honestly I really just dont want to see anyone spend 5K and still have to completely improvise that just doesnt make sense. 5K is a good budget to get you a great little shop. Don you bring up some very good points Don. I should have skipped the domino at just got the sawstop CNS. Quote
Nick2cd Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 My vote would have to go with a table saw. The sawstop contractor is an excellent choice. Upgrade the fence and to the cast iron wings and u have one of the best saws on the market with a safety feature that is so valuable, it's nearly priceless. I'll never buy any other saw. My rationalization for the table saw would be cutting small parts. Now I don't have an mft/ts55, so take this with a grain of salt, but from what I've read and watched, it can be difficult or impossible to safely cut small parts. I guess it depends on what u build. If u use lots of sheet goods the mft route may be best. But it sounds like you'll be cutting a mixture of sizes and materials. I believe u will get more versatility from the tablesaw. Quote
stahlee Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 No point just and opinion. The mft is just a little table with a guide and a bunch of holes. For a contractor to throw in the back of a van thats great. You have the ts75 on your list so you already have a guide. There is just no bang for the buck. I think the first time you want to rip a 6" wide board down to 3" you will regret not getting a table saw. For the money even the cheap panel saw will out perform the ts75 and actually use less space when wacking up sheet goods. I have a $5000 dollar band saw and even at that its not going to cut a line like a tablesaw. It seems to me like you want to make a full shop on your budget. Honestly I really just dont want to see anyone spend 5K and still have to completely improvise that just doesnt make sense. 5K is a good budget to get you a great little shop. Don I don't think cutting a 6" wide board down to 3" is that big of deal. Why is this difficult? There would simply need to be support for the back part of the track which would be quite easy. The TS 75 would tear through that without issue. I think if you ask this question over on the FOG you'll get a different perspective. Quote
stahlee Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 you bring up some very good points Don. I should have skipped the domino at just got the sawstop CNS. The Domino is an amazing tool. Have you used it yet? Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 you bring up some very good points Don. I should have skipped the domino at just got the sawstop CNS. The Domino would be great for a production shop, an expensive luxury for a hobby shop but if everything you ever build has lots of tenons you'll be glad you bought it. A quality tablesaw would have been my first purchase then accessory tools but that's me. Quote
jmaichel Posted February 14, 2013 Author Report Posted February 14, 2013 The Domino would be great for a production shop, an expensive luxury for a hobby shop but if everything you ever build has lots of tenons you'll be glad you bought it. A quality tablesaw would have been my first purchase then accessory tools but that's me. I know the Domino is probably a little over kill for a hobby shop but I am sure I will not regret having it. When I first set out on this tool buying venture I had full intentions of getting a table saw, in fact that was going to be my first purchase. I had an order ready to go on the Grizzly site for a table saw, 6" jointer and a dust collector. I decided to hold off and go to my hardwood dealer who also happens to sell Sawstops and Festool's. I looked hard at one of the Sawstop CNS and was very close to pulling the trigger. I then started thinking about 1.75 HP PCS but it was $2700 for the model I was looking at and for $300 I could have had the 3 HP saw. Now this would have been and easy choice but their were two contributing factors. 1) I don't have 220 nor do I have the option of adding it. 2) I am moving in 3 years and then 2 years after that I am moving again, so it will be at least 5 years before I am settled anywhere. I did not want to spend 2k on the CNS knowing that I really would have liked at least the 1.75 HP PCS but at $2700 it would have made more sense to get the 3 HP version for another $300 more. I started looking at the Festool stuff and that is ultimately what I ended up with. Quote
knotscott Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 There's no chance I'd give up my TS. Quote
dcustoms Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 There's no chance I'd give up my TS. Out of my cold dead hands! Quote
wdwerker Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 I think I would pick up a used tablesaw and then sell it when you move. Quote
pghmyn Posted February 14, 2013 Report Posted February 14, 2013 You say that you have no option for 220v wiring where you are living currently, and you plan to move in the coming future. When you do move, do you see an option for permanent 220v wiring? If you do, you can always buy 220v tools, and use a commercially available 110v -> 220v transformer. It is not something that is cheaply made. However, it is not meant to be run for extended periods of time. But, using a table saw, I don't see you using it for too long at a shot, anyway. I forget where I saw it, but I remember exactly how it works. It comes as a box that has an outlet in it, and a LED light. Out the back is two long cords that you plug into two regular 110v outlets. I think they might have to be on different circuits (not sure on that one). If the current is where it should be, the light on the front of the box will light up and it is safe to use. However, you can not overdraw your circuit (common sense). If one of your two receptacles is rated for 15A and the other is 20A, you can not exceed the 15A. I will try to find the product. I just thought I would tell you about it seeing as it might be a good temporary solution for you. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.