Chuck Melton Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 I know that I want to work with rough cut lumber, and while the jointer I have professes to be a combo machine, I just don't see how well it would function as a planer. I know that when I am ready I am going to buy a lunchbox style planer (been keeping an eye out for a dewalt 735). Until I have one, I am stuck paying for milling, which isn't a significant amount of money but I also feel like I am missing out on part of the processes of building something. I also know that I am probably going to get a better quality of milled lumber when paying a hardwood dealer for it, which also sways my decision. By my estimate, I would need to pay to have about 200BF of lumber milled to equal the cost of decent used planer but the quality and the experience of milling lumber myself are factors that I think are goin to drive the decision of when to purchase a planer. In your experience, does a lunchbox planer do an adequate job? Do you feel like milling your own lumber gives you more control over your work and a greater connection to it? Quote
STL Woodguy Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 Sure, milling my own feels good, I don't know why but I've always enjoyed the milling process and get annoyed when a TV show skips over it. Something else to consider is that even S2S / S4S boards from the hardwood dealer may still have imperfections or slight wood movement - especially if sitting for a while - so being able to remill helps with that. I also like having rough wood as a purchasing option. A lunchbox planer will be just fine for most purposes if what you're milling is under 13" wide. Maybe it's trickier if you're trying to mill much longer boards, but even that can be helped via more in-outfeeds. My only problem with lunchboxes is that they are ridiculously noisy, the concern being for others in the area, not so much for myself with hearing protection. Quote
TerryMcK Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 Lunchbox planers in my experience are great. You can thickness to whatever sizes you want and I feel milling your own stock gives more flexibility. I personally have a lunchbox planer and two combination jointer/planers (one bench top and one full size floor mounted) and they all produce excellent results. If I need to thickness up to 12" then the lunchbox planer gets used. Up to 8" wide and one of the combo machines is used. Longer boards go on the floor mounted machine. But when I just had the lunchbox one I used a couple of stands as in/outfeed support and it was just fine. Quote
TRBaker Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 I love my Dewalt 735 and for the money, it can't be beat. I get my lumber from a wholesaler that I've dealt with for years. He always sends me quality stock. Lately I've been paying a few cents extra per foot to have them s3s the material for me and it saves a ton of production time, but, I still end up having to use my planer for a lot of milling. Quote
dwacker Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 Im not a believer in buying S anything unless you intend to use the board as purchased. Lumber should be roughed to close to use size then machined into s4s. When you buy that pretty s4s board 8" wide and rip it into smaller strips chances are very good all the machining was wasted and to remachine will net a board to thin to be of any use. Wood has alot of pent up energy that is released when cut causing it to bow and twist. If you've ever been around a big band saw resawing wide thick stock into thin stock and heard a bang like a gun shot that is the energy being released. It cost alot of money for kiln operators to raise the MC back up to OD equalization so they dont do it this makes the stress even worse. Tablesaw jointer and planer IMO are the first three tools anyone should buy. 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 Im not a believer in buying S anything unless you intend to use the board as purchased. Lumber should be roughed to close to use size then machined into s4s. When you buy that pretty s4s board 8" wide and rip it into smaller strips chances are very good all the machining was wasted and to remachine will net a board to thin to be of any use. Wood has alot of pent up energy that is released when cut causing it to bow and twist. If you've ever been around a big band saw resawing wide thick stock into thin stock and heard a bang like a gun shot that is the energy being released. It cost alot of money for kiln operators to raise the MC back up to OD equalization so they dont do it this makes the stress even worse. Tablesaw jointer and planer IMO are the first three tools anyone should buy. Good advice from PB The tension within timber can be really violent. Iroko being the worst species for this I have worked with. +1 totally on a saw (table or band) and jointer planer (combo or separate). If you add to this a router table (home made or purchased) you get a decent joinery shop. Just a quick point also (forgive me if you know already) when you need to make lots of short pieces of same the section don't be tempted reduce a board into little pieces. leave it in long lengths, sawn to width and thickness and only cut them to length once planed and thicknessed. Short sections are sure way to introduce fingers and cutters. Sound like your shop is developing fast! Quote
mikem Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 Another thing to point out with any "S" board is that the price goes up, dramatically, of the board. I have found box stores tend to sell s4s boards at close to 3x the cost if you buy it as rough kiln dried lumber. Not to mention, having a planer and jointer opens up the door to all kinds of lumber options that you don't have today. Quote
Eric. Posted April 8, 2013 Report Posted April 8, 2013 There are times, though, that I prefer buying surfaced boards. Whenever I buy curly or bird's eye maple...or any figured wood for that matter. Or expensive exotics. Or lumber for a project where consistency is important...cherry projects come to mind. I like seeing what I'm buying. With surfaced lumber you can select the clearest boards, or boards with more sapwood if that's what you want, or boards with the most intense figure. It's a guessing game with rough. But most of the time, rough is definitely the way to go. A full inch thick and much cheaper is obviously an advantage. Every shop needs a jointer and planer. Period. Even if you don't mind paying for S3S. What happens when that S3S moves? And it will...it always does. What happens when you want 3/8" or 1/4" stock for some little drawers? Quote
Chuck Melton Posted April 9, 2013 Author Report Posted April 9, 2013 Thanks for the advice gentlemen. 735 is officially on the shopping list (Is the comparable Rigid planer worth a look?) Anyone use a lunchbox planer outside? What do you do for infeed and outfeed support? I was wondering if I can scheme up something using an old solid door and some saw horses.. Quote
Vic Posted April 9, 2013 Report Posted April 9, 2013 I don't know of any lunchbox planer that is "comparable" to DeWalt's 735. I have the 734 and the 735. The 734 is probably what is comparable to most other planers. While I don't necessarily agree with Steve's beginning tool list, as I think it depends on what you plan to build. The jointer and planer are definitely in the starting line up for power tools. Quote
Jfitz Posted April 9, 2013 Report Posted April 9, 2013 "In your experience, does a lunchbox planer do an adequate job? " More than adequate, I would say. The results do depend somewhat on good technique and also good machine setup (indeed/out feed tables, waxed beds, clean rollers). If snipe is a problem, you might need to mill the boards a little long and cut off the excess, but it's really not a big deal. "Do you feel like milling your own lumber gives you more control over your work and a greater connection to it?" Definitely. Not being tied into the species and dimensions of pre-milled lumber is great. Also, as opposed to buying rough and having it milled, having your own planer gives you much more flexibility of time - not having to drive to/from some place when you need a board milled. It also let's you make minor adjustments or tweaks to ensure pieces are the same dimension. When I got my planer, I was amazed at how out of flat/square "dimensioned" lumber was. Getting good joints with that lumber is difficult at best. And, as Don said, cutting a milled board into smaller pieces often releases all sorts of internal stress and causes the milling effort to be wasted. Quote
Chuck Melton Posted April 10, 2013 Author Report Posted April 10, 2013 Looks like I am picking up a Delta 12" lunchbox planer this evening. It wasn't my first choice but the price is right ($100) and it comes with an extra set of knives. Quote
pghmyn Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 Looks like I am picking up a Delta 12" lunchbox planer this evening. It wasn't my first choice but the price is right ($100) and it comes with an extra set of knives. I have this Delta planer: I never use the extension beds. They are more a nuisance on this model. Snipe is a big problem, but you can get around it. Two method I know of that work well are: 1) Add 5-6" to each board you plan to mill. Cut off the ends when you are done. 2) Continuously feed stock so the rollers are always supported. Start with a sacrificial piece, then all your stock, then end with a sacrificial piece. Never let a piece pass a roller without another piece right behind it or next to it. Quote
sjeff70 Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 I was going to wait until I researched this but since Chuck brought it up... What cutter heads can we expect on these planers. I was shopping for a jointer first, based solely off the type of cutterhead I planed to use. I've seen recommendations here to buy straight knifed machines with the intention of upgrading to a Tersa cutterhead in the future. So does this apply to the planer as well... look for straight knife planers? Is this because you just replace the knives with Tersa's replacement knives? Ultimately I want to use the Tersa R2000 System for the planer at least, which replaces the entire cutter head. It uses 4 knives and the blades take only seconds to change. Do certain planers make it easier to upgrade to the Tersa R2000? I don't want to have to fiddle with fine tuning knives all the time, it is my greatest concern. I can make up the cost by buying used machines which I prefer anyway. Quote
dwacker Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 I was going to wait until I researched this but since Chuck brought it up... What cutter heads can we expect on these planers. I was shopping for a jointer first, based solely off the type of cutterhead I planed to use. I've seen recommendations here to buy straight knifed machines with the intention of upgrading to a Tersa cutterhead in the future. So does this apply to the planer as well... look for straight knife planers? Is this because you just replace the knives with Tersa's replacement knives? Ultimately I want to use the Tersa R2000 System for the planer at least, which replaces the entire cutter head. It uses 4 knives and the blades take only seconds to change. Do certain planers make it easier to upgrade to the Tersa R2000? I don't want to have to fiddle with fine tuning knives all the time, it is my greatest concern. I can make up the cost by buying used machines which I prefer anyway. Your not going to get a tersa or teminus for these little machines. They are straight knived, I think you can get a helical for the dewalt but dont quote me on that. Straight knived machine are not as bad as folks seem to make them out. It take me longer to drink a cup of coffee than it does to change out planer knives. I would not stress out over cutter heads and just try to get the best you can within your budget. Quote
pghmyn Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 I replaced the knives on the planer I linked above in about 20-25 minutes. Haven't fiddled with them yet after the initial change. I don't rely on the scale on the side, at all. I have calipers that give me the dimensions of the lumber. Quote
rodger. Posted April 10, 2013 Report Posted April 10, 2013 I have the ridgid tp1300, and have had it for about 5 or 6 years. It has been a great planer, and the knives can be changed in less than 10 min. I have no complaints with the unit. Well worth the money. Now that being said, don't expect much from their so called "lifetime warranty". I have had nothing but issues with their warranty program ( for a different tool). Quote
sjeff70 Posted April 11, 2013 Report Posted April 11, 2013 Hopefully Chuck can use the info regarding the knives. My questions were on the Tersa replacement knives and R2000 System that I'll post in a new thread. ...don't want to hijack the thread. I was interested in knife changes in less than 1 minute with no adjustments. On both jointer and planer but on American machines (PM and Delta): Quote
Chuck Melton Posted April 12, 2013 Author Report Posted April 12, 2013 I have to ay that that cheapy Delta did a much better job than I expected. I ran some test pine through it before sending an 11x24 cutting board slab I am working on through it. I was making light passes but it did the trick in no time. And wow, it makes a lot of saw dust. Looks like a dust collector is definitely on the shopping list. Quote
pghmyn Posted April 12, 2013 Report Posted April 12, 2013 Hopefully Chuck can use the info regarding the knives. My questions were on the Tersa replacement knives and R2000 System that I'll post in a new thread. ...don't want to hijack the thread. I was interested in knife changes in less than 1 minute with no adjustments. On both jointer and planer but on American machines (PM and Delta): Not something I would do with the tool still plugged in... Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted April 13, 2013 Report Posted April 13, 2013 I'm a bit late, but in my world, saving money has nothing to do with owning a thickness planer. The main reason I own a planer is having any thickness of stock I want at my disposal. I buy wood both rough and surfaced. My dealer only drops ~ $0.25 a bd/ft for rough, for non-production quantities, so for wood that will become trim, cabinet face frames, etc... I'll let him mill it slightly oversize. Milling can be expensive if you're buying several hundred board feet or more, at one time, but I don't buy wood that way. A big order for me is 150 bd/ft, so cost is not a factor. For most stuff that will become furniture, I'll often have him mill it oversize, 7/8 or 15/16 for 4/4. This makes selection and layout a lot easier, then I'll finish dimensioning it with my jointer, planer and 22" drum sander. An in-house thicknesser allows me to easily have the most structurally appropriate, or simply best looking, thickness for every part I produce. It's an electric apprentice, period... For 15 years, I've been looking for a reason to upgrade my DeWalt 733, but it's perfect for what I need to do. Straight knives don't bother me. as I have a 22" drum sander to finish dimensioning figured stock, and I can use the jointed faces as references, then flip them. None of the surfaces created by my straight knife machines have to be finished surfaces. I can finish show faces with the sander or high-angle hand plane, and enjoy zero tearout. Quote
sjeff70 Posted April 13, 2013 Report Posted April 13, 2013 I'm a bit late, but in my world, saving money has nothing to do with owning a thickness planer. The main reason I own a planer is having any thickness of stock I want at my disposal. I buy wood both rough and surfaced. My dealer only drops ~ $0.25 a bd/ft for rough, for non-production quantities, so for wood that will become trim, cabinet face frames, etc... I'll let him mill it slightly oversize. Milling can be expensive if you're buying several hundred board feet or more, at one time, but I don't buy wood that way. A big order for me is 150 bd/ft, so cost is not a factor. For most stuff that will become furniture, I'll often have him mill it oversize, 7/8 or 15/16 for 4/4. This makes selection and layout a lot easier, then I'll finish dimensioning it with my jointer, planer and 22" drum sander. An in-house thicknesser allows me to easily have the most structurally appropriate, or simply best looking, thickness for every part I produce. It's an electric apprentice, period... For 15 years, I've been looking for a reason to upgrade my DeWalt 733, but it's perfect for what I need to do. Straight knives don't bother me. as I have a 22" drum sander to finish dimensioning figured stock, and I can use the jointed faces as references, then flip them. None of the surfaces created by my straight knife machines have to be finished surfaces. I can finish show faces with the sander or high-angle hand plane, and enjoy zero tearout. Ah, the voice of reason! It is sometimes difficult to get past marketing ploys that are only interested in selling their products. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.